國民╱國情教育

ABC-DAD

飲杯茶先啦。人地覺得啱，唔高興，就算啦，睇表演，唔使錢，我都覺得袋左錢落袋嘅，大開眼界。

reei

模仿官方國民教育文件的教材:

我國中超球隊北京國安對德甲球隊拜仁輸0比6，你會：
A. 感到不開心
B. 感到開心
C. 體育就是體育，誰踢得好便支持誰

（答案：A。如學生答B或C，建議要求學生反思，因國民教育科的​宗旨是培養學生對祖國的自豪感）

reei

if this is the materials they are using, how not to protest? kids are in school to learn, not to be taught how to think 'appropriately". no brainwashing please.

annie40

回復 ABC-DAD 的帖子

飲杯茶先啦。人地覺得啱，唔高興，就算啦，睇表演，唔使錢，我都覺得袋左錢落袋嘅，大開眼界。
***    ***    ****       ****       ****     ****
我也觉得大開眼界, 听闻世上有种職業名曰: 職業写手, 或者唔觉意的遇上了?  真是失觉失觉, 荣幸荣幸!

啊! 如身份暴露, 或被怀疑, 不知会否被老细扣减工资呢?  或是背后还有'超级边写手'仲未出场show quali, 博古通今, 我是引頸以待等睇表演!  实在太好奇了, 边位认识職業写手, 得閒上来分享吓! 或许也是份'筍工',多可以考虑!

reei

my answer is A. but I dont think there is anything wrong with ppl answering B & C.
the problem is not the facts they are teaching, but they are trying to mold you to think in a certain way.. that is brainwashing, that ppl are afraid of .

reei

if i am teacher, i wont ask such stupid question in the first place.

annie40

回復 kenfu 的帖子

等我模仿下先 "

2020 World Cup : China vs Germany,  result : 1 vs 2 ，你會：
A. 感到不開心
B. 感到開心
C. 體育就是體育，誰踢得好便支持誰

How about your answer ??
***      ****     ****   ****
我又玩吓先.  我不是忠诚的足球fans, 偶尔看Europe Cup and World Cup.  只因多靓仔.  好吸引, China vs Germany,  result : 1 vs 2 ，可否選(D), 感到非常非常開心,

现实是中国波好死, 排名70? or better, or worse? 2020年入到世界杯十六强已经是还得神落, 仲系输一球, 简直是五千年祖先的保佑, 重唔开心到飞起?

我喜欢发白日梦, 如何钟爱阿女也好, 佢系番薯就一定要认, 因为我爱佢, 更要认清她的本领,历史和背景.  吓? 放屁都话好香播? 除时爱变成害.

reei

kenfu, i think you are a parent too.

will you ask your child " if mummy and daddy hurt myself in accident, will you be worried and unhappy? "
If your child is very worried and sad, because you hurt yourself, that is the correct answer?
If your child says he or she has no feeling whatsoever, you will punish your child for time out and think about how you should be feeling and the 'correct' answer?
If your child has no feeling whatsoever, it's time to think about, your relationship with the child, why he or she feels this way, the upbringing, what you have done for him/her , taught her, treated him or her.

if you choose to punish your child for not loving you, then there is no need for further discussion as.. it's just totally different "channel".

friendlyguy

回復 kenfu 的帖子

1.
我剛從歐洲回來，到過幾個教堂：梵蒂岡聖比得教堂和比薩大教堂-------有人在旁邊的小教堂做Mass，亦有人在主教堂祈禱。威尼斯聖馬可大教堂和科隆大教堂有service, 入唔到。May be you and me go to different Europe!

2.
有人說：中國大陸有兩種人，一種人(大多數)很窮，可能一無所有；一種人也很窮，窮得衹有錢。

3.
也有人說：30歲以前不信共產黨，是沒有夢想；30歲以後還信共產黨，是不切實際。May be you are less than 30yrs old!

annie40

回復 kenfu 的帖子

I feel sad & love my child more!! But still teach my child should be love with me.

***  Love is a nature , a feeling. No need to teach.

平凡的我, 根本无立场, 因为还是弄不清
國民╱國情教育
会教D物东东, 只不过香港学生已经很忙. 就算是精致甜品, 一般已是吃不下了,请放过他们吧!

阿女不用读.  也难得费心看curriculum, 然街头智慧是件货品好, 阿猪阿狗会搶住要, 家长老师齊声反对, 话唔要,当然有极大理由.  那位做'推销的'系甘强人所难, 话佢件野'超正', 一定要你收货, 你行动不便或是很有礼貌的谢绝, 佢还是紧持要你收货,扮到自己好合理地话可以分三年收货, 看似合情合理, 但底牌依然摆明是家长,学生, 学校无得SAY NO, NO, NO........件货实在太可疑了. 明哲保身(保住孩子).  本人唯有一起参加'谢绝'行列.  

kenfu,

你写的道理好深奥, 看不懂.  以我的想象力, 开始觉得你有可能是'无间道', 或是背后非常用心良苦呢? 方便的话可以pm 那个入HK$100 来支持'反对人士'的户口给我吗?  如果我估错左, 请继续教诲, 当然以我的资質, 教极都唔明的机会好大.   千奇唔好楼. 这边有你, 热闹多了.


女人多疑, 从来相信任何运动,政治, 很容意有幕后黑手的加入. 然今天的香港教育已是多灾多难, 大家容许孩子多点自由空间, 多点空余. please don't trouble them.

ABC-DAD

好奇怪，古今中外大量文學作品會有愛國情懷，係人文素質上的升華，兩位的表演，出嘅題目，無論中文、同英文，娛樂、創意並重，不過好奇怪，都盡量掩藏自己嘅高尚情操，可能我眼朏，你地要加油。