各位媽媽對九龍塘宣道小學的看法

金毛B媽

你的問題好深, 真的好難解答........以下只是我個人感覺 :

我聽朋友講, Holy Angel 小一考試後, 已經立即收到老師 call, (當然是有禮貌) 叫家長努力, 小一成績要 over 90 分, 先叫 "達標" 當然做家長要找一個平衡點, 如果引至壓力, 就會令自己同小朋友都辛苦, 如果覺得是一個動力, 就很好了, 畢竟直上 St. mary 真的很吸引, 如果我個囡有機會入到, 都會心動的, 不過要預左在這六年, 都不會輕鬆的

最重要, 如果小朋友係叻, 去到邊都會叻的

myac

那麼,協恩小學 跟宣小又如何取捨呢 ? 請分享.

palmchristy

當年我大女只抽一間學校, 就是協恩.

wttclh

但佢本身不係有幼稚園生直上嗎?

一班有42人,即係不係小班教學?

原帖由 金毛B媽 於 11-12-7 14:20 發表
學校請的樂器老師 quali 好勁, 好多都係演藝畢業, 所以學費唔會平過出面, 我估係貴過出面 tim

宣小一, 一年收 168 人, 4班每班最多 42 人

wttclh

抽到嗎?

原帖由 palmchristy 於 11-12-7 20:41 發表
當年我大女只抽一間學校, 就是協恩.

palmchristy

如果抽到協恩小學, 將來就好大機會讀協恩中學.

不過按而家的進程, 似乎有機會同其他同學仔一齊挑戰協恩中學同埋其他的Dream school.

[ 本帖最後由 palmchristy 於 11-12-7 21:12 編輯 ]

myac

We 抽中協恩 with 20 分, 真感恩. 但很like APS, 因本人是APS graduate and 塘宣会友.

myac

咁妳女兒現在那裡讀書?

palmchristy

為你感恩呢!

palmchristy

我個女係校友，同其他同學仔一齊快樂地奮鬥中。

[ 本帖最後由 palmchristy 於 11-12-7 21:54 編輯 ]

myac

當年give up 協恩 而揀APS 原因何在呢?

nabi

Good Luck to all applicants.  Chance to admission is keen every year esp this year.  The interview is not difficult  comparing to most other prestigious schools.  Make sure your child speak up and be polite.  They do not care too much about your religion preference for admission and they do not pick on older children.  They care more on your child's performance more than anything.

APS is a very good school with very caring teachers.  Like all other schools, school workload will add up as their level go up.  On top of that, music achievement also add up. Time for everyone is the same, so it will be quite hard for upper forms.  But they will be pay off with well-preparation for S1 interview and adjustment.  Remember we all need to work hard to have better future. People choose APS should understand that there is another big challenge for S1 admission.  The school will help you and your child to prepare for that.  It takes you and your child's co-operation too.  Most the students are very happy and are very presentable.  They do not label any child nor give up  on anyone.  The principal stress that all the students are bright and good.

Even there are not much homework and no 無謂抄寫 but your child will be busy most of the time with different tasks.  I found that the sense of belonging to school is very strong among the students, parents, graduates and even teachers.  They all love the school, think of the reasons then :)

kls12

原帖由 630 於 11-12-7 14:25 發表
Just wonder whether attend interview as already get offer from Holy Angel though APS is a good school with strength in English and academic knowledge. Any advice. I worry the English standard is not s ...

讓我嘗試回答這問題，單是比較英語課程，我覺得APS是比天神、HY或SMCS較為着重併音，經過六年的正統訓練，讀音及有關的問題，會比以上的學校優勝。舉一例子，為什麼是用an hour 和a university,當年我的老師是說這些是exception,見一個，記一個。我曾經問過一個就讀於SMCC由天神升上來的中三學生，她也未能解答。我相信一個APS高年級學生可能能夠以併音來解釋吧！

我看過一位APS同學的作文改正，老師有很詳盡的解釋及建議，對學生來說是很有幫助，但不肯定是否所有APS的老師都是這樣。

除此之外，我看在英語的課程上，相差不大。值不值得為了這些而放棄一條龍上SMCC呢？

金毛B媽

協恩 --> 想當年, 協恩都係我 dream school, 囡囡當年考不到協幼......

如果你俾我揀, 我會揀一間學校有升中保障, 雖然而家協中係直資, 不知道收幾多位協小的小朋友, 但我覺得一定會有優先, 我不知道協恩的課程怎樣, 你去了解一下先啦

宣小, 真的是一間好學校, 有朋友同我講, 訓練小朋友, 在小學階段好重要, 我同意的, 宣小訓練小朋友有一手, 學術, 品格上, 都很好.....

你呢個 case, 又真的很難選擇, 你又是舊校友, 又是教友, 不過你想一想, 你和你囡囡有無信心面對程分試 ?

[ 本帖最後由 金毛B媽 於 11-12-8 10:16 編輯 ]

金毛B媽

一直以來, 宣小都不是小班教學呢

宣幼小朋友不是直升, 都要去 interview, 宣小 offer 60 個位給宣幼生  (大約一半人)

金毛B媽

myac --> 我幫你係隔壁 forum 問了協中收幾多協小的學生, 不過未有人回答

Angelakibb

咁街外生考中比率咪即是成25-27:1

原帖由 金毛B媽 於 11-12-8 10:19 發表
一直以來, 宣小都不是小班教學呢

宣幼小朋友不是直升, 都要去 interview, 宣小 offer 60 個位給宣幼生  (大約一半人)

Angelakibb

到我女考中學的六年後,協恩直資一定大熱 ..
要以街外生身份考 .. 一定要好top ..
讀協小or其它小學都一定要是最top個派

原帖由 金毛B媽 於 11-12-8 10:34 發表
myac --> 我幫你係隔壁 forum 問了協中收幾多協小的學生, 不過未有人回答

[ 本帖最後由 Angelakibb 於 11-12-8 10:53 編輯 ]

jj_bb

今年升中講座,內容提到協恩中會收3班協恩小

KikiDaddy

Thanks for your information.

Please advise if my son needs to be good in music in order to do well in APS. He is learning piano but does not show enough enthusiasm.

原帖由 nabi 於 11-12-8 00:04 發表
Good Luck to all applicants.  Chance to admission is keen every year esp this year.  The interview is not difficult  comparing to most other prestigious schools.  Make sure your child speak up and be  ...