教育王國

標題: 細仔? [打印本頁]

作者: queensroad 時間: 08-10-31 22:59 標題: 細仔?

我發覺好多學校都唔係好收細仔....你哋有無同感?
請問有幾多細仔係in邊間,邊間都收呢?
我個仔in了十間,依家得一間收,我啲friend又係細仔,到依家一間都無係手,所以,想了解吓係唔係細仔會好蝕呢?

作者: lemonred 時間: 08-10-31 23:12

我好有同感, 但有何辦法, 我不會要亞仔讀多一年k3, 等出年變大仔再考, 我相信有學校會收, 最多抽獎. 現在是蝕底, 但不會蝕好耐.

原帖由 queensroad 於 08-10-31 22:59 發表
我發覺好多學校都唔係好收細仔....你哋有無同感?
請問有幾多細仔係in邊間,邊間都收呢?
我個仔in了十間,依家得一間收,我啲friend又係細仔,到依家一間都無係手,所以,想了解吓係唔係細仔會好蝕呢? ...

作者: rookiemom 時間: 08-10-31 23:14

It is only natural, 細仔can be 6-12 months younger, in the 5-6 years old range, 6 months can make a huge difference.

原帖由 queensroad 於 08-10-31 22:59 發表
我發覺好多學校都唔係好收細仔....你哋有無同感?
請問有幾多細仔係in邊間,邊間都收呢?
我個仔in了十間,依家得一間收,我啲friend又係細仔,到依家一間都無係手,所以,想了解吓係唔係細仔會好蝕呢? ...

作者: IceCrm 時間: 08-10-31 23:31

Yes, it is true. My child is the youngest in her class and her friend was born in the same month. No matter how good they did the interview and they showed confidence, the result is they are not likely to be chosen. I finally woke up.... this reality!

作者: lemonred 時間: 08-10-31 23:34

IceCrm,

Does your girl get any offer?

原帖由 IceCrm 於 08-10-31 23:31 發表
Yes, it is true. My child is the youngest in her class and her friend was born in the same month. No matter how good they did the interview and they showed confidence, the result is they are not likel ...

作者: Geni 時間: 08-10-31 23:41

其實點解一定唔會俾佢遲一年入學呢? 一世受用o家~~

原帖由 lemonred 於 08-10-31 23:12 發表
我好有同感, 但有何辦法, 我不會要亞仔讀多一年k3, 等出年變大仔再考, 我相信有學校會收, 最多抽獎. 現在是蝕底, 但不會蝕好耐.

作者: IceCrm 時間: 08-11-1 01:42

Lemonred,

No offer at the moment... however, waiting for result of GHS, KTS and DGJS (hasn't got interviewed yet), also the gov't allocation. Perhaps I under estimated the 'discrimination of young kids', I didn't enrol many primaries as I only apply for those I would like my daughter to go. God bless....

原帖由 lemonred 於 08-10-31 23:34 發表
IceCrm,

Does your girl get any offer?

作者: rookiemom 時間: 08-11-1 09:55

If my 'small' son is not performing as good as his peers, of course I would let him repeat 1 year. However, my son's performance is above average in kindergarten, he would get bored if repeat 1 year, also he doesn't want to lose his peer friends.

He is doing great in P.1 now!

原帖由 Geni 於 08-10-31 23:41 發表
其實點解一定唔會俾佢遲一年入學呢? 一世受用o家~~

作者: ming2 時間: 08-11-1 10:33

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-11-1 10:49

queensroad

你個小朋友係邊個月? 我e+先至知原來d學校係睇出生日期選B,唔係睇表演.

原帖由 queensroad 於 08-10-31 22:59 發表
我發覺好多學校都唔係好收細仔....你哋有無同感?
請問有幾多細仔係in邊間,邊間都收呢?
我個仔in了十間,依家得一間收,我啲friend又係細仔,到依家一間都無係手,所以,想了解吓係唔係細仔會好蝕呢? ...

作者: lemonred 時間: 08-11-1 10:50

IceCrm,

No offer for my kid at this moment. Same to you waiting. Although he finished the 2nd interview of Ying Wah and performed really excellent during the 2nd interview, I am afraid he may not get the seat as he is a "small" boy. What I need to do is to prepare for the worst -- no offer at the end. Actually, I don't want to wait until June, 2009.

Nice to talk to those parents who also suffer from this realistic treatment.

原帖由 IceCrm 於 08-11-1 01:42 發表
Lemonred,

No offer at the moment... however, waiting for result of GHS, KTS and DGJS (hasn't got interviewed yet), also the gov't allocation. Perhaps I under estimated the 'discrimination of young ki ...

作者: queensroad 時間: 08-11-1 12:08

ming2 :

你覺唔覺得icqm係人都收?
因為我個仔得呢間收......
我稔住讀一年再搵學校

[ 本帖最後由 queensroad 於 08-11-1 12:14 編輯 ]

作者: queensroad 時間: 08-11-1 12:13

catcatmom:
無錯,我都醒覺啦~~
其實間間都暗地裡唔收細仔,女就好啲!
所以,我都心淡,稔住讀一年再搵過小一,

不如又統計吓呀~~

queensroad 仔(OCT) 得一間收

作者: ming2 時間: 08-11-1 13:16

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: queensroad 時間: 08-11-1 13:31

ming2:

我就係問親個個都收,無人被reject先存這個懷疑,我有個朋友被reject係因為考中一,所以我都好想知道小一有無被reject

我都幾鍾意呢間學校校舍

作者: IceCrm 時間: 08-11-1 15:31

lemonred,

As long as YW offered your son the chance of 2nd interview, meaning that they accept your son as a 'small boy'. Chance is high as he performed well.

Wish to hear good news from you. I start to feel exhausted and disappointed about this game and just look forward for 1st round of gov't allocation. I don't want to suffer from heart-attack until June 09.

Wish all kind BK moms can get ideal offer in 2008 too.

原帖由 lemonred 於 08-11-1 10:50 發表
IceCrm,

No offer for my kid at this moment. Same to you waiting. Although he finished the 2nd interview of Ying Wah and performed really excellent during the 2nd interview, I am afraid he may not ge ...

作者: ming2 時間: 08-11-1 19:17

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: queensroad 時間: 08-11-1 23:56

早知有啲咁既問題當初遲一年先入學啦~~
依家好像半桶水咁!!

作者: rookiemom 時間: 08-11-2 11:02

Don't look back! It's not that bad, at least you already have an offer from ICQM, you can also go for govt lottery.

I know some people got rejections from ICQM, so don't think they accept everyone, of course the competition for getting a seat there is not as keen as DBS, DGS etc, but it doesn't mean it's not a good school. I think lots of misconception from parents: if a school is more difficult to get into = it must be a better school.

The important thing is whether that school is suitable to your kids.

原帖由 queensroad 於 08-11-1 23:56 發表
早知有啲咁既問題當初遲一年先入學啦~~
依家好像半桶水咁!!

作者: Crystal111 時間: 08-11-2 12:05

Please excuse my ignorance. Could you pls tell me which school is icqm? What is its full name or chinese name?

Thanks!

原帖由 rookiemom 於 08-11-2 11:02 發表
Don't look back! It's not that bad, at least you already have an offer from ICQM, you can also go for govt lottery.

I know some people got rejections from ICQM, so don't think they accept everyone, o ...

作者: ming2 時間: 08-11-2 18:12

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: eileenycm 時間: 08-11-2 23:18

如果小朋友能力得, 為何要遲一年入學? 只係某校學校認為細囝細女係能力有限, 各樣發展未及年頭出生的小朋友. 我認為呢個可能係事實, 但唔係每一個細囝/囡都係一樣比不上較大的小朋友. 如果佢地係要面見小朋友的話, 而佢地嘅表現又好的話, 應該接受他們無論是大是細. 而我不是要誇耀自己小朋友, 他當然是超級細囝, 佢嘅成績, 信心, 表現係相等於一個小學的學生, 完全唔會輸比大囝, 唯一蝕低就係細囝. 如果 d 學校唔想收細囝, 不如佢地係我地報名時寫出要求, 唔洗家長同小朋友都撲個空. right?

quote]原帖由 Geni 於 08-10-31 23:41 發表

其實點解一定唔會俾佢遲一年入學呢? 一世受用o家~~

[/quote]

作者: LV77 時間: 08-11-3 00:11

Hi all,

我係路過既

我仔都係細仔 (9月尾),但唔係小一生:loveliness:

我唔認為學校專揀大仔 (尤其是小學階段),
但點解多數大仔入圍

講真係5-6歲階段,大家同年,你個係1/2月出世,我個係10或11月出世,相差十個月,
面試表現一定高下立見

我地身邊可能得十個八個
同齡朋友仔比較(唔會覺得自己果個差很多),但各校既校長一見要見幾佰甚至乎二仟申請者,咁你諗細仔係唔係會較“輸蝕 ”!

至於你地話重讀K3 ,我都覺得
小朋友能力可以的話都唔需要啦,反而我識得個小朋友,
為了插班入名校,重讀小一,最終真的成功插班入DXX

請各位唔好氣餒

我認為細仔一定有機會!! 仲有,
就算面試唔成功,各位係大抽獎時再諗清楚點排位,
成功讓仔女可以入讀一間適合既學校! 祝各位順利

作者: mymelody2003 時間: 08-11-3 10:13

囝囝係細仔, 自問他相比"大仔'的程度真係差d, 再加上名校多收大仔也是事實, 再加上就算同月份女仔比男仔叻d, 所以選校唯有隨緣啦, 好講運氣, 但我唔會要囝囝重k3, 因為怕囝囝小學時讀不上才用這機會吧 !

經過今次選小一經驗, 真係唔想升中時重演一次.....

作者: lemonred 時間: 08-11-3 10:59

我想這個細仔不被接受的現象, 可能形成一個新現象,就是媽媽會要9-12月出生的小朋友遲一年才讀幼稚園. 我會學你一樣,不會俾我的細仔重讀k3, 況且他真的每天在進步中. 不過, 不要擔心, 我不相到了升中時, 還會有這現象, 12-13時, 相差10-11個月, 應該不會象現在般分別那樣大. 請努力教你的細仔..

原帖由 mymelody2003 於 08-11-3 10:13 發表
囝囝係細仔, 自問他相比"大仔'的程度真係差d, 再加上名校多收大仔也是事實, 再加上就算同月份女仔比男仔叻d, 所以選校唯有隨緣啦, 好講運氣, 但我唔會要囝囝重k3, 因為怕囝囝小學時讀不上才用這機會吧 !

經過今次 ...

作者: joannespapa 時間: 08-11-3 11:05

我都係過來人，阿仔係02年12月27出世，上年考咗4間直資/私小，只得一間收，不過好好彩係宣小收咗阿仔。各位細仔/細女家長，唔好灰心，如果大抽奬結果唔滿意，到出年9月開學都重有機會叩門架，阿仔有幾個同學都係開咗學先轉過嚟。

阿仔而家係班上第二高嘅男仔，想像唔到如果repeat一年先讀小一個情景會幾突兀

作者: lemonred 時間: 08-11-3 11:31

你個仔好叻, 宣小好難考, 真有鼓舞作用, thanks.

原帖由 joannespapa 於 08-11-3 11:05 發表
我都係過來人，阿仔係02年12月27出世，上年考咗4間直資/私小，只得一間收，不過好好彩係宣小收咗阿仔。各位細仔/細女家長，唔好灰心，如果大抽奬結果唔滿意，到出年9月開學都重有機會叩門架，阿仔有幾個同學都係開咗學先轉過嚟。

阿 ...

作者: joannespapa 時間: 08-11-3 11:38

唔使客氣，其實阿仔唔算特別叻，可能係interview臨場表現不過不失掛。而家返小一嘅最大問題都係專注力唔夠，可能呢個係細仔嘅弱點，不過未至於話應付唔到。

原帖由 lemonred 於 08-11-3 11:31 發表

你個仔好叻, 宣小好難考, 真有鼓舞作用, thanks.

作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-11-3 11:43

queensroad

音小都好好, 仲係全英文私校, 如果比佢再讀k3, 你要同佢轉kinder, 其實小一課程都好淺(除了某幾間出名深既之外.) 如果小朋友跟得到, 無謂"size"時間.

一鳥在手, 勝過百鳥在林, 你都有一鳥在手.我係"0"鳥在手, 而且私校仲可以抽, 入了優質津校, 好過好多直資小學+!

如果細仔細女都收既, 暫時我知道係陳守仁同優才, 兩間都一定唔理既!我老公4個同事小朋友去考陳守仁, 3個已reject, 應該係大仔, 我11月B 已殺入2nd, 雖然必收, 但証明幾個陳守仁媽咪講既野無錯!

我知你之前考個間唔收, 唔係亞仔表現唔好, 係表現好好都唔收, 佢地要收大仔先.

唔灰心! 我個街坊好9笑, 佢個仔係細細仔12月, 讀緊nursery,去考k1九龍塘幼稚園,點知亞爸9錯了, 插班去k2, 之後去九龍塘宣小,宣小唔收, 9月開學,宣小有位,叫佢去, e+p6啦! 全班2-4名,出年考皇仁啦!

原帖由 queensroad 於 08-11-1 12:13 發表
catcatmom:
無錯,我都醒覺啦~~
其實間間都暗地裡唔收細仔,女就好啲!
所以,我都心淡,稔住讀一年再搵過小一,

不如又統計吓呀~~

queensroad 仔(OCT) 得一間收 ...

[ 本帖最後由 catcatmom 於 08-11-3 11:50 編輯 ]

作者: lemonred 時間: 08-11-3 12:12

無錯, 我都覺專注力唔夠係細仔的問題, 所以我以盡力改變他這方面的問題, 已有好轉.

原帖由 joannespapa 於 08-11-3 11:38 發表
唔使客氣，其實阿仔唔算特別叻，可能係interview臨場表現不過不失掛。而家返小一嘅最大問題都係專注力唔夠，可能呢個係細仔嘅弱點，不過未至於話應付唔到。

...

作者: Ng360 時間: 08-11-3 14:08

I wanna say that I have the same problem.

My son is small boy but accept by KV in K1 now, he is the youngest in class and I used to think to shift another kinder like SC, CCKG next year by letting him to repeat one year. However, my son is really enjoy in KV and KV teachers are just so nice and I didn't made up my mind to shift.

Now, I am worrying about his path. If he continues to study in KV for 3 years, he is the small boy in P.1. I don't wanna let him repeat in primary because I think he would have hard feeling by then.

For those parents would like to apply the second year for primary, can I ask:

1. Is it ok to apply lucky draw again?
2. Will the private school consider and have bigger chance when they know you are applied for 2nd year already?
3. What did you let your kid do in the repeat K3? In case you are not in the same school?

Thanks for the answer.

作者: joannespapa 時間: 08-11-3 16:02

我是路過的，據我所知大抽獎只能參加一次。

不知你小朋友在KV的成績怎樣？個人覺得不需要太早下定論決定是否要重讀，除非學習上真的有很大困難，相信到時老師亦會主動向家長提出建議小朋友重讀。

不用担心細仔考小一時會輸蝕，KV應該在學術上有質量保證，老師會覺得KV出來的學生“好教啲”。

原帖由 Ng360 於 08-11-3 14:08 發表

I wanna say that I have the same problem.

My son is small boy but accept by KV in K1 now, he is the youngest in class and I used to think to shift another kinder like SC, CCKG next year by letting h ...

作者: ericby 時間: 08-11-5 11:41

重讀K3 support

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)