英華vs宣小

KikiDaddy

Choose APS if you aim at top secondary schools like DBS and SPCoed. Of course, you and your son need to work really hard to get good result in secondary school allocation.

If you don't want to take any risk, go for YWPS. It has a solid Band 1 secondary school as back up.

KikiDaddy

YWPS is definitely a good school and the DSE results of YWC can only be better when the students from the feeder school start to participate in the examination.

Having said that, both APS and SFA are very good primary schools and strong in both academic and extra-curriculum activities (APS - Music, SFA - Maths). Indeed both schools win a primary school debate competition this year. Despite without a through train secondary school, secondary school allocation of APS / SFA, is probably the best in Kowloon side. Look at the historical data in their websites, you can see that 25% of the boys can be allocated to Band 1A schools like SPCoed / QC / LS / DBS. However, getting into top 25% in these school is not easy and no guarantee.

In all, choose YWPS if you don't want to take any risk. You and your kid should have a happier primary school life.

Choose APS / SFA if your kid (or you) are so desperate to get into those most elite schools. Your whole family need to work really hard to achieve this target. However, more than 50% of chance that your kid will be allocated to a school inferior to YWC.