Thanks all for comments

Julybabe

ilmsc 發表於 19-8-2 09:38
但點知道實際自行位收不少Band2生？

maybe it's reflected by the banding of shcc? top scorers will have moved elsewhere according to the school's 升中去向 page... if that's the case I think it's fair where high flyers will land on in those top schools whereas the remaining ones will stay at where they should be.. they could be 1b.. 1c.. 2...etc...

Julybabe

sunflower2000 發表於 19-8-2 08:53
另外，聖心4+、5+幾多?

what's 4+ 5+ please?

Julybabe

sunflower2000 發表於 19-8-1 13:38
In take 照計唔差，入U率的確強差人意，問題出在哪裡?

exactly.. so it goes back to the original question.. this school has whatever it takes to be a top school but why the outcome is not consistent with the expectation...

Julybabe

sunflower2000 發表於 19-8-3 09:42
培正收至少8成培小學生，其中起碼2、3成爲band 2生，但係DSE成績仲係keep得幾好。其實聖心書院同培正DSE邊 ...

I vote for sh

Julybabe

chanti 發表於 19-8-3 13:10
聖心有收小學部band 2生的話、而top 10 又吾走的話、平均收生質素是band 1B-C 咁上下、咁樓上jm話佢公開試 ...

yep.. 但個問題係為何聖心那麼催谷 但成績又不到st Mary 或其他較輕鬆學校呢？既然教快一年、半年，成績也不比輕鬆學校更好，那麼是什麼出現了問題呢？又，既然教快了但仍是1B,何不走輕鬆路線呢？there may not be answer for these questions but it's just something out of a mind....

Julybabe

chanti 發表於 19-8-3 14:14
催谷及教快就代表成績好嗎？小學還可谷、去到公開試level 如dse 不是話谷就谷吧。
我自己細個係被谷之下成 ...

dont get me wrong I didn't mean to say intensive approach will deliver good results / quality teaching.. what I'm trying to say is if it doesnt seem to achieve anything.. what's the whole point of teaching things in advance...

Julybabe

fionaytwong 發表於 19-8-3 14:19
回覆 Julybabe 的帖子

教快1年、半年？你指書院定小學？

primary..

Julybabe

fionaytwong 發表於 19-8-3 14:31
私小教快咗同書院B1B有關係咩？唔好意思，唔係太明

no direct relationship.. you may wish to read from first thread under this post if you wish to look out what's been discussed..

Julybabe

sunflower2000 發表於 19-8-3 20:22
睇返入U率，SH 似乎不及培正。

PC even has 狀元 ..another different between the 2 is .. PC is an 中中

Julybabe

sunflower2000 發表於 19-8-3 20:22
睇返入U率，SH 似乎不及培正。

candidly my girl did hv PC and sh offer before and we hv chosen the latter for her..

Julybabe

chanti 發表於 19-8-3 18:49
咁你指既achieve不是指成績是指什麼呢？
’第一頁你講banding好像下滑、聽聞入U率也下降‘
...

本帖最後由 Julybabe 於 19-8-3 22:03 編輯

if you are so keen to get to know, you can refer to post above.. i cannot help if you still dont get it...

Julybabe

sunflower2000 發表於 19-8-3 22:03
但係SH的DSE及入U率真係強差人意，奇怪。

yep...

Julybabe

fefemom 發表於 19-8-4 08:52
從升中派位可以估到私小 band 1、band 2 %應該唔低，所以私小課程是有「成效」。
但私小6x人上書院，一級 ...

thanks for yr comments

Julybabe

sunflower2000 發表於 19-8-4 20:19
相信SH的中一新生一定不會差。

same thought.. and so we would expect the school to be of top tier... yet it turns out to be 1b...