SPPCS Vs Sacred Heart (P.M.) - 小一選校

cmchang0927

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9424

2^#

發表於 10-7-10 17:30 |只看該作者

SH 課程深d, 一年級教二年級野
ST Paul's 淺d, 一年級教一年級野

其他校風, 有直屬中學同間中學都係band１英中女校

I think the difference is, u need to spend more time on school work and revisions for SH?

(My girl is going to St Paul's in Sept.....

)

學校情報
一條龍學校名單
2012終極小一校網詳細分析

iantsang

珍珠宮

Rank: 11

醒目開學勳章


	46447

3^#

發表於 10-7-10 18:12 |只看該作者

"SH 課程深d, 一年級教二年級野" <-- This is SHCSPS (Private am), not the case for SHCS (gov't aided pm).

SHCS is first 4 years pm, then P5 and 6 whole day.

SPCPS is P1/3/5 pm, P2/4/6 am.

原帖由 cmchang0927 於 10-7-10 17:30 發表
SH 課程深d, 一年級教二年級野
ST Paul's 淺d, 一年級教一年級野

其他校風, 有直屬中學同間中學都係band１英中女校

I think the difference is, u need to spend more time on school work and revisions for SH?

( ...

Rattie

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	5083

4^#

發表於 10-7-12 16:28 |只看該作者

其實兩間學校各有捧場客，揀邊一間都應該ok，請問樓主最後決定如何，相信兩間學校都有叩緊門嘅家長好心急咁等緊。

原帖由 szeric 於 10-7-10 14:57 發表
本來已決定讀聖心，但今早接到跑馬地聖保祿天主教小學的電話說有學位，如接受便要星期一到校註冊。兩間都是下午班，都要乘校車，程度是不是差不多？現在我又十五十六了，可否幫忙分析一下，thanks! ...

lauerica

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3364

5^#

發表於 10-7-12 17:48 |只看該作者

上年我個女又係呢二間學校揀，曾經係度都有問過大家意見，結果一面倒揀聖保錄，都係比你作參考，自已決定啦。

szeric

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	382

6^#

發表於 10-7-14 04:45 |只看該作者

我喜歡聖心用普教中和有兩年全日制的小學生活；但又很多人喜歡聖保祿，因能升上直屬中學的百分比大些。

在自己左思右想都選不到的情況下，我問女女想到那間升小一，始終她才是「用家」，她說喜歡聖保祿，結果昨天便帶她到聖保祿註冊了，她很開心和期待九月的來臨。

我則有點擔心和憂慮，因在諮詢各方好友的過程中得悉該校很「谷」，很多功課、默書、測驗，考試的題目「會轉彎再轉彎」，總之要求高，我要返工，她讀下午，我上午跟不到，時間可能會很緊迫。如小朋友真的在適應方面有問題，學校會否提供協助？抑或向家長施壓？如何準備才會過渡得好些？可否分享一下你們的經驗。

Rattie

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	5083

7^#

發表於 10-7-14 09:46 |只看該作者

歡迎歡迎。

今年升中好理想，全級只得十幾人入唔到band1英中，咁當然大部分係過去隔離中學。

放心喇，小一係適應期，佢返下午唔洗咁早訓，你會有足夠嘅親子時間。

我哋小學一覽嗰邊有好多好熱心嘅家長，應該幫到你同你囡架。

原帖由 szeric 於 10-7-14 04:45 發表
我喜歡聖心用普教中和有兩年全日制的小學生活；但又很多人喜歡聖保祿，因能升上直屬中學的百分比大些。

在自己左思右想都選不到的情況下，我問女女想到那間升小一，始終她才是「用家」，她說喜歡聖保祿，結果昨天便帶她到聖保祿 ...

lauerica

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	3364

8^#

發表於 10-7-14 10:07 |只看該作者

其實都重有一個case可以同大家分享，有位小學時期就讀聖保錄小學女生，佢可以原校直升中學，但因為係中文小學關系，初上中學全部變哂英文教學，佢話頭半年係課室恰眼訓，因為唔係好聽得明老師講乜？後來都係要靠一的朋友幫助先追得返個程度，由此可見，中文小學同英文小學分別係邊，所以我自已覺得讀英小係好繄要，純粹分享，無意貶低中文小學。

traeh

別墅

Rank: 4

醒目開學勳章


	943

9^#

發表於 10-7-14 10:48 |只看該作者

咁嘅情況，一係學校做銜接做得差（尤其係，如果連自己小學升上來都有問題，就真係好有問題，除非得佢一個有問題），一係個小朋友自己有問題。

你諗下當年（甚至而家）有幾多間英文小學？英文中學相對要多，而大部分小朋友都可以順利過渡。

原帖由 lauerica 於 10-7-14 10:07 發表
其實都重有一個case可以同大家分享，有位小學時期就讀聖保錄小學女生，佢可以原校直升中學，但因為係中文小學關系，初上中學全部變哂英文教學，佢話頭半年係課室恰眼訓，因為唔係好聽得明老師講乜？後來都係要靠一的朋友幫助先追得 ...

Rattie

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	5083

10^#

發表於 10-7-14 11:44 |只看該作者

e d case相信間間學校都有可能發生，初中教育嗰邊周不過時有post話升中後成績大倒退。

去到中學係進入另一個階段，面對嘅問題以及其原因各自不同。

KK07

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1378

11^#

發表於 10-7-14 15:34 |只看該作者

I am old enough to tell you that in the past, there were nearly no (or very few) English primary school (local education system) and over 85% secondary schools are so called English secondary schools. So, no need to worry much about the transition, it should be ok when your kids are serious to handle that. On the other hand, I did feel I was lucky to attend a chinese primary school, otherwise, my chinese standard would not be able to meet today's requirement (China trade...etc)

cmchang0927

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	9424

12^#

發表於 10-7-15 00:20 |只看該作者

其實我覺得過唔過到chinese primary school to eng primary school 呢關, 最重要係個人本身學習態度問題.... I have three old colleagues who were old girls from St Paul's Catholic Primary to St Paul's Secondary. Before I chose the primary school for my girl, I asked them the same Q, if they found any difficulties transit from Chinese Primary school to Eng Secondary, they all said that they have no problems on that (Their characters are quite similar, humble, positive and v. hard working). 又例如, 我小學都係讀中文小學, 仲要係地區ok個隻only. 我讀A班精英班, D同學差不多全部都派BAND ONE 學校. 有對孖女, 入BPS, 大咗一個婦產科, 一個精神科醫生. 有個成日考頭三名男同學, 自己考入ST PAUL CO EDU, 後來去咗美國, 係NORTON VIRUS做............ 有個成績中等, 入咗QC, 而家做緊LECTURER......... So I think the failure of transition isn't due to the chinese primary school, it's the personality of the student who deals with difficulties.......... 我個時都係band one 英中, 初時都覺得有困難, 只要肯查字典, 肯學, 第一課可能廿個字要查, 慢慢到第十課可能就只有幾個字要查. 好似我阿媽男朋友個女, 個性從小到大都係好逸惡勞. 佢升咗band 5 英中, 見到d野難即放棄, 又跟班人到處wet, 後來hkcee 都0 分.............英小有幾多間呢, 如果担心transition有問題, 可以買英數補充比佢keep 住做, d英小都係用longman本英數多, 睇多d readers, 都可是幫助小朋友適應英中環境

[ 本帖最後由 cmchang0927 於 10-7-15 00:23 編輯 ]

szeric

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	382

13^#

發表於 10-7-15 22:58 |只看該作者

原帖由 lauerica 於 10-7-12 17:48 發表
上年我個女又係呢二間學校揀，曾經係度都有問過大家意見，結果一面倒揀聖保錄，都係比你作參考，自已決定啦。

lauerica,

你上年最終揀了那一間？抑或揀讀英文小學？如想由中文小學轉讀英文小學會否很困難？我有朋友最後選了讀國際學校，小學四年級已有本地初中生的水平，閒時愛看英文書，對中文興趣不大，不知對未來升學就業有何影響。我負擔不起國際學校的費用，也不用想這條路了。

Babyarsene

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	2408

14^#

發表於 10-7-23 01:09 |只看該作者

I am old gals of SPSS, only the secondary school part, but not from their pri. school. 80% of my school mates are from st. paul primary school, and i was also from chinese primary school. I also had difficulty in learning at first since all subjects were conducted in English except Chinese and Chin. History. Even the morning assembly, recess, principal and the teachers used English to deliver school messages and talked to us in English. in first few days, i can't even get a single word of what they're talking about. But you know, children's adapation and launguage abillity are far more greater and better than adults. I think around 1-2 weeks later, i get used to the environment and one day i found i can understand what the teachers said 100%. For sure, it's within a month. Therefore, no need to worry that much of language ability, once you're in the environment, your children can do it easily. I was a good sample, so as my other classmates.

原帖由 lauerica 於 10-7-14 10:07 發表
其實都重有一個case可以同大家分享，有位小學時期就讀聖保錄小學女生，佢可以原校直升中學，但因為係中文小學關系，初上中學全部變哂英文教學，佢話頭半年係課室恰眼訓，因為唔係好聽得明老師講乜？後來都係要靠一的朋友幫助先追得 ...