教育王國

標題: 細仔讀遲一年做大仔, 有冇問題? [打印本頁]

作者: Tree630 時間: 11-9-14 14:45 標題: 細仔讀遲一年做大仔, 有冇問題?

我個仔10月尾出世, 原本明年9月是要讀K1的.
如果明年9月先讀兩歲班, 讀多一年.
這樣日後考K1及小學有冇問題?
會不會有學校不收? 或者PRIORITY較低?

還有, 我應該明年讀K1, 之後再重讀K1;
還是明年讀2歲班, 之後才讀K1呢?
請大家給意見, 謝謝.

[ 本帖最後由 Tree630 於 11-9-14 14:48 編輯 ]

作者: gtgy 時間: 11-9-14 15:11

Hi Tree630,

其實可以上咗K1先，如果老師話佢唔係好跟到其他同學仔進度，咁咪留K1，再唔係留K2都ok，因為佢地到時重係懵下懵下，唔會好hurt。

如果選擇K3先留班，有個好處係如果第一次直資、私立小學面試全軍覆沒，留班可以有考第二次嘅機會，但缺點怕佢所有同學仔畢業上小學，佢自己留班好傷佢自尊心。

以上意見希望幫到你。

原帖由 Tree630 於 11-9-14 14:45 發表
我個仔10月尾出世, 原本明年9月是要讀K1的.
如果明年9月先讀兩歲班, 讀多一年.
這樣日後考K1及小學有冇問題?
會不會有學校不收? 或者PRIORITY較低?

還有, 我應該明年讀K1, 之後再重讀K1;
還是明年讀2歲班, 之後才 ...

[ 本帖最後由 gtgy 於 11-9-14 15:14 編輯 ]

作者: gtgy 時間: 11-9-14 15:31

其實部分學校(例如：培X)都講明唔收8月31日後出生嘅細仔啦。

作者: Tree630 時間: 11-9-15 13:42

多謝你的意見, 很有幫助呢.

作者: OB-father 時間: 11-9-15 17:02

唔好咁快要佢REPEAT,大仔好似有優勢,要知道出生率一年比一年高,競爭一年比一年大,遲一年所面對的只是更大競爭
等佢去到K3,如果真的跟唔上,到時REPEAT都未遲

作者: mimics218 時間: 11-9-16 10:22

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Sumyeema1 時間: 11-9-16 10:34

今朝系麥當當看免費雜志，讀到趙德榮也建議作大仔好，如果系細仔，也應考慮越小 repeat 越好。

作者: 常樂 時間: 11-9-16 10:38

小孩子還未上K1, 已經想讀多一年K1?

作者: bunbuncoco 時間: 11-9-16 13:29

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 11-9-16 10:34 發表
今朝系麥當當看免費雜志，讀到趙德榮也建議作大仔好，如果系細仔，也應考慮越小 repeat 越好。

從來佢都係咁講3歲入學做大仔,佢係前LS 副校長.

作者: QQ1125 時間: 11-9-16 14:26

我囝囝都係11月尾細B,12月插PN Class, 睇吓佢讀成點先決定K1 repeat, 我覺得轉校repeat比較好同K1轉校好D!

作者: LPN 時間: 11-9-17 23:30

我都係咁諗，所以而家都係兩手準備

作者: mimics218 時間: 11-9-18 19:53

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ting-ma 時間: 11-9-19 00:31

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: newmommy 時間: 11-9-19 19:36

FYI, some primary schools require both K2 and K3's school reports.

Therefore, I think providing the same kindergarten's school reports in K2 and K3 is better. Otherwise, the primary school may ask you why you change kindergarten during K2 / K3.

原帖由 ting-ma 於 11-9-19 00:31 發表

但係有幼稚園比你repeat K3 ma?? 到時冇咁點呀?

作者: ting-ma 時間: 11-9-19 22:51

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: dolphinmama 時間: 11-9-20 11:18

一直我都支持做大仔,但到後來又見到咁多細仔都好叻(返興趣班),就開始認同為何要刻意遲一年,根本他們就跟得上,但自己自己的仔仔開學後,我終於設身處地明白"大仔"的優勢!

講返我個仔,佢係8月中的唔大唔細仔,但在佢的kg,佢已經算係細的一批,因學校只係收前一年10月至本年10月的學生,咁計起數,仔仔就係當中的較細那一批,開學到現在,我明顯見到班中大仔大女的同學的整體表現係唔同d!

然後,試想想,當大佢半年的一批同學同佢一起學執筆寫字時,人家已經夠晒有力啦,但佢就......(呢個係我估計,因為仲未到個一日.....)

作者: pipip929 時間: 11-9-20 14:23

對對對. 我女都係細女.. 而家k1要上色, 畫線.佢手隻根本未夠力... 而表現明顯同大b有分別.

我會轉佢做大女.

作者: angeemama 時間: 11-9-20 14:41

My girl was 0612 small bebe and now she is in K3. From my experience, I only found that she was a bit off the track as compared with other kids in her first 6 months of school life. She started picking up the pacing by second term of K1.

Now we are going to apply for P1 and she shouldn't be even 5 by the time she has most interview. Don't get so panic to think whether you should delay the start of school life for your kids. If your kid is mature and ready, we should let them go for it. They will adapt to the life in school. The most important thing is that. the school will provide them with an environment to being with others. Sharing, communicating, etc. These are far more important and can't be learning at home.

原帖由 pipip929 於 11-9-20 14:23 發表
對對對. 我女都係細女.. 而家k1要上色, 畫線.佢手隻根本未夠力... 而表現明顯同大b有分別.

我會轉佢做大女.

作者: pipip929 時間: 11-9-20 15:33

angeemama..你個都係細女? 我女剛上k1, 執筆填色都好似未用到力咁, 所以擔心. 而家用緊好粗既三角筆比佢用.

作者: angeemama 時間: 11-9-20 19:51

yup. She was almost the smallest in her class when she started K1 in 2009 Sept. She also used that kind of pencil in school but she didn't like it. She only used for about 3 months and switched back to normal pencil. Her muscle coordination is very ok and even her teacher gave her good comment on her Chinese and English writing!

作者: BallBall417 時間: 11-9-20 21:55

我女女係0811, 一早決意比佢做大女。原因最主要係，我想佢各方面（心理同生理）都ready好先。人生幾十年遲唔遲一年,又或者早唔早一年，對我黎講最緊要係適當時候學適當既野。

作者: frentec5 時間: 11-9-20 21:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: angeemama 時間: 11-9-20 22:00

St Catherine's

原帖由 frentec5 於 11-9-20 21:55 發表
Angeemama, do you mind to tell us what school your girl is studying now. Is it some famous school or traditional local kindergarten.

作者: pipip929 時間: 11-9-21 02:12

原帖由 angeemama 於 11-9-20 19:51 發表
yup. She was almost the smallest in her class when she started K1 in 2009 Sept. She also used that kind of pencil in school but she didn't like it. She only used for about 3 months and switched bac ...

我女學野無問題, 但性格好BB, 超慢熱..有時覺得佢同B大玩吾黎咁. @_@ 人就高, 但對手超細, 而家我要比佢用JUMBO PEN先搓到..唉.

我本身係一個大女, 點知屋企提早趕我入學, 變左超超細女.
當時學野都係無問題, 只係礙於個人性格吾夠同班小朋友成熟, 好多時人地玩既野, 講既野我都未明..所以呢好多時都係跟人隊尾咁....所以轉呀女做大女既感受更深...

但呢... 吾係間間都收大女... 細女真係煩d.

作者: 上等人 時間: 11-9-21 02:32

如果唔係唸住大抽獎, 做大仔會好D. 因為過左適齡參加大抽獎,好似會少5分.

作者: angeemama 時間: 11-9-21 08:33

I see. I must say SC had given my girl a really good start for her school life. Both her teachers were caring and spent decent time with all the kids in the class. Even now she is in K3, she would run to both teachers when she see them in school and greet with big hug. May be my girl was quite mature even when she was in K1. She never cried when going to school. To her, school is a fun place where she can have lots of friends.

原帖由 pipip929 於 11-9-21 02:12 發表

我女學野無問題, 但性格好BB, 超慢熱..有時覺得佢同B大玩吾黎咁. @_@ 人就高, 但對手超細, 而家我要比佢用JUMBO PEN先搓到..唉.

我本身係一個大女, 點知屋企提早趕我入學, 變左超超細女.
當時學野都係無問題, 只 ...

作者: dolphinmama 時間: 11-9-21 10:52

可惜唔係個個細B都有你囡囡咁叻,我就覺得做細B的,係應該先試一年,如果真係未如理想,就重多年K1,唔好等到K2/K3先來重讀,咁樣小朋友就可以冇咁"唔知點".

原帖由 angeemama 於 11-9-21 08:33 發表
I see. I must say SC had given my girl a really good start for her school life. Both her teachers were caring and spent decent time with all the kids in the class. Even now she is in K3, she would ...

作者: pipip929 時間: 11-9-21 11:27

認同dolphin mama. 轉吾轉大仔除左睇學習能力, 仲要睇小朋友本身性格係點. 個個小朋友都吾同的.

作者: sllau 時間: 11-9-21 11:29

要重讀k1,個人認為轉校重讀好D...

作者: mimics218 時間: 11-9-22 17:48

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)