德雅 vs 海壩街官立小學(荃灣)

fatfatguy

got offer from 德雅 and have 20 marks in 1st round for 官小, can any one give advice on these 2 schools based on education level, teacher's quality and chance in entering band 1 secondary school in the future, both have their backup secondary school, which one get high chance?
Very trouble!:(

[ 本帖最後由 fatfatguy 於 11-11-8 10:00 編輯 ]

fatfatguy

Thanks a lot for your kind advice, just wonder is the address important when entering the 2nd round in secondary school selection, not too familiar with this game at this moment!

fatfatguy

Mine is daughter, it is the fact that the secondary school allocation result attract me at the beginning.
德小 means Tak Nga? I think little pressure is sometimes good! if yes, what are the pressure you consider, can you share? thanks!

原帖由 eunice.lee 於 11-11-8 10:33 發表


揀小學~住宅地址
揀中學~學校网
兩者略有不同!

其實官小唔洗$, 的確很吸引, 同埋往後小朋友的仔仔女女亦可follow.

我小朋友讀德小, 很開心, 不過都有壓力!
而且學校小班教學, 老師照顧亦很全面.
另外, 睇吓你位 ...

fatfatguy

See, so if I choose the primary school in SSP net, then I can have a choice on both SSP net or Tsuen Wan net in the future, as I live in Tsuen Wan, right?
But is that the rule similar to what we face in primary school selection for 2nd round, you got higher ranking in selecting the school filled in the form if you are band 1 student then vice versa, sorry for asking too much question on this, anyway I may go on checking this, thanks!

原帖由 Yukyuk 於 11-11-8 10:34 發表
升中派位之第二階段即是"統一派位"。
分為甲乙兩部分:

甲部可選不受地區限制的三間心儀中學。

乙部只可以選該區中學及少量跨區中學。

choice 1) 因為本身學生是在所屬校網就讀，順理成章學生自動成為所得校網之學生 ...

fatfatguy

I find this http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1579/leaflet_sspa1012%20(c).pdf

fatfatguy

In fact, I think so!
Should I choose solely in view of the chance of entering English secondary school in the future or can you share more?

原帖由 eunice.lee 於 11-11-8 11:44 發表
我只覺得ssp好過tw网 (兩者比較而已)唔等同ssp係全港最好個网
因為tw网只得3間英中
3間英中又各自有自己的小學

fatfatguy

can you help?

原帖由 eunice.lee 於 11-11-8 12:04 發表
刪除! 刪除! 刪除!
抱歉!

fatfatguy

If accept TN's offer,

the advantages are:

1. better result in secondary allocation as more band 1 school(to be verified)
2. a little bit higher education standard
3. free school fee

the disadvantages are:

1.longer travelling time (1 hour more than HPSPS and the school bus stop quite far away from my estate), less rest time

2. monthly school fee $2.5k  (approx)

Still be trouble on choosing between them!

fatfatguy

Seems Tsuen Wan has comparatively less band 1/English secondary schools for selection.
If studying in Hoi Pa Gov't primary school, seems only the top 10 got high chance for Tsuen Wan Gov't secondary school!

fatfatguy

Fo me, I need to take on school bus by 6:35am, too early for her!

原帖由 jomel 於 11-11-10 14:53 發表
我個仔仔返德雅都係要1個小時,要早上6:30到校車站

fatfatguy

yes, just consider there is at least band 2A secondary school for garantee if my daughter is at the middle ranking at TN in the future. But in Tsuen Wan, no grantee due to high competition. Isn't it?

原帖由 長生不老 於 11-11-10 15:45 發表
樓主, 不要忘記鄰區葵青的林護, 安柱, 善德, 李兆基, 簫明, 保六等band1英中有好多位留给荃灣區學生, 其實你的孩子成績保持band1內, 都有機會入荃官, 不一定前10名. ...

fatfatguy

In fact, I need to make a balance between them, better secondary school net but longer travelling time and additional school fee.

原帖由 eunice.lee 於 11-11-10 16:21 發表
如果小朋友係BAND1或2都會有保障
同教會
BAND1~聖母攻瑰
BAND2~德雅中學

其實德小亦有好多女仔去咗上智(BAND1)~

好似上年度班女仔, TOP個班去女拔, 瑪利諾等..
可在官网上SEARCH派位就可以 ...

fatfatguy

Heard this before!

原帖由 jomel 於 11-11-11 17:31 發表
絕對同意!而家心大心細!不過聽有D學校好似註冊時要我地簽紙,放棄其他包括政府學位,又或者佢地會遞註冊學生既名比政府嗰邊,cut左佢地個位,你地有無聽過?

fatfatguy,pls check PM ...

fatfatguy

Can anyone help, still very trouble on choosing one between them!:(