教育王國

標題: 終於見完民生喇 [打印本頁]

作者: fc1668 時間: 08-11-9 01:27 標題: 終於見完民生喇

今日終於見完得唔得都好都叫做完成左,今日面試都唔似人地講得咁困難既,好輕鬆又夠快唔駛等成個鐘,真係20分鐘搞掂

作者: lkyma 時間: 08-11-9 01:34

原帖由 fc1668 於 08-11-9 01:27 發表
今日終於見完得唔得都好都叫做完成左,今日面試都唔似人地講得咁困難既,好輕鬆又夠快唔駛等成個鐘,真係20分鐘搞掂

just change from this year!

作者: bbmuimui 時間: 08-11-9 02:11

yes,我個囡舊年in都係分開見ga,maybe因為今年轉左新校長啦, anyway,祝你小朋友成功.

作者: jojoplanet 時間: 08-11-10 10:06

原帖由 bbmuimui 於 08-11-9 02:11 發表
yes,我個囡舊年in都係分開見ga,maybe因為今年轉左新校長啦, anyway,祝你小朋友成功.

見完之後對呢間學校印象唔係咁好.

作者: tszwaima 時間: 08-11-10 10:08

點解呀?

作者: stone940828 時間: 08-11-10 10:15

點解呀!可唔可以分享下呀!
我本來都有報民生,
但最後都係沒有面試,
當然我自己就唔會覺可惜,先作決定.

今年的安排,好似有好多家長唔太滿意,
但我自己又覺得呢種面試方式,
小朋友冇咁大壓力喎!

原帖由 jojoplanet 於 08-11-10 10:06 發表

見完之後對呢間學校印象唔係咁好.

作者: jojoplanet 時間: 08-11-10 10:47

我第一間in既係又一村, 感覺好好, d 人好親切, 有training有preparation咁，　你唔好理佢真定假起碼你覺得佢地又heart, 星期六早上我in咗協和先既, 感覺都係一般, 係等緊既時候阿仔因為個波"look'咗出班房出面, 當時有兩個先生係度傾緊計阿仔行出去攞返, 佢地都係無理佢....到in既時候係一張長枱有6-7個小朋友加家長, 咁一路玩就問下小朋友, 問下我野咁...總括佢先生比我既印象唔係咁專業....但係去見民生時, d先生同樣比到呢ｄ感覺我，

但係ｉｎ既過程仲衰過協和，因為佢間房大ｄ，有三張長枱，每張有５－６個小朋友，你可唔可以想象到有幾嘈。我個張枱ｄ小朋友都係２．５歲，但係我個仔係未夠２歲，我之前都係ｂｋ知道ｄ媽咪話佢地都係偏向選大仔，我預咗唔得當係比ｂｂ一個經驗啫，我見個先生問其他人係有心機ｄ，問我同ｂｂ就好求其咁．佢地比我既感覺係覺得自己學校好醒唔憂做咁．．．唔係只係我覺得我朋友都有ｉｎ．．都係覺得ｄ先生無愛心．．

原帖由 stone940828 於 08-11-10 10:15 發表
點解呀!可唔可以分享下呀!
我本來都有報民生,
但最後都係沒有面試,
當然我自己就唔會覺可惜,先作決定.

今年的安排,好似有好多家長唔太滿意,
但我自己又覺得呢種面試方式,
小朋友冇咁大壓力喎!

...

作者: lovebbmom 時間: 08-11-10 13:39

之前果日, DADDY 同妹妹IN 過本區另一間...佢話INTERVIEW 既SITUATION 大至一様...都係OBSERVATION 為主...

今年妹妹都有INTERVIEW, 但DADDY 同佢入去, 所以我同仔仔係出面等...我大仔時, 都係DADDY 同佢去INTERVIEW...因為果年岩岩妹妹出生...DADDY 話比以前简單好多...家下妹妹係細女(接近兩歲), 比起哥哥當年(接近3 歲), 所以可以話MUG 都唔識...迫唔來...佢得自然做到...但係自侓(食飯, 自理能力相)好過哥哥...心諗係咁短INTERVIEW, 係睇唔到D MUG...收佢CHANCE 可能唔多...我報區外只有呢一間,...不過, 可能因為咁....縱使我希望兩兄妹同一間學校...我又好輕鬆...相信一定有一間幼稚園收佢...起碼, 同培正比起來, 妹妹有CHANCE IN 先...都幾阿Q架....

果日, 我係出面等...我印象好深...唔係學校...係有兩位家長...有個女家長遲到, D 童子軍叫住佢, LEAD 佢去課室,竟然XXX...罵個童子軍...佢唔係好大聲..不過係正我同阿仔前...HUH...

另外, 係出口等, 又有一位男家長唔肯聽過小童話講企後D...個小童子軍仔好有禮貌咁解釋老師叫佢地呼籲D 家長合作...之後..果位家長EEOO咁話佢...HUH, 可能D 家長好緊張, 又無留意呢D唔起眼小童子軍仔...但係我欣賞佢地盡己份...

作者: Jackdude 時間: 08-11-10 16:38

I didn't think the arrangement is that impressive anyway.. especially the powerpoint presentation, it is not informative. Parents are just there, waiting, and they don't even bother offering a Q&A session.

作者: jojoplanet 時間: 08-11-10 17:07

Oh..my interview was at 4:30 pm and didn't have any presentation wow...and before I called to check if there was any briefing to parent and they said NO.

原帖由 Jackdude 於 08-11-10 16:38 發表
I didn't think the arrangement is that impressive anyway.. especially the powerpoint presentation, it is not informative. Parents are just there, waiting, and they don't even bother offering a Q&A se ...

作者: chaukwan 時間: 08-11-10 17:52

我星期日都同個囡去in咗, 印象麻麻, d先生好似唔係好俾心機佢咁啱問著我個囡的弱項colour, 跟住佢都冇再問佢其它嘢
但隔離果位小朋友答到佢d問題佢就問佢好多嘢, 唔鐘意佢哋咁囉, 顏色唔識你可以再問吓其它都得但佢就咁算啦
所以唔係幾好俾我個感覺係要子識嘢果d小朋友先得囉
同埋如果小朋友答得佢d嘢唔多佢同家長的談話都係冇乜兩句

作者: lee111mama 時間: 08-11-11 00:09

嘩!!聽講有外籍老師面試,好彩我個仔見慣外籍朋友所以沒有怕羞,相反也看到其他bb的面試,很能夠看到真實的一面,書得也服!!!!

作者: fc1668 時間: 08-11-11 01:21

嘩, 咩有外籍人咩,唔覺既?果日iNTERVIEW係真係幾嘈架,10幾個小朋友係間房度,都唔知聽唔聽到佢地答野野既,不過是但啦,反正答晒問題又唔一定收既,是是但求求其啦,最緊要亞仔玩得開心

到最後咩學校斬無我都無法~

作者: coeyyeung 時間: 08-11-11 08:57

I also feel the progress of the interview is not so impressive. Quite noisy, many people in one room. Teacher 無愛心. only ask 2 questions for my child. (1) 你玩咩？（２）你叫咩名? (3) Bye Bye

作者: noelyip 時間: 08-11-11 12:52

妳都好過我見果個，個老師又係無咩愛心咁，見我個女答得唔好，就好尤其咁問我兩句就算，全程黑口黑面，連拜拜都無一句，認真無禮貌！

作者: Jackdude 時間: 08-11-11 13:11

原帖由 jojoplanet 於 08-11-10 17:07 發表
Oh..my interview was at 4:30 pm and didn't have any presentation wow...and before I called to check if there was any briefing to parent and they said NO.

Hi Jojoplanet,

The presentation i refer to is for parents who waited outside while baby is having their interview.

My wife went into the interview with my daughter, while I attented the interview. but trust me, you didn't miss anything AT ALL!!!

作者: jojoplanet 時間: 08-11-11 14:13

I see...well....even if they accept my son, I even won't pay the reservation fee.....those teachers disappointed me so much...

原帖由 Jackdude 於 08-11-11 13:11 發表

Hi Jojoplanet,

The presentation i refer to is for parents who waited outside while baby is having their interview.

My wife went into the interview with my daughter, while I attented the interview ...

作者: sweetcouple 時間: 08-11-11 15:43

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: coeyyeung 時間: 08-11-12 08:57

I also have same feeling with sweetcouple. 好似內定左, Interview 只係做樣比父母睇.唔想我地問唔公平.

作者: secondbaby 時間: 08-11-12 11:32

o個日interview o個個老師總共兜左三個圈，問左我個囝囝同埋我共三個問題:
1)問我個囝囝:你叫咩名呀?你幾多歲呀?(我個囝囝好快咁答完佢，老師就好快咁走左)
2)問我:平時同囝囝會有d咩親子活動?(我都未答完佢，佢個身就已經向左我地右邊o個個小朋友同埋家長，我覺得佢完全唔在意我既答案，只係好似敷衍了事)
3)問我個囝囝:佢攞起其中一籃玩具問我個囝囝邊個係綠色?(我個囝囝雖然係知道綠色係邊個，但係我個囝囝就攞左個紫色話俾老師聽呢個係紫色，之後先至答老師個個係綠色，我以為我個囝囝今次答得咁精靈，應該冇問題啦，但係老師又再一次行左去，究竟係唔係真係內定左o架，有d失望)

我有留意到同我個囝囝同一group interview既小朋友，個個都被lee位老師問colour，雖然有d bb答到亦有d bb答唔到，但係lee位老師完全冇諗過再問其他問題，枱上面仲有d車d動物puzzle，我覺得可以問下其他野囉?
經過lee次interview我就有個問題想問番lee位老師:除左colour之外，其他既常識就唔重要嗎?同埋想問民生既收生定義係咩呢?

我知道今年既interview同過往唔同，但係我真係覺得民生真係要檢討下佢地個收生interview程序呀!

[ 本帖最後由 secondbaby 於 08-11-12 11:37 編輯 ]

作者: bbmuimui 時間: 08-11-12 15:04

看到很多家長interview完的留言, 我想借個位講幾句話, 我囡囡現讀k1班, 其實, 大家覺得interview時兒戲, 我估主要原因係因為interview時實在太多人了, 試想想一日要面見5000位幼兒, 有時唔係老師唔想問, 而係礙於時間有限.
至於有家長話唔知收生標準, 我自己覺得民生唔係要收好叻的小朋友, 同我囡同班亦有細囝細囡, 反而民生在乎家長與孩子的關係, 所以民生用觀察形式interview, 老師可以從旁看家長與孩子的親子關係.
另外亦有家長提到老師無愛心, 這點我絕對唔認同, 我囡囡的老師好關心小朋友, 跟小朋友跟得好足, 囡囡在校有任何問題都會聯絡家長, 我囡囡亦好鍾意老師, 好鍾意返學.

~以上只是我個人的意見和感受.

作者: lovebbmom 時間: 08-11-12 17:37

bbmuimui,
Hihi, I agree...
Too many candidate...
My son is in K2.  He love his school and teacher so much.  And, I sometimes even receive the phone calls from his class teachers.  They are very kind.

It is not a school to train the kids to be very outstanding but one the kids love to learn and emphasize on good family relationship.

Anyway, my son can read all the books when come back home ...and the reading programmes ...stimulate him to read a lot...

Honestly, my son and my daughter also interviewed some other schools.  I don't think any of them give me the impression of very good arrangement in the process of interview...

The choice of kindergarten is of course up to you all ... But, if just look at one angle and give comments...it's not the proper way..Try to seek more advice from others first.

Hope u all find a good kindergarten.  And, no matter how good the school is...., more communicate with kids...

^_^

作者: kwklam 時間: 08-11-12 20:52

外籍teacher 會計分嗎? At my classroom, 1 local teacher mark 1 table, and that 外籍teacher asked my BB only for my table, but my BB didn't answer any questions

作者: TseTszMa 時間: 08-11-14 00:32

見完民生，覺得學校的整體安排真的有很大問題！我和老公帶埋大仔同細仔到校，首先要在窄窄的行人路排隊，巳經好唔好，接著有老師阻止我們入內，說只可以二位家長陪同小朋友入內，咁我老公即刻問佢咁唔通要我個大仔响門口等咩？（佢６歲）咁即係叫我老公唔好入啦！
入到去我唔記帶出世紙正本，叫我老公拎番比我，我响門口等佢，個老師又同我講話我老公可以有信入嚟，吓
咁即係你又比佢入啦？
咁我同細仔入到去，每一個童軍都好盡責咁問我見幾多號室（係每一個），咁我即係比人問左好多好多次！上到課室場面混亂，十幾個小朋
友加十幾個家長，外耤老師不是所有人都有傾計，其餘３個老師又沒有分配清楚，有小朋友問完又問，有小朋
友不太回應老師問題，老師說好，轉頭再問，接著又沒有轉頭再問巳可離開，吓咁即係點呀？最終出世紙正本當然完全沒有看一眼，咁叫人帶來做咩呢？
完全給人很公式的感覺！太多人可以分多１日見啫，如果咁樣見法，同唔見又有咩分別呢？
小學幼稚園加埋我都見過十幾間，呢間既見法同安排真係...........都唔識形容！

[ 本帖最後由 TseTszMa 於 08-11-14 00:34 編輯 ]

作者: dora611 時間: 08-11-14 21:44

不用show出世紙正本? 我interview個日無帶正本, 民生要我3日內帶返張正本去校務處俾佢check wor.

作者: oliviapylo 時間: 08-11-16 21:14

我大女依家讀緊k.3, 回想當日面試同今次細仔去見相差非常大.

大女嗰時係小學班房見, 每個時段10個小朋友, 係一個課室等, 無玩具呀, 啲小朋友如果係第8, 9, 10個都等幾耐呀. 見就係第二個班房見, 老師係每次見一對親子, 大人係班房尾, 小朋友係班房頭, 兩個老師係裡面, 非常認真.

今次細仔見係返幼稚園班房, 我都有啲出奇, 好以一般稚幼園咁, 一大班小朋友係同一個班房, 老師見完一個再一個, 等小朋友可以係處玩.

各有各好啦, 其實點做都唔會完美.

作者: coeyyeung 時間: 08-11-18 08:43

I think too much application in Munsang. and they need to complete it in one day. It's the only method!!

作者: jojoplanet 時間: 08-11-18 09:12

原帖由 coeyyeung 於 08-11-18 08:43 發表
I think too much application in Munsang. and they need to complete it in one day. It's the only method!!

咁點解佢地一定要一日完成先, 咪就係唔想浪費佢地自己既時間囉...我阿仔會見創價, 原先一路都係話22-23/11但係後來收到信, 因為佢地收到太多申請所以會加多一日...係29/11 in..雖然我未in..但係人地起碼會付出多d時間呀..

覺得好多學校可能都係有好多申請，從申請表資料己經做咗一次ｓｃｒｅｅｎｉｎｇ再ｓｈｏｒｔｌｉｓｔ一批出黎，咁再加埋佢地ｉｎ既表現就作決定．．．佢地既ｃｒｉｔｅｒｉａ可能係，大仔，有讀ｎｕｒｓｅｒｙ，家庭背景．．．呢ｄ可理解之不過我覺得ｍｕｎｓａｎｇ門面功夫做得唔係咁好睇囉．．

作者: ChristieMing 時間: 08-11-18 10:19

雖然,我都覺得今次民生o既面試欠妥善，但我又覺得唔可以單單憑面試o既模式and老師表現而去決定是否選擇呢一間學校。

大家試想想，同一日有咁多人面試，早o個批o個o的，可能會見到老師和顏悅色，下午in o個o的，可能會見到o的老師無表情，又黑口黑面咁。換轉係你，同一日，要不停去做同一樣野，你都一樣會好攰，會無表現吧！！！

我in o左另一間學校，個情況就如大家所講o既，老師黑口黑面，無表情，問野好求奇，但因為我係下午4點先in，佢地已經做o左一日野，所以我都好體諒佢地。呢間學校係同區點名讚好，老師很有愛心的學校呢！我唔會因為面試o個日見到o既，就一口否定老師沒有愛心。

民生面試當日，單單見童軍o既表現，我已經覺得好好。可能我早in(9am)，老師面試好好，好nice，我見隔離位小朋友唔答問題，佢都會引導佢去答。

作者: chunlaifat 時間: 08-11-18 14:27

I think the arrangment is better than St. Cat. At least my daughter played happily during the interview and didn't feel the pressure.

作者: bbmuimui 時間: 08-11-18 22:26

有家長提意民生做多一日INTERVIEW, 其實民生亦有一定難處, 我小朋友讀民生K1, 每個星期六, 民生都會有興趣班, 例如畫班及舞蹈班俾民生的小朋友參加, 如果要開多一日INTERVIEW, 我相信對學校本身的行政亦有一定影響. 不過, 始終果句啦, 民生真係一間好學校.

作者: 似水流年 時間: 08-11-20 18:54 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

請問當天要交一張由家長填寫點解要選民生的那封信重要嗎？如果家長寫得好，合他們意，不知道會增加取錄的機會嗎？還是只看當天bb和家長的表現呢？

作者: fc1668 時間: 08-11-21 13:31

應該係睇運氣

作者: **芳芳** 時間: 08-11-21 18:07

但係若然連問卷都答得 "求其", 又怎可能令學校去考慮取錄呢???

作者: babydarren 時間: 08-11-27 10:13

我都覺得民生面試做得不夠妥善, 整體嚟講印象麻麻, 感覺唔到學校有幾重視今次面試,老師亦表現唔到愛心. 至於面試形式, 我只能說環境太嘈, 連埋家長有成廿幾人喺間課室裡面, 未in嘅家長就有佢地講, 有啲小朋友爭玩具. 老師有老師問問題, 小朋友唔答就算, 好似冇用心去in. 試問係啲咁嘈吵+迫嘅環境, 小朋友又點會專心?? 又點會有好表現?? 我小朋友都冇好表現, 結果都應該係睇運氣.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)