教育王國

標題: 仲未決定到選蘇浙 or St.Catherine, pls help! [打印本頁]

作者: pingu_k 時間: 11-3-19 23:38 標題: 仲未決定到選蘇浙 or St.Catherine, pls help!

蘇浙(local stream) vs St.Catherine (英粵班),仲係決定吾到,點攪???

如果係你,你會選邊間呢? (不用考慮地區)

作者: joeyma 時間: 11-3-20 00:44 標題: 回覆 1# pingu_k 的文章

我大女讀ST cat英普班，車費連學費過五千，連興趣班約8000。細女考到KCS只係400幾，都係英普，我就覺得好抵。當然，如果唔考慮金錢問題，ST cat 相當唔錯。

作者: vlui55 時間: 11-3-20 10:27

will you consider 蘇浙 primary school??? heard that it's not easy to be admitted and both boy n girl of my friend studied at 蘇浙, to me, their language is really good, as i think mandarin is getting more important to them, why not go for 蘇浙 given they have voucher and good in language????
that's only my thought to share with you...

原帖由 pingu_k 於 11-3-19 23:38 發表
蘇浙(local stream) vs St.Catherine (英粵班),仲係決定吾到,點攪???

如果係你,你會選邊間呢? (不用考慮地區)

作者: linushui 時間: 11-3-20 12:43

if location is no a matter to concern, I will choose 蘇浙, KCS只係6xx幾，都係英普，really good.
平時英普都要3-4千. save more 做其他事. 我阿B都考到蘇浙(pm),不過因為沒有nanny bus安排到, 才沒有去register. 我住東九的, 希望其他小朋友快D有offer. 我到現在都念念不忘蘇浙的offer.

作者: pingu_k 時間: 11-3-21 00:30

原帖由 joeyma 於 11-3-20 00:44 發表
我大女讀ST cat英普班，車費連學費過五千，連興趣班約8000。細女考到KCS只係400幾，都係英普，我就覺得好抵。當然，如果唔考慮金錢問題，ST cat 相當唔錯。 ...

金錢問題方面.....雖然負擔到(特別係我只得一個小朋友),不過兩者既$$$方面真係差太遠,所以係諗緊linushui同另外有d support選蘇浙既家長所講,係咪拎蘇浙慳到既$$去學野,得到既效果都會差不多?

其實選蘇浙的話,至少好似"攪掂左"普通話一科; 選St.Cat,我就有少少擔心,我個小朋友會英/普都半桶水(因為我屋企吾係用英文同佢溝通)!

但St.Cat既英文又好多人讚.....而且,有support St.Cat既媽媽又話,St.Cat個名好似響d,將來考學校著數d!不過,如果係考港島區小學,係咪又同樣講法呢?.....

作者: pingu_k 時間: 11-3-21 00:34

原帖由 vlui55 於 11-3-20 10:27 發表
will you consider 蘇浙 primary school??? heard that it's not easy to be admitted and both boy n girl of my friend studied at 蘇浙, to me, their language is really good, as i think mandarin is getting ...

tks for your sharing!你朋友既仔女係讀蘇浙小學?幼稚園?蘇浙小學如果考到都好吾錯呀!!咁當然都會考其他,但如果最終係讀蘇浙小學,我都會好滿意!可惜,而家好似得幾班,好難入得番......

作者: yantabo 時間: 11-3-21 00:48

really no school bus?? have u ask the private school bus?
finally which school u choose??

原帖由 linushui 於 11-3-20 12:43 發表
if location is no a matter to concern, I will choose 蘇浙, KCS只係6xx幾，都係英普，really good.
平時英普都要3-4千. save more 做其他事. 我阿B都考到蘇浙(pm),不過因為沒有nanny bus安排到, 才沒有去register. ...

作者: zooooman 時間: 11-3-21 13:31

我原本亦有KCS offer, TKO 呢邊實在佷難安排交通，無辦法,只好放棄!

作者: linushui 時間: 11-3-21 17:12

Actually I live in 東九龍, there isn't any nanny bus arranged. But there IS "保"姆車 to TKO, I had on-site inspection at 蘇浙, 舒太92393940, try to call, hope this can help.

作者: linushui 時間: 11-3-21 17:14

I have 2 offers, 金巴倫& 浸幼, not yet confirmed
still thinking .

原帖由 yantabo 於 11-3-21 00:48 發表
really no school bus?? have u ask the private school bus?
finally which school u choose??

作者: joeyma 時間: 11-3-21 19:36

I live in east kln, and there has nanny buy point to point from my estate to school.

作者: meimei223 時間: 11-3-21 21:09

Before I also hope can get into st.Cat, after I got the KCS AM offer , I feel much relief even st.Cat just on the waiting list, because I got twins, it is much expensive if studying in St.Cat, now, they are studying in York, I think it is no need to think too much and directly change to KCS,right?

作者: linushui 時間: 11-3-22 08:46

Can you give more information about the nanny bus.

Althought i did not go to register, but I hope I still have a chance to get a seat back.

Thanks a lot.

原帖由 joeyma 於 11-3-21 19:36 發表
I live in east kln, and there has nanny buy point to point from my estate to school.

作者: baby-cj 時間: 11-3-22 11:06

原帖由 meimei223 於 11-3-21 21:09 發表
Before I also hope can get into st.Cat, after I got the KCS AM offer , I feel much relief even st.Cat just on the waiting list, because I got twins, it is much expensive if studying in St.Cat, now, th ...

meimei223, both of your twins got accepted in KCS AM? Feel so happy for you :) Bet they must have done well in the interview.

作者: meimei223 時間: 11-3-22 12:09

When I received the letter, I was so happy,because only a few offer given to them.

Yes, the teacher was so nice and like them very much, keep asking them questions,and tell others they are very smart, I asked my child sing the songs 大象 using Manderine, and my kids they don't know how to speak Cantonese and only using English, teacher asked me to ask them questions using english, but still accept them, I really suprise.  Thus, I found this school is really fair.

At the beginning, she asked the animals, I kept pointing all the animals from the book, my babies answers very fast and accurate, I think have around 20 animals.

After that, I asked teacher to write any english words to test them, she wrote around 4 words, and she suprise they can answers and she found so happy on that.

But finally, she said, oh but your children are so small, I don't know her meaning is her body size so small or the age....thus, I expect another waiting or reject....

作者: hoho_ruby 時間: 11-3-22 13:53

上年我仔仔都係有St Cat AM offer(英粵)及蘇浙 AM offer,最後我都選擇了蘇浙,原因都是學費問題, 蘇浙本身都已是英普,當時我想慳回的學費可以出面再補英文,而且st cat 今年K1 已是過4千,計埋車費真的好貴,唔係俾唔到,而係值唔值! 而且佢年年都加5-10%學費,那K3 那年學費會是什麼情況呢

作者: hoho_ruby 時間: 11-3-22 13:58

另外我是住TKO,校車絕不是問題,因有唯一一間保母車承接 (今年是1200車費),而坦白說保母車的安全帶比校車更安全,因佢是好似BB車安全帶設計。唯一是保母車不可進入學校,而要於校外上落車。

作者: hoho_ruby 時間: 11-3-22 14:01

不過要有心理預備,蘇浙只間好傳統的學校,要是你想tain 小朋友禮貌品德應該無問題,但老師要求嚴格,太活潑四圍走的則不太適合,可能要見家長。

作者: zooooman 時間: 11-3-22 14:29

hoho_ruby
Pls check PM

作者: hoho_ruby 時間: 11-3-22 18:38

原帖由 zooooman 於 11-3-22 14:29 發表
hoho_ruby
Pls check PM

已回覆了

作者: meimei223 時間: 11-3-23 07:46

That's what I want they really learn, I believe EQ is more important than IQ development, probably traditional school is good for a younger children.

原帖由 hoho_ruby 於 11-3-22 14:01 發表
不過要有心理預備,蘇浙只間好傳統的學校,要是你想tain 小朋友禮貌品德應該無問題,但老師要求嚴格,太活潑四圍走的則不太適合,可能要見家長。

作者: Dad-Li 時間: 11-3-23 08:47 標題: St. Catherine is really great!

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cherrieshum 時間: 11-3-23 10:22

如果住在九龍及經濟能力許可，我選St Cat。相反，經濟負擔很大，就無謂勉強了，始終蘇浙也是很好的學校。另外，我覺得作為家長並不一定要為子女選擇最一流的幼稚園，二線也是很好了！

作者: meimei223 時間: 11-3-23 11:55

But st.Cat. is only Eng/Can class, not Eng/Manderine, I think you can teach them good eng by bring him/her to outside playgroup. Many st.Paul kg also no NET,still ok.

作者: newmommy 時間: 11-3-23 12:21

Friendly reminder: Please be reminded that the kids at St Cat has good Eng not (only) because of the English teacher there. A lot of them have many extracurricular activities including phonics, so please, don't think simply SC = Good English!

Both KCS and SC are great schools, and I really don't think one is second tier while another is first tier. It is just that SC parents are relatively much more aggressive and target the top primary schools for the kids and would do a lot for their kids to achieve such goal.

If I were you I would have such headache too!

作者: newmommy 時間: 11-3-23 12:34

for your information and in response to earlier post: SC current K3 fees is about $4237, 10 installment. No other fee except the books and stationery fees about once or twice per year.

作者: morning617 時間: 11-3-23 12:35

joeyma,
我的bb考到蘇浙n班, 知道是間好學校, 但因住在東九龍, 怕沒有保姆車所以還不知去唔去讀 (唔讀好似有啲可惜)...請告知有關保姆車資料 (車程需時多久 / 車資 / 聯絡電話...)
萬分感激

作者: meimei223 時間: 11-3-23 19:24

Do you think KCS is lower level then St.Cat?

作者: joeyma 時間: 11-3-23 19:47

someone post the phone No b4,

舒太 92393940

$1150/月

車程，我唔清楚

[ 本帖最後由 joeyma 於 11-3-23 19:48 編輯 ]

作者: vlui55 時間: 11-3-23 22:56

true true....her elder girl is studying in primary section now and heard that it's really difficult to get in!

原帖由 pingu_k 於 11-3-21 00:34 發表

tks for your sharing!你朋友既仔女係讀蘇浙小學?幼稚園?蘇浙小學如果考到都好吾錯呀!!咁當然都會考其他,但如果最終係讀蘇浙小學,我都會好滿意!可惜,而家好似得幾班,好難入得番...... ...

作者: vlui55 時間: 11-3-23 22:59

in my opinion, i will definitely switch to KCS coz
1) you have twins which is really expensive
2) KCS is famous for mandarin (given it's a school with voucher)

原帖由 meimei223 於 11-3-21 21:09 發表
Before I also hope can get into st.Cat, after I got the KCS AM offer , I feel much relief even st.Cat just on the waiting list, because I got twins, it is much expensive if studying in St.Cat, now, th ...

作者: meimei223 時間: 11-3-23 23:17

Yes,that is true,now, they are studying in York, every month over $10,000.  If including other activities, it is really cost alot.  Before I think only without voucher KG will have NET and manderine.
I really cannot believe have Voucher KG can have such language envirnment to provide to us.

If it is famous, then will be even better, as I know there Primary and Secondary is just so so.

But anywhere I don't have st.cat offer, thus, no need to think, hehe.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)