HY or MCS?

Manwingtak

回覆 JustAParent 的帖子

As many parents stated before, both schools are elite schools. One should think of which school suit your daughter more instead.
However, some of the comments seems without ground particularly related to DSE results.
The information from both schools are incomplete and indeed difficult to compare fairly.

I try to dig out the data collected by hkpapa.
The following include HYS  2015,2016,2017 and the average figure. I cannot find the data of 2014.
For MCS, I find the data from the MCS website.
Some of the data are from HYS or MCS annual report.
You may judge yourself. (Both schools' DSE performance are clearly top 10 in HK)
However, there is data available for us to compare the performance in various subjects.

		5級或以上			4級或以上	33222  (%)	3大聯招	8大聯招	聯招學士	本地大學	Degree  courses**
校名	Year	人均	4主科平均 (%)	所有科目(%)	所有科目(%)
HYS	2017	2.7	39.45				52.84		76.7		83	(assume  all overseas studies are degree courses)
HYS	2016	3	44				54.25	75.16		80.4	85.2
HYS	2015	3	42.6			85	50.3		<80%
HYS	Average (2015-17)	2.90	42.02				52.46				84.10
MCS	Average (2014-17)	3.19		45.9	79.6	87.83*	55.15	81.97			85.84
	*	data from annual report
	**	HYS data from annual report

Manwingtak

回覆 babyduo 的帖子

From the website of MCS, it stated there are 3 groups.For HYS, it only shows the combinations of electives but without mentioning the number of groups. There may be 2 groups only. May be you can call the school office to confirm.