選校心得 - 小一選校 - 教育王國

登錄 | 註冊

討論區

教育王國: 教育講場; 使用意見

幼兒教育: 幼校討論; 幼教雜談

小學教育: 小一選校; 小學雜談

中學教育: 升中派位; 中學交流; 初中教育

專上教育: 備戰大學; 選科選校

國際教育: 國際學校; 海外留學

知識增值: 課外活動; 教材閱讀; 公開考試; 深造進修

特殊教育: 特殊教育; 資優教育; 自閉寶寶; 智能評估

徵求專區: 二手市場; 誠徵老師; 組班專區; 徵保母車

聯絡管理員

教育王國 › 討論區 › 小一選校 › 選校心得

發新帖

查看: 3026\|回覆: 17	go 選校心得 [複製鏈接]

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1884

1^#

發表於 12-4-9 21:10 |只看該作者 |倒序瀏覽 |打印

首先申報利益,我不是來屆既小一家長,而是升中家長,今次寫野係希望幫到大家既子女能夠輕鬆d上band1中學. 首先要知道個升中制度,每間小學大約係會有1/3既人屬於band1,名校會多d,弱校會小d,以以上既條件計,先看自己子女屬於強者還是中間,弱者不說了,因為讀邊間都冇望, 好喇,強者之路固然可以選擇名小學,但大家要記住,讀得呢d學校既,相信個個小朋友都有返甘上下,當佢1/2係band1, 甘就要進行強者困獸鬥遊戲,大家要知道,呢d強者即使係band2生,好可能在一d中階既小學係屬於band1生,所以在小學階段係唔係應該甘早同小朋友搏名小學呢,定係穩穩當當搵間中階小學,冇甘大威脅下拎張band1既入塲卷呢.大家自己唸下.我就應為普普通通一間小學比小朋友輕鬆上中學好好多.唔洗響名小學到爭崩頭,到頭來得不常失.

點評

Mymaggie 我囡囡讀了間普普通通的私校(因為唔算深，考試範圍又少)，結果入到band1，現在考到間名中學，雖然唔知能否追上，但總覺得有賺。發表於 12-4-25 22:24

Rank: 4


	830

2^#

發表於 12-4-9 23:00 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 rinapang 於 12-4-9 23:00 編輯

中學係自行收生階段會睇學生呈分試之"教育局次第", 咁一個小六生在一間普通小學就讀, 即使名列前茅, 與其他名校小學學生相比, 排名會否比他們後呢?

另外, 名小學在學術方面程度較高,學生根基打得好, 上到中學學習也較容易適應, 這點你又有何意見呢?

請分享, 謝!

Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


	46447

3^#

發表於 12-4-9 23:37 |只看該作者

Thanks both parents for their sharing.  Both parents have brought up important points for consideration.  However, nothing is perfect in this world so parents need to make the choice that is suitable for them.

The situation where renewdanny has described is that for someone target the central allocation round (i.e. 2nd round) and to target any band 1 schools (not specific one) in the district.  Since all band 1 students are treated the same within the band, so being the top band 1 and bottom band 1 are the same during this stage.  If that's satisfy the parents, then choosing a slightly less competitive primary school would work as it may be easier to be on the top of this school and fall into the band 1 category.

However, one very important point to note: it is possible a primary school has no band 1.  So, do your homework and don't take it for granted.  The ratio of band 1, 2, 3 students in a school has a much bigger variation from one-third.  The highest percentage of band 1 in a school as I know can be up to near 80% (which is very very high) and certainly I am aware there are 0% band 1 schools.

The situation rinapang brought up is a valid consideration for those parents who plan to compete in both rounds.  It is because in order to stay competitive in the discretionary places stage (i.e. 1st round), a student need to be rank very high in the territory banding (meaning entire HK).  In order to do so, these students have to be coming from schools with top band 1 history.  If a parent chose a school without such strong background, then basically they are forfeiting the first round to compete for competitive schools.

Just depends on what you would aim for.  Good luck to all!

(Just my personal sharing)

點評

Yanamami Fair and realistic comment. 發表於 12-4-10 09:16

學校情報
一條龍學校名單
2012終極小一校網詳細分析

Rank: 4


	830

4^#

發表於 12-4-9 23:48 |只看該作者

多謝iantsang的分享, 你解釋得非常清楚!

點評

u'r welcome! Thx all! 發表於 12-4-10 00:46

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1884

5^#

發表於 12-4-9 23:50 |只看該作者

rinapang 發表於 12-4-9 23:00
中學係自行收生階段會睇學生呈分試之"教育局次第", 咁一個小六生在一間普通小學就讀, 即使名列前茅, 與其他 ...

第一點,如小朋友響名小學係名列前茅,當然係更上一層樓,但如是中游位置甚至更差就冇咩野意思,因為第一階段自行收生唔係比平常既小學生玩架.第二點,名小學根基可能個個都打得好好,但都要接受現實,有一半既人始終都要去band2,即使你果一半人都叻過其他小學既band1生都係甘話.

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1884

6^#

發表於 12-4-10 00:00 |只看該作者

大家可以上d小學既校網睇派位結果,可以大約知道該校有幾多%既人入到band1中學,有1\3既應該就係最易拎到入場卷.

Rank: 4


	830

7^#

發表於 12-4-10 00:00 |只看該作者

另外, 想回應一下樓主:"先看自己子女屬於強者還是中間,弱者不說了,因為讀邊間都冇望, 好喇,強者之路固然可以選擇名小學..."

其實升小一的孩子, 我覺得能看到真正的實力不會有太大分別, 分別在於家長如何去栽培他, 你們有多大能耐去教導他,我的意見是, 做家長要對子女有信心, 持久而有質量的教導對子女日後發展有重大的正面影響, 不要太快認定子女是弱者.

樓主, 唔好意思呀, 在這裡借題發揮了一下自己的意見!

點評

Kitty1230 Totally agree~~~ 發表於 12-4-10 09:49

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1884

8^#

發表於 12-4-10 00:30 |只看該作者

栽培其實已經要從幼稚園開始,記得我仔一年級返學果時,佢同我講點解d同學連普通既顏色,生果名既英文都唔識.呢d就係強弱既對比,結果亞仔被編入精英班,甘就6年,學校自動精英式既訓練.咩都精英班先,慳返唔少心力.當然持續培養係好重要,亦見過有d同學仔後上打入精英班,但唔會多.

點評

Mymaggie 好彩我囡囡間小學無分精英班，真好彩，因為她在小一時真是唔識普通的顏色和生果的英文，其實分精英班的制度是否有問題呢? 發表於 12-4-25 22:28

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1764

9^#

發表於 12-4-10 00:35 |只看該作者

大家會否把學校逺近放在考慮因素較前位置?

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1884

10^#

發表於 12-4-10 00:50 |只看該作者

每個區都有好既小學,睇心頭要幾高而定,我就唔會山長水遠倒屎甘早去返學.

Rank: 13


	88132

11^#

發表於 12-4-10 09:19 |只看該作者

renewdanny 發表於 12-4-9 23:50
第一點,如小朋友響名小學係名列前茅,當然係更上一層樓,但如是中游位置甚至更差就冇咩野意思,因為第一階段自 ...

係名小學中游都非常"殺食", 比普通小學頭排更有競爭力. 而且名小學只有20% band2+3, 唔係50% band2+3. 差好遠.

點評

Mymaggie 請問那間名小學有80%是band1?好勁! 發表於 12-4-25 22:30

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	6315

12^#

發表於 12-4-10 09:58 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 Kitty1230 於 12-4-10 11:08 編輯

我的小朋友現在讀緊舊油天, 上年全級頭124名都可以入到Band 1英中, 但相反隔離方XX和基x要全級考頭20名才可以入Band 1英中, 這就是名不名小學的分別了。如果比我揀, 我寧願响舊油天做 "中游分子" , 都吾想响隔離果D小學度做Top果批。

我選舊油天事實上係喜歡這間學校學術性高、校風好、師資好、質素有保證, 相反隔離果間太多新移民、單親家庭、綜緩家庭, 甚至乎果D新移民家長朝頭早吾梳頭送番學, 拎住支煙傾電話時講粗口等放學, 吾知作為家長的你見到會點睇呢??? 其實小朋友是一張白紙, anyway, 未試過又點知佢係弱者? 有時小朋友係會 "遇強愈強" 架, 吾好睇少佢地!!!

點評

Mymaggie 我唔明，舊油天都是津校，照計家庭的情況/家長的質素與其他津校的機會應該差不多?? 發表於 12-4-26 19:55


	3505

13^#

發表於 12-4-10 10:15 |只看該作者

回覆：選校心得

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 14

醒目開學勳章王國長老


	58865

14^#

發表於 12-4-10 11:03 |只看該作者

人各有志

有家長會認為, 小朋友應該要讀書, 而且要努力讀書力爭上游, 就算自己間中學好好, 都仲要做得更好(O係中學版我見到有家長, 有SCHOLARSHIP唔要, 寧願去搏間更掂架), 當然過5關斬6將就一定小不免, 除左小朋友跑, 家長都要陪跑的, 一分耕耘一分收獲, HOPEFULLY結果會係甜美

亦有家長主張多方面發展, 除左學業, 仲希望小朋友可以有其他時間試下其他野, 間中學唔錯已經OK, 咁條路又唔一樣

最怕有家長睇唔清現實(又唔去睇), 前面條路係點都未知, 到殺到埋身至發現大鑊(例如去到P5至發現原來P6派位非常不堪但已經走唔到), 又或者選校太AGGRESSIVE到頭來得個吉, 咁就最慘, 跑就有份跑, 但又跑得唔夠快又或者跑條爛路

所以家長想條路點行, 一定要及早想清楚的, "抽到邊間只要有心讀都係好學校" SORRY我從來唔認同


	3505

15^#

發表於 12-4-10 12:11 |只看該作者

回覆：選校心得

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1571

16^#

發表於 12-4-10 16:39 |只看該作者

聽一些過來人說,一些中上遊的學校,因為想improve ranking,比名校仲谷,如是屬實,點樣才find out 到avoid錯佩lei?

Rank: 8 Rank: 8


	19492

17^#

發表於 12-4-10 17:14 |只看該作者

可比較小ㄧ的功課量，包括假期前的功課，有些學校會把小一的功課冊放上網。不過，不要信人家說做幾多分鐘和小時，因每個小孩的效率都不同，要確切看和比較ㄧ週的家課冊，也可問附近跟功課的補習社。

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	13885

18^#

發表於 12-4-11 11:44 |只看該作者

Yes, SFA is really outstanding but I know some pupils had quitted SFA midway as too hard to study; I know some pupils of YMT Catholic PS whose ranked 3x-5x could not get an interview chance for some B1 schools like WYK; My colleague’s son was in St. Joe, almost all pupils’ projects were done by parents, P6 exam were very hard (top pupils got low marks) as they just wanted to keep some good pupils no matter they got low marks; I know some pupils were top 10 in P6 got offers from SPCC but could not got offers nor even 2nd interview from Ying Wah, ranked 2x in the form got 2nd interview and one got offer from Ying Wah; My friend had selected a good school in the living district for his son, his son ask his parents why didn’t select La Salle for him… So believe in your kids.

I agree with many parents’ respective comments above. All parents know that to select some secondary schools where high % can go to U and select some primary schools where high % can go to those secondary schools. Parents and kids with less pressure to select secondary schools, the best way is to select some or like “一條龍” schools such as Marymount, La Salle, Pui Ching, Ying Wah… However, for studying in primary schools, I think the location is also very important, some “good” schools in the living district are better than “名校”. 做家長真艱難…

‹ 上一主題|下一主題 ›

發新帖

熱門主題

最高瀏覽主題

Copyright © 2002 - 2024 Baby-Kingdom.com Limited, All Rights Reserved.
有關我們
使用條款
免責聲明
私穩政策
廣告查詢