教育王國

標題: St. Clare's, 協恩，德望。。怎麼選擇？ [打印本頁]

作者: fc1111 時間: 11-12-13 16:33 標題: St. Clare's, 協恩，德望。。怎麼選擇？

St. Clare's, 協恩，德望。。怎麼選擇？。。請各位給一點意見。。。（1.學校地址不在考慮之中；2.沒有任何世襲分）

作者: 5162002 時間: 11-12-13 19:11

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 5162002 時間: 11-12-13 20:49

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Yipapa 時間: 11-12-13 23:03

I know they are all my dream school. All are band 1 in secondary school for a very long history.

作者: iantsing 時間: 11-12-14 00:01

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: curtislee 時間: 11-12-14 00:32

I think good hope is the best choice

作者: beagoodman 時間: 11-12-14 01:17

唔要求best of the best, 其實亦唔識分best of the best,是旦其一間中都極好!

作者: behappydad 時間: 11-12-14 07:58

協恩上唔返学除非你有分

如果我揀
揀st clares

作者: Syamky 時間: 11-12-14 08:44

協恩不是龍校，協小要靠政府派位。其餘兩間係龍校，因小學係私小。如為上小學角度，會先考慮GH & st clare先

作者: Cutemom0808 時間: 11-12-14 09:17

I prefer HY > St Clare > GH

作者: byc6 時間: 11-12-14 14:24

To me, Heep Yunn is the best choice.

作者: jocelynma0504 時間: 11-12-14 14:59

I prefer Good Hope! It is because it is really a one dragon school, even though I am an old girl in Heep Yunn School. If HYS change to one dragon, i will choose HYS as the first choice. I will not choose St Clare because i live in KLN side!

作者: Cutemom0808 時間: 11-12-14 15:02

原帖由 jocelynma0504 於 11-12-14 14:59 發表
I prefer Good Hope! It is because it is really a one dragon school, even though I am an old girl in Heep Yunn School. If HYS change to one dragon, i will choose HYS as the first choice. I will not cho ...

你係HY old girl唔係有25分可直入？讀邊間都冇問題呢

作者: jocelynma0504 時間: 11-12-14 15:38 標題: 回復 13# Cutemom0808 的帖子

But I am old girl of Heep yunn secondary school only, not priminary school. Therefore, no advantage for me! But may help in the admission of kindergarten because i need to hand in the graduate certificate of the school also!

作者: HelloKittyBuzz 時間: 11-12-14 15:53

I prefer GH

作者: fc1111 時間: 11-12-15 14:29

或者我換個方式問這個問題吧：

我知道3家的中學都是BAND 1 學校，不過希望更清楚了解一下3家學校的小學和中學在學生的學術教育、人格道德培養、校風等方面會不會還是有點差異？

作者: QQMonkey 時間: 11-12-16 10:21

HY:基督教，不是全一條龍
GH , SC: 天主教，一條龍，只要品學兼優，就自動直上中學

囡囡當年都是GH和SC都收咗，我不是天主教徒，但中小學都在天主教學校就讀，很接受天主教教義，大學時曾接觸基督教，不大認同部份教徒想法。曾在SC間介會有人問，如一基督徒入讀天主教學校有否思想conflict，老師答得非常得體及有胸襟，她說:"同是一個神，只是worship方式不同罷了。"
我選了GH,因她是band1頭，中小學校舍設備新，運動出色，且家住九龍。SC我亦非常喜歡，她是band 1尾，如家住香港西區，又不想小朋友長途車，我會選SC.
HY好像是band1尾，運動場常與GH 和DGS碰頭,小學不用錢，但不是直上，所以看你想不想take a risk

作者: pajero2400cc 時間: 11-12-16 10:54

協中體育, 全港學界稱雄, 女拔也只能平分秋色.

但係GH, SC 個名就唔係成日見架.

作者: 小K 時間: 11-12-16 11:16

ST. Clare is an English school with small class (30). Even in the primary school, all subjects are in English. The English language capability is the best compare with HY and GH. I went to St. Clare Secondary School last week (open day) and the girls welcome us are all talking English with confident. Most of the students are come from SC kinder (i asked them and they told me). They are so proud of themselves whe studied in SC kinder. They love the school very much. My husband is very like that school bcoz the girls are very polite.
I am a Catholic mother and I totally highly recommend St. Clare rather than GH

[ 本帖最後由小K 於 11-12-16 11:17 編輯 ]

作者: waiwai1234567 時間: 11-12-16 11:30

all is good

作者: fc1111 時間: 11-12-16 12:03

谢谢各位，提供了很好的资料可供参考！！

我也知道三家都是很好的学校，我自己也实地观察了3家学校和学生，谁知了解越多，选择越难。。。哈哈。

若有任何其他资料的提供，我都是非常欢迎的，特别是在校学生的家长能够提供多些贵千金在校的第一手信息。。。。再次谢谢大家！

作者: lovelinda 時間: 11-12-16 12:17

唔好意思, 我女女都唔係讀呢3間.........我無第一手資料, 唔知幫唔幫到你, 你去呢幾條link睇下啦!

資料由一位熱心mami提供的~~(不過有些資料只提供津校的)

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... 0037&extra=page%3D1

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... 1081&extra=page%3D1

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... 9167&extra=page%3D1

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... 4159&extra=page%3D1

[ 本帖最後由 lovelinda 於 11-12-16 12:21 編輯 ]

作者: Cutemom0808 時間: 11-12-16 12:35

原帖由 lovelinda 於 11-12-16 12:17 發表
唔好意思, 我女女都唔係讀呢3間.........我無第一手資料, 唔知幫唔幫到你, 你去呢幾條link睇下啦!

資料由一位熱心mami提供的~~(不過有些資料只提供津校的)

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... 0037&extra=page% ...

原來林護排第三o甘利害

聖公會林護紀念中學

英中

葵青區

男女

作者: lovelinda 時間: 11-12-16 13:01 標題: 回復 23# Cutemom0808 的帖子

係呀, 我兩個表弟都係林護畢業, 由細到大, 我睇佢兩個讀書就

mouth:" />

不過呢個排名好似無私校的, 如果有, 排位可能有變呢? 因為仲有dbs, dgs, st.paul .......等等

作者: B.BB 時間: 11-12-16 13:42

原帖由 fc1111 於 11-12-16 12:03 發表
谢谢各位，提供了很好的资料可供参考！！

我也知道三家都是很好的学校，我自己也实地观察了3家学校和学生，谁知了解越多，选择越难。。。哈哈。

若有任何其他资料的提供，我都是非常欢迎的，特别是在校学生的家长能够提供多些贵千 ...

而家所有野都係空談，因為首先係學校選唔選擇你個女，到有多過一間收你先至有選擇權。

講真，三間學校的水平唔會有好大分別，協恩對升協小無優勢，單憑呢一點已足以令好多人唔會選。其餘兩間，一在港島一在九龍，其實真係唔係好難選。

作者: 5162002 時間: 11-12-16 15:21 標題: 回復 19# 小K 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: tiggerpiget 時間: 11-12-16 15:28

唔知点解GH 要等到2月先出result, 等到頸都長

作者: 5162002 時間: 11-12-28 00:40

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: hklbj 時間: 11-12-28 23:06

如GH係Band1頭, St Clare's係Band 1尾(亦有人說係Band2 頭), 咁即係學術上嚟講巳差一大截??

作者: yslgirl 時間: 11-12-28 23:48

但係我識幾個朋友o係st clare's畢業, 佢地讀書真係唔掂架, 亦不是品行好好的...當然我的朋友都已經係媽媽級, 唔知呢幾十年呢間學校係咪進步左. 不過間間學校都有讀到讀唔到書的.

作者: SmartCandy 時間: 11-12-30 11:34

jocelynma0504 發表於 11-12-14 14:59
I prefer Good Hope! It is because it is really a one dragon school, even though I am an old girl in ...

Even though Good Hope is one dragon, its secondary school' academic seems not good wor (see its web site)...If the school is no good, it is no use If for dragon.

作者: sunnygirl 時間: 11-12-30 17:54

我本身住中西區，st clare 係本區街坊心目中向來都只是二線學校。

作者: fc1111 時間: 12-1-1 17:42

lovelinda 發表於 11-12-16 12:17
唔好意思, 我女女都唔係讀呢3間.........我無第一手資料, 唔知幫唔幫到你, 你去呢幾條link睇下啦!

資料由 ...

Hi lovelinda, thanks a lot for your information.

作者: qyeternity 時間: 12-1-2 13:36

回復 fc1111 的帖子

協恩 is not our cup of tea, so we did not apply last year, but its secondary school has changed to 直資, if its primary school will change too, 協恩 is a good choice indeed. However, meanwhile, after kg graduation, you stll need to go through lucky draw to go to its primary school, not really a one-dragon girl school, but who knows when will its primary school change??

St.Clare's is an english girl's primary school as well as secondary one, students therein can definitey go to its primary school, if u don't wanna go through the tough application

作者: qyeternity 時間: 12-1-2 13:38

St. Clare's is a good choice too, the campus is comparatively, facilities may not as good as GOOd Hope. I like St. Clare's much cos the students are 純樸

作者: qyeternity 時間: 12-1-2 13:39

For academic results, GH is comparatively the best among the three, but it is also the most expensive one

作者: qyeternity 時間: 12-1-2 13:41

Campus is beautiful and the environment is good indeed. GH is also famous on its sports and musical performance. However, taking into the consideration of high school fee in the long run (primary + secondary school), we gave up the offer last year.

作者: qyeternity 時間: 12-1-2 13:44

Anyway, I heard people said that St.Clare's secondary school is not good, but I think if your gal can study in an Eng primary school, not difficult to go to another emi secondary school, right?

作者: fc1111 時間: 12-1-2 20:08

回復 qyeternity 的帖子

Heard that St Clare's is not allow students to lucky draw/ 叩門 if the students want to go direct into secondary school, right?

作者: qyeternity 時間: 12-1-3 00:57

本帖最後由 qyeternity 於 12-1-3 00:58 編輯

回復 fc1111 的帖子

as i only have my friend's gal now studying at primary school, I cannot comment on its secondary school.

However, I think students who had studied at an english primary school for six years, should be easy to get a place from EMI secondary school interview

I heard that the principal speaks in eng all the times, assemblies, recess whenever the students meet her, so eng standard should be better than general primary schools

作者: katebb 時間: 12-1-3 09:48

本帖最後由 katebb 於 12-1-3 09:55 編輯

我都係住中西區呀, 我又唔覺st clare's 係本區二線學校播. 呢區一線女校 (kg+primary) 除左聖心, 就係st clare's. (唔計聖士提反, 因kg 都要計分先入得, primary 又係津貼). 因住得近st clare's, 唔想阿女細細個搭校車. 所以俾左個女讀,

另外, 我相信間間名校都會有讀書唔好o既學生, 唔會有100% 入u 掛. 我對面屋個女, 佢kg 都係讀其他學校, 今年primary 考左入o黎, 佢爸爸不知幾開心, 捉住我傾一輪. 佢話考左入st clare's, 唔洗左考聖心. 我話: 考埋啦, d人都話聖心好d, 佢話: 一dd 人講o者, 我表妹都係st clare's 畢業, 佢依家好本事, 好叻. 佢對st clare's 不知幾有信心.

作者: 小幸子 時間: 12-1-3 17:44

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: spmok1999 時間: 12-1-3 19:47

回復小幸子的帖子

聖心, 聖嘉勒 & 真光中學都係津校, 係派位的唔係考的 ....
只要係 BAND 1 成績就有機會派到 BAND 1 中學, 仲有真光係唔同區的, 灣仔區有間, 南區都有間, 唔知你講邊間呢?

作者: highhand29 時間: 12-1-5 12:40

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: iambluecat 時間: 12-1-5 12:47

協恩in左la?

作者: fc1111 時間: 12-1-9 13:53

协恩还没有in，连interview的通知letter都还没有收到。

作者: desmond100104 時間: 12-1-10 23:26

我係GHS舊生, 希望能俾D意見大家.
Good hope 英文 training 由小學開始巳做得幾好, 小學打好基礎, 上中學全英文課本都唔覺得辛苦.
校風嚴, 同埋印像中幾緊張學生的成績, 係度讀書如果係中下遊位置的話會有一定的壓力.(我當時是10幾20年前的事, 不知道現在情況如何了)

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)