滬江維多利亞學校(小學)﹐想聽一下大家的意見

Yau_Cheung

原帖由 qqzzma 於 08-12-9 16:53 發表
Yau Cheung,

Would you mind telling which primary (IS?) is your son going to now?

hi qqzzma,

My kid will join a bilingual international school located in HK Island.

Yau_Cheung

原帖由 gentlemanhk 於 09-2-2 13:37 發表
Having read through this topic, I feel that I am obliged toshare my view on VSA and those negative comments on VSA here.

Both of my girls are studying at Victoria for PN and K2. Honestly speaking, VS ...

各位家長及同學, 農曆新年快樂!

我相信所有家長均同意無一間學校係完美既, 非常好、好、不太好、不好或差, 只是相對.  我覺得係度討論既家長都唔係話維小差, 只係唔係預期咁好, 呢個係家長對學校既期望, 我亦相信家長就算有期望, 都唔會將教小朋友既責任放曬係學校度.  覺得維小好既家長可能係對學校要求/期望無咁高, 覺得維小不太好或不好的家長對學校的要求/期望比較高....................待續

[ 本帖最後由 Yau_Cheung 於 09-2-3 13:00 編輯 ]

Yau_Cheung

"I was even not aware that she was  learning phonic until one day, my friend has bought us a phonic DVD." - 你與部份家長(包括本人)真有點不同, 我認識的家長不少在學期初已瞭解孩子這個學期會學/學校會教的東西, 我在K2開學已知悉會教 phonics, 並且每天用phonics 袋 (由學校提供, 每天須帶回校, 每日放學亦會帶回家供小朋友練習) 與小朋友温習/玩.

Her English (nosupplementary classes) - 部份家長(包恬本人) 均會提供其他英語活動予小朋友 e.g. chatterbox class, phonics class, play days with english speaking friends, attend other IS kin, etc.

由此已略見大家的要求/ 期望不同.

以上只是以事論事, 若有冒犯, 請勿見怪.

[ 本帖最後由 Yau_Cheung 於 09-2-3 18:45 編輯 ]

Yau_Cheung

“….But my boy was studying in Victoria Kin morning session and another international kin afternoon session last year.  So I think that most of his English skills are learned from international kin instead of Victoria….
“….My kid is also a "bookworm" but I don't think his reading habit is come from the school (as the english books provided by the school are too simple)…”

Kids are learning every day, every minute and from all different kinds of sources. Kids are inspired to do something through complicated and interactive processes. Such conclusions were obviously made based on biased and premature assumptions.

我同意你既看法, 我們看到的結果, 有時會包括很多原因.  但從小學收生方面看, 除去父母兄姐的關係, 維幼的畢業生並非好受名小學 (包恬國際及本地) 歡迎, 呢個係事實.  詳情可見維幼的小一派位表.

Yau_Cheung

I believe that VSA is a very good school.......VSA is not my first choice. - 恕我直言, 我覺得有點欠缺說服力.  除非小朋友能力有限或家庭背景很差, 目標係本地學校既家長絕大部份都會報 DBS/DGS and SPCC, 目標係國際學校既家長多數亦會報 GSIS, HKIS, CIS or ESF, 入到唔讀上述學校唔係無, 但唔讀上述學校而選維小則絕無謹有.  雖然以上只係顯示左學校受歡迎既程度, 不過我覺得香港既家長/消費者都係好精明架.  可以講維小一定唔係"物超所值", 係咪"物有所值"係唔同家長既心目中有唔同既答案.

Yau_Cheung

While VSA has an international perspective,almost 100% of its students are local. It is however my personal preference to have my girl exposed to a more international environment. - 維幼學生考入ESF小學的成功率只有約50%, 其他真正國際幼稚園 (e.g. Woodland, Anfield, ESF, etc) 的成功率係超過95%.  維幼入到GSIS, HKIS, CIS 的比率更低.  祝好運!!

Yau_Cheung

"不想好似international school 咁free" - 你所講既 "free"，如果係指 creative，是正確；但如果係指 discipline，真不敢苟同。

實際上，多間好既國際學校 (e.g. GSIS中小幼, ESF中小, KCIS中小幼, etc)在紀律上比維幼 & VSA更好。

原帖由 hoboy 於 08-11-6 22:19 發表


在BK, 似乎喜歡維小的家長唔多. 其實你心目中想給仔仔一間怎樣的學校? 想佢係小學學到些甚麼?

如果你是一個要求高, 要跟其他學校程度比較的, 那就不要選維小了! 如果你想小朋友在冇壓力下開心學習, 但又不想好似i ...

[ 本帖最後由 Yau_Cheung 於 10-12-7 14:57 編輯 ]

Yau_Cheung

自問並非 "評擊" VSA，只是以是論事，本人對 VSA 的意見與 bobodad 非常接近，見 bobodad 在此發言，講中我既心底話，有感而發。
我的小朋友亦曾於維幼就讀，本人亦喜歡維幼，亦曾打算選VSA，但越瞭解 VSA，越發現 VSA 的中、英程度與我理想有距離 (中文不及 local school，英文又不及 international school)；部份學生品行亦有問題 。
作為一個家長，我會評論一間我熟識既學校，但我唔會 "賣花讚花香"，一面倒覺得學校無問題、無弱點。

原帖由 Share 於 10-5-17 18:08 發表
Yau_Cheung,
點解你的孩子都無讀ＶＳＡ小學，但你又經常回覆／評擊ＶＳＡ小學？？？？？


一個局外人對這間學校的認識又有幾深？？？？

還是ＶＳＡ小學做了什麼令你十分不滿？

但如果我誤解你，願聞其詳。 ...

[ 本帖最後由 Yau_Cheung 於 10-12-6 14:06 編輯 ]

Yau_Cheung

請問是誰說 esf 幼稚園紀律好？誰說 that's a first? 是你的意見嗎？

印象中你話自己個女讀 "菁一"，唔係有學障, 但係唔係star student, 比普通小朋友學習能力差d, 主要係lack of concentration同冇自信，又想將來選 IS 嗰位家長。(But VSA is not an international school)


[quote]原帖由 elmostoney 於 10-7-16 12:15 發表


有人話esf 幼稚園紀律好? that's a first!!

[ 本帖最後由 Yau_Cheung 於 10-12-7 15:15 編輯 ]