教育王國

標題: 值唔值得為咗高主教而放棄自行及大抽獎 [打印本頁]

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-10 13:51 標題: 值唔值得為咗高主教而放棄自行及大抽獎

高主教是我第5心儀的小學, 好大機會會收, 但係就要放棄自行及大抽獎, 自行我有20分, 想楝St. Joseph, 呢間係我第2心儀的小學, 值唔值得為咗高主教而放棄楝St. Joseph的機會呢?

作者: 小曳人 時間: 12-9-10 14:16

問題係你有無另一間可以接受嘅私小做back up
我聽過有人唔要YW去抽LS
但係高主教.... 值唔值就因人而異喇！

作者: cmir 時間: 12-9-10 14:24

本帖最後由 cmir 於 12-9-10 14:26 編輯

The chance of getting into St. Joseph with 20 marks is fair, coz they have lots of 25 marks and brothers who are studying in st Jo.

Is your 1st, 3rd and 4th 心儀 primary school are DSS/private?
You have to evaluate the chance of getting in those school as well. Also, if you are living in Wan Chai District, i think it's worth to try St joseph again in [size=1.2em]大抽獎. If not...Raimondi is more safe

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-10 14:27

本帖最後由 Silverhawk 於 12-9-10 14:28 編輯

回復 cmir 的帖子

1st - SPCC
3th - DBS
4th - YW

I can move to Wan Chai if necessary.

作者: cmir 時間: 12-9-10 14:34

Let's put 自行 aside...will you give up the lucky draw if you get admission from DBS and YW? If you are willing to give up, then same thing to Raimondi. If you get guarantee admission of Raimondi, i would rather take it first and then wait for SPCC/DBS/YW, at least it's the 5th choice.

There's no guarantee on St. Joseph..what if you fail, you won't be sure what are you going to get. Again...if you are not living in Wan Chai district, the chance is quite slim.

(i understand St.Joseph is very attractive..but i would rather to have something acceptable than going into unknown.)

作者: copywai 時間: 12-9-10 14:42

聖JOSEPH當然好過高主教，但20分未必一定入到聖JOSEPH。

作者: CoffeeCake 時間: 12-9-10 14:57

表都未開始收，咁快就知好大機會會收？

作者: fatgoat 時間: 12-9-10 15:00 標題: 回覆：copywai 的帖子

有没有人听过不放棄私小，走去抽奖，最後真係比学校取消学位？

作者: copywai 時間: 12-9-10 15:07

私小與直資不同，直資收生會取消自行收生及大抽獎資格。

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-10 15:19

fatgoat 發表於 12-9-10 15:00
有没有人听过不放棄私小，走去抽奖，最後真係比学校取消学位？

校長話年年都有人因為咁而被取消學位.

作者: 點算好 時間: 12-9-10 15:24

Silverhawk 發表於 12-9-10 15:19
校長話年年都有人因為咁而被取消學位.

我有個問題，高主教要九月底先開始申請，自行收生都報左啦～～仲點可以要人放棄自行收生？

作者: ethanjoyce 時間: 12-9-10 15:36

If your son is the type who likes to win, like to compete, and can deal with homework and exam easily, then St Joseph is better. Their secondary result is way better than Raimondi.

Looking at your list of choices/preferences, I think you should be quite confident with your son, so I would suggest you give it a try for St. Joseph. There are 75 seats for lucky draw, not bad!! Many ppl in Wan Chai won't choose St. Joseph because it is too demanding...

作者: 小曳人 時間: 12-9-10 15:37

咁高主教幾時出結果/註冊呀？同出自行差唔多定自行之前？
如果係同自行差唔多，無嘢要放棄呀！

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-10 15:42

點算好發表於 12-9-10 15:24
我有個問題，高主教要九月底先開始申請，自行收生都報左啦～～仲點可以要人放棄自行收生？ ...

呢個問題我都諗咗好耐, 我估計係註冊時要求你在自行出結果前, 到果間學校去取消你個申請.

作者: 點算好 時間: 12-9-10 15:45

Silverhawk 發表於 12-9-10 15:42
呢個問題我都諗咗好耐, 我估計係註冊時要求你在自行出結果前, 到果間學校去取消你個申請. ...

咁佢要好快手先得，但系又系要in兩次，有冇可能咁快手呢．．．

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-10 15:46

小曳人發表於 12-9-10 15:37
咁高主教幾時出結果/註冊呀？同出自行差唔多定自行之前？
如果係同自行差唔多，無嘢要放棄呀！
...

早過自行十幾日出結果, 註冊都一定會早d.

作者: ha8mo 時間: 12-9-10 15:50

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: lugano 時間: 12-9-10 16:38

Silverhawk 發表於 12-9-10 13:51
高主教是我第5心儀的小學, 好大機會會收, 但係就要放棄自行及大抽獎, 自行我有20分, 想楝St. Joseph, 呢間 ...

睇左你個 List

1st - SPCC
2nd - SJPS
3th - DBS
4th - YW
5th - Raimondi

邏輯上唔明, 何解"要放棄自行"階段? 你報高記，亦可同時用 20 分自行報 SJPS ，無問題喎。(唯一是當高記收你並註策後，你要跟高記指引放棄中央大抽獎啫)

都係個句，考到/收左先諗

作者: cmir 時間: 12-9-10 16:44

回復 lugano 的帖子

coz the result of Raimondi will be announced on 19/11, before 自行 and also the registration date.
Once you have register with Raimondi, you can't go and register for 自行.

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 12-9-10 17:00

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: moonychan 時間: 12-9-10 17:08 標題: 回覆：值唔值得為咗高主教而放棄自行及大抽獎

樓主5個選擇，只有一間是津小，不如比心機考好 DSS n private school 啦！至於RC, 考到先煩！

作者: evasoeeyy 時間: 12-9-10 17:12

不是我還想要參加大抽獎, 可由accept 變為waiting 嗎? 我自己都係想等左大抽籤成功與否先, 但希望有高主教waiting.

作者: Jessy 時間: 12-9-10 17:28

CoffeeCake 發表於 12-9-10 14:57
表都未開始收，咁快就知好大機會會收？

可能佢識人....

作者: lugano 時間: 12-9-10 17:41

本帖最後由 lugano 於 12-9-10 17:53 編輯

cmir 發表於 12-9-10 16:44
回復 lugano 的帖子

coz the result of Raimondi will be announced on 19/11, before 自行 and also the ...

咪自己嚇自己......

Quote from a previous post

http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=redirect&goto=findpost&ptid=2198115&pid=32857359

"......... 記得當年收到高主教之取錄信後,其中一項註明,若交留位註冊費後,發現若有家長仍参加統一派位,即會取消其留位資格.!! ps. (但並沒有要求要 SIGN LETTER放棄.)........."

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-10 18:00

hophopbunny 發表於 12-9-10 17:00
唔明點解要放棄自行。
如果自行OK，當然去St Jo唔去高記
自行唔得都沒有理由話你報過自行就取消你個位吧。 ...

係高小個校長自己講的, 除非我hb聽錯啦.

作者: CoffeeCake 時間: 12-9-10 18:31

即係高小真係收, 咁你就要放棄自行既位..

作者: twinsstar1 時間: 12-9-10 18:51

本帖最後由 twinsstar1 於 12-9-10 18:55 編輯

回復 lugano 的帖子

I wonder if both the government and RC has enough time to do every thing in a week. I guess RC will give some time for parents to register and RC will need some time to inform the government after receiving the registration .... and the government needs sometime to process everything ... and by that time, you will probably know the government first round result already.

I remember I read a post last year, RC asked parents to register 2 days after the release of gov. result. But I couldn't find the post. I am not sure if this year is the same too. May be it is better to call the primary school directly

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-10 22:24

ethanjoyce 發表於 12-9-10 15:36
If your son is the type who likes to win, like to compete, and can deal with homework and exam easil ...

我其實對我囝囝無咩信心, 佢雖然有d小聰明, 但絕對唔係最top果批, 我心儀果d學校只係我個人喜好, 知佢考入的機會好微, 但又貪心想佢讀間好d, 先會諗自行揀st. joe, 其實高小可能真係比較適合佢.

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 12-9-10 22:50

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: daisy17772 時間: 12-9-10 23:00

NO, DSS won't be able to disallow you from entering 自行, but after 自行 has the result, you will then need to decide whether to give up 自行 or register with the DSS. Just as all other DSS schools.

作者: jenny888 時間: 12-9-10 23:19 標題: 引用：即係高小真係收,+咁你就要放棄自行既位..

原帖由 CoffeeCake 於 12-09-10 發表
即係高小真係收, 咁你就要放棄自行既位..

絶對係！

作者: jenny888 時間: 12-9-10 23:30 標題: 引用：Quote:ethanjoyce+發表於+12-9-10+15:36+If

原帖由 Silverhawk 於 12-09-10 發表
我其實對我囝囝無咩信心, 佢雖然有d小聰明, 但絕對唔係最top果批, 我心儀果d學校只係我個人喜好, 知佢考入 ...

我可以講高小大部份小朋友都有小聰明，而且不乏資優生添!簡單舉例；在平常的默書、評估和考試，我們的學生甚少出現很低甚至不合格的分數，而且只會是很少的差別，競爭也很大！我們也不是最top的一羣，但勤學，思考敏銳的學生也很多！

作者: twinsstar1 時間: 12-9-11 09:45

本帖最後由 twinsstar1 於 12-9-11 09:47 編輯

回復 jenny888 的帖子

Yes ,,,,, for RC;s case, I know parents can't take 2 offers at the same time, no matter first round or 2nd round govt allocation. But I do want to know if the govt first round result be known to us first, before I inform RC I will take the offer. Or we have to declare to RC to give up the first round allocation (not just the 2nd round) right after they accept us? Do any of the existing RC primary parents know? Thx!!

作者: twinsstar1 時間: 12-9-11 09:48

回復 daisy17772 的帖子

So does it mean that everyone can go for first round, even you accept DSS offer before the release of first round result????? Thx!

作者: cmir 時間: 12-9-11 10:17

After clarify with the Raimondi Primary, please find the response below:
The result announced date for Raimondi will be earlier than 自行, however the registration date of Raimondi will be after the result announced for 自行, so parents can make the decision after 自行.

作者: CoffeeCake 時間: 12-9-11 12:23

cmir 發表於 12-9-11 10:17
After clarify with the Raimondi Primary, please find the response below:
The result announced date f ...

That sounds fair.

作者: twinsstar1 時間: 12-9-11 12:36

回復 cmir 的帖子

Thanks very much for your help!!!

作者: lugano 時間: 12-9-11 13:49

本帖最後由 lugano 於 12-9-11 13:50 編輯

cmir 發表於 12-9-11 10:17
After clarify with the Raimondi Primary, please find the response below:
The result announced date for Raimondi will be earlier than 自行, however the registration date of Raimondi will be after the result announced for 自行, so parents can make the decision after 自行....

我都話咪自己嚇自己..... 高主教管理層點會"輸打贏要"咁無邏輯

作者: dandau 時間: 12-9-11 13:51

本帖最後由 dandau 於 12-9-11 13:52 編輯

Do you know Raimondi is not boys school?

All your dream schools are boys school except Raimondi. Are you sure Raimondi is one of your dream school?

作者: cmir 時間: 12-9-11 13:57

回復 dandau 的帖子

but the first choice is also a cd-edu school wor....

作者: sauwaileung 時間: 12-9-11 14:16

you are right. 高主教 is private, therefore, you can also apply 自行.

作者: albert831 時間: 12-9-11 14:19

你覺得用20分入st. Jo. 機會很大嗎???

作者: 點算好 時間: 12-9-11 14:22

albert831 發表於 12-9-11 14:19
你覺得用20分入st. Jo. 機會很大嗎???

我覺得唔大，因為很多是２５分的！

作者: iamfansma 時間: 12-9-11 15:26

請問是否即係高主教結果會係LUCKY DRAW(B部)前就有?

作者: iamfansma 時間: 12-9-11 15:32

同埋請問高主教好定係般主好?高主教有邊方面好,謝謝~!!!

作者: ihv2kids 時間: 12-9-11 16:13 標題: 引用：高主教是我第5心儀的小學,+好大機會會收,+

原帖由 Silverhawk 於 12-09-10 發表
高主教是我第5心儀的小學, 好大機會會收, 但係就要放棄自行及大抽獎, 自行我有20分, 想楝St. Joseph, 呢間 ...

你要參考埋上年數據。上年sjoe第一輪自行收生中，結果收多10人。即係首輪自行必收生(25分)有咁多人。20分入到sjoe機會好微！高主教如果收左小朋友先至要"嘔"返個政府位出來，就算自行派到位，都可以報/in高主教。明嗎？

作者: iamfansma 時間: 12-9-11 17:41

唔該晒,好清楚,咁我要會考慮,軒小,般小或者華仁,

作者: Silverhawk 時間: 12-9-12 14:13

dandau 發表於 12-9-11 13:51
Do you know Raimondi is not boys school?

All your dream schools are boys school except Raimondi. A ...

My dream schools are one/half dragon schools, not boys school.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)