York, keenmind, st johannes 點選擇？

余魚媽

我囡係0711B，有以下OFFER：
1。YORK：英文好，但怕太辛苦，商業化
2。KEENMIND：出名，人報我又報，其實點好法？
3。ST JOHANNES：英文好，喜歡有宗教活動，德育會好D，有小學聯系，但小學有唔少壞消息在網上流傳。

請大家給意見！

小曳人

KM~ 功課會多, 但係多數5-10分鐘就做得哂!  上傳統小學適應上無問題, 小朋友會自己做功課, 課程深, 數學K3教P1英數, 有NET有PTH, 學校學生唔多, 老師姨姨都好nice, 每星期手冊會話俾家長知教過乜, 開學頭幾個星期老師會主動打電話嚟報告!

JackieEE

If I were you, I will choose York rather than St. Johannes, coz St. Jon is fully english teaching only and whole day class in K2K3, K1 has a little bit chinese due to in-transition period. I feel that to learn Chinese/pth is quite difficult than english. However, if in-between York and Keenmind, I will choose Keenmind due to their education and moral doing well and their child show strong english and pth background and decipline too, I think both York and Keenmind a good kindergarten, but York is most expensive than Keenmind, it's a consider factor too.

原帖由 余魚媽 於 09-12-11 06:34 發表
我囡係0711B，有以下OFFER：
1。YORK：英文好，但怕太辛苦，商業化
2。KEENMIND：出名，人報我又報，其實點好法？
3。ST JOHANNES：英文好，喜歡有宗教活動，德育會好D，有小學聯系，但小學有唔少壞消息在網上流傳。

請大家給意見！ ...

muibaby

Personally I will choose KM as KM is quite balance (they have one net teacher and one local teacher, they have PTH, they have a very strong academic training and they also emphasis on creativity....)

sinyee11

3。ST JOHANNES：英文好，喜歡有宗教活動，德育會好D，



我都係喜歡有宗教,,但K2,K3好似唔同校舍嗎?

Fionyiu

York is more famous than Keenmind.  
York english is very good.  Their teacher is very experienced.
I don't know the school fee compare with Keenmind.  But I know that Keenmind is not cheap.

YukoGlico

ST JOHANNES 的老師好唔好架?

vivicicimimi

But i do not like KM, they have tell lie in last year!

bobo1314

heard from a ex-york teacher  (now work in a full-time playgroup school), the academic standard of york is dropping,quite a no. of experienced teachers have quitted, and most assistants employed are not qualified.........

余魚媽

May i know what happened?
THX

原帖由 vivicicimimi 於 09-12-15 12:09 發表
But i do not like KM, they have tell lie in last year!

BBG1

超收！結果有人收了也無得讀。

原帖由 余魚媽 於 09-12-15 13:46 發表
May i know what happened?
THX

shootingstar

i also agree that york is more famous than keenmind,

maybe more principals know its brand name (i mean york) and have advantages in 叩門.

vivicicimimi

yes! 超收(２歲班)！校方話因有課室內爆水管，未能趕得切維修，查實是被教署發現超收，因此向D家長話爆水管，有D家長打電話去教署查詢時踢爆佢哋講大話囉！我都是係BK 內睇到先知咋！:;pppp:

原帖由 余魚媽 於 09-12-15 13:46 發表
May i know what happened?
THX

Tabobo

我都知 km 超收問題, 的確有 d 影響信心,

但係小女依家讀緊 km n1, 佢係一個被縱壞又怕醜的小朋友, 但係番左學之後有好大進步, 亦睇得出 d 老師好鍚佢, 佢好好好鐘意番學 !

我地其實都有另一 offer, 亦知 km 唔夠出名, 但係都有唔捨得轉校的感覺, 所以仲考慮緊

所以, km 其實都唔錯架 !

ysnmama

三者中我會排列

1) 劍鳴
2) 約克
3) 聖若望

可以的話選平均的. 其實劍鳴的名氣也不錯. 整體感覺上可能比約克更好.

Fionyiu

York 既學業水平真係好好, 就以去年升小結果為例, 80%入到A GRADE既小學.  20%入左B GRADE 既小學. 叩門有好多都OK 左. 至於今年升小結果就要明年6月才知道.

chung222

請問資料從何處得到?又唔見網上有公佈?

原帖由 Fionyiu 於 09-12-16 16:31 發表
York 既學業水平真係好好, 就以去年升小結果為例, 80%入到A GRADE既小學.  20%入左B GRADE 既小學. 叩門有好多都OK 左. 至於今年升小結果就要明年6月才知道.

Woodyryan

我同你一樣，就算有其他offer, 我好大機會留係劍鳴！
因為真係好好！好全面！
功課係深，係多，但個仔愈做愈有自信！
中英文都識好多好多字，能併讀初小英語同理解8、9成意思，有中、英題目的數學，
由怕醜、不敢與陌生人對話及對視，
至現在KMk3一個活潑，開朗，健談，不怕與外籍人士溝通，照顧朋友，有愛心，有思想，有智慧的小朋友，除了我與丈夫的努力，KM的功勞實在不少。相信KM為仔仔打好咁好ge基礎，將來升小絕對無難度！
我細女就讀n班，亦是怕醜膽小，但好聰明；初時諗住報某d popular學校，再自已教佢KM d 書本，但一諗起要放棄KM 實在太可惜la，所以多數留低！
其實超收事件都過左去la，再犯機會都極微，我認為問題不大！

原帖由 Tabobo 於 09-12-16 08:57 發表
我都知 km 超收問題, 的確有 d 影響信心,

但係小女依家讀緊 km n1, 佢係一個被縱壞又怕醜的小朋友, 但係番左學之後有好大進步, 亦睇得出 d 老師好鍚佢, 佢好好好鐘意番學 !

我地其實都有另一 offer, 亦知 km 唔夠 ...

Tabobo

我其實都仲 15 16 緊, 好多朋友叫我轉去出名 d 既學校, 有利小朋友考小學, 但係去完 x'mas party 加每次收完 class teacher 電話都好心軟, 因為睇到老師真係好有愛心好鍚小朋友, 不過, 我終極 dream school 係 st paul kindergarten, 如果呢間成功, 就幾留戀都要走啦, 因為自己想阿女讀天主教學校...

係呢, 你細女讀邊班 ? 係唔係同學仔呢 ? 我阿女係讀 n1c pm

Fionyiu

我的小朋友就讀此校, 是校長告訴我們的.

原帖由 chung222 於 09-12-16 16:41 發表
請問資料從何處得到?又唔見網上有公佈?