教育王國

標題: 女拔面試, 2分30秒, 多謝$40/分鐘 [打印本頁]

作者: mycarrie 時間: 08-10-13 21:49 標題: 女拔面試, 2分30秒, 多謝$40/分鐘

各位, 我雖然面試機會尚少, 但女拔的面試速度之快及混亂係我最佩服的.

準備時間, 企係大門口等了15分鐘, 跟住入去登記房等了20分仲
面試時間, 不足5分鐘, 仲要同另一個小朋友share. (每人得2分半仲, 計埋行行企企)
得中文問題(我見到有個女仔滿口流利英文咁睇英文書, 仲要同我一紅, 我心唸你實得la, 點知問問題係全中文law): 你讀邊間幼稚園? 你叫咩名? 你返學做咩? 完了多謝$100, 每條問題係$33.3, 你唔好以為帶埋成績表正本佢會睇你la, sorry wor, 我個女話張成績表個校長原封不動比返你(因為我張成績表3摺的所以證明佢係無睇過)

我覺得學校並不是以學生interview為收生標準, 極有可能係har下我地呢班家長同小朋友.

ps. 等待期間, 大門口的登記阿姐態度很囂, 仲有wait緊interview間房得一把吊fan, 內面有成廿幾人等, 熱到爆...

有同感家長請一齊來傾下....

[ 本帖最後由 mycarrie 於 08-10-13 21:54 編輯 ]

作者: BBR 時間: 08-10-13 21:55

你睇到個女interview?我今個星期至interview,之前D媽咪話要等好耐

作者: youma 時間: 08-10-13 21:58

校長會否觀察女生看英文書態度, 再問書中內容?

作者: okokdad 時間: 08-10-13 22:03

I don't know but my daughter only answer several simple questions. I think that the chance is very small!

原帖由 youma 於 08-10-13 21:58 發表
校長會否觀察女生看英文書態度, 再問書中內容?

作者: juniorpam 時間: 08-10-13 22:06 標題: DGS

I totally totally agreed your comment.
St Stephen College Preparatory School gets you about 20-25 minutes for 5-6 children.
St Paul Co-ed primary school gets you about 45 minutes for 6-8 children.
Good Hope School gets you about 15-20 minutes for 4-5 children.
Whatever in cost of interviewing time, application fees and waiting time, DGS absoultely wins in this game.
What a pity that the parents never know the rating mechanism in the overall interviewing process, is it fair? any social factors? Sorry, we cannot know. But, at least, it can to a certain extent be respected.
Just a kind relief
Sorry for any misinformation
thanks

原帖由 mycarrie 於 08-10-13 21:49 發表
各位, 我雖然面試機會尚少, 但女拔的面試速度之快及混亂係我最佩服的.

準備時間, 等了30分鐘
面試時間, 不足5分鐘, 仲要同另一個小朋友share. (每人得2分半仲)
得中文問題(我見到有個女仔滿口流利英文咁睇英文書, ...

作者: anak 時間: 08-10-13 22:06 標題: DGJS interview experience

My experience is different.
They allow you to enter on time, wait in the room only about 15 mins. About 6 interviewees with parents.
Clerk very polite.
Interview time about 10 mins.
Pricipal seems nice.
:)

原帖由 mycarrie 於 08-10-13 21:49 發表
各位, 我雖然面試機會尚少, 但女拔的面試速度之快及混亂係我最佩服的.

準備時間, 企係大門口等了15分鐘, 跟住入去登記房等了20分仲
面試時間, 不足5分鐘, 仲要同另一個小朋友share. (每人得2分半仲, 計埋行行企企) ...

作者: redfacewai 時間: 08-10-13 22:07

My dauhther interview time is 7mins (of course share w/ other girl)

-what yr name & how old u are,
-kingergarden name

DISAPPOINTED

expensive interview

原帖由 mycarrie 於 08-10-13 21:49 發表
各位, 我雖然面試機會尚少, 但女拔的面試速度之快及混亂係我最佩服的.

準備時間, 企係大門口等了15分鐘, 跟住入去登記房等了20分仲
面試時間, 不足5分鐘, 仲要同另一個小朋友share. (每人得2分半仲, 計埋行行企企) ...

作者: juniorpam 時間: 08-10-13 22:09 標題: DGS

The principal will not watch your kid in the waiting room. Just maybe assistant there makes the arrangement. There are about 50-60 books on the table. I do not believe she will know all the content of the books
thanks

原帖由 youma 於 08-10-13 21:58 發表
校長會否觀察女生看英文書態度, 再問書中內容?

作者: tiggger 時間: 08-10-13 22:32

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mycarrie 時間: 08-10-13 22:42

校長好nice? 我只係係interview房門見到佢一眼jar, 前後唔夠5秒, 之後就"的"左另外2個小朋友入去la.

仲有個clerk我都唔知佢係傻定係無知, 有個家長登記時竟然問個cleak呢間學校係咩教??(此問題已經夠經典, 竟然唔查清楚就來interview?)跟住個clerk仲搞笑答:我唔知wor, 係咪天主教ar .....:;pppp:跟住個clerk走去問個登記員至知jar. 簡直嘆為觀止的妙問妙答. 成個interview過程係無一個係老師, 根本你係waiting room做d乜都無人知無人理, 只係靠短短的interview時間, 祝大家好運.

不過本人覺得此校並不是以interview表現為收生標準....poor girls

作者: juniorpam 時間: 08-10-13 23:10 標題: DGS

Correct. No teachers approached the parents during the interview. Only a likely assistant to guide you from waiting room to a bench can be realised. Maybe two teachers in the interview room assess all the children.
Your experience is really interesting
What a funny story

原帖由 mycarrie 於 08-10-13 22:42 發表
校長好nice? 我只係係interview房門見到佢一眼jar, 前後唔夠5秒, 之後就"的"左另外2個小朋友入去la.

仲有個clerk我都唔知佢係傻定係無知, 有個家長登記時竟然問個cleak呢間學校係咩教??(此問題已經夠經典, 竟然唔查 ...

作者: andykwan 時間: 08-10-14 07:27

what 收生標準 do you think? family background?
girls' KG?

原帖由 mycarrie 於 08-10-13 22:42 發表
不過本人覺得此校並不是以interview表現為收生標準....poor girls

作者: calipama 時間: 08-10-14 08:42

我只能說這些名校完全以商業形式運作,
Demand & Supply,生意好，當然吊高黎賣！

作者: Reximom 時間: 08-10-14 08:58

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Reximom 時間: 08-10-14 09:12

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: BBR 時間: 08-10-14 09:33

i will interview on this Sat, then what shall i do

作者: mycarrie 時間: 08-10-14 09:34

我個人覺得女拔真係是是但但咁in, 浪費晒一班家長心機, 相反蔡繼有就真係好有誠意咁interview小朋友, 我地in左1個小時有5part 環節考小朋友, d 小朋友仲好開心. 大家都係要比$100面試費, 但人地真係有heart law. 雖然可能interview時間長或短, 抑或interview問題多寡都不能確定收生, 但當然時間長d, interview多方面d, 小朋友可以有多d 機會發揮同表現自己. 起碼呢d先叫做interview過....

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-10-14 09:45

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: vanessa2003 時間: 08-10-14 09:53 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

Hi mycarrie,

Can you tell me more about the content of the interview in CKY? What questions have been asked? How about the parents' questionnaire?

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-14 09:55

當年我個仔面試，我都係覺得蔡繼有是最全面的，而小孩子都是臉帶笑容走返出來的，連門口個【實ｑ】都是很有禮貌的。

男拔就成間學校連個校長都是黑口黑臉的，祇是見過一位老師是面帶笑容啫。

原帖由 mycarrie 於 08-10-14 09:34 發表
我個人覺得女拔真係是是但但咁in, 浪費晒一班家長心機, 相反蔡繼有就真係好有誠意咁interview小朋友, 我地in左1個小時有5part 環節考小朋友, d 小朋友仲好開心. 大家都係要比$100面試費, 但人地真係有heart law. 雖 ...

作者: easybring 時間: 08-10-14 10:46

畀d耐性....唉, 又會咁架.

原帖由 BBR 於 08-10-14 09:33 發表
i will interview on this Sat, then what shall i do

作者: Vinyny 時間: 08-10-14 10:57

無法啦。。鬼叫我們求人啊！

可憐天下父母心。。。

原帖由 easybring 於 08-10-14 10:46 發表
畀d耐性....唉, 又會咁架.

作者: conniengor 時間: 08-10-14 11:01

Hi mycarrie,

你嘅comment我都有同感,我個女3年前都int過呢間, 唔駛2分鐘出返黎 (3個小朋友共分5分鐘), 個校長企在門口好似scan下d家長先帶小朋友入去int嘅!

記得果日特登攞日大去int, int完後都話自已笨, 簡直係浪費時間, 不過就可見識下乜野叫做"呢d名校嘅咁嘅風範"!!!

作者: BBR 時間: 08-10-14 11:11

咁我要成身名牌去

原帖由 conniengor 於 08-10-14 11:01 發表
Hi mycarrie,

你嘅comment我都有同感,我個女3年前都int過呢間, 唔駛2分鐘出返黎 (3個小朋友共分5分鐘), 個校長企在門口好似scan下d家長先帶小朋友入去int嘅!

記得果日特登攞日大去int, int完後都話自已笨, 簡直係 ...

作者: conniengor 時間: 08-10-14 11:34

梗係啦! 重要帶d架餐喎....哈哈!

作者: Cathleen 時間: 08-10-14 11:45

本來同時間我係撞左女拔同禮賢, 禁我而定都係去禮賢好d啦

作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-10-14 11:49

Anyone got funny things to tell !

//仲有個clerk我都唔知佢係傻定係無知, 有個家長登記時竟然問個cleak呢間學校係咩教??(此問題已經夠經典, 竟然唔查清楚就來interview?)跟住個clerk仲搞笑答:我唔知wor, 係咪天主教ar .....:;pppp:跟住個clerk走去問個登記員至知jar. 簡直嘆為觀止的妙問妙答. //

作者: SandyWu 時間: 08-10-14 11:54

原帖由 Cathleen 於 08-10-14 11:45 發表
本來同時間我係撞左女拔同禮賢, 禁我而定都係去禮賢好d啦

我上年interview既時間成家唔係香港,dgs既interview時間成兩個月,kum都撞正,所以咪give up左,反正都明知係陪跑,之後我囡認識既小朋友中,interview完後都同大家既感受一樣,得個2分鐘見到d咩呢

作者: YongXin 時間: 08-10-14 12:14

舊年仲好笑，BK呢度有朋友開topic，研究呀校長出來叫小朋友入校長室interview時，眼尾有無望各位爸爸，來估計收唔收個女呀！有望個老豆0個0的，網友估好似機會大0的0窩

真係有創意，我地0的網友！

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 12:17

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-14 12:23

我相信以全面的評估，才會減低錯配的問題。

原帖由 wisekid2007 於 08-10-14 12:17 發表
I remembered my boy's year 1 interview at GSIS that the whole interview process lasted for almost 1 hours, including reading a few books, answering questions, verbal Maths, free drawing and free writi ...

作者: Geni 時間: 08-10-14 12:25

我有個朋友就有個相反o既經歷, 俾成$200 面試費, in o左成1.5hr, 個女in完出o黎話好悶, 之後每次in都問係咪仲係去上次"好悶"o個間, 係就唔去. 我就同佢講都幾底吖, $200 / 1.5hr, 底過去playgroup

作者: LS+MCS 時間: 08-10-14 12:30

Interview is just a kind of formality. The principal has already in mind who are the girls to be enrolled.

作者: conniengor 時間: 08-10-14 12:35

Geni,

點解會比$200.-?????

作者: 囝囝爸 時間: 08-10-14 12:36

記得往年女拔面試, 有報導稱是校長每個學生見約3分鐘.  現在有2分半鐘, 都唔錯了.

女拔是否有千幾二千人報讀?  我以前都計過數, 如二千人見哂計埋間塲時間, 大大話話約要一百個鐘.  每日見五個鐘都要十幾廿日.  校長都是血肉之軀,  頭一二年對面試會趣味央然, 年年係咁都幾難頂.  老師職員身為大場面咖哩啡, 除陪塲外事前事後仲多手尾跟.  所以偶有態度不恭乃人之常情, 所以家長亦應以禮待之, 以免令好老師好職員流失.

遊戲規則係咁玩, 大家都要造作公平認真, 唯有有苦自家知.  但選擇準則, 可能出人意表, 或早已暗藏玄機.

作者: Geni 時間: 08-10-14 12:45

我唔係講女拔要俾$200, 係另一間. 至於點解要收成$200, 我就唔知o勒~~

原帖由 conniengor 於 08-10-14 12:35 發表
Geni,

點解會比$200.-?????

作者: conniengor 時間: 08-10-14 12:50

Geni,

oh, i see!

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-10-14 12:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 13:07

I think every parents who join DGJS's Interview becos they want their kids to study there. So... join game then have to follow their rules no matter its fair or not. You have rights to choose not to join. So take it easy, this school not accept yr kid..i believe still have at least one will accept yr kid.

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 13:23

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-10-14 13:27

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 13:36

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: MY2GIRL 時間: 08-10-14 14:23

如果好似你地所講既 DGJS INTERVIEW 既方式可能校長真係有特異功能間到佢想要既學生o
咁我仲帶唔帶個女去 interview 好呢, 因為特燈請假去陪跑, 玩3分鐘之後落選 ...... ???

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 14:25

Hm..i will think of cos try la..otherwise..u may feel regret later why dont bring daughter to try.. me too.

原帖由 MY2GIRL 於 08-10-14 14:23 發表
如果好似你地所講既 DGJS INTERVIEW 既方式可能校長真係有特異功能間到佢想要既學生o
咁我仲帶唔帶個女去 interview 好呢, 因為特燈請假去陪跑, 玩3分鐘之後落選 ...... ??? ...

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 14:26

but ofcos..less competitors..increase chance

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-14 14:31

我都相信他們的優先權一定落入以下人仕：

-家庭背景，我認識一位當大學教授的女孩，可成功考入
-孩子的特別成就，記住是成就，如全港公開賽冠軍之類

真人真事一樁。曾有一名泳界好手成功插入女拔，但後來身體不適，醫生說不宜游泳，但學生成績乃中中下下，立刻被老師揶揄，「當天學校收妳，就是因為游泳了得，現在學校應如何對待妳。」學生現在是否仍在女拔，就不得而知了。

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 14:34

Hm i still believe every school got their own special outstanding things... like we like different brands..must becos different reasons. I wont say which school not good..but if choose to apply means u think these schools are matched w ur criteria..

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-14 14:31 發表
我都相信他們的優先權一定落入以下人仕：

-家庭背景，我認識一位當大學教授的女孩，可成功考入
-孩子的特別成就，記住是成就，如全港公開賽冠軍之類

真人真事一樁。曾有一名泳界好手成功插入女拔，但後來身體不適，醫生說不宜游 ...

作者: ysnmama 時間: 08-10-14 15:11

若是真....這學校真是社會的縮影 - 現實

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-14 14:31 發表
我都相信他們的優先權一定落入以下人仕：

-家庭背景，我認識一位當大學教授的女孩，可成功考入
-孩子的特別成就，記住是成就，如全港公開賽冠軍之類

真人真事一樁。曾有一名泳界好手成功插入女拔，但後來身體不適，醫生說不宜游 ...

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-14 15:16

其實傳統名校之中，有些是較aggressive，如DGS, DBS，亦有些是較humble的，如SPCC。校風各有不同，各取所需啦！

原帖由 rabbit 於 08-10-14 14:34 發表
Hm i still believe every school got their own special outstanding things... like we like different brands..must becos different reasons. I wont say which school not good..but if choose to apply means ...

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-14 15:27

真人真事之二，一名乒乓球高手（小學）因經常練習及比賽，有時更需要走堂參加比賽，父母擔心會影響孩子學業，所以要求學校作特別安排，派老師為孩子補課，原校不予答允。後來，該家長安排孩子轉校到男拔，得咗，聽聞學校亦答允其特別安排的要求。

原帖由 ysnmama 於 08-10-14 15:11 發表
若是真....這學校真是社會的縮影 - 現實

作者: Smalljokerbb 時間: 08-10-14 15:37

原帖由 wisekid2007 於 08-10-14 13:36 發表
DGS is famous to produce "女強人", very tough and with highly competitive characters that are not so welcome by others especially men. Therefore, there is a rumour (may be just a joke and please don't take it serious) that there are over 30% DGS graduates cannot find a husband throughout their lifes

Actually, after 20-30 years, not only 30% DGS graduates can't find husband..... Because of the ratio of male/famale, I think 30% HK girls can't find husband too!

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 15:39

yes agreed.

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-14 15:16 發表
其實傳統名校之中，有些是較aggressive，如DGS, DBS，亦有些是較humble的，如SPCC。校風各有不同，各取所需啦！

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 15:46

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: E.D. 時間: 08-10-14 16:04

All parents....pls don't forget the profolio that you provided. It is showing what you did and you provided for your kids. DGJS is good a school so they are very profession on selecting a right girl. The basic requirement is......you can/should provide more for your kids other than academic!!!! Understand.

Game is game, rule is rule.....just like the society. You can play or not....however, you must follow the rule if you play. Are you totally agree the opinion from you boss? If not, why you are still there.....That's it.

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 16:48

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: E.D. 時間: 08-10-14 17:05

Good or bad is totally depending on your point of view!!!!! Have you apply DGJS? If yes, why? If not....you can say DGJS is not good enough because it is not "the cup of tea" for you.

Example: Do you thing "Jacky Chan" is good/successful man? He got a lot of reward but his family life is totally failed. He is good but he also bad....just depends!!!!

原帖由 wisekid2007 於 08-10-14 16:48 發表
***DGJS is good a school ***

Good??? In what way?

Is it the way it teases those students who no longer be able to gain fame for the school?

Is it the way it ignores its own mediocre students?

I ...

作者: ysnmama 時間: 08-10-14 17:08

其實我也相信DGJS 是 "good school". 因為他們如果懂選擇"好"的家庭背景, "好"的家長(專業), "好"的學生(如有優秀技能).多個"好"加起便可以變成"good school". 若是真的話, 這樣豈不是好家庭好家長好學生打造成好學校多於好學校打造成好學生?! 但它仍是很多家長的"夢想".

[ 本帖最後由 ysnmama 於 08-10-14 17:11 編輯 ]

作者: AliJasEd 時間: 08-10-14 17:12

My kid is also involving in the game this year. I think there is no perfect system that makes everybody happy. As parents are discussing about the interview process of DGJS here, I am sure that we all know how to do searching in the internet. Honestly speaking DGJS does not change a lot in term of the interview process this year and such in interview process had been discussed in bk in the past and I am sure many of the parents have known such process before they have brought their kids to the interview or even before they made the application. If you do not feel comfortable with the process, then don't go. Otherwise, just trust your kids. Blame is not going to help as we can't change. Be positive and your kids should be able to find a suitable school.

作者: SmallTungmama 時間: 08-10-14 17:13

一個願打, 一個願捱, 你情我願, 相信絕大部份去Interview 的家長都清楚DGJS interview 的模式, 收與唔收都是 In 3 min, 亦唔會有人有特權可以In 多幾分鐘, result 一日未公報, 都唔知自己個女得唔得, 每年成2千人申請, 只收105人, 無錯, 真系唔得的比得多好多. 但亦可以用另一個角度去睇, 起碼小朋友都能夠有3min的時間見到校長, 而一些用一個多小時去in的模式, 可能跟本就無機會見校長, 但校長是最有權去收生的人, 每間學校都有自己要的學生, 亦有自己的一套選人的方式. 放鬆心情, 話唔定有意外收穫. 香港好的學校多的是, 每人心中都有自己心中的名校, 希望各位今年考小學的都能夠找到自己心目中的好學校.

原帖由 wisekid2007 於 08-10-14 16:48 發表
***DGJS is good a school ***

Good??? In what way?

Is it the way it teases those students who no longer be able to gain fame for the school?

Is it the way it ignores its own mediocre students?

I ...

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 17:31

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: tingtingting 時間: 08-10-14 17:32

Hypocrisy is it that DGSJ puts up a big show and tells eveybody that they welcome everybody and judge everybody fairly, but deep inside they know it full well that they only want kids from the privileged class and those who are of use to the school.

作者: sunkist-lime 時間: 08-10-14 17:33

好想問問是不是一定由校長見?
因為個女話佢只係同一位老師談話, 完畢就坐下來看圖書, 而另一個女孩就見完老師再同校長談話.
想知是否這樣的?是否代表我個女都唔洗望?

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 17:35

agreed. We also got different point of views on schools..which is good or not for kids.. we all have freedom to choose. some good in my mind but maybe vice verse on you. So...no need to fight what's good n what's bad. If you applied means you agreed with their teaching theory..

just like we go for interview.. u succeeded maybe i'm failed.. dont think i'm below the standard..maybe just cant match what the employer needs...

原帖由 SmallTungmama 於 08-10-14 17:13 發表
一個願打, 一個願捱, 你情我願, 相信絕大部份去Interview 的家長都清楚DGJS interview 的模式, 收與唔收都是 In 3 min, 亦唔會有人有特權可以In 多幾分鐘, result 一日未公報, 都唔知自己個女得唔得, 每年成2千人申 ...

[ 本帖最後由 rabbit 於 08-10-14 17:38 編輯 ]

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 17:37

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: E.D. 時間: 08-10-14 17:40

totally agree....."一個願打, 一個願捱, 你情我願" this is the major point!!!!!

If the parents don't like or interest to DGJS, why you access this topic? For example, I have no interest to some particular schools so I never access those topics in BK.

If you want to apply DGJS, you need to follow the rule even you don't like it.

原帖由 SmallTungmama 於 08-10-14 17:13 發表
一個願打, 一個願捱, 你情我願, 相信絕大部份去Interview 的家長都清楚DGJS interview 的模式, 收與唔收都是 In 3 min, 亦唔會有人有特權可以In 多幾分鐘, result 一日未公報, 都唔知自己個女得唔得, 每年成2千人申 ...

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-10-14 17:41

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 17:46

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 17:47

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 17:48

I still believe...applied ofcos should go for interview no matter what comments about the school. If u cant have a firm mind...then how to teach/guide ur kids?

Of cos school always got some good AND bad comments...never ONLY good good good, no one is perfect.. Principal also a human only. Before we applied the schools for kids...SURE everyone should read their theory on websites.

Anyway.. just stick to yr 宗旨, a lot of 以訛傳訛, 以偏概全. We cant sure all news are correct but at least trust what u choose..I think its enough!

[ 本帖最後由 rabbit 於 08-10-14 17:49 編輯 ]

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-14 17:52

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-14 17:53

yes everyone here same thought - expressing their own feelings.

原帖由 wisekid2007 於 08-10-14 17:52 發表
Of course, there are many cases that there would be no absolute right or wrong, good or bad.

I am just expressing my personal values here while we can have a look on what others' values too.

作者: Yau_Cheung 時間: 08-10-14 21:40

Agree. The interview is not a genuine assessment. The most important is RELATIONSHIP & BACKGROUND!!

原帖由 stjoboldboy 於 08-10-14 12:55 發表

Equally funny that some DGJS fans here insisted the Principal could really make a genuine assessment and selected the girls by their performance within this lousy 2-3 minutes interview.

作者: BBauntie 時間: 08-10-14 21:44

想問一問咁多位，如果萬一 DGJS 真係收咗你地，你地會唔會讀呢？定係會放棄呢？

原帖由 Yau_Cheung 於 08-10-14 21:40 發表
Agree. The interview is not a genuine assessment. The most important is RELATIONSHIP & BACKGROUND!!

作者: Yau_Cheung 時間: 08-10-14 21:47

原帖由 wisekid2007 於 08-10-14 17:31 發表
Of course, I haven't applied DGJS for my BOY!!!

I also haven't applied DBS for my boy too because the philosophy in education in both DBS and DGJS has certain extent of similarities of which I don't ...

作者: Yau_Cheung 時間: 08-10-14 21:49

原帖由 tingtingting 於 08-10-14 17:32 發表
Hypocrisy is it that DGSJ puts up a big show and tells eveybody that they welcome everybody and judge everybody fairly, but deep inside they know it full well that they only want kids from the privile ...

作者: Yau_Cheung 時間: 08-10-14 21:57

Good luck! Hope your girl will not be unable to gain fame for the school. Hope your gril will not be mediocre student. Hope your girl will not be less capable student.

原帖由 E.D. 於 08-10-14 17:40 發表
totally agree....."一個願打, 一個願捱, 你情我願" this is the major point!!!!!

If the parents don't like or interest to DGJS, why you access this topic? For example, I have no interest to some partic ...

作者: okokdad 時間: 08-10-14 22:01

Of course, I will let my daughter to try

!!
But I think it may be dreaming

that my daughter can go into DGJS. My daughter only answer several simple questions and get out. I think.....

原帖由 BBauntie 於 08-10-14 21:44 發表
想問一問咁多位，如果萬一 DGJS 真係收咗你地，你地會唔會讀呢？定係會放棄呢？

作者: smartcar 時間: 08-10-14 22:12

即係咁:夠好多人話LV d sales串,白鴿眼同無禮貌啦, 咪一樣都有好多人甘心命抵比好唔值既價錢去換取名牌效應囉!虛榮心囉!
又即係:用100蚊買3mins希望=買六合彩,中左當然開心;唔中,都不必太在意!
DGJS有魅力吸引咁多家長,也有能力摧谷學生(or摧谷家長),亦明白市場需要,不斷推出有noise既產品(既學生),抵佢有今天的成功既!!

作者: aniwong 時間: 08-10-14 23:48

very good comments! Perfect!

原帖由 smartcar 於 08-10-14 22:12 發表
即係咁:夠好多人話LV d sales串,白鴿眼同無禮貌啦, 咪一樣都有好多人甘心命抵比好唔值既價錢去換取名牌效應囉!虛榮心囉!
又即係:用100蚊買3mins希望=買六合彩,中左當然開心;唔中,都不必太在意!
DGJS有魅力吸引咁多家 ...

作者: Pianokc 時間: 08-10-15 00:05

But Mrs Dai is infamous for her "fairness" in choosing girls for entry into the school.

I know of cases where the parents are doctors, Mother is old girl, but the daughter STILL did not get in.

A girl from a simple family, mother housewife, father in banking, no relationship.... from not St. Cat, Kentville, or CCKG. got chosen!

Don't read too much into the factors affecting the DGJS interview, just ask our daughter to TRY HER BEST, and we as parents, try OUR best !!! (Not breast) ....hahahaha.

原帖由 aniwong 於 08-10-14 23:48 發表
very good comments! Perfect!

作者: juniorpam 時間: 08-10-15 00:14 標題: DGS

If there are choices to consider, DGS may be set as the low priority.

原帖由 BBauntie 於 08-10-14 21:44 發表
想問一問咁多位，如果萬一 DGJS 真係收咗你地，你地會唔會讀呢？定係會放棄呢？

作者: Heiyingleefamil 時間: 08-10-15 00:17

作者: SmallTungmama 時間: 08-10-15 08:36

當你去見工時, 公司搵個人同你做一個多小時測試, 另外一間個老闆親自用幾分面見你, 難道老闆親自面見沒有誠意嗎? 面試時間的長短絕對同認真不成正比, 每間學校要求的人不同, 面試的方式亦不一樣, 沒有對錯, 正如每個家長耍求的理想也不一樣. 我只是發表下自己的意見咋, 唔好駡我.

原帖由 stjoboldboy 於 08-10-14 17:41 發表

你又幾好笑, 講到好似dgjs個校長係天王巨星, 或者咩政要人物, 見到佢3min d家長都執到咁.

要去個interview, d小朋友要請假, d返工既家長要請假, 我諗佢地唔會在乎見到邊個, 佢地只會在乎有無一個認真既intervie ...

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-10-15 09:00

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Reximom 時間: 08-10-15 09:29

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: SmallTungmama 時間: 08-10-15 09:58

如果所有學校面見小朋友時都面見家長的話, 相信一定大大減少錯配情況.

原帖由 stjoboldboy 於 08-10-15 09:00 發表

我諗你要搞清楚,
“公司搵個人同你做一個多小時測試, 另外一間個老闆親自用幾分面見你,”

依家dgjs個case係無人同你做過”一個多小時測試”, 只有個老闆用2-3分鐘同你面見, 我諗無一間公司會咁請人lor!
如果見工 ...

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-15 10:31

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-15 10:34

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Felicia726 時間: 08-10-15 11:01

Yes, Reximom, I only asked my friend in overseas to buy LV for me as I need good customer service when shopping which I can't find it in LV shops. In HK, I like to buy handbags in BV, BV bags are made of leather, better than the thick plastic LV bags. haha.

原帖由 Reximom 於 08-10-15 09:29 發表

可能你屬虛榮心重個類, 所以係咁諗姐!

有好多人見識過LV d sales點串, 自始從不去LV!

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-15 11:14

Besides of the quality, the customer service of BV is superb. There are some elite schools could strike a good balance in academy and philosophy.

原帖由 Felicia726 於 08-10-15 11:01 發表
Yes, Reximom, I only asked my friend in overseas to buy LV for me as I need good customer service when shopping which I can't find it in LV shops. In HK, I like to buy handbags in BV, BV bags are made ...

作者: E.D. 時間: 08-10-15 11:18

So...don't keep chat on this topic (DGJS) lar. It wastes you time!!!!!!

I am wondering....how come so many people don't like DGJS but keep chatting here? Spend more time on you kids lar...

原帖由 Reximom 於 08-10-15 09:29 發表

可能你屬虛榮心重個類, 所以係咁諗姐!

有好多人見識過LV d sales點串, 自始從不去LV!

作者: Reximom 時間: 08-10-15 11:33

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-15 11:42

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: E.D. 時間: 08-10-15 11:49

ok...good luck!!! I trust your character can train up a super kid.

Frankly, I should say thank you. If no people like you....HK has no people to support the low level at the society (無文化).

原帖由 Reximom 於 08-10-15 11:33 發表

你真攪笑, 要like 個topic先可以係度chat得個咩? 你係BK老細呀?

我鍾意chat mug 就chat mug, 關你咩事!

聽講開topic個樓主都唔多like dgjs個播!

我個kid幾自動波, 我又想train佢既自學能力, 唔使Spend ...

作者: E.D. 時間: 08-10-15 11:50

Thank you for the advice.

原帖由 wisekid2007 於 08-10-15 11:42 發表
Just let you and others know that DGJS/DGS is not really so "GOOD" as you think.

作者: Reximom 時間: 08-10-15 11:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: tsanfamily 時間: 08-10-15 12:02

to Wisekid2007

I agree with u, what kind of school u like,

I want my kid can study in a school that can help her/him to develope her ability and explore her view of life...not just 'vanity and successful' in life.

i found most of the new DDS school has the same idea of mine. but the not well'-known and famous one, as they have to maintain their 'goodwill' so uncapable to afford change....

what do u think?

作者: rabbit 時間: 08-10-15 12:11

anyway..道不同不相為謀. Every Moms will choose the best for their kids.

作者: SmallTungmama 時間: 08-10-15 12:17

E.D.
你現在知道點解我說學校In 小朋友時都要In 家長, 睇到家長才真正了解小朋友.

原帖由 E.D. 於 08-10-15 11:49 發表
ok...good luck!!! I trust your character can train up a super kid.

Frankly, I should say thank you. If no people like you....HK has no people to support the low level at the society (無文化).

...

作者: wisekid2007 時間: 08-10-15 12:30

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)