聖保羅堂 vs 聖瑪加利大

CWong

我囝囝明年將讀k1... 想請問.. 這兩間幼稚園... 邊間會好些呢???如課程...升學方面....  謝謝!!!!

CWong

請問有無人可以幫到我呢??? 謝謝!!!

CWong

請問有無人可以答我呀？？？

angelyiu

I will chose SMM.

5354

it depends on which primary u want him to go.

bettym

can you quote some example of which primary SMM can usually go and which SPC can go?

kiu_ma

You can check it in their website.  

CWong

但其實單睇佢地既派位會唔會唔準確呢... 因可能同其他因素有關.... (例如 old boys or old girls.... 統一派位等...)....

bettym

of course I saw already. But if we target, say, St Joseph or Wah Yan, which  both kindergarten have students going there by lucky draw, how would you choose?

CWong

H20,

心儀小學.... 尚未諗呀...... 不過都想佢入 St. Joseph... 華仁... 或者 聖公會聖彼得...... 英皇書院小學...

bettym

Hi Cwong

Why do you compare these two? Are you choosing between them? They are in different district and the religion is different.

CWong

bettym,

SPC.... 我喜歡佢係基督教.... 但唔係好鐘意佢既上課環境... 但D 老師好似好NICE....

SMM..... 喜歡佢既上課環境.... 同埋好似家校合作得幾好....

所以個心都幾矛盾... 妳點睇呀???

bettym

True, I think both are good.

CouchPotato

For those moms who are interested in SMM,

聖瑪加利大 has no direct primary school, but according to the past years, around 50 girls and 42 boys graduated every year :

16-20 girls will go to St. Paul's Catholic Primary School (which is a girl school)

13-15 girls will go to MaryMount Primary School (which is a girl school as well),

10 girls will go to 嘉諾撒聖方濟各學校
and the rest students will enter St. Joseph, 聖公會聖雅各小學, 軒尼詩道官立小學, 嘉諾撒聖心學校 or 香港嘉諾撒學校.

CouchPotato

MarcMarc

Hi CouchPotato,

I also want to send my son to 聖瑪加利大, is it easy to get  to St Joseph or Wah Yan for primary school?  Thanks for your info..

IceCrm

CWong,

I have asked for you! St. Paul's Church. This is because their academic level is higher and having a longer history, their students are very welcome by many elite primary schools.

CouchPotato

Hi MarcMarc,

I am not sure, please see this is last year's result for SMM.

But last year, there are around 10 boys entered St. Joseph and 番禺會所華仁小學 respectively.  (Is that 'wah yan you referring to ? ) There are totally around 40 boys graduated a year in SMM.

Actually, you can visit SM'M's website :http://www.stmkg.edu.hk/html/frame.htm for details.

Hope this help.  

CouchPotato

chun12

Hi Couchpotato

But isn't it Wah Yan and St Joseph both 'subsidize school' and we need to lucky draw for a place in school? So I thought which kindergarten is not relevant in this case??!