教育王國
標題: Pui Ching or St Paul Convent [打印本頁]
作者: boboluk 時間: 09-2-11 17:56 標題: Pui Ching or St Paul Convent
ask for opinion? which would you choose for your girl?thanks for advise.
作者: pluto_yuen 時間: 09-2-11 20:57
St. Pauls convent coz the primary school and secondary school are english school. Moreover they has better academic results than PUI CHING
作者: alowe 時間: 09-2-11 23:35
Absolutely St Paul's Convent, except you think a co-ed school is more suitable for your girl.
作者: ysnmama 時間: 09-2-12 10:22
St. Paul Convent.
作者: BabyHilary 時間: 09-2-12 10:39
St Paul's Convent for sure
作者: mow-mow 時間: 09-2-12 12:06
Pui Ching is a good school but if pitched against St Paul Convent I think most parents would opt for St Paul Convent.
作者: marcusmom 時間: 09-2-13 18:08
100% St Paul Convent
作者: sallyfung001 時間: 09-2-14 09:15
It depends your choice between:
1. co-ed vs convent
2. english medium vs chinese medium
作者: KeranMa 時間: 09-2-14 11:04
St Paul Convent
作者: HebeMama630 時間: 09-2-14 15:12
of course st.paul convent no matter where you live
作者: sallyfung001 時間: 09-2-14 17:10
for me absolutely St Paul convent!
作者: bigbighei 時間: 09-2-16 11:17
may I know ST.Paul convent is that girl school?
作者: hellomickey 時間: 09-2-16 11:24
Yes,for girls only!!
作者: rosalini 時間: 09-2-23 00:34
那麼 St Paul Convent與協恩相比又如何?
作者: alowe 時間: 09-2-24 00:22
先旨聲明, 以下是本人之愚見, 並不是權威. 歡迎指正.
兩間學校小學相差不大, 除了St Paul's Convent 是私校, 協恩是津校外. St Paul's Convent 可能較活, 較多攪作. 協恩則較以學業為主. 但中學開始分歧較大.下面是兩間中學的比較.
St Paul's Convent 學業成績可能比協恩好些少. 在課程方面, 學校比較開放, 能跟上甚至帶領潮流. 因學校已轉直資, 課程靈活性較大, 學生背景不錯,有較多學生會出國留學, 學校與外國亦有很多聯繫.
協恩則比較傳統, 或可說保守. 但學生有全面性發展, 音樂, 體育都非常出色. 學業成績也不差.
如果你囡囡已有計劃他日出國留學, St Paul's Convent 會適合些. 如果你囡囡音樂或體育都好, 協恩較多機會發揮. 此外, 前者較洋化, 後者較中國化.前者是天主教, 後者是基督教.
作者: kyliejet 時間: 09-2-24 09:44
alowe,
我好認同你的睇法，咁協恩與聖心又如何？是否比較相近？
作者: rtam 時間: 09-2-24 13:08
Hi alowe,
我覺得你講得好有道理。我其實好喜歡協恩girls, 她們真的好all-rounded, 個個都好有自信和好活躍,…另外港島區的表表者有St.Stephen Girls’ 亦同協恩好近似, 不過我認識不深, 感覺較貴族, 不知有沒有多些關於此校之意見，讓我也多了解幾間1st tier的女校。我許多媽媽級朋友都以DGS,Maryknoll,St.Paul視為一線名女校,緊貼的是St.Stephen Girls,聖心和協恩, 不知你又同意否。
quote]原帖由 alowe 於 09-2-24 00:22 發表 
先旨聲明, 以下是本人之愚見, 並不是權威. 歡迎指正.
兩間學校小學相差不大, 除了St Paul's Convent 是私校, 協恩是津校外. St Paul's Convent 可能較活, 較多攪作. 協恩則較以學業為主. 但中學開始分歧較大.下面是 ... [/quote]
[ 本帖最後由 rtam 於 09-2-24 15:26 編輯 ]
作者: invitation 時間: 09-2-24 15:34
Dear rtam,
i think a lot of people do not agree with "以DGS,Maryknoll,St.Paul視為一線名女校,其次才是St.Stephen Girls,聖心和協恩, ".
in addition, there are many excellent girl schools like Marymount, St. Mary... etc etc.
作者: rtam 時間: 09-2-24 16:11
Yes, I actually agreed.
I see all those schools are very top schools but they just nurture their students in different ways.
Perhaps the parents I talked with are all DGS / Maryknoll fans so they gave me such impression.
Hope my message won’t upset anyone.
quote]
原帖由 invitation 於 09-2-24 15:34 發表
Dear rtam,
i think a lot of people do not agree with "以DGS,Maryknoll,St.Paul視為一線名女校,其次才是St.Stephen Girls,聖心和協恩, ".
in addition, there are many excellent girl schools like Marymount, ... [/quote]
作者: yoyojohn 時間: 09-2-24 16:13
請問你們所講的聖心是那一間？
作者: iantsang 時間: 09-2-24 16:49
There should be only one 聖心, which is 嘉諾撒聖心. Their primary campus is in mid-level. Technically, you can say two if consider the AM section (private) and PM section separately, but they share the same campus. Their secondary section is in HK island south.
原帖由 yoyojohn 於 09-2-24 16:13 發表
請問你們所講的聖心是那一間？
作者: alowe 時間: 09-2-25 00:52
在各位提出的學校中, 我始終覺得就小學來說, 分別不太大. 因為小學沒有公開試, 很難作學業上的比較. 而且各小學都有feeder school 亦不需太谷學生, 所以學生潛力亦未盡出. 看不到真實.
不過在收生方面, 私立和直資小學會較著數, 因為可揀學生. 好似DG 同St Paul's Con, 小學同中學都可以唔好唔收, 但津小好似Maryknoll, St Mary, Marymount, 協恩,則有部分學生是攪珠入的, 這些學生可說是良莠不齊, 間接拉低學校整體成績. 據知Maryknoll 小學每年亦有很多學生升不回原校, 要知道只要有Band 2成績, 而學校又有位就可升回原校. 因此是學校辦得唔好還是制度所累, 值得大家思考.此外, Band 2就可升回自己中學, 這亦會影響會考成績, 所以Maryknoll, St Stephen's 等學校成績好像不如前了. 這亦是有些名校要轉直資的原因.
我個人認為DG在音樂, 體育及學業成績都是非常出色; St Paul's Con 學業成績亦很好, 學生靈活又具創意, 目光遠大, 課外活動成績亦不錯; Marymount 從小學升上的學生成績並不太突出(因為是feeder school), 但學生會考成績甚佳, 這證明學校辦得很好, 令學生增值; 協恩學生全面發展, 學業成績亦很好, 這些學校都可撥入第一梯次頭. 聖心, 聖瑪琍成績也很好但其他方面略遜, Maryknoll, 聖士提反成績和課外活動成績稍退,但憑過去名氣, 這些學校仍可在第一梯次佔一席位.
作者: rtam 時間: 09-2-25 08:30
多謝你的意見, 真是極好的綜合, 與我向教育界朋友及多位該等學校家長收集的寶貴意見很接近, 但你的綜合就更precise。每間學校也如此出色,希望我們沒有把女兒放錯位置。
原帖由 alowe 於 09-2-25 00:52 發表
在各位提出的學校中, 我始終覺得就小學來說, 分別不太大. 因為小學沒有公開試, 很難作學業上的比較. 而且各小學都有feeder school 亦不需太谷學生, 所以學生潛力亦未盡出. 看不到真實.
不過在收生方面, 私立和直資 ...
作者: yoyojohn 時間: 09-2-25 09:35
原帖由 iantsang 於 09-2-24 16:49 發表
There should be only one 聖心, which is 嘉諾撒聖心. Their primary campus is in mid-level. Technically, you can say two if consider the AM section (private) and PM section separately, but they share ...
Thanks，原來校址在港島南，相信應該在置富花園旁，我錯覺以為有一間在九龍塘港鐵出口是聖心 
作者: yoyojohn 時間: 09-2-25 09:39
原帖由 alowe 於 09-2-25 00:52 發表
在各位提出的學校中, 我始終覺得就小學來說, 分別不太大. 因為小學沒有公開試, 很難作學業上的比較. 而且各小學都有feeder school 亦不需太谷學生, 所以學生潛力亦未盡出. 看不到真實.
不過在收生方面, 私立和直資 ...
多謝你的分析，令我開始對一線學校有一個概念。
作者: iantsang 時間: 09-2-25 21:05
Yes, you are correct! SHCC is right next to 置富花園.
The one you mentioned, I guess you may have mixed it up with 嘉諾撒聖家?
原帖由 yoyojohn 於 09-2-25 09:35 發表
Thanks，原來校址在港島南，相信應該在置富花園旁，我錯覺以為有一間在九龍塘港鐵出口是聖心
作者: iantsang 時間: 09-2-26 00:08
Here are some links to public exam results for parents' references:
St. Paul's Convent School (English subject only)
http://ihouse.hkedcity.net/~sp1400/curriculum/department/eng/pubexam.htm
香港培正中學 (listed the top ranked students only)
http://www.puiching.edu.hk/
Marymount Secondary School
http://www.mss.edu.hk/Achievement/hkcee/ce2008/ce2008.htm
http://www.mss.edu.hk/Achievement/hkal/al2008/al2008.htm
Sacred Heart Canossian College
http://www.shcc.edu.hk/info/061107aa.pdf
Belilios Public School
http://www.belilios.net/academic/hkcee2008.html
Not everyone of them posted their HKCEE on the web so I can only manage to provide some of them for reference.
原帖由 alowe 於 09-2-25 00:52 發表
在各位提出的學校中, 我始終覺得就小學來說, 分別不太大. 因為小學沒有公開試, 很難作學業上的比較. 而且各小學都有feeder school 亦不需太谷學生, 所以學生潛力亦未盡出. 看不到真實.
不過在收生方面, 私立和直資 ...
[ 本帖最後由 iantsang 於 09-2-26 00:15 編輯 ]
作者: Mollymama 時間: 09-3-12 14:25
There is another Canossian School at Quarry Bay. Is it belonged to the same group as SHCC next to 置富花園?
原帖由 iantsang 於 09-2-25 21:05 發表
Yes, you are correct! SHCC is right next to 置富花園.
The one you mentioned, I guess you may have mixed it up with 嘉諾撒聖家?
作者: Mollymama 時間: 09-3-12 14:26
Your info is very helpful. Thanks a lot!!
作者: iantsang 時間: 09-3-12 15:36
That's Canossa College, and it's under the same group.
原帖由 Mollymama 於 09-3-12 14:25 發表
There is another Canossian School at Quarry Bay. Is it belonged to the same group as SHCC next to 置富花園?
作者: mansumbb 時間: 09-3-12 16:01
Hi iantsang,
Refer to the ihouse.hkedcity.net link you quoted, do you know how to browse the result for other school? Thanks.
作者: iantsang 時間: 09-3-12 16:09
Hi mansumbb,
I reach that site from St Paul's Convent own web site. Some school use the hkedcity platform to put their own web site only.
It took me a lot of time to eventually find that result from St. Paul's Convent, they didn't put all the result out and only have posted the English result under their English department.
Ian
原帖由 mansumbb 於 09-3-12 16:01 發表
Hi iantsang,
Refer to the ihouse.hkedcity.net link you quoted, do you know how to browse the result for other school? Thanks.
作者: Ms.ChanChan 時間: 09-3-15 18:01
原帖由 iantsang 於 09-3-12 16:09 發表
Hi mansumbb,
I reach that site from St Paul's Convent own web site. Some school use the hkedcity platform to put their own web site only.
It took me a lot of time to eventually find that result fro ...
iantsang,
You can refer to their prospectus for their HKCEE and A-level result for all the subjects (P. 7) -
http://ihouse.hkedcity.net/~sp1400/prospectus.pdf
[ 本帖最後由 Ms.ChanChan 於 09-3-15 18:02 編輯 ]
作者: yeungmaple 時間: 09-3-15 19:07
請問大家知道怎麼可以找到協恩的公開試成績嗎?我在hkedcity網頁acheivement部分只找到課外活動的資料，先謝。
作者: iantsang 時間: 09-3-15 20:48
Thanks very much Ms.ChanChan!
mansumbb, please refer to the link to access SPCS's HKCEE results in 2008.
作者: boboluk 時間: 09-3-18 10:57
咁究竟SPK 定培正ranking 好D?係咪應該話培正比較樸素DSPK比較新潮D?thanks
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |