SFA VS St. Paul boys 你地會揀邊個？

flyda

假如地點唔係考慮因素...... Thanks!

chicken

Thanks for your sharing

KikiDaddy

Well said!

原帖由 bb@wonderland 於 11-11-23 11:02 發表
It very much depends on how high you aiming at.

St. Paul's Boy for sure is a good school with long history. If its Secondary School already satisfied you, then of course St. Paul's Boy, as you no nee ...

bb@wonderland

It very much depends on how high you aiming at.

St. Paul's Boy for sure is a good school with long history. If its Secondary School already satisfied you, then of course St. Paul's Boy, as you no need to go through the process again in P6.

If you aim higher, and you also understand both your family and your kid are capable and can work hard for a good result, then in SFA - you may enter an even better, top Secondary school.

Both schools are great, if your boy being accepted by them, that means your boy having the required quality for both school.

Other people can just give you some advice, as none of us can make a real comparsion, unless one can study in both school at the same time which is impossible.

You will be the only one to answer the question.

Anyway, Congrats for your good offers!

[ 本帖最後由 bb@wonderland 於 11-11-23 11:06 編輯 ]

flyda

Thx for sharing, where did you get this?

chicken

我同樓主一樣情況, 唔知點揀好, 小朋友係傳統學術型, 大家覺得邊間合適d呢? 中學backup是否真的很重要?

KikiDaddy

Where did you get such information or is it just your own guess?

原帖由 ukodelechan 於 11-11-23 09:43 發表
well I think that most SPB boys went to prestigious schools in UK and US, like Eton College, Oxbridge etc, which obviously are better and higher ranking than those in Hong Kong

smartcash

I think Paul Boys encourages all-rounded development and life balancing, not just focus on academic side.  So I will choose Paul Boys.

ukodelechan

well I think that most SPB boys went to prestigious schools in UK and US, like Eton College, Oxbridge etc, which obviously are better and higher ranking than those in Hong Kong

flyda

請問，St. Paul boys 比其他band 1中學貴的架咩？

Ving

Can you suggest which one will you choose then? Thx

sytw

原帖由 imdaddy 於 11-11-22 18:30 發表


希望你決定到一間合你仔仔嘅學校.Good Luck.

Thank you
我都想快些有決定，放返個位出來

KikiDaddy

In the past decade, I believe LS and St. Jo have the best public examination results among the secondary schools in HK. They are not thru train schools. Only 70% of the feeder school students can get a place in the secondary school. Competition among the students are intensive. Students need to work very hard to get a guaranteed place in the secondary school. I think it is the students' hard work at primary school that lay a good foundation for their excellent academic results in HKCEE.

KikiDaddy

Of course there are many cases like your friends' but the kids need to do extremely well in their schools and get excellent results in public exam before they can enroll in top tier overseas university.

原帖由 CandyTheMom 於 11-11-22 20:53 發表
'讀得到嘅使嘜去留學啊!'? A lot of my friends around sent their children 留學 to really top ranked secondary schools or universities aboard wor (too smart to go to those in HK).

Please be more open-mi ...

小曳人

原帖由 CandyTheMom 於 11-11-22 20:53 發表
'讀得到嘅使嘜去留學啊!'? A lot of my friends around sent their children 留學 to really top ranked secondary schools or universities aboard wor (too smart to go to those in HK).

Please be more open-mi ...

認同
出唔出國留學，同讀得好唔好無乜關係！
攞住獎學金去外國讀書嘅，大有人在，始終出過國，眼界都唔同d

CandyTheMom

'讀得到嘅使嘜去留學啊!'? A lot of my friends around sent their children 留學 to really top ranked secondary schools or universities aboard wor (too smart to go to those in HK).

Please be more open-minded.

原帖由 長生不老 於 11-11-22 18:26 發表
聖保羅書院成績差咗好多年啦! 收唔到叻學生咪唔掂囉! 讀得到嘅使嘜去留學啊!要俾錢才讀間band1c嘅, 我就選第間了.

PWHPOPO

我朋友(他是教書)的例子如下:
當年為兒子(讀St Cat),考到TSL,APS and
St. Francis.
DBS and YW rejected
St Paul's -first batch waiting,最後他選了St Francis.他說如果最後St paul's Boy收他兒,他一定會讀Paul Boy,可惜最後都得個wait。之後,他留在St. Francis,希望每年都試插DBS,但又談何容易!今年到他細女考小一,她只報了DGJS & GH,都是有直屬英中的小學呢!

hyatt

如果地點不是問題，我會棟SPB，6年後唔想再搞一次，而過往成績只係一個參考，都好睇個小朋友本身。