(叩門)港島民生vs聖馬可

hkpapa852

afternoontea372 發表於 17-8-3 10:41
港島民生在DSE分派成績當日已在網上公開成績。張祝珊個官方網頁到現時為止只有2016年嘅資料，請問你在那裏 ...

CCS每年都係頭幾日有份獨立資料公佈, 校網慢慢會再update.
其實好多中學都係咁.

而且CCS會一直keep住多年DSE成績比大家check, 但港島民生會每年update同一頁, 之前無睇/留底既就唔會搵得番

hkpapa852

afternoontea372 發表於 17-8-4 01:12
講多無謂，數據最實際。

事實上港島民生係被外間低估, 近2-3年佢既多個選修科目學生達4+比例, 的確比筲官同聖馬可出色.
不過受中一生源限制, 港島民生中英文兩科成績還是較差.

雖知道入大學要求, 唔係 4C+2X 就係 Best 5 科目成績, 即係除非你有三科選修科兼成績都好, 否則點都要睇至少3個主科成績, 尤其係英文基本上係必睇.

hkpapa852

Jack0128 發表於 17-8-3 17:18
回覆 dorchiu 的帖子

聖馬可仲好好過港島民生, the standard is different level . 聖馬可 Band 1

坦白講, 近年DSE成績話我地知, 呢個未必再係現況

hkpapa852

有冇人知港島民生既選修科係咪都用英文考？

hkpapa852

greenapple1093 發表於 17-8-5 11:28
校網上列出的科目若是寫英文名的話(例如History)，就用英文考，若是寫中文名的話(例如通識教育及視覺藝術) ...

原來有玄機，無留意到。咁大部份英文考既科目成績都幾好，只要主科成績再改善，入Um率應可再提升。

hkpapa852

mama_papa 發表於 17-8-5 13:07
點解選修科D選修學生數字咁少？最多那科BAFS得47，約班半；M2得20，完全冇M1。 ...

睇多D唔同學校既校務報告，就知呢個係正常現象。

hkpapa852

ANChan59 發表於 17-8-6 12:27
回覆 hkpapa852 的帖子

Just for discussion.

Base on the statistic those MS provided, I believe most of the MS students only attended DSE with 2 electives.
Base on the minimum requirements to obtained an UGC-degree in recent years:  minimum 20 marks for 5 subjects, performance of 3 core subjects of MS students need to take into consideration. Therefore, MS may not have a better % when compare with St Marks because their core subjects are relatively weak.

On the other hand, 4+ performance is only a partial view to justice a the academic performance of a school. It is true that MS students have a better 4+ % when compare with St Marks, but I doubt the % of 5+ will not be the same picture.

I do appreciate the work MS done for the students, it is because the intake of student level (the banding) are relatively weaker when compare with St Marks, but MS can lift up the student to perform good in most of the electives.

If my kid is a B1C student, I will happy to let him goto MS if he/she desire.

hkpapa852

bobbob 發表於 17-8-7 12:31
民生收生質素低過聖馬可真係未必，響東區唔少家長buy民生多過聖馬可，尤其係幾年前負面新聞多，好多band 1 ...

我相信, 視港島民生為B1生保險線既家長, 遠較選港島民生而棄聖馬可既多.
而且就算佢地棄聖馬可, 相信都係寧選中婦, 筲官, 之後才會再考慮港島民生.

hkpapa852

ANChan59 發表於 17-8-7 15:07
回覆 王家爸爸 的帖子

How about other electives ?

if we have the info about 5+ of both schools, we can rank the schools in better way