ESF CAT2 K2學生會否落第ESF Primary?

oooray

原帖由 myhappyfamily 於 11-11-15 02:24 發表
真唔明 cat2 仲走去讀 esf kinder 為乜, 出路幾乎無 ,  回流去讀local kinder好過,

如果真係唔明白就虛心請教用家；
如果真係明白(但又扮唔明)但唔認同也應該尊重別人的選擇；
這是為人父母對孩子基本的身教。

yanyan123

Agree x 2

原帖由 oooray 於 11-11-15 09:23 發表

如果真係唔明白就虛心請教用家；
如果真係明白(但又扮唔明)但唔認同也應該尊重別人的選擇；
這是為人父母對孩子基本的身教。

victoriarosary

I agree with oooray. There are always difficult parents who think they are always right. Their senseless comments can be ignored.

lovelyteresa

Will cat 2 esf k2 kids be directed to other esf p1 by esf kindergarten principal? Or direct other cat 1 non esf kids to less crowded schoolS?

原帖由 tomintoul 於 11-11-9 00:36 發表
今年 CWBS 暫只計算 siblings /舊生/職員工及 ESF Cat 1 學生已經爆凸, ESF Cat 1 學生都有機會要 waiting. KGV 更加不可能有本地學生位, 單收番 waiting list 學生已經足以新 school term 開班
...

cissyc

I heard a parent's younger kid being allocated to other ESF primary school (but only subject to the vacanies)then the kid was transferred back one year later. I'm not sure if it really happened, but chance won't be high  I guess.

蜜蜜

Why not keep her up as Cat 1 until she got an offer in Year 1? Consider about this.

蜜蜜

原帖由 lovelyteresa 於 11-11-9 08:49 發表
So that means there will be quite a lot of Cat2 esf k2 kids can't have any esf yr 1 offer unless they have island catchment? Poor poor...anyone know more if QBS can absorb the Cat2 from TY esf if they ...

QBS was also over-subscribed last year.

蜜蜜

Half of the class in year one classes this year are non-Chinese. And...what's the problem if there are more Chinese? QBS is also a good school.

jujuxxx

Anybody knows if Beacon hill also over subscribed seriously like the other ESF in this year? Is it a good school as not many comments about it?

debbieip

我的意思係, 如果上年有咁多香港人(CAT 2)入到, 咁CAT 2 都唔係真係冇機會!

蜜蜜

for QBS last year, according to Vice principle of an ESF kindergarten which my daughter attended, she said even those in ESF kindergarten, no chance for interview if your are a Cat 2.

lovelyteresa

聽到大家講CAT2咁慘要係咁擔心，可能要放棄讀IS，都係排本地學校可能都差唔多咁辛苦呀！除非大把錢可以讀其他買DEBENTURE嘅IS。。。。真灰

nicky127

如果想入esf kinder只係想攞interview ticket,我勸你放棄吧,wks kinder今年好多學生(報sjs,包括cat 1/cat 2)連in都無得in,我小朋友亦是其中一位,好多家長不滿

karenchan99

How did SJS inform you?  Did they send you a letter?

nicky127

今日剛收的email

karenchan99

So, will put in waiting list?  Did you apply RC & DC?

FennieMan

For my understanding, if they not offer an interview for your kids right now, they even won't put your kids in waiting lists as well!

glorylove

ESF would place your application on waiting list if you send them the reply slip (attached in their email to you) on/before Dec 2 stating that you are wishing to be on the waiting list. All the applicants who fail to be invited for interview in coming Jan will receive such email from the school. And I am one of them, haha....

karenchan99

So, it has 3 type of replies from school.  
1. Interview + offer
2. Interview + waiting list offer
3. No offer at all

Is it right?  Does it apply to all esf primary schools?