教育王國

標題: 想請教嘉諾撒聖心會收超大女嗎 [打印本頁]

作者: 小山竹 時間: 11-9-15 10:14 標題: 想請教嘉諾撒聖心會收超大女嗎

小女 08OCT出生, 想請教嘉諾撒聖心會收超大女嗎?
另外, 我們家住紅磡, 會有校車嗎?

作者: lymchau 時間: 11-9-15 10:57

My experience is NO. They won't super big girl even my girl is born on Sep. Don't waste time la!

作者: w_y 時間: 11-9-15 10:59

9 月唔收, 10 月可以一試.

作者: McBonnie 時間: 11-9-15 12:03

you should call and ask the school

作者: 萬樂豬 時間: 11-9-15 23:25

其實點解唔收超大女呢 ?? 不是大一點學習及小肌肉更運用得好嗎 ??

我都好想知道依個問題...我也想仔仔做超大仔......3歲 N1, 4 歲 K1.....

作者: pooh仔 時間: 11-9-15 23:40 標題: 回覆 5# 萬樂豬的文章

你小朋友4歲讀K1, 咁即喺6-7歲讀完k3, 你要小心計算你小朋友到入小一時（即喺九月一日）是否已超出七歲零一日？！如是的話，你選小一計分你會少10分！因這10分是五歲零八個月至七歲先可以取得，亦即人人都有。
除非你放棄官津選校，直接考私小直資就不用戶理會！

作者: 萬樂豬 時間: 11-9-15 23:46

原帖由 pooh仔 於 11-9-15 23:40 發表
你小朋友4歲讀K1, 咁即喺6-7歲讀完k3, 你要小心計算你小朋友到入小一時（即喺九月一日）是否已超出七歲零一日？！如是的話，你選小一計分你會少10分！因這10分是五歲零八個月至七歲先可以取得，亦即人人都有。
除非你放棄官津選校， ...

咦~~乜咁架 ?? 我真係唔識喎....咁如果我仔仔係 9月23 號出世, 咁到小一有無超齡呢 ? 我唔係好識計添.....

作者: 萬樂豬 時間: 11-9-15 23:52

即刻同老公傾左~~好彩到入小一先 6 歲 11 個半月....差少少超額.....

作者: pooh仔 時間: 11-9-16 00:05 標題: 回復 8# 萬樂豬的帖子

Yr hubby is right! Don't worry!

作者: joanna1388 時間: 11-9-16 15:11

紅磡, 會有校車

作者: Cutemom0808 時間: 11-9-16 15:31

聖心好似冇偏向收大女or細女多d，按道理如果你上次有報k1佢地應已公平考慮過吧

作者: stinkyrabbit111 時間: 11-9-16 17:07 標題: 回覆 11# Cutemom0808 的文章

when my boxing day girl went for interview the first year, the teacher did tell us to come back 1 year later!! But still we were unsuccessful the second year..

For a kg like shck, since they don't discriminate "small B" at all, then their uptake of super big B must be very very little compare to others..
(correct me if I am wrong Ian! )

作者: ting-ma 時間: 11-9-16 18:22

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: stinkyrabbit111 時間: 11-9-17 07:49 標題: 回復 13# ting-ma 的帖子

what year and what month is your child born in? as mentioned above, if you had applied last year, and IF your child was born early Dec, you would had given equal chance as others..

for my case and my experience, I gut feeling is..the chance is low, being born end of Dec, and especially my girl is not smart, just average (but did managed to do everything she was asked during interview the second time...)

不過我都無再去深究了, 因為這都是上天安排的...假若當日真的入到, 都唔知點返學...though I liked this school a lot, my mother was a graduate from SH..

but i hate to discourage the mama who post this thread, my bet is, super big girl from Oct has 0 chance for k1 (sorry Ian again for jumping into conclusion!!! just don't want them to have false hope!! sorry!), but if she is keen enough, she should try k2 插班 and start writing letters now for next year!

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-9-17 10:24

原帖由 小山竹 於 11-9-15 10:14 發表
小女 08OCT出生, 想請教嘉諾撒聖心會收超大女嗎?
另外, 我們家住紅磡, 會有校車嗎?

Sorry for the late reply as I have been very busy lately.

As I mentioned before, I don't remember exactly the earliest allowed age limit is, it was either October or November of the previous year. The best thing to do, is just to call the office and check!

There are NO school buses in Hung Hom, but as I know there is a private nanny bus.

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-9-17 10:32

原帖由 stinkyrabbit111 於 11-9-17 07:49 發表
what year and what month is your child born in? as mentioned above, if you had applied last year, and IF your child was born early Dec, you would had given equal chance as others..

for my case and m ...

I do agree that if for a October-born, probably it is a better idea to try to 插班, rather than re-applying.

For the cases of super-big B, it seems there are a bit more this year than before, but mainly December-born.

作者: 008mama 時間: 11-9-18 09:44

我是今年 NC (K1) 家長, 小女7月出世,但見到同學的出生月份很平均,而當中很多都是細女 (born in oct-dec),我自己識的都有幾個08年12月出生,有個媽咪話佢地個班有個仲係08年12月30日出生的 ! 所以我覺得聖心真是一間很公平的幼稚園,即使細女也有機會,好過某些幼稚園連申請的機會也沒有 !!
所以各位家長,細仔,細女依然有機會,不要放棄

作者: 小山竹 時間: 11-9-18 13:52

謝謝大家的回覆
我想我知道大慨機會率不會太大

只是小女在10月出生, 發展不快不慢, 其實我知道她一定跟得上一般幼稚園的進程, 只是害怕現在出生率越來越高, 要是不REPEAT, 三年後考直資/私校都不容易.

有怕大抽獎太沒有保障.

所以打算試多一年考龍校, 之後的保障就大很多.
我很BUY IAN的想法, 讀龍校, 讓孩子幼稚園的三年可以輕輕鬆鬆, 不用太擔心之後升小.

我知道, 因為出生率高, 聖心小學已不能收足幼稚園的小朋友.

出生率高是叫人最頭痛的.

今天和一個NOV10年的媽媽傾, 她告訴我完全找唔到明年的N位, 無學校肯收插班, 現在連屋村學校, 你想讀都未必有位.

另外一個可能性, 可能多了內地人在港生下的BB選擇在HK讀幼稚園, 所以就難上加難.

無論如何, 我會讓女兒試試SPK同培正REPEAT K1
(找些喜歡收超大B的學校...HAHA)

結果如何就交給天父啦, 我不是虎媽, 我只想女兒有一個快樂的童年, 只不過又不能不考慮現實因素.

至於插班popular 學校的K2, 我只是認為是一件很難的事, 一定難過當初考K1更多.

不過我都會試試, 我的女兒去INTERVIEW只是當去玩, 我亦不會給自己太大PRESSURE.

不過總算試過就是了

[ 本帖最後由小山竹於 11-9-18 19:12 編輯 ]

作者: snowygary 時間: 11-9-18 18:01 標題: 回復 16# iantsang 的帖子

it mean that late-DEC 08 is no chance,why they don't like super big B?

作者: ting-ma 時間: 11-9-19 22:35

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ting-ma 時間: 11-9-19 22:38

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-9-20 09:53

原帖由 小山竹 於 11-9-18 13:52 發表
謝謝大家的回覆
我想我知道大慨機會率不會太大

只是小女在10月出生, 發展不快不慢, 其實我知道她一定跟得上一般幼稚園的進程, 只是害怕現在出生率越來越高, 要是不REPEAT, 三年後考直資/私校都不容易.

有怕大抽獎 ...

Thanks a lot for agreeing with my thinking!  However,  the key in my thinking is that we, as parents, can be in control on our kids' development, rather than simply chasing the standard set by others.  All children are different, and they should deserved to be treated differently.

As for the case of SHCK, I must stress one point.  As parents all we know is from observation there are less super big Bs.  It doesn't necessary mean this is how the kindergarten select students.  To be honest, what we missed is very likely that those super big B and big B have other options so they selected not to attend this kindergarten.  It may well be the case as you know there are certain kindergartens that have such preference.

So, let's not jump into any conclusions here.  As long as your kids are allowed to apply, then your kid will be treated fairly.  It is not necessary the same treatment that you will receive from different kindergartens.

By the way, so far SH two primary schools still able to accept all their own kindergarten students (who wanna return) before school start.  There has been some changes in admission policy so some students will get admit first and some later, simply due to the limited space only.

Finally good luck and all the best!

Ian

作者: 小山竹 時間: 11-9-20 10:20

Dear Ian,

謝謝你的回覆及資訊
我明白你的意思, 我會讓女兒試試的.

IN完仲可以去動植物公園同SOHO區食野/飲野HAHA!

作者: angel_laam 時間: 11-9-20 11:54

甘我好想問下, 我囡囡係08christmas BB, 可唔可以同時APPLY K1 & K2 插班架呢?

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-9-20 12:14

原帖由 angel_laam 於 11-9-20 11:54 發表
甘我好想問下, 我囡囡係08christmas BB, 可唔可以同時APPLY K1 & K2 插班架呢?

I think you are asking a question not a parent can answer you. Make an inquiry to the office if you intend to do so.

作者: angel_laam 時間: 11-9-20 13:07 標題: 回覆 25# iantsang 的文章

我都係隨口問, 想睇下你有無聽過有家長甘做, 我都會打去學校問下,THX!IAN

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-9-20 14:48

原帖由 angel_laam 於 11-9-20 13:07 發表
我都係隨口問, 想睇下你有無聽過有家長甘做, 我都會打去學校問下,THX!IAN

hehe, I also just reply you causally only!

So far being here in BK for the past 3 years, you happen to the first parent to be so creative and asked me about this! So, no I haven't heard of any cases like this before.

作者: MAMA-BEANBEAN 時間: 11-9-21 17:12

HI ANGEL_LAAM,

CAN YOU LET US KNOW WHAT THE SCHOOL SAID RE YOUR QUESTIONS ? TKS !

原帖由 angel_laam 於 11-9-20 13:07 發表
我都係隨口問, 想睇下你有無聽過有家長甘做, 我都會打去學校問下,THX!IAN

作者: sunnygirl 時間: 11-9-21 17:23

原帖由 008mama 於 11-9-18 09:44 發表
我是今年 NC (K1) 家長, 小女7月出世,但見到同學的出生月份很平均,而當中很多都是細女 (born in oct-dec),我自己識的都有幾個08年12月出生,有個媽咪話佢地個班有個仲係08年12月30日出生的 ! 所以我覺得聖心真是一間 ...

知道聖心會收細女真係多左一線柱光。

另外請問你囡囡係上午班定下午班？因為我想知聖心會唔會好似某d出名幼稚園咁細仔細女只會收讀下午班！謝謝！

作者: gret 時間: 11-9-21 17:49

原帖由 小山竹 於 11-9-15 10:14 發表
小女 08OCT出生, 想請教嘉諾撒聖心會收超大女嗎?
另外, 我們家住紅磡, 會有校車嗎?

舊年在網頁無講出生年齡限制, 收咗報名費, 兩星期後回電話小朋友07Sep太大, 叫我轉k2插班, 點知等到今年7月, 話無人退學, 叫我們拿回報名費. 可是我們住九龍, 來回車費都差不多等如報名費, 所以$ 30

作者: w_y 時間: 11-9-21 18:31

舊年我排隊親身交表的. 入到去已有老師指示話07年9月30 日後出世至可報名喎?!

作者: MoJoJoJo 時間: 11-10-2 10:05

我見學校有之前一年 10 / 11 / 12 月既超大B (真係唔識有之前一年9月既超大B, so may be 真係有 30/9 個 cut off)

細b都有唔少, 我亞囡係10月尾, 仲有好多同學仔係 11 / 12 月既

聖心真係睇小朋友能力 & 表現 rather than 邊個月份出世架 :)

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)