教育王國

標題: 優才聖馬加利選邊間﹖ [打印本頁]

作者: dong-dong 時間: 09-10-20 23:02 標題: 優才聖馬加利選邊間﹖

兩間都收着仔仔﹐選邊間﹖

[ 本帖最後由 dong-dong 於 09-10-21 08:40 編輯 ]

作者: Felixcwt 時間: 09-10-20 23:14

我會揀聖瑪加利,因為佢哋係用英語教學,又注重三文四語,而且辦學年資較長.

作者: coachnewspaper 時間: 09-10-21 00:27

我会揀優才。上年小女幸運地都考獲此两間小學,雖然两間都沒有入讀,但就被優小校長老師對教育的熱誠及培育小孩的方法深深感動,既然你仔仔是資優生,更加適合入讀優小,我所知道學校是資優生雲集,是有系统培育及發掘資優生,亦曾有優小畢業生跳級考獲會考狀元,學生很喜愛上學,最難得是學校不是傳统小學的教學模式但學術成績卓越,老師師資是全港最佳,更是專科專教,視學報告佳,英數程度很高。

原帖由 dong-dong 於 09-10-20 23:02 發表
兩間都收着仔仔﹐選邊間﹖個人比較喜歡聖馬加利外語環境﹐但又喜歡優才教學方法﹐我小朋友是資優生﹐在語言及數學方面都頗有天份﹐如果是你﹐怎樣做選擇﹖ ...

[ 本帖最後由 coachnewspaper 於 09-10-21 10:23 編輯 ]

作者: Rose^^ 時間: 09-10-21 01:14

SMC有良好的外語環境,是一所不錯的學校!

但本人比較喜歡優才的教育理念和特色。
優才小班教學(24人), ,比較着重發展個人興趣和專長，所有小一生須參加多元智能測試，找出其才華所在,設有76班才華班供學生選收(不另收費),加以裁培，學習過程，不重抄寫,無需做大量無謂機械式的功課，重質不重量,讓學生有更多時間閱讀及作課外活動。
專科專教。有多位NET教授英語課，英文程度高，小一有普通話課，循序漸進地由小二開始用普通話教中文。一條龍直升優才中學,如無記錯優中是Band1英文中學!
(如有錯請指正)

作者: dong-dong 時間: 09-10-21 06:31

謝謝﹐我最終選擇去優才留位啦

作者: dabbycheung 時間: 09-10-21 07:23

原帖由 Felixcwt 於 09-10-20 23:14 發表
我會揀聖瑪加利,因為佢哋係用英語教學,又注重三文四語,而且辦學年資較長.

優才辦學年資較長, 已辦學1X年!

作者: fongyuen 時間: 09-10-21 10:29

原帖由 coachnewspaper 於 09-10-21 00:27 發表
我会揀優才。上年小女幸運地都考獲此两間小學,雖然两間都沒有入讀,但就被優小校長老師對教育的熱誠及培育小孩的方法深深感動,既然你仔仔是資優生,更加適合入讀優小,我所知道學校是資優生雲集,是有系统培育及發掘資優 ...

coachnewspaper,

既然優才咁好，深深感動你，咁為何當年不入讀呢？有另一間學校更能深深打動你？可否請教係邊一間學校？

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-10-21 13:56

很高興dong-dong和我的小朋友在來年成為同學。

我個女10月7日去聖瑪加利面試，還未有第二次面試的消息，但我上星期收到優才的取錄信後，已決定不會考慮聖瑪加利的了。

我選擇優才的原因是喜歡這間學校的教學理念，希望小朋友讀得開心，優才是中文學校，但英文程度很高，我擔心若果入讀聖瑪加利的話，中文會比較差。

以上是我個人意見，是針對我女兒作出我選擇。

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-10-21 15:08

其實聖瑪加利都係小班教學(24-28人), 也是較着重發展個人興趣和表達自己意見，學校有不同才華班供學生選收(不另收費), 等學生可以有多元化發展. 學習過程，亦係不重抄寫,重質不重量,讓學生有更多時間閱讀及作課外活動。

學校有多位NET教授英語及不同學科，英文程度高，有20%外籍學生, 所以英語環境好好. 小一開始用普通話教中文。一條龍直升中學. 學校仲可以多學一種外語(法文, 西班牙文, 日文), 都係外籍人士教授.

其實聖瑪加利同樣好注重中文, 只係所有其他科目都用英文教, 咁相對係學到既中文詞彙上會比外面其他官津少一點, 不過呢d係可以係日常生活中累積到返嚟, 我地生活係一個中國人社會, 要學好中文唔難, 所以並唔係聖瑪加利中文較差, 只係針無兩頭利, 想要一個好既英語環境, 中文就要花長一d時間.

[ 本帖最後由 G-Ma 於 09-10-21 15:10 編輯 ]

作者: cylokmum 時間: 09-10-23 13:59

請問ST Margaret小一用普通話教中文, 如果小朋友聽唔明, 老師會唔會用一些廣東話講解呢?

ST Margaret 啲老師是否大部分很有愛心和耐性? 流失量高嗎? 有冇一些專科專教?整體師資如何?

ST Margaret小一家長是否頭幾個星期可以入學校與小朋友一起午餐?

作者: 一家三口 時間: 09-10-23 15:02

原帖由 cylokmum 於 09-10-23 13:59 發表
請問ST Margaret小一用普通話教中文, 如果小朋友聽唔明, 老師會唔會用一些廣東話講解呢?

ST Margaret 啲老師是否大部分很有愛心和耐性? 流失量高嗎? 有冇一些專科專教?整體師資如何?

ST Margaret小一家長是否頭幾 ...

1)小一開初都會用少少廣東話, 但之後就續漸減少.

2) 當然, 有些老師比較嚴. 流失量就不大清楚. 今年學校有部份科目已實行專科專教. 師資可以參考學校網頁. (真係唔係好多學校show 老師的qualification架)

3)今年好似只有9月份可以陪食lunch咋.

作者: 中天英 時間: 09-10-24 01:40

{今年學校有部份科目已實行專科專教}

今年開始? 部份科目?
- 唔知有冇記錯, 貴校既 Comprehensive Review Report, 寫明好多老師係 non-subject trained 喎。

{當然, 有些老師比較嚴. 流失量就不大清楚}

- 老師有幾嚴呀? 流失量有幾多呢?

原帖由 一家三口 於 09-10-23 15:02 發表

1)小一開初都會用少少廣東話, 但之後就續漸減少.

2) 當然, 有些老師比較嚴. 流失量就不大清楚. 今年學校有部份科目已實行專科專教. 師資可以參考學校網頁. (真係唔係好多學校show 老師的qualification架)

3)今 ...

[ 本帖最後由中天英於 09-10-24 01:45 編輯 ]

作者: 中天英 時間: 09-10-24 01:49

請問貴校學術水平如何? 有冇公開試成績參考吓?

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-10-21 15:08 發表
其實聖瑪加利都係小班教學(24-28人), 也是較着重發展個人興趣和表達自己意見，學校有不同才華班供學生選收(不另收費), 等學生可以有多元化發展. 學習過程，亦係不重抄寫,重質不重量,讓學生有更多時間閱讀及作課外活動。
...

作者: jaycee_mami 時間: 09-10-24 07:24

原帖由 中天英 於 09-10-24 01:49 發表
請問貴校學術水平如何? 有冇公開試成績參考吓?

我都想知呀, 成日有家長話聖瑪加利英文好, 多net teachers, 很好奇該校的公開試成績如何.

作者: SumSumBB 時間: 09-10-24 07:48

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 09-10-21 13:56 發表
很高興dong-dong和我的小朋友在來年成為同學。

rachncurtsmom, dong-dong：

很高興我們的小朋友在來年成為同學。

我的小朋友無報考聖馬加利，但就早已心儀優才，現在可以入讀，好開心！:loveliness:

作者: 一家三口 時間: 09-10-24 08:31

原帖由 中天英 於 09-10-24 01:40 發表
{今年學校有部份科目已實行專科專教}

今年開始? 部份科目?
- 唔知有冇記錯, 貴校既 Comprehensive Review Report, 寫明好多老師係 non-subject trained 喎。

{當然, 有些老師比較嚴. 流失量就不大清楚}

- 老師 ...

專科專教, 係一位今年專科教中文科的老師講給我知的. (去年她需要教埋初小數學科)
Comprehensiv Review Report 係早年的報告, 會唔會係老師去左進修呀. 妳可以嘗試入學校網頁, 可以看到老師的qualification. (唔係間間學校有得睇)

http://www.smcesps.edu.hk/staff.php
老師比較嚴, 係可能唔想課堂秩序鬆散.

[ 本帖最後由一家三口於 09-10-24 08:53 編輯 ]

作者: soscso 時間: 09-10-24 10:25

原帖由 Felixcwt 於 09-10-20 23:14 發表
我會揀聖瑪加利,因為佢哋係用英語教學,又注重三文四語,而且辦學年資較長.

If you count 聖瑪加利 from 'Band 5' era, it is longer than 優才.
But if you only count DSS, 優才 should be longer than 聖瑪加利.

作者: lauerica 時間: 09-10-24 11:37 標題: 問題

原帖由 fongyuen 於 09-10-21 10:29 發表

coachnewspaper,

既然優才咁好，深深感動你，咁為何當年不入讀呢？有另一間學校更能深深打動你？可否請教係邊一間學校？

good,question,佢話(老師

師資是全港最佳),係佢先夠膽咁講。

作者: dabbycheung 時間: 09-10-24 13:24

原帖由 lauerica 於 09-10-24 11:37 發表

good,question,佢話(老師http://ads.baby-kingdom.com/www/delivery/avw.php?zoneid=93&cb=12345623&n=a0f73aad師資是全港最佳),係佢先夠膽咁講。

唔係學校自己講, 係幾年前某報做過統計而講既!!!!!!!(當年有晒數據)

不過事隔咁多年, 依家情況仲係唔係咁就唔清楚?

[ 本帖最後由 dabbycheung 於 09-10-24 16:28 編輯 ]

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-10-24 15:15

今年小學部先有第一批學生升上中一, 所以暫時無公開成績.

現時中學中二以上既學生都係街外收生, 並唔係小學直升, 所以成績未必可以作準.

原帖由 中天英 於 09-10-24 01:49 發表
請問貴校學術水平如何? 有冇公開試成績參考吓?

作者: 中天英 時間: 09-10-25 02:34

中文科老師去教數學, 呢D咪係 non-subject trained 囉。

原帖由 一家三口 於 09-10-24 08:31 發表

專科專教, 係一位今年專科教中文科的老師講給我知的. (去年她需要教埋初小數學科)
Comprehensiv Review Report 係早年的報告, 會唔會係老師去左進修呀. 妳可以嘗試入學校網頁, 可以看到老師的qualification. (唔 ...

作者: 中天英 時間: 09-10-25 02:41

好似話因為學費 over 左佢既 budget, 所以忍痛放棄。

原帖由 fongyuen 於 09-10-21 10:29 發表

coachnewspaper,

既然優才咁好，深深感動你，咁為何當年不入讀呢？有另一間學校更能深深打動你？可否請教係邊一間學校？

作者: 一家三口 時間: 09-10-25 08:13

原帖由 中天英 於 09-10-25 02:34 發表
中文科老師去教數學, 呢D咪係 non-subject trained 囉。

中天英,

所以我講, 係今年開始有部份科目專科專教囉, 這位老師今年只係教中文咋. 你可能誤會左啦....

[ 本帖最後由一家三口於 09-10-27 07:00 編輯 ]

作者: tinkerbell2004 時間: 09-10-25 09:55

I have attended the briefing sessions of both schools this year.

For me, I prefer St. Margaret more because I admire the quadrilingual learning environment and the through-train mind.

The school campus of G.T. college is really larger, but the lower forms pupils need to go to the school in Mongkok. I just don't know why they carry out the briefing session in G.T. college instead of the Mongkok campus.

It's just my personal opinion. Please forgive me for making any mistakes, if any.

作者: Felixcwt 時間: 09-10-26 00:21

原帖由 tinkerbell2004 於 09-10-25 09:55 發表
I have attended the briefing sessions of both schools this year.

For me, I prefer St. Margaret more because I admire the quadrilingual learning environment and the through-train mind.

The school c ...

I agreed with tinkerbell !!

作者: edea 時間: 09-10-29 23:49

原帖由 dong-dong 於 09-10-21 06:31 發表
謝謝﹐我最終選擇去優才留位啦

歡迎加入優才大家庭呢!

作者: chichipa 時間: 09-10-30 00:43

The presentation of SMC is good and the language evironment is very attractive too but the interview process give me negative impression.

Firstly, there was no clear procedure or instruction for the interview flow. The staff just issue and gather the questionaire, then gather the children to taket the lift upstairs.

Secondly, they don't show concern on the children. I saw a kid was afraid and cried when he need to left his father to attend the interview, his father didn't know how to do but nobody help them. The staff continued to take all other children into the lift and I didn't see any other staff take follow up action.
After waiting for 30 min, only 2 of the kids 'early' finished the interview. They seems not happy and I think they knew they were not qualified. After 30 min more, a staff took the rest of the children back to us but she went back to the office immediately without saying a word. Nobody told us the interview was finished and when will we get the result.
I have attended interview of so many schools but most of them have better arrangement, at least take care of the 'crying' kids.

GT give me good impression. The headmaster Mr. Chan played with the kids during interview. My kid told me that she likes this school very much.

I feel warm at GT, so I choose GT.

作者: tracytang 時間: 09-10-30 00:53

I will choose 優才.

作者: 中天英 時間: 09-10-30 00:54

你地份視學報告係幾年前寫既喎, 寫明non-subject trained; 你話今年中文開始專科專教, 即係話過去幾年都唔係喇; 只係部份科目專科專教, 其他科目又係唔係呢? 咁出年中文又會唔會專科專教呢?

唔好意思, 問係咁多問題, 我只係想知道貴校既專科專教政策姐。

原帖由 一家三口 於 09-10-25 08:13 發表

中天英,

所以我講, 係今年開始有部份科目專科專教囉, 這位老師今年只係教中文咋. 你可能誤會左啦....

作者: minidanny 時間: 09-10-30 01:02

SMC總算有"呀"遮頭,男拔同St Francis仲差, 要家長及小朋友在烈日當空暴曬....我見到有小朋友喊, 男拔老師都唔理, 只有些"義工小朋友"叫家長攪番好佢情緒再入去.

原帖由 chichipa 於 09-10-30 00:43 發表
The presentation of SMC is good and the language evironment is very attractive too but the interview process give me negative impression.

Firstly, there was no clear procedure or instruction for the ...

作者: chichipa 時間: 09-10-30 01:23 標題: 回覆 30# minidanny 的文章

I saw DGJS, TSL and EC take action immediately to settle the crying children.

作者: 一家三口 時間: 09-10-30 07:03

原帖由 中天英 於 09-10-30 00:54 發表
你地份視學報告係幾年前寫既喎, 寫明non-subject trained; 你話今年中文開始專科專教, 即係話過去幾年都唔係喇; 只係部份科目專科專教, 其他科目又係唔係呢? 咁出年中文又會唔會專科專教呢?

唔好意思, 問係咁多問題 ...

中天英,

Sorry! 你/妳真係太多問題, 我都唔識答你/妳....再加上學校明年或後年或大後年的事我真的不知道, 如果你/妳對SMC的專科專教有趣興, 你/妳或可以抽少少時間, 打去學校問啦, 希望你/妳會揾到答案啦????

SMC 電話 : 2396-6675

[ 本帖最後由一家三口於 09-10-30 09:41 編輯 ]

作者: spiderlily 時間: 09-10-30 09:20

一家三口

Interested parties always learn and understand the school through more constructive means.

The accelerating popularity of the school has revealed in the increasing number of applicants year by year.  Heard from other parents that last year's P6 TSA results was very promising (students are now in S1), showing the efforts put by the school in past years.  This may be why there is a tremedous increase in the number of applications this year (50%+).  Hence, the administration office is overloaded and longer process time is understandable.

Human beings sometimes are quite contradictory.  They may change 180 degree on something when the outcome is not in their favor.

I am very glad to join the SMC family, to know you, G-ma, Yoyocheungma and others...  You all are very helful.  We all know SMC is not a prestigious elite school or the best school in HK but we are well aware of its distinguished advantages and the school has shown to us it is our cup of tea.

原帖由 一家三口 於 09-10-30 07:03 發表

中天英,

Sorry! 你/妳真係太多問題, 我都唔識答你/妳....再加上學校明年或後年或大後年的事我真的不知道, 如果你/妳對SMC的專科專教有趣興, 你/妳或可以有少少時間, 打去學校問啦, 希望你/妳會揾到答案啦????:fu ...

作者: 一家三口 時間: 09-10-30 09:44

原帖由 spiderlily 於 09-10-30 09:20 發表
一家三口

Interested parties always learn and understand the school through more constructive means.

The accelerating popularity of the school has revealed in the increasing number of appli ...

spiderlily,

yes! SMC 正是我要的那杯茶.

好合我口味呀.

[ 本帖最後由一家三口於 09-10-30 09:46 編輯 ]

作者: cylokmum 時間: 09-10-30 09:52

After thoughtful considerations among two schools, I prefer to choose SMC for my daughter.

My daughter has interviewed for 6 schools. I'm fine with SMC's arrangement! My impression for SMC is that the school takes a much longer interview periods (from late Aug to late Oct) and spend so many human resource dealing with the selection process (1 hour group assessment in the 1st interview and individual 2nd interview with vice-principal) because the school really want to find some kids who are suitable for the school. They are more serious in the selection process as compared to other schools (ie use only 10-20 minutes to access and then have final result). For my case, we got fast response from the school. Maybe it is due to my early application in late Aug, that's why many SMC parents reminded us - earlier is better...... Maybe the number of applications is surging during Sept and Oct (I don't know the exact no of applications?) and the administrative office is really overload.....

Anyway, hope those really like SMC can join the big family in the coming year!

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 09-10-30 10:30

想請問優才的旺角校舍是作臨時安排，抑或是永久校舍供小一、二學生之用呢？

作者: edea 時間: 09-10-30 11:15

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 09-10-30 10:30 發表
想請問優才的旺角校舍是作臨時安排，抑或是永久校舍供小一、二學生之用呢？

永久作小一至小三校舍, 除非將來學校能爭取到更大的校舍.

作者: Mimi_Ma 時間: 09-10-30 11:24

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 09-10-30 10:30 發表
想請問優才的旺角校舍是作臨時安排，抑或是永久校舍供小一、二學生之用呢？

應該係永久, 記得幾年前旺角校舍係要殺校的, 後來優才與志潔合併. 才有這間校舍, 但志潔祗有12個課室及音樂室, 優才還要加建才有現在規模.

作者: tinkerbell2004 時間: 09-10-30 13:30

I partially agree with you that there may need some improvements during the procedure for interviews. However, not all the schools can handle the crying children well (I saw a girl cried during the 1st interview in DGJS also and the staff had the similar actions).

Therefore, we shouldn't give the children too much pressure before interview.

原帖由 chichipa 於 09-10-30 00:43 發表
The presentation of SMC is good and the language evironment is very attractive too but the interview process give me negative impression.

Firstly, there was no clear procedure or instruction for the ...

作者: Flying-Man 時間: 09-10-30 13:57

我在 DBS 都遇過唔太好的對待.我幫囝囝交 dbs 申請表時,由排隊攞籌,到正式交表到職員手,成個半鐘 (我之前以為半個攪掂),交完後已人有三急得難頂,由樓上行到樓下,未到鈄路落大街之際,見到個女校工,於是問她"呢度有無女厠",佢一指指向落大街條路,仲一句話"呢到落去啦",真係興到我同佢講"唔該晒"!!! 校工(個別例子??)都串過人??? DBS ge interview process also gave me very very negative impression.

原帖由 chichipa 於 09-10-30 00:43 發表
The presentation of SMC is good and the language evironment is very attractive too but the interview process give me negative impression.

Firstly, there was no clear procedure or instruction for the ...

作者: chichipa 時間: 09-10-30 14:02 標題: 回覆 39# tinkerbell2004 的文章

As a parent, I want to know as much as I can when I visit the school. Interview time is a good opportunity for the school to show their strengths to us. Many schools are very serious on this event, e.g. arrange student helpers, parent volunteers, video, preparing clear instructions and procedures....
When we struggling on choosing schools, we will consider all aspects including the interveiw experience before we make decision.

Hope all kids make perfect match!

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-10-30 14:24

原帖由 Mimi_Ma 於 09-10-30 11:24 發表

應該係永久, 記得幾年前旺角校舍係要殺校的, 後來優才與志潔合併. 才有這間校舍, 但志潔祗有12個課室及音樂室, 優才還要加建才有現在規模.

優才的取錄信附有一份同意書，其中有以下一點：

本人知悉優才書院仍會進行學校合併計劃，地點為將軍澳區或九龍區之校舍，本人亦願意在必要時作校舍調遷，以配合優才書院中小學一條龍計劃。

我問過主任，主任話如果找到新校舍，小學六年會同一間校舍。

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-10-30 14:43

你是做廣告推銷行業的嗎?!

原帖由 coachnewspaper 於 21/10/2009 00:27 發表
我会揀優才。上年小女幸運地都考獲此两間小學,雖然两間都沒有入讀,但就被優小校長老師對教育的熱誠及培育小孩的方法深深感動,既然你仔仔是資優生,更加適合入讀優小,我所知道學校是資優生雲集,是有系统培育及發掘資優 ...

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-10-30 14:51

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-10-30 14:43 發表
你是做廣告推銷行業的嗎?!

可能其他家長在TSL的討論區都想問你同一個問題。

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-10-30 16:03

呢樣真,連大肚婆都有幾個照咁樣晒着等..... :-|

原帖由 minidanny 於 30/10/2009 01:02 發表
SMC總算有"呀"遮頭,男拔同St Francis仲差, 要家長及小朋友在烈日當空暴曬....我見到有小朋友喊, 男拔老師都唔理, 只有些"義工小朋友"叫家長攪番好佢情緒再入去.

...

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-10-30 16:18

ha ha ha!! you are right!!
that's partly my duty of job in the real life...

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 30/10/2009 14:51 發表

可能其他家長在TSL的討論區都想問你同一個問題。

作者: tinkerbell2004 時間: 09-10-30 22:02

Totally agree with you.

原帖由 cylokmum 於 09-10-30 09:52 發表
After thoughtful considerations among two schools, I prefer to choose SMC for my daughter.

My daughter has interviewed for 6 schools. I'm fine with SMC's arrangement! My impression for SMC is that th ...

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-10-30 22:24

所言甚是!!!

原帖由 spiderlily 於 09-10-30 09:20 發表
一家三口

Interested parties always learn and understand the school through more constructive means.

The accelerating popularity of the school has revealed in the increasing number of appli ...

作者: diversity 時間: 09-10-30 22:33

G-Ma, spider & revolving globe

SMC

yeah!

作者: Moonhui 時間: 09-10-31 12:25

想問小朋友係咪要英文好掂先取錄呀! 是否用英文來interview?

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-10-31 19:20

學校一般會收英文底子較好既學生, 會用英文interview.

原帖由 Moonhui 於 09-10-31 12:25 發表
想問小朋友係咪要英文好掂先取錄呀! 是否用英文來interview?

作者: spiderlily 時間: 09-10-31 20:59

G-Ma,

Learnt from my boy's class teacher, they look at both English and Mandarin this year.

作者: diversity 時間: 09-10-31 21:17

原帖由 spiderlily 於 09-10-31 20:59 發表
G-Ma,

Learnt from my boy's class teacher, they look at both English and Mandarin this year.

oh, is that so?? How about French, German, Math, calculus....what a superb school!!

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)