教育王國

標題: 明慧上午班VS蘇浙下午班 [打印本頁]

作者: teresahsu 時間: 11-7-6 18:45 標題: 明慧上午班VS蘇浙下午班

交佐差不多5000俾明慧先收到蘇浙OFFER, 點算好?! 如果講心怡哽係蘇浙啦, 但我地家住將軍澳, 又冇校車搭, 如果明慧上午班爸爸可以湊返學因為係港鐵站口好方便, 如果返蘇浙只可以搭出面嘅媬姆車, 又唔知安唔安全.....唉好頭痛, 大家點睇?

作者: alicialee1210 時間: 11-7-6 19:02

如果本身都LIKE蘇浙, 當然簡蘇浙啦~

作者: mykate 時間: 11-7-6 20:37

明慧NP - local or int'l?

Local - 唔好啦...

作者: teresahsu 時間: 11-7-8 01:00

但又好唔忍心3歲小朋友長途跋涉搭媬姆車, 其實真係好矛盾, 想佢讀一間好D嘅學校, 到考到啦, 又好多其他因素令妳唔放心...唉

作者: queen_sze 時間: 11-7-8 01:05

我仔讀樓下迦南國際, 又比佢考到金巴倫K2, 星期六要交錢, 都唔知去唔去好!

作者: Sorb 時間: 11-7-8 01:27

Disregarding the issue re transporation.  I will vote for KCS.

Money-wise:  KCS after deducting government coupon, almost equivalent to free education but with a very good language environment.

Campus:  The campus of KCS is not very ideal, but must be much better and more spacious than Ming Wai.

Popularity:  KCS is more famous than Ming Wai

Lastly, KCS is not commercial at all whereas Ming Wai gives me the feeling of quite commercial.

I would not vote for KCS if I were you for one reason:

PM class:  I do not prefer PM class as I think afternoon sleep is important for a kid.

原帖由 queen_sze 於 11-7-8 01:05 發表
我仔讀樓下迦南國際, 又比佢考到金巴倫K2, 星期六要交錢, 都唔知去唔去好!

作者: Firstson 時間: 11-7-8 01:53

揀蘇浙,搭校車...

[ 本帖最後由 Firstson 於 11-7-8 01:56 編輯 ]

作者: teresahsu 時間: 11-7-8 19:04

其實我本人唔BUY明慧架, 當初選佢係因為見佢出來嘅學生小學派位都OK, 同埋買個保險...

蘇浙只有媬姆車...因為校車只有港島線

大家覺得工人湊返學安全D定係坐媬姆車呢(非校車, 所直不能駛入校園)?

作者: Sorb 時間: 11-7-9 01:00

Based on my friends' comment, the 媬姆車 serving KCS students is safe. Class finishes at 11:45am, her girl can reach home in TKO at 12:10pm.

If you ask me, I personally do not suggest children at the age of 3 to ride on school bus nor 媬姆車 by herself. If you have the resource, just let your helper take her to school, unless you don't trust in your helper. I have chosen the later instead of school bus though I live in HK Island and have the school bus.

原帖由 teresahsu 於 11-7-8 19:04 發表
其實我本人唔BUY明慧架, 當初選佢係因為見佢出來嘅學生小學派位都OK, 同埋買個保險...

蘇浙只有媬姆車...因為校車只有港島線

大家覺得工人湊返學安全D定係坐媬姆車呢(非校車, 所直不能駛入校園)? ...

作者: teresahsu 時間: 11-7-10 23:03

100%肯定唔讀明慧, 呢間真係一間超級商業化學校, 已經交佐5000, 今晚發現其中一張通告寫住為保留學位, 8月份之學費將會於6/7自動轉帳繳交, 真係好利普, 欠佐佢架咩, 8月9日先開學, 早成個幾月收學費~~~我個囡而家都讀緊私校, 但絕對唔係用佢地呢D手法咯, 我本人好唔認同, 所以決定放棄! 未見官先打三十板

作者: meimei223 時間: 11-7-11 01:56

No need to think, KCS, Ming Wai is relatively easy to get in.

作者: mykate 時間: 11-7-11 10:08

要退學唔讀仲嘔血!

6月中已經書面通知唔上 K1~
學費要收到7月31日!!!
咁講咩1個月通知呀~~!!

作者: Lovely-Boy 時間: 11-7-11 10:43 標題: 回復 12# teresahsu 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: smfwong555 時間: 11-7-11 11:29

我個仔都讀緊明慧N, 我唔覺得學校收學費有問題,間間學校都一樣.....入學時佢講明全期學費分11期,仲有當初交留位費和K1學費自動轉帳通告都有說明第一期學費自動轉帳日期...做人要公道d...雖然我仔仔K1都會轉校...但明慧太子嘅老師都很有愛心同埋都教得d小朋友好好

作者: Rioboyboy 時間: 11-7-11 11:41

原帖由 Lovely-Boy 於 11-7-11 10:43 發表
蘇浙 ---- 成個東區,不二之選

What if to choose between Victoria (Kornhill) VS 蘇浙? Pls advise comments, thanks.

作者: tanglulu 時間: 11-7-11 11:43

of course KCS, no need to think!
i am sure many many parents will hunger for your place if you give up this offer!

作者: Lovely-Boy 時間: 11-7-11 13:34 標題: 回復 2# Rioboyboy 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: teresahsu 時間: 11-7-11 14:04 標題: 回復 4# smfwong555 的帖子

大家係度開topic都只係想其他人俾d意見自己參考, 講出事實同自己嘅想法並不等如做人唔公道, 如果唔啱聽大可以當睇唔到~

<雖然我仔仔K1都會轉校...但明慧太子嘅老師都很有愛心同埋都教得d小朋友好好> 咁妳又轉校, 繼續升上k1咪仲好!

作者: Rioboyboy 時間: 11-7-11 15:03

Thanks for your comment.
When considering P1 allocation, if we target at DSS school, which will be in a better position?

原帖由 Lovely-Boy 於 11-7-11 13:34 發表
KCS - 有學卷既不牟利私校, 歴史尤久, 基本上免費, 辦學團体並不為$$, 又有不錯的蘇小back up (no guarantee to get in but 優先interview取錄).

Vic (Kornhill) - 勁貴既牟利私校, 商業機構, 加上Victoria KG 以北 ...

作者: Lovely-Boy 時間: 11-7-11 16:06

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cutiedara 時間: 11-7-11 17:44

小囡也是讀緊北角明慧國際班, 來緊8月我會繼續比佢升讀K1, 因係學Jolly Phonic, 及到K3時會報考"英國劍橋英語"課程 (這課程應該係小學開始, 但因明慧部份國際班學生在K3期間都已取得14分或以上), 一星期返學5天, 每天3小時, 好過你出外讀比幾百元一堂, 而且一星期只得一至兩堂. 雖然比較商業化(其實好多私校幼稚園都是這樣), 但老師很有愛心和耐心, 定期會跟家長溝通, 以及本人相信英文根基會打得很好. 我囡囡每天回家都會講有關學校所發生既事, 唱歌及同學仔名字. 加上小學派位都唔差.

至於KCS, 我有朋友囝囝之前係度讀K1-3下午班, 今年考P1試過自行考St. Joseph, 軒尼詩官立, 基灣, 華仁, 高主教, 玫瑰崗... 都唔得, 派位也派唔到以上學校 (他家住灣仔), 最後只有KCS收番, 但要比成$3,xxx 一個月.

康怡維記都收左小囡, 但因女兒係8月7日之後出生, 維記要佢讀playgroup, 嘩無端端要讀多一年, 所以無揀到.

其實每間學校都會有佢優點及缺點, 只要間學校既教育模式適合你們子女, 佢地一定會讀得開心.

作者: ala28 時間: 11-7-11 19:37

咁蘇浙本地部 vs 蘇浙國際班又點睇呢?

作者: akj 時間: 11-7-11 20:03

明慧,差!差!差!
教職員勁無禮貌!
佢收左我仔仔K1 AM,我最後決定唔讀,好彩放棄明慧!

作者: JanetKaKa 時間: 11-7-11 23:01

如果蘇淅與銅纙灣維多利亞比呢？

作者: Sorb 時間: 11-7-12 00:40

KCS is 英普班, if Victoria is also 英普班, the determing factor to me is if money is a concern to you. If no concern, I may choose Victoria as the class size in Victoria is better, I trust personal attention to the students in Victoria from teacher will be better. If Victoria is 英粵班, I think one more determing factor to be added is the mandarine. If you think Mandarine is important, suggest you choose KCS so as to learn mandarine early and in a school environment.

My kid did have both offers from KCS and Victoria PN before, I have finaly chosen KCS, as I value Mandarine important and have chosen to use the fee saved from Victoria to let my kid to attend interests or other language course outside. Besides, I like KG in a school campus setting more.

After all, I do have this feeling during my previous dealings and have heard people comment Victoria or Ming Wai are commercial. I think if they can give me what I want for the amount of fee paid, I don't mind they are commercial.

For KCS, I think it has given me much more than I have paid (less than $300 per month in coming Sept after deducting the government coupon) though it does have room for improvement in some areas too.

原帖由 JanetKaKa 於 11-7-11 23:01 發表
如果蘇淅與銅纙灣維多利亞比呢？

[ 本帖最後由 Sorb 於 11-7-12 00:41 編輯 ]

作者: Lovely-Boy 時間: 11-7-12 10:00

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ling121933 時間: 11-7-12 22:11

其實我見好多家長話明慧唔好
但係我從無見過有家長喺呢度講實質例子
講來講去得一個好耐之前嘅例子
事實上我個仔將會喺8月返明慧PN
我上個禮拜尾去家長會
反而覺得係佢個課程吸引我(例如學PHONICS加日文加劍橋英文)
PN-K3都有外籍老師做班主任
而且我之前有好多問題
例如返學安排同校車等等
每一次打去啲人都好有禮貌咁答我
我SO FAR未預過冇禮貌嘅對待

到於交錢方面
我見有啲學校已經喺6月份交咗第一個月學費嘅尾數
咁明慧7月頭DIRECT DEBIT過咗第一個月嘅學費都好正常丫

不如你試吓問吓學校睇吓佢嘅課程果啲同你心目中想要嘅嘢一唔一樣先
因為每個家長想要嘅嘢都唔同
問清楚再揀，你自己都會安心啲
報得私資嘅家長
其實都願意俾錢去搵好嘅學校俾子女
當然如果間學校好又學費平就最好啦
只要學校MEET得到你想你個小朋友得到嘅嘢
其他問題相對冇咁重要
有得必有失嘛

作者: miuchumama 時間: 11-7-13 14:38

My son will start Ming Wai PN in August too. The Principal's introduction was very impressive and strategical, she gave me confidence to join this schoool as they provide a long tern teaching plan. I will let him to start first and decide whether to continue the K1 course.

I heard many negative comments but the most important is whether the child likes the school and adapts the environment.

作者: yaulinda 時間: 11-7-13 15:31

明慧話"NET"你唔好信,
接觸過,
你會想死,
因為未必好過菲傭

作者: Lovely-Boy 時間: 11-7-13 15:36

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cutiedara 時間: 11-7-13 17:20

Totally agreed to Miuchumama & Ling121933!!!

作者: Lovely-Boy 時間: 11-7-13 17:39 標題: 回復 11# cutiedara 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mykate 時間: 11-7-13 23:25

原帖由 miuchumama 於 11-7-13 14:38 發表
My son will start Ming Wai PN in August too. The Principal's introduction was very impressive and strategical, she gave me confidence to join this schoool as they provide a long tern teaching plan. I ...

去年, 同你有一樣的感覺...
讀完一年之後... >_<

作者: mykate 時間: 11-7-13 23:25

原帖由 yaulinda 於 11-7-13 15:31 發表
明慧話"NET"你唔好信,
接觸過,
你會想死,
因為未必好過菲傭

唉...

作者: baby_jkk 時間: 11-7-14 09:55

唔會唔好過菲傭掛? 雖然有幾個唔係鬼様, 但都係native English speaker.

其實我女都係ming wai 讀緊 pre-nursery. 我覺得佢哋教得好好, 學習進度又寫得清清楚楚, 家長又容易跟到. 如果我女考唔到龍校或者我個女夠高分派小一的話, 我會繼續比佢係度讀.

作者: helenChan77 時間: 11-7-14 16:12

因為有親友想報讀蘇幼而我老死女兒是從蘇幼一直讀到蘇小現在升小五，所以我問老死意見，她同我說幼稚園算是不錯，有國語及外國老師教英文，但蘇小近年就不太好有點亂，因為有一些比較麻煩的家長因為本身利益而影響都其他同學。有一次她女兒班中一位同學的媽媽發瘋的沖進班房裡破口大罵，罵全班學生欺負她小孩要怎樣怎樣！這件是只是冰山一角，還有爭畫時件，她小孩強搶了另一位同學的畫交給老師說是自己畫的這事也鬧得很大，要報警又要鍳証，她常常到學校鬧事，最後她女兒班中最好的一名同學怕了跟那小孩一班受影響而轉到另一班去了，老死因為怕形響女兒所以才沒有轉校。

她還說最好笑是最近有一天快吃午飯時在班外面傳來很大的哭聲，原來另一班的班主任要離開學校，她那一班學生剛知道後，全班廿十多人一起痛哭，哭聲震動整層樓，送飯工人和清潔姐姐也驚惶失措，最初以為是那位老師離開學生不捨得才哭，後來該班的一位朋友告訴她女兒，是因為學校受到同一班的一位同學家長不斷的投訴和壓力而不再跟該老師續約還要在放暑假前才通知離開，因近全同學都不捨得她走，同學的家長也覺得不公而出面向校長求情及申訴，當然最後也是改變不到，因為知情的老師暗示校長年紀大不太管事了，事務是副校長處理，真不知道投訴的家長有何大力量一人可以蓋過全班的家長而影響學校決定。真的比電視劇好看。

作者: tanglulu 時間: 11-7-14 16:44

haha, is so funny that i keep on seeing the same post in every thread concerning KCS.

but even if that's true, i will view it as some kind of incident,but definitely, these incidents can't reflect the quality of the school at all and , is not conclusive either.

作者: Lovely-Boy 時間: 11-7-14 16:48

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: helenChan77 時間: 11-7-14 17:15

太着績喇甚麼?蘇幼是好學校我認同，我又不是網頁打手，人家選那一間與我沒關，故事是有趣所以才貼幾貼！故事主角是那所學校發生當然在這些貼上回應。新登記又如何?長期舊會員又怎樣？新就是打手舊的就不是？信不信沒問題，如果有今年小四蘇小家長可作求証，事實有否發生過？

作者: yaulinda 時間: 11-7-14 17:23

教過我個囡既明慧的"NET'
只是一個很勇敢講英文的中國藉後生女,
不地道,帶奇怪口音,錯誤句子結構,有限詞彙..
唉, 我是不是太直接了?

作者: baby_jkk 時間: 11-7-14 18:01 標題: 回復 40# yaulinda 的帖子

真的嗎? 等我留意吓先. 你個女係local class or int'l class?

作者: tanglulu 時間: 11-7-15 11:36

i think there is no point to argue wether the KCS incident is true or not, and i am not criticising who is spreading negative comments about the school either. because even if that is true, what does it mean? to me, it means nothing at all.

i think all the smart parents will analyse all the threads and judge by themselves.

作者: yaulinda 時間: 11-7-15 13:02 標題: 回復 41# baby_jkk 的帖子

Int'l class (pn)

作者: ling121933 時間: 11-7-19 20:09

其實我唔係唔信各位家長
只係我暫時都係覺得要自己親身體驗吓先可以知道學校係好定唔好
如果學校係唔好嘅，我一定會幫小朋友轉校

作者: applehoney 時間: 11-7-20 02:18 標題: 回復 27# ling121933 的帖子

1年前我係forum搵唔到關於明慧差什麼,都是話佢商業化, 到今日我覺得學校不是太差(至少我無聽過佢虐兒) 不過學校令你感到很神秘,我仔仔的班主任很少主動告訴家長孩子上學的情況,英文班主任返了鄉下也不通知! toilet training 佢地唔會主動去教所以下學期著片返學都無人理. 我覺得佢未必是一所以兒童為本的學校......
佢地老師做法參差,有2班的班主任很有爰心也有主動幫小朋友戒片,不過我仔仔無入到佢個班, 所以都要睇你好唔好彩!!!

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)