歪理還是道理? - 小一選校

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	4011

101^#

發表於 14-4-7 17:08 |只看該作者

回覆：甘恩的帖子

真心請教。雖然說獎項對考小一幫助不大，還是想請教一下你囝囝報了什麼課外活動，以作參考。另外，英，普語文証書又對升小有幫助嗎？

點評

甘恩已pm 發表於 14-4-7 22:56

Ving

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3543

102^#

發表於 14-4-7 18:50 |只看該作者

One advantage of St Paul Boy is higher rate from SPB primary to SPB secondary that can avoid too much competition in P5 and P6.

Rank: 4


	654

103^#

發表於 14-4-7 20:45 |只看該作者

引用：One+advantage+of+St+Paul+Boy+is+higher+r

原帖由 Ving 於 14-04-07 發表
One advantage of St Paul Boy is higher rate from SPB primary to SPB secondary that can avoid too muc ...

As long as you get good pass on the major subjects with satisfied conduct, you can promote to the St Paul's College with no doubt.

Pertra

禁止訪問


	6654

104^#

發表於 14-4-7 22:47 |只看該作者

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

Pertra

禁止訪問


	6654

105^#

發表於 14-4-7 23:02 |只看該作者

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

Rank: 4


	654

106^#

發表於 14-4-8 00:27 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 WingBB-222 於 14-4-8 00:36 編輯

回覆 Pertra 的帖子

I am trying to collect all the data I can access from SPC’s school reports. As per my records, there were only couple years the academic performance declining due to the change of DSS (SPC became a DSS school in 2002). Here is my finding......

Year	Jupas Offers
2000	57
2001	60
2002	71
2003	59
2004	61
2005	50
2006	54
2007	63
2008	57
2009	26

You may find the number of Jupas Offers dropped a lot on year 2009 (they were the last batch from government allocation before changing to DSS).

When everybody is talking about the banding of different secondary schools, they all refer to khmama's 18區中學banding排名 (http://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=2230797&extra=page%3D1).Since the list was analyzed based on the records collected on 2009, you can see how unlucky SPC was......

So here is my finding on the recent few years.....

On 2009, the university admission rate was 38%

On 2010, the university admission rate was 47%

On 2011, the university admission rate was 51%

On 2012, only 85 students enrolled in F.7 for this cohort, DSE: LOCAL DEGREES: 43.0% TOP 3 Us: 23.1%

On 2013, 71 Jupas Offers (57.72%), 86% having 33222, 22% achieving 25 grade points or above in the best 5 subjects. The highest grade point for the best seven subjects was 44 points.

The reason why I showed all these is everyone has different measure on ranking. I believe only the data can justify while there are different arguments on SPC’s banding. So these were what I found from the school reports, school website and the parents (special thanks to khmama, hogwarts and all those existing SPC parents).

To answer your question, SPC was band 1C according to khmama. In considering the improvement of academic performance in these few years, I would rank SPC is band 1B (保守地). Besides,all the sources or rumor you may say, the students in SPC or SPCPS are getting much improved years by years. So, I am waiting to hear more and more good news from SPC.

Sorry for the lengthy reply, hope it can help.

點評

Jackieson

發表於 15-1-21 09:37

ACE2126 Good. Support. 發表於 14-4-8 06:32

Ving

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3543

107^#

發表於 14-4-8 09:30 |只看該作者

Thx WingBB-222 data collection and I believe these are real fact.

But my question is, based on the quoted data, how do we really know that SPC is still Band 1C, Band 1B, or above. Or these result only reflect Band 2.
Is there any objective measurement as Kahma analysis is only based on past exam standard.

ppmmbb

子爵府

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	11668

108^#

發表於 14-4-8 10:05 |只看該作者

Ving 發表於 14-4-8 09:30
Thx WingBB-222 data collection and I believe these are real fact.

But my question is, based on the ...

今天入小一，12年後才考大學！
今天入U率，會否等同12年後！

Ving

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3543

109^#

發表於 14-4-8 11:33 |只看該作者

Of course things will change after 12 years. That's not only apply to school branding but everything. I believe syllabus and exam structure will change after 12 years time by our exam authority.

ericby

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	4514

110^#

發表於 14-4-8 12:14 |只看該作者

ckcleung 發表於 14-4-7 11:39
SPB 奧數小學組2013攞第二, 2014攞第三, 叻仔!

好勁

Rank: 4


	654

111^#

發表於 14-4-8 14:12 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 WingBB-222 於 14-4-10 18:00 編輯

"今天發生了一件事情，當時我曾經想力陳己見，最後選擇了沉默。我認為沉默是必要的。"

ppmmbb

子爵府

Rank: 7 Rank: 7 Rank: 7


	11668

112^#

發表於 14-4-8 15:18 |只看該作者

WingBB-222 發表於 14-4-8 14:12
回覆 Ving 的帖子

Actually only the P6 students are classified as band 1, 2 or 3 according to EDB, n ...

唔好意思，令你有不歡感！
我只想講太多人用中學部公開試成積去評小學部，而忽略小學自己真正一面！

點評

Jackieson 的確係, KTS是一例子發表於 15-1-21 09:32

Rank: 4


	654

113^#

發表於 14-4-8 22:50 |只看該作者

回覆：ppmmbb 的帖子

本帖最後由 WingBB-222 於 14-4-10 18:03 編輯

"今天發生了一件事情，當時我曾經想力陳己見，最後選擇了沉默。我認為沉默是必要的。"

深明樓主發此帖時的感受，批評別人太容易了，他們又何嘗了解到樓主花了好幾年的時間日日陪孩子玩、陪孩子學習成長、陪孩子閱讀，no pain no gain. 每一個 offer 都是得來不易的。祝願各位家長能多學懂包容、欣賞、互勵互勉！

對不起 ppmmbb, 有點借題發揮，你並沒有使我難受，你的疑慮和態度並沒有使我不高興，只是剛好借題發揮而已，sorry!