應怎樣為perfect pitch 小朋友選鋼琴老師？

786

Perfect pitch對鋼琴只是成日說走音，卻表演者自己改不了音。對弦樂就是表演者手指去就位，根源還是要扭耳仔。對聲樂和管樂，卻是表演者自己控制用氣速來控制音準，這是它們基本發音原理。

786

原帖由 oboe_bassoon_hk 於 14-10-10 發表
I have to disagree that perfect pitch is not useful for learning stringed instruments.  On stringed  ...

I

I say limited only. Not useless

btrue

Perfect pitch is becoming more and more common.
Amongst the kids I know who start learning the piano at age 3-4, majority can tell me what key I play just by ear.
My girl tells me each key has a particular sound, independent of the pitch, like "A" sings "A" itself no matter which "A" it is.
Baffles me!

786

原帖由 oboe_bassoon_hk 於 14-10-10 發表
I have to disagree that perfect pitch is not useful for learning stringed instruments.  On stringed  ...

木管的雙簧類我是絕對音的（如錯請更正　），但有其他樂器如單簧和銅管多移調。perfect pitch的人在學習移調樂器，宜有鋼琴底子，否則會認錯音。但學了鋼琴認對音，他們心裡就「有數」，是沒有perfect pitch所難有的。

LeeCC

bebebe12345 發表於 14-10-10 08:45
知女莫若母.....

謝謝你，你明我還有其他難言之隐

786

原帖由 oboe_bassoon_hk 於 14-10-10 發表
From my experience with fellow musicians and teachers, those with perfect pitch actually have more t ...

Yes, they will have trouble if they don't start with correct notes on piano. But most wind musicians who have perfect pitch has learn the calculation inside.

For wood wind, yes, it may be limited as well. But for brass, there are only 3-4 buttons. The control of the notes is really relying the performer physical strength(lung, mouth, lips, air speed and pressure)

Of course, perfect pitch is important to vocal, same rational, needless to say.

LeeCC

LeeCC 發表於 14-10-10 10:18
謝謝你，你明我還有其他難言之隐

lilimarrie, 其他問題必同老師講，反应也預期
謝謝各位前輩的指引

bebebe12345

LeeCC 發表於 14-10-10 10:18
謝謝你，你明我還有其他難言之隐

客氣.....好好陪伴著孩子成長才是最重要的事! 為你打氣。
近年也在摸索聲樂中, 發覺以前所知只是皮毛之皮毛.....現正受教中.....

hongk

why not asking your current teacher to recommend one for your kid? She knows your kids and the qualified teachers.

katherinelam825

我覺得係咪樓主諗太多?定係我當時好彩

我曾經都係同妳囡囡情況差不多。但真係會有老師肯細心聽，同觀察我的情況。而且，佢講的東西全部都無觀察錯……結果當然係繼續努力，應該發揮的發揮到啦

我當時都無特別選老師，只係感覺上個老師有heart，同埋覺得跟佢學會有進步……

lillymarie

LeeCC 發表於 14-10-10 10:40
lilimarrie, 其他問題必同老師講，反应也預期
謝謝各位前輩的指引

想深一層，或者未見面前不要講，見了面，老師對小朋友有興趣後才講亦可以。我幫大仔找老師時就是這樣。「問題」或perfect pitch不是小朋友的全部，小朋友也有很多可愛之處。老師喜歡小朋友，到問題出現時才解釋，容易些接納。

LeeCC

hongk 發表於 14-10-10 17:01
why not asking your current teacher to recommend one for your kid? She knows your kids and the quali ...

老師介紹的太遠了，或時間夾不到

LeeCC

bebebe12345 發表於 14-10-10 11:24
客氣.....好好陪伴著孩子成長才是最重要的事! 為你打氣。
近年也在摸索聲樂中, 發覺以前所知只是皮毛之皮 ...

學校的音樂老師也問阿仔有冇興趣參加聲樂班，但可惜時間撞了其他訓練
其實一年前和鋼琴老師傾現時香港好多小朋友都学2種樂器，當時老師也建議阿仔去學聲樂

786

原帖由 LeeCC 於 14-10-11 發表
本帖最後由 LeeCC 於 14-10-11 07:53 編輯

perfect pitch在聲樂中有用好多

musickwong

前天去試音(小提琴)，老師無意間考下亞仔耳仔，佢話佢有absolute pitch, 老師話對8級以下學習有用，會學得比較快。除聲樂以外，還有其他好處嗎？