兩條隊競逐大學學額 衝擊考試制度公平性（社評）

friendlyguy

hogwarts 發表於 13-11-10 08:33
就算是網友間的討論和互相學習，每當設計一個系統或制度，都應該有「願境」和」目標」，個人非常同意如拿香 ...

1. Non-jupas 要IB dip.， 要IB dip.就一定要1) theory of knowledge (TOK); 2) extended essay; and 3) creativity, action, service (CAS). 我相信會考起好多學生。
2. general comment is that IB is not suitable for all students. I heard this comment over and over again including an ex-IS Princial whose son did not take IB.  Are those students suitable for Ib more elite? I don't know.
3. Don't under estimate the difficulty of IB Chinese A. Some people says that it may be more difficult than DSE even for SL Chinese. May be my EK 偶像 Anchan can comment more about this. Of course one can get away from it by choicing Chinese B or other language to fullfil the language reqirement. However, English is not avoidable since it is the prinical learning language in most of the U subjects.

friendlyguy

samsam123321 發表於 13-11-10 10:30
考4c 唔係問題，但應該要係jupas set up 時提出，而唔係自己擺龍門，好似港視發牌咁。即係我現在叫dse 學生 ...

要全部公平好難, IB/GCE AL 英文一定比DSE難, 因為當First language 考，DSE 衹是Use of English。通識就是香港全球獨有。唔通要Non jupas 特別考DSE通識一科。又要jupas students 交1) theory of knowledge (TOK); 2) extended essay; and 3) creativity, action, service (CAS). 咁就死得人多。

friendlyguy

samsam123321 發表於 13-11-10 19:49
其實is 學生要考dse 都無問題，如果中文可用外語代替，liberal study 照考都無問 ...

我覺得點解要保護考試局班官僚呀？

friendlyguy

annie40 發表於 13-11-12 13:56
今晨朋友自动报告:

B) 期考最佳成绩的一位是ESF 的IB 同学

賽果正常，入得 medic，應該都是叻仔叻女，IQ，學習能力等等都應該差不多，但IBHL/GCE都是U year 1程度，知識上應比DSE學生強，而IB學生也應該比DSE/GCE學生更快適應大學學習模式！

我覺得Medic 收top 1% of DSE, Top 0.5% of other qualification 以經是「保育」。不過我都贊成，因為IB/GCE學生 usually family background more well off，唔係香港讀medic，還有好多其它好選擇。

又會比人插啦！

friendlyguy

///jessimm  這醫科教授是如何臨床看症?不過他埋怨也是無可厚非，十隻手指長短。///

現在教DSE的應該是pre-clinical，不需要臨床看症。會想為學生心理辅导是非常好了，以前的lecturer唔鬧到你哭算偷笑！

friendlyguy

I think it is better to have MBBS/ Chinese Medicine double degree.