培正小學幼稚園 VS 民生書院幼稚園 (result 6:3)

yiuyau

是囡囡,  
你會選那一間

原帖由 chunchun321 於 10-2-6 09:49 發表
我個係仔, 有民生/KV offer, 入唔到培正, 今日都唔會去in SP, 但兩年後一定同個囡去考SP

你的是囝或是囡?

yiuyau

SPK is not my favour because it is far away from my home.
I just let my daught try to attend the interview of a famous school.



但如果有SPK offer, ...都唔知點選 好... ?  

原帖由 chunchun321 於 10-2-8 13:08 發表
入到SPK會讀嗎?hehe

chunchun321

如果SPK收, 而你接受囡囡讀女校的話, 緊係讀哩!真係無咩人會放棄 SPK & SC (for girl), SPK & SC將會是我幫細囡的首選!

我個囝得15分, 都係選one dragon了,入 kv 我自問3年後把握不大，我個囝不是一目十行, 現在教英文數學都教到我氣咳，我都好想入PC 呢!所以真羨慕你有多個好選擇

原帖由 yiuyau 於 10-2-9 00:51 發表
SPK is not my favour because it is far away from my home.
I just let my daught try to attend the interview of a famous school.



但如果有SPK offer, ...都唔知點選 好... ?  

chunchun321

sorry, it should be SH. 聖心

原帖由 chunchun321 於 10-2-9 11:58 發表
如果SPK收, 而你接受囡囡讀女校的話, 緊係讀哩!真係無咩人會放棄 SPK & SC (for girl), SPK & SC將會是我幫細囡的首選!

我個囝得15分, 都係選one dragon了,入 kv 我自問3年後把握不大，我個囝不是一目十行, 現在教英 ...

yiuyau

Do you live in hk or kln side? I'm live in Kln side.
MS is in Kln but SPK & SH are in HK side.  Long travel distance may be a problem for a children.

原帖由 chunchun321 於 10-2-9 11:58 發表
如果SPK收, 而你接受囡囡讀女校的話, 緊係讀哩!真係無咩人會放棄 SPK & SC (for girl), SPK & SC將會是我幫細囡的首選!

我個囝得15分, 都係選one dragon了,入 kv 我自問3年後把握不大，我個囝不是一目十行, 現在教英 ...

chunchun321

My boy in nursery now, but he takes nearly 1 hr from Kln Est to Kln Est (same region返學頭站放學尾站), so, I don't think Kln side and HK side have much difference. The key point is if you travel by school bus, how many dropping points will the bus go through. If you drive her to school, tunnel fee is a cost. It's also headache to me if one in HK side and one in Kln side!

So, to search out a short travel time school bus is the most important rather than distance. I know many school bus from SPK/ SH to kln region as too many students came from Kln and NT.

When SPK announce? wish u can make the best choice!

原帖由 yiuyau 於 10-2-9 23:50 發表
Do you live in hk or kln side? I'm live in Kln side.
MS is in Kln but SPK & SH are in HK side.  Long travel distance may be a problem for a children.

yiuyau

I believe that PC and MS are good for my daughter. Both of them fully meet my expectation.  However, if my daughter choose the PC, my little daughter may have a better chance to enter the same school.   Therefore, I may choose PC.



SPK will announce the result in mid of March.  But up to this moment, I have not made consideration on it(Maybe I do not think my daughter can have the offer of this school.)
Will let you know if I get the result.

原帖由 chunchun321 於 10-2-10 09:29 發表
My boy in nursery now, but he takes nearly 1 hr from Kln Est to Kln Est (same region返學頭站放學尾站), so, I don't think Kln side and HK side have much difference. The key point is if you travel by sc ...

chunchun321

I support you, I myself quite satisfy with PC & MS. Anyway, I like PC more than MS. But my son can only enter to MS, not bad la!

原帖由 yiuyau 於 10-2-18 13:34 發表
I believe that PC and MS are good for my daughter. Both of them fully meet my expectation.  However, if my daughter choose the PC, my little daughter may have a better chance to enter the same school. ...

yiuyau

MS is also very good.  Many people revealed that the academic result is very good.

np

我路過...見大家對民生有很多看法, 我囡囡讀緊民生K1, 可以分享少少感想.
我囡囡非常喜歡上學, 佢以前返過其他學校, 都無呢間咁鍾意, K1功課唔多, 上學期勁少, 下學期開始1,3,5有功課.
英文程度我好滿意, 因為一星期有4堂英文堂, 3堂普通話, 佢勁鍾意外籍老師, 會成日同我講學校的情況, 也會自動講下英文(當然只係單字咁啦), 我屋企無特別train佢的....佢地的英文堂係用情境學習方式, 即係在不同的環境(例如活動室有一間小型屋仔, 就會扮下屋企人, 煮下飯等等), 用角色扮演去學習溝通, 當然也有基本的ABC教, 感覺上學校好重視英語...學校也很重視閱讀, 要求學生做2種閱讀報告(超簡單果D), 主要作用係鼓勵小朋友自己讀, 同埋對住其他人勇敢地讀出來...
學校的教學活動都算全面, 傳統教學有, 體能, 音樂等都齊, 由於校舍大, 所以可以搞好大型的活動, 例如年宵市場, 真係好熱鬧, 小朋友好投入好開心...
至於升小的問題, 民生唔係100%直上, 老師話要視乎小朋友在K2的表現(功課及操行)而定, 小學預留85%學位給幼稚園學生, 但係要留意, 由於小學學位比較少, 所以今年的K1只有六成可以直上...
我對培正的情況不大清楚, 以上只講我對民生的觀感.

chunchun321

Thank you. I hope my son will not be the lowest 40% in K2. Or say, I will try my best to keep my boy good in both acedamic and moral performance. It seems that another battle and challenge to me la! Some people say "港媽", somehow I think I am!

原帖由 np 於 10-2-22 18:12 發表
我路過...見大家對民生有很多看法, 我囡囡讀緊民生K1, 可以分享少少感想.
我囡囡非常喜歡上學, 佢以前返過其他學校, 都無呢間咁鍾意, K1功課唔多, 上學期勁少, 下學期開始1,3,5有功課.
英文程度我好滿意, 因為一星 ...

SNOWPUI

"港媽" ~ 一定好過 "懶媽"

yiuyau

原帖由 np 於 10-2-22 18:12 發表
我路過...見大家對民生有很多看法, 我囡囡讀緊民生K1, 可以分享少少感想.
我囡囡非常喜歡上學, 佢以前返過其他學校, 都無呢間咁鍾意, K1功課唔多, 上學期勁少, 下學期開始1,3,5有功課.
英文程度我好滿意, 因為一星 ...

見到很多家長對民生的觀感都是非常好及正面的。
但升小的問題, 民生唔係100%直上, 今年的K1只有六成可以直上，
但在培正的通知書上寫明是100%直上培正小學的。

baby_sugar

Thank you for your information.  My daughter received the PM session.  You mentioned that only 60% students could go to P1.  K1 in 2009-2010 or K1 in 2010-2011?

原帖由 np 於 10-2-22 18:12 發表
我路過...見大家對民生有很多看法, 我囡囡讀緊民生K1, 可以分享少少感想.
我囡囡非常喜歡上學, 佢以前返過其他學校, 都無呢間咁鍾意, K1功課唔多, 上學期勁少, 下學期開始1,3,5有功課.
英文程度我好滿意, 因為一星 ...

B.B.BaBa

照計就係百份之六十幾，不過因為會有自然流失 (唔打算升民小)，其實絕大多數都會收番。

據說，民小係偏向收民幼學生為先，每年只會收個位數的外來生，甚至唔收。信不信由你...

bobechristy

其實民小好唔好？

Cheerglory

民小口碑一向很好, 是很多家長心目中的Dream School。
但可能比較”谷”及程度較深, 家長可能要有心理準備多花時間跟進。學校星期六有很多課外活動（包括樂器）可供學生參加。此外，校舍大，設施好（超大型運動場+泳池），小朋友活動空間充足亦是它的優點。民生傳統上非常著重英語教學，是目前少數既可享用學卷又有NET Teacher 教的學校, 亦是董伯伯年代政府強行推行母語教學時獲教統會特批保留的少數純英中之一。民生80多年歷史，
出過很多名人精英，
詳情可參考學校網頁。以上資料希望幫到你.

原帖由 bobechristy 於 10-2-24 21:13 發表
其實民小好唔好？

bobechristy

多謝呀，其實我就係想要"可能比較”谷”及程度較深" 同 "非常著重英語教學，是目前少數既可享用學卷又有NET Teacher 教的學校"

民幼有學卷又有4日NET Teacher, 係好好.

BBG1

其實不單培正及民生，而是好多有學卷的kg，即使是村校都有net teacher呢！

yiuyau

Yes, my daughter studies nursery in Lam Tin Estate.  The KG also has native english teacher.

原帖由 BBG1 於 10-2-25 22:58 發表
其實不單培正及民生，而是好多有學卷的kg，即使是村校都有net teacher呢！