Sacred Heart accepted my girl's p1 app admission

tweetyho

原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-15 00:26 發表
Dear Sunglasses,

Both ar definitely good schools.  However, I learned that SHCS seems like having a higher branding than Good Hope.  Friend of mine have two daughters studing in Good Hope n she said  ...

the academic performance of SHCC (sec sch) is dropping rapidly these years..........

嘉諾撒聖心書院，升大學比率下跌

嘉諾撒聖心書院過往屬一線名校，升大學率超過九成，但近年成績不斷下滑，家長選校要小心選擇。

根據該校官方資料，中七畢業生升讀本地大學學位課程連年下跌，由高峰期九成大跌至五六成，整體已跌至Brand 2水平。而升讀IVE或副學士的中七畢業生，則不斷上升。

嘉諾撒聖心書院中七畢業生升讀本地大學學位課程：
2006年：90.82%
2007年：81.73%
2008年：56.48%
2009年：64.20%

嘉諾撒聖心書院中七畢業生升讀IVE / 副學士 / 其他非學位課程：
2006年：0%
2007年：13.43%
2008年：34.26%
2009年：22.10%

官方Report：
2006-2008 成績 - http://www.shcc.edu.hk/info/report0809/2.pdf (Page 20)
2009 成績 - http://www.shcc.edu.hk/info/report0809/2.pdf (Page 14)

[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-15 20:37 編輯 ]

tweetyho

原帖由 fsforth 於 09-12-15 22:15 發表


"谷" 得太盡...小學生仲會怕呀媽怕老師, 大個左就"hea"哂!

i think the reason is that top students are leaving SH for better schools such as St Paul co-ed, belilios, dgs etc......when they are promoting to sec sch

tweetyho

原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-16 00:20 發表
May I know why the P6 pupils are leaving ?

coz it's obvious that SH 's academic performance is dropping tremendously these years......

top students of course leaving la..........for better schools .....

tweetyho

原帖由 kidsmother 於 09-12-16 10:06 發表
Do you have any idea why their academic performance (HKCEE results) is getting worse?  

i think that's a vicious cycle:
top students leave --> results getting worse
--> more students leave

may be schools of southern districts are less popular .... coz it's a bit far away, unless u are living there .... top students in hk island have a few more better choices like St paul co-ed, belilios and ying wa... rather than SH

and most of the schools in southern districts are of band 2 or 3... (as many parents are working parents .... they dont have time to care much about there children w.r.t. their academic work)

... i think the overall standard of SH is lowered by some of these students ......

[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-16 10:58 編輯 ]

tweetyho

原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-16 14:54 發表
Dear Tweetyho,

Do you like the academic result is getting worse because of the Sec Sch is not DSS?  What I mean is she is still a subsidized sec sch n have no right to select P6 pupils?  

What we ar ...

I dont think so ..... coz BPS, QC, SJC and some traditional famous sch on kln side  are not DSS... but still they can sustain their academic level ...

i think i would choose SH ... coz it's in central (save travelling time)
and she can change to St Paul co-ed, BPS or Ying Wing etc later if she is capable of

tweetyho

原帖由 bkychan 於 09-12-17 00:04 發表
Below are the HKCEE 2009 examination results of the named schools:

School                       2009英文 5* %中文 5* %人均A人均優良率今年6科14分佔嘉諾撒聖心書院 11.4%10.4%  85.1%庇理羅士女子中學 19. ...

so ur conclusion is ? ..........

i know this year SPCC has about 88% of students getting 14 pts or above ......

and that last year SH only got 70% of students with 14 pts or above

seems that there is not sufficient data for comparing ying wa

i think SPCC is the best among all ........
BPS has better results than SH and YW .... esp for science stream

% in 6科14分資料(2008)

%
79.50         寶血會上智英文書院
85.90         庇理羅士女子中學
88.40         張祝珊英文中學
71.08         嘉諾撒聖心書院
79.10         聖士提反女子中學
75.90         聖若瑟英文書院
82.50         皇仁書院
81.00         瑪利曼中學
75.80         嘉諾撒聖方濟各書院
71.00         喇沙書院
74.00         保良局第一張永慶中學
79.20         聖公會林護紀念中學
87.70         道教聯合會鄧顯紀念中學
85.40         聖公會曾肇添中學
78.70         沙田崇真中學
78.60         浸信會呂明才中學
75.00         沙田培英中學
93.60         聖保羅男女中學
74.00         拔萃男書院
85.50         英華女學校
86.60         嘉諾撒聖瑪利書院
75.00         伊利沙伯中學

[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-17 01:04 編輯 ]

tweetyho

原帖由 wootaitai 於 09-12-17 09:15 發表
Can you share what is the source of the information?

in other posts ......

tweetyho

原帖由 panbaby 於 09-12-17 21:46 發表
應該這樣想, 聖心是津校, 一方面受政府派位, 一方面又特別照顧自己的幼稚園, 小學的學生, 其中當然會有好有不好, 不似其他沒有小學的名校, 可以左選右選......

另外, 聖心是女校, 我想文科是較多人讀, 文科的成積當 ...

some ppl said that SH's performance is declining ...
that's true .... and i've seen a few such posts b4 ...
it's not as top as st paul co-ed , bps etc....

but u may say that SH is a gd school ... regarding to the sense of belonging SH gals have ... to their sch ...

though some ppl leave every year for st paul co-ed, bps, dgs and ywgs ....

many students remaining there love their school and enjoying going to school


according to previous analysis, the top ten traditional famous schools are (w.r.t to HKCEE results of recent years):

1. st paul co-ed
2. La salle, DBS, QC, St Joseph
3. Maryknoll, BPS, St Mary's, DGS, St Paul convent

[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-17 23:24 編輯 ]

tweetyho

原帖由 rachaeltam 於 09-12-20 00:03 發表


相信這是你的想法，其他家長是否如你所說，個人就覺得是見仁見智。你可以翻閱 http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2141081&extra=page%3D1 的數據分析再作比較，聖心是在Band 1頭學校的前列，並不遜於這些學 ...

w.r.t to university admission rate and the number of students eligible for early admission (hkcee > 6As), SH really can't compared with those top girl schools .....

and it's very true that some top students leave every year....

http://www.shcsps.edu.hk/download/2008-09p6-f1.pdf

for BPS, St Paul co-ed, DGS and YWGS

[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-20 00:53 編輯 ]