教育王國

標題: 根德園同St. Catherine都收讀K1點算好? [打印本頁]

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 17:53 標題: 根德園同St. Catherine都收讀K1點算好?

根德園同St. Catherine都收Joshua讀K1點算好?

作者: BoBo1 時間: 08-12-3 18:20

我都係兩間收左a.m. class.

如果係男仔應該選KV, 如果係女仔應該選St. Cat, 因為只係我個人意見，不過St. Cat好全面，樣樣都好平均，KV就會讀得辛苦d, 無咩課外活動．

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 18:41 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

謝謝意見,我知道响我嘅情況,KV會係比較識合我小孩,但我想知道我會唔會對SC比較注重英文的優點外,仲有一些優點我係唔知道呢.而依D優點對我小孩是否有幫助呢?因我想小心作出選擇.所有希望知道大家作出選擇的原因.

作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-3 18:50

原帖由 jennychin 於 08-12-3 18:41 發表
謝謝意見,我知道响我嘅情況,KV會係比較識合我小孩,但我想知道我會唔會對SC比較注重英文的優點外,仲有一些優點我係唔知道呢.而依D優點對我小孩是否有幫助呢?因我想小心作出選擇.所有希望知道大家作出選擇的原因. ...

哈哈,點解你原文quote我嘅回應出嚟嘅???

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 18:54

原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 18:50 發表

哈哈,點解你原文quote我嘅回應出嚟嘅???

sorry la as same as u ma...

作者: 小程程 時間: 08-12-3 18:54

之前諗住考完真係收先算,而家好好彩地兩間都收am,我同老公都要開始好好study依兩間學校.

bobo1,點解你會講男仔應該讀kv既?可以俾d意見我嘛?

作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-3 18:56

haha, no need to say sorry. I just wonder may be you have the same situation as me.

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 18:59

原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 18:56 發表
haha, no need to say sorry. I just wonder may be you have the same situation as me.

so any decision? actually i prefer kv.

作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-3 19:05

As i mentioned from the other thread, my kid is suitable for KV, but i just like to hear more comments about selecting SC. At this moment, 95% for me KV la. My kid is very impolite, lack of discipline, well behaved in school but not at home. Very tough character. I'm sure she will have no problem in KV

作者: bebegirl 時間: 08-12-3 19:08

我都係，好好彩兩間都收o左亞仔，我自己住得較遠，所以兩間都只申請o左pm，而St. Cat就取錄了英普班！我自己又想亞仔讀得開心，又想亞仔英文好，又想佢接到小學課程，中數好，所以真係好頭痛！今日仲知道創價都收佢，雖然，辦學理念同呢兩間完全不同，但in完覺得d staff同校舍又ok喎，所以都唔知點算好！

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 19:10

原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 19:05 發表
As i mentioned from the other thread, my kid is suitable for KV, but i just like to hear more comments about selecting SC. At this moment, 95% for me KV la. My kid is very impolite, lack of discipline ...

exactly like me, my monster is a boy & i think is worse than yr girl hehe...

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 19:13

原帖由 bebegirl 於 08-12-3 19:08 發表
我都係，好好彩兩間都收o左亞仔，我自己住得較遠，所以兩間都只申請o左pm，而St. Cat就取錄了英普班！我自己又想亞仔讀得開心，又想亞仔英文好，又想佢接到小學課程，中數好，所以真係好頭痛！今日仲知道創價都收佢，雖然，辦學理念同呢兩間 ...

i'm still waiting for soka result but i think i'll choose btw kv & sc

作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-3 19:17

I think if your boy is a tough one, it doesn't matter to let him study in KV. I'm not afraid the school will be supressing kid's creativitity too coz i know my kid's character very well. Just we parents know how to give good supplement and education, I think it's fine to let her study in KV.

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 19:25

原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 19:17 發表
I think if your boy is a tough one, it doesn't matter to let him study in KV. I'm not afraid the school will be supressing kid's creativitity too coz i know my kid's character very well. Just we paren ...

多謝你寶貴意見,我好大機會選擇根德園,但總是心大心細...

作者: KingYiBaBa 時間: 08-12-3 21:48

I think it depends on which 'type' of primary school you prefer...

If study at KV, your kids will be more easy to pick up when they at conventional primary school (e.g. 九龍塘宣小....).

If you prefer the non-conventional one (e.g. 浸會小學, 培橋...), SC will be better.

Just my opinion and experience....

My daughter studied at York (similar approach with SC) but now she and I are very tired to pick up at 九龍塘宣小....

My son is also admitted at KV and SC this time. I think I will choose KV :)

作者: wheels 時間: 08-12-3 22:14

When did u receive the admission letters? I haven't received anything yet. Will I still receive a letter even if rejected?

作者: hcheng 時間: 08-12-3 22:23

原帖由 BoBo1 於 08-12-3 18:20 發表
我都係兩間收左a.m. class.

如果係男仔應該選KV, 如果係女仔應該選St. Cat, .

===>SC will becomes girls' KG and KV will become boys' KG

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 22:44

原帖由 wheels 於 08-12-3 22:14 發表
When did u receive the admission letters? I haven't received anything yet. Will I still receive a letter even if rejected?

i received this afternoon and u better check on tomorrow ... good luck!

作者: qqbby 時間: 08-12-3 23:09

如果係大仔, kv 會好d,因kv 專教大仔，sc 可能教細仔好d

作者: 仔仔錫錫你 時間: 08-12-3 23:13

恭喜晒, 其實你應該好清楚自己個仔性格適合讀邊間. 我個仔比較活躍, 所以外區我剩係報st cat, 因為活動教學中呢間名氣最勁, 其它kln tong 幼稚園我覺得同青衣d幼稚園無咩大分別, 好彩st cat 都收左.

作者: BoBo1 時間: 08-12-3 23:45

小程程,

我覺得如果係大仔入KV會好些，因為中數強，英文就要出去補習，其實我囡囡都比較慢熱，所以希望讀左St. Cat之後佢慢慢改變，我大女讀緊St. Cat K2, 我覺得老師好有愛心，日日返學都好開心，又學到好多野，英文課程好好，St. Cat真係一間好好的學校．

作者: jt0606 時間: 08-12-4 00:35

原帖由 仔仔錫錫你 於 08-12-3 23:13 發表
恭喜晒, 其實你應該好清楚自己個仔性格適合讀邊間. 我個仔比較活躍, 所以外區我剩係報st cat, 因為活動教學中呢間名氣最勁, 其它kln tong 幼稚園我覺得同青衣d幼稚園無咩大分別, 好彩st cat 都收左. ...

Hi, 我都好同意, 我囝囝又係超活潑好動, 我自巳都覺得SC較適合囝囝, 唔知你信唔信呢, 我覺得小朋友都有感覺, in KV 係入門口交form時佢摟計喊到唔肯入, 結果足足遲了一個鐘才入去in, 結果是waitng list 但in SC 反而瞓咗整醒佢, 佢仍然very happy 入去in, 最後SC 收左, 我覺得都係緣份

作者: SCKnight 時間: 08-12-4 02:20

Haha,同我個仔反應都幾似。未入到去KVin已經話想走。個人比較喜歡SC，英文好，老師nice，囝囝又喜歡。但係Honey覺得KV夠傳統，讀完出黎競爭力同適應力較強。長輩鍾意靈糧堂同啟思，宜家仲到拗緊邊間好。咁攪法，未決定入邊間，屋企人可能打大交！

原帖由 jt0606 於 08-12-4 00:35 發表

Hi, 我都好同意, 我囝囝又係超活潑好動, 我自巳都覺得SC較適合囝囝, 唔知你信唔信呢, 我覺得小朋友都有感覺, in KV 係入門口交form時佢摟計喊到唔肯入, 結果足足遲了一個鐘才入去in, 結果是waitng list 但in SC 反 ...

作者: chez 時間: 08-12-4 08:57

各位，我仔仔都好好彩被KV取錄了, 伹我仲未決定讀边間, 因為仔仔好好動, 冇時停, 暫時都未肯聽老師instructions, 亦未戒到片, 所以好擔心唔知KV呢類甘傳统的學校可否包容到 (especially interview 時覺得老師一般, 唔似係好有耐性&愛心) 我係呢度見有其他家長都話自已小朋友好動, 但會揀KV, 点解呢 ? 可否分享吓. Does any one knows if KV can accommodate naughtier kid. I'm afraid that the school will recommend/push us to quit school in the end.

Besides, SCKnight, my son is also accepted by 靈糧堂, which is very different from KV. My husband likes 靈糧堂. Do u know any comments/details about this school ? Thanks.

原帖由 SCKnight 於 08-12-4 02:20 發表
Haha,同我個仔反應都幾似。未入到去KVin已經話想走。個人比較喜歡SC，英文好，老師nice，囝囝又喜歡。但係Honey覺得KV夠傳統，讀完出黎競爭力同適應力較強。長輩鍾意靈糧堂同啟思，宜家仲到拗緊邊間好。咁攪法，未決定入邊間，屋 ...

作者: hyto 時間: 08-12-4 09:36

chez,
意見我就未必比到你...
但我同你既看法完全一樣...:loveliness:

KV---(especially interview 時覺得老師一般, 唔似係好有耐性&愛心)

My husband likes 靈糧堂.

作者: dingdingbb 時間: 08-12-4 10:06

等我又share下先,根據朋友既comments, sc既英文的確係好的, 老師感覺上friendly的,但問過現就讀kv既朋友,佢地都認為kv既老師有佢地對小朋友既一套,佢地覺得在校既老師都好nice,小朋友都讀得好開心,可能大家都比老師面試果日既急趕樣子嚇怕左姐~~希望幫到大家啦~~

作者: ysnmama 時間: 08-12-4 10:22

老師愛心問題. 坦白說, 國際及根德園兩間也收生多, 相對班數也多. 那麼老師也多之下. 愛心程度總有差異. 其實曾聽過兩間有也家長認為沒有愛心的老師.

至於英文. 若希望說方面較強可選擇國際. 若希望寫方面. 可選擇根德園.

作者: 仔仔錫錫你 時間: 08-12-4 10:29

每個父母諗法都唔同, 我報名搵kg 只係從小朋友性格去決定, 所以傳统教學我地一間都無報. 有d父母大包圍, 跟住就諗邊間派位好就入邊間. 有d父母覺得仔仔比較活躍, 諗住讀傳统教學要佢學坐定定; 覺得仔仔較靜就讀活動教學希望佢活潑d. 老實講無話邊個啱邊個唔正確, 只係大家都想比小朋友最好吧.

作者: kitcatchi 時間: 08-12-4 11:11

BoBo1:

你囡囡係咪7/11 3:45pm in 的??? 因為睇你囡囡張相好熟口面呢....

原帖由 BoBo1 於 08-12-3 23:45 發表
小程程,

我覺得如果係大仔入KV會好些，因為中數強，英文就要出去補習，其實我囡囡都比較慢熱，所以希望讀左St. Cat之後佢慢慢改變，我大女讀緊St. Cat K2, 我覺得老師好有愛心，日日返學都好開心，又學到好多野，英文課程好好，St. Ca ...

作者: Belami 時間: 08-12-4 11:28

same as my case, now I choose St. Caterine for my daughter. As SC have more outdoor activities and English teaching is much better than KV.

作者: jt0606 時間: 08-12-4 13:18

剛與曾在幼稚園教的朋友傾, 幾年前St. Cat 每班有30-34人, 雖說會分組上堂, 但仍担心老師未能照顧班上每个小朋友, 未知現況是否一樣, 有冇讀緊St. Cat 嘅媽咪可分响吓?

作者: WanWah 時間: 08-12-4 13:20

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wttclh 時間: 08-12-4 20:45

我好同意.

我見好多家長話小朋友好NAUGHTY, 所以想入KV, 因為夠嚴, 真係要唸清楚, 可能適得其反.

兩年前我小朋友考幼稚園時, 考到KV, 嗰時我都驚我小朋友不合適, 因為佢好NAUGHTY, 不專心, 後來抱住給佢一試的心態, 點知越讀越抗拒, 最後都要轉校. 所以不係間間名校都適合所有小朋友, 亦都不好唸住名校, 就可以改變你的小朋友, 真係要依小朋友的性格去選擇幼稚園.

純粹分享, 如有得罪, 請見諒.

原帖由 WanWah 於 08-12-4 13:20 發表
我有個朋友嘅女讀緊KV - K1, 佢都認為老師較嚴厲, 唔會好似其他KG咁, 咁溫柔咁同佢講說話(用小朋友語氣). 如果識應力強嘅小朋友可能會應付得到. 相反小朋友較'嗲'嘅話, 可能會嚇怕... 所以真係好視乎小朋友本身嘅性 ...

作者: wttclh 時間: 08-12-4 20:47

係呀, 讀得名校幼稚園, 真係不好唸住老師會樣樣跟到足.

原帖由 ysnmama 於 08-12-4 10:22 發表
老師愛心問題. 坦白說, 國際及根德園兩間也收生多, 相對班數也多. 那麼老師也多之下. 愛心程度總有差異. 其實曾聽過兩間有也家長認為沒有愛心的老師.

至於英文. 若希望說方面較強可選擇國際. 若希望寫方面. 可選擇 ...

作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-4 22:11

原帖由 wttclh 於 08-12-4 20:45 發表
我好同意.

我見好多家長話小朋友好NAUGHTY, 所以想入KV, 因為夠嚴, 真係要唸清楚, 可能適得其反.

兩年前我小朋友考幼稚園時, 考到KV, 嗰時我都驚我小朋友不合適, 因為佢好NAUGHTY, 不專心, 後來抱住給佢一試的心態 ...

也不能把工作全交給學校,就算學校點嚴,番到屋企種到個小孩死嘅,咁學校點教都無用啦.小孩一天响學校數小時,不能期望學校識變魔術.最重要都要睇屋企點教嘅,能否配合到學校嘅理念.

作者: SCKnight 時間: 08-12-4 23:41

Which LingLiang KG? LingLiang is one of the KG get HK Education Dept inspection report with good comment. Teachers are well trained and provide good care to kids. It encourages develop Kids talent by enhancing their strength. If not demand for an intensive English skills training, your kid will probably have an enjoyable KG life. KV - 1 comment - no pain no gain, not only to your kid, but also to parents. If you buy traditional education method - discipline & repetive training, please go ahead.

原帖由 chez 於 08-12-4 08:57 發表
各位，我仔仔都好好彩被KV取錄了, 伹我仲未決定讀边間, 因為仔仔好好動, 冇時停, 暫時都未肯聽老師instructions, 亦未戒到片, 所以好擔心唔知KV呢類甘傳统的學校可否包容到 (especially interview 時覺得老師一般, 唔 ...

作者: Janicelobby 時間: 08-12-5 01:08

原帖由 hyto 於 08-12-4 09:36 發表
chez,
意見我就未必比到你...
但我同你既看法完全一樣...:loveliness:

KV---(especially interview 時覺得老師一般, 唔似係好有耐性&愛心)

My husband likes 靈糧堂. ...

why choose 靈糧堂?

作者: rainbowbb 時間: 08-12-5 01:30

KV - traditional school, no outings, start writing in K1 (so no problem with 'big' kid), good for parents that don't have time to study with kids as the school will train the kids to do their homeworks by themselves.

ST. Cat - activity based, starting writing in K2, has phonic class, emphasis on 親子, prefers parents to work with their kids on their homeworks

作者: wttclh 時間: 08-12-5 09:31

就係不想啲家長以為學校會變魔術, 所以先出來分享下.

小朋友naughty, 不代表家長無給心機教.

原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-4 22:11 發表

也不能把工作全交給學校,就算學校點嚴,番到屋企種到個小孩死嘅,咁學校點教都無用啦.小孩一天响學校數小時,不能期望學校識變魔術.最重要都要睇屋企點教嘅,能否配合到學校嘅理念. ...

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-6 11:44

原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 19:17 發表
I think if your boy is a tough one, it doesn't matter to let him study in KV. I'm not afraid the school will be supressing kid's creativitity too coz i know my kid's character very well. Just we paren ...

We've decided to Reg. KV on 13/12 as his mama said kv is more famous & suitable to him. (his mama is a retired teacher) can keep in touch if u choose kv...

[ 本帖最後由 jennychin 於 08-12-6 11:46 編輯 ]

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-6 11:45

原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 19:17 發表
I think if your boy is a tough one, it doesn't matter to let him study in KV. I'm not afraid the school will be supressing kid's creativitity too coz i know my kid's character very well. Just we paren ...

We've decided to Reg. KV on 13/12 as his mama said kv is more famous & suitable to him. (his mama is a retired teacher) can keep in touch if u choose kv...

作者: prosperityyan 時間: 08-12-6 12:48

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: prosperityyan 時間: 08-12-6 12:54

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: prosperityyan 時間: 08-12-6 13:00

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-6 16:26

原帖由 jennychin 於 08-12-6 11:45 發表

We've decided to Reg. KV on 13/12 as his mama said kv is more famous & suitable to him. (his mama is a retired teacher) can keep in touch if u choose kv...

Yes thanks. At this moment we intend to go for KV and will register. However, final decision will not be made until next March. I'm sure your family will make a perfect choice for your little kid.:)

[ 本帖最後由 fishny 於 08-12-6 16:28 編輯 ]

作者: lingpanda 時間: 08-12-6 19:42

Hi,我囡囡讀緊St.Cat k3,佢地係會有30人一班的情況，不過k1有分大仔班和細仔班，通常細仔會是小班得十幾二十個，不過行雙班主任制，其中一個是net teacher。就算我囡囡k2時個班有30人，但他們行多時都分組教學，班房裡會有三個老師，一個是班主任，一個是協作老師，一個是net teacher，所以問題不大，而且我覺得老師好關心囡囡，對她也很了解而且。
其實三年前我都和你們一樣，兩間都收。但最後我都選st.cat，因為st.cat英文程度較好，而且有net teacher，小朋友從小便接觸外籍老師，對他們不會產生恐懼感。有時候去公園玩見到囡囡好樂意和外籍人士說笑，全不恐懼和害羞，我想與他在校已經習慣和外籍老師相處，無不關系。此外，我最喜歡St.cat的閱讀氣氛，他們會鼓勵小朋友看課外書，而且用Oxford Reading Tree來教英文，小朋友不是死記、死背英文，感覺較生活化。
在這兩年半裡，我感覺我囡囡是好享受上學的生活，而且口中經常提及老師和學校的事情，而我自己亦好回味每年的親子旅行、學習日、到班房做協助教學......這些都使我更清楚囡囡在校的情況，讓我們共同有一個甜蜜的回憶！
要選哪間學校給自已的仔女，只有父母自已最清楚，任何一間學校都有人話好和唔好，想一想你想他怎樣、想一想你想他在怎樣的學習環境下學習，然後再問一問他想怎樣，問一問他想在怎樣的學習環境下學習。這樣便有答案了。

原帖由 jt0606 於 08-12-4 13:18 發表
剛與曾在幼稚園教的朋友傾, 幾年前St. Cat 每班有30-34人, 雖說會分組上堂, 但仍担心老師未能照顧班上每个小朋友, 未知現況是否一樣, 有冇讀緊St. Cat 嘅媽咪可分响吓? ...

作者: Cardiff 時間: 08-12-7 17:15

Thanks for your valuable advice! Enjoying learning process is an important element of applying knowledge in our daily life.

作者: jt0606 時間: 08-12-8 00:26

原帖由 lingpanda 於 08-12-6 19:42 發表
Hi,我囡囡讀緊St.Cat k3,佢地係會有30人一班的情況，不過k1有分大仔班和細仔班，通常細仔會是小班得十幾二十個，不過行雙班主任制，其中一個是net teacher。就算我囡囡k2時個班有30人，但他們行多時都分組教學，班房裡會有三個老 ...

Hi, Lingpanda,

好多謝你保貴的分享,我想再請教一吓St.Cat是否很注重家長協助,形式怎樣而次數是否頻密呢?因我是在職媽咪未知能否兼顧得好, 唔該晒!!

作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-15 17:53

原帖由 lingpanda 於 08-12-6 19:42 發表
Hi,我囡囡讀緊St.Cat k3,佢地係會有30人一班的情況，不過k1有分大仔班和細仔班，通常細仔會是小班得十幾二十個，不過行雙班主任制，其中一個是net teacher。就算我囡囡k2時個班有30人，但他們行多時都分組教學，班房裡會有三個老 ...

thank u for the advice! kv & sc both are very good and difficult to make decision...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)