教育王國

標題: SFA Acceptance Letter [打印本頁]

作者: Piaget 時間: 09-11-6 23:02 標題: SFA Acceptance Letter

Heard that some people have got the offer letter already. Much earlier than the expected date!

作者: luiluimama 時間: 09-11-6 23:11

唔係呀麻? 早成個星期?

原帖由 Piaget 於 09-11-6 23:02 發表
Heard that some people have got the offer letter already. Much earlier than the expected date!

作者: KwokYi 時間: 09-11-6 23:26

Really?? I have not received any letter from SFA. When did he/she receive the letter??

作者: Piaget 時間: 09-11-6 23:30

This Wednesday i.e. Nov. 4, 2009.

原帖由 KwokYi 於 09-11-6 23:26 發表
Really?? I have not received any letter from SFA. When did he/she receive the letter??

作者: kikispider 時間: 09-11-6 23:31

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: childrenfirst 時間: 09-11-6 23:44

Piaget, you must be kidding, SFA won't issue acceptance letter, they post it in front of their school at 8:00am on Nov 13. They do it like this every year. I doubt where you get the source from.

作者: childrenfirst 時間: 09-11-6 23:46

sorry, i didn't read it carefully, they said they may issue the letter before the notice date. sorry for that.

作者: luiluimama 時間: 09-11-6 23:48

唔係喎, 學校通告寫明獲取錄既學生, 會於13/11學校報告版公佈, 但學校亦會於當日前發信通知獲取錄學生, 不獲取錄既學生就唔會收到信

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 09-11-6 23:44 發表
Piaget, you must be kidding, SFA won't issue acceptance letter, they post it in front of their school at 8:00am on Nov 13. They do it like this every year. I doubt where you get the source from.

作者: tiksilong 時間: 09-11-6 23:55

That means it is possible that 13/11 前發信通知獲取錄學生.

原帖由 luiluimama 於 09-11-6 23:48 發表
唔係喎, 學校通告寫明獲取錄既學生, 會於13/11學校報告版公佈, 但學校亦會於當日前發信通知獲取錄學生, 不獲取錄既學生就唔會收到信

作者: Piaget 時間: 09-11-6 23:56

I wonder if I still have to bother to go to the school in order to check the result on black Friday if I receive nothing before that day.

原帖由 luiluimama 於 09-11-6 23:48 發表
唔係喎, 學校通告寫明獲取錄既學生, 會於13/11學校報告版公佈, 但學校亦會於當日前發信通知獲取錄學生, 不獲取錄既學生就唔會收到信

作者: luiluimama 時間: 09-11-6 23:57

係呀, 通告係咁寫咖, 所以我都諗緊到時去唔去睇

原帖由 tiksilong 於 09-11-6 23:55 發表
That means it is possible that 13/11 前發信通知獲取錄學生.

作者: tiksilong 時間: 09-11-7 00:21

都係, 如果係冇信...山長水遠去到為mug...

原帖由 luiluimama 於 09-11-6 23:57 發表
係呀, 通告係咁寫咖, 所以我都諗緊到時去唔去睇

作者: KwokYi 時間: 09-11-7 00:50

Anyone alse received acceptance letter??? When did you receive it???

作者: VIRUS 時間: 09-11-7 10:39

anyone received ?

作者: MaggieHei 時間: 09-11-7 10:59

收到都唔奇. 因為封信寫明, 13/11 在校門張貼公布. 如果取錄, 會在 13/11 前收到信, 如果不予取錄, 不會及信通知.

所以, 現在已收到信的, 一點也不出奇...
反而, 13/11 仍未收到信. 你去唔去睇放榜才是問題. 因為好似是去確認自己個小朋友榜上無名..會否有點難受呢

作者: dougdora 時間: 09-11-7 13:57

personally, i really find this school is living in "stone age".. the way they communicate and treat applicants.. fm accept appln (long Q), interview registration and waiting arrangement (long Q again and more put kids to a temp toilets!!!), fm result announcement...

this is age of communication, internet and web is so common, why can't they post on web????

strange, anyone it is only my personally opinion.. of course we always have right to choose and vice versa... .. just to release my stress here!

作者: euka 時間: 09-11-7 14:45

Good hope issued acceptance letter earlier as well.
For SFA, they will send letter in previous years.
For me, I have not received letter yet

作者: sylam28 時間: 09-11-7 16:24

今早我打電話問學校, 他們說錄取信還未寄出.

作者: lbb 時間: 09-11-7 16:55

Thank you for your info..

作者: pyyip 時間: 09-11-7 17:20

Sylam, 多謝妳的消息.

原帖由 sylam28 於 09-11-7 16:24 發表
今早我打電話問學校, 他們說錄取信還未寄出.

作者: cherryyim 時間: 09-11-7 17:31

I have also taken a look at the letter (application procedures) of the school. It says they will mail to the successful candidates, but it doesn't mention when wor... There is nothing like "mail before Nov 13".

Anyway, it's good to know the truth at last. I will go to the school on Nov 13 even if I haven't received anything next week.

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-11-8 01:02

Couldn't agree with you, and not only with school. The whole system is so wasteful. Why just use the internet its so simple.

原帖由 dougdora 於 09-11-7 13:57 發表
personally, i really find this school is living in "stone age".. the way they communicate and treat applicants.. fm accept appln (long Q), interview registration and waiting arrangement (long Q again ...

作者: KwokYi 時間: 09-11-9 17:01

The acceptance letters will be sent out on this Wed/Thu.

On the other hand, I also hope that they will have a better arrangment about toilet from next year. At least Several Hundreds people for a day to use only four movable toilets. Try to think about the hygiene and the difficulties for the children to use. (expecially for girls). For the staff, they could use the toilets upstairs. If they though the movable toilets are fine to use, why they did not use it together??? Terrible !!!!!!!!

作者: luiluimama 時間: 09-11-9 17:03

請問你點知今個星期三/四會寄出D信呀?

作者: Piglets 時間: 09-11-9 17:12

The school mentioned the letters will be sent out on this Wednesday. I phoned up the school today.

作者: fatbb_mama 時間: 09-11-9 17:19

原帖由 KwokYi 於 09-11-9 17:01 發表
The acceptance letters will be sent out on this Wed/Thu.

On the other hand, I also hope that they will have a better arrangment about toilet from next year. At least Several Hundreds people for a da ...

yes, I agree, very bad arrangement during the interview.

My another point is that there is a large empty hall inside, but it didn't arrange some seats for parent to sit inside, but force them to wait on the playground for hot sunshine.

If the school does not pay consideration to the parents, I don't think they will pay consideration to the students too.

[ 本帖最後由 fatbb_mama 於 09-11-9 17:22 編輯 ]

作者: childrenfirst 時間: 09-11-9 18:20

The whole process of SFA was very annoying. From the form getting to the interview day.

I wanted to bring the kid to toilet before the interview but was rejected by the students helper. They insisted my kid should use the toilet upstairs. But he was very desperate so I ignored them and took him to use the mobile toilet at the playground. The condition of the mobile toilet was really bad. Not clean and very very difficult to be used by young kids. When we were back, we missed the line! He was standing there without help for a while and finally someone took him up the classroom.The student helpers were later scolded by the teacher for not enforcing well my kid to go up the classroom and not allowing them to use the toilets as the playground. poor kids..the teacher scolded them quite hard. For the next session of parents, they all needed to quene around the school outside. Poor kids and parents, it was so hot that day. Some kids wore long sheelves and they looked very tired under the sun.

For picking up the kids, it was quite smooth. This school is very mechanical, i could not feel much warm and care there.

作者: tiksilong 時間: 09-11-9 18:46

Since I was the first session of the day so the arrangement for us was not bad. Of course during the interview we took a breakfast nearby instead of waiting at the playground under the hot sun. We were also being interviewed by 2 students and my impressions to the students were not bad.

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 09-11-9 18:20 發表
The whole process of SFA was very annoying. From the form getting to the interview day.

I wanted to bring the kid to toilet before the interview but was rejected by the students helper. They insiste ...

作者: pyyip 時間: 09-11-9 19:58

Yes, I am very appreicated on what their students did on their [so-called] interview. Their English is fluent. Good performance.

原帖由 tiksilong 於 09-11-9 18:46 發表
Since I was the first session of the day so the arrangement for us was not bad. Of course during the interview we took a breakfast nearby instead of waiting at the playground under the hot sun. We wer ...

作者: fatbb_mama 時間: 09-11-10 00:05

原帖由 pyyip 於 09-11-9 19:58 發表
Yes, I am very appreicated on what their students did on their [so-called] interview. Their English is fluent. Good performance.

actually, I feel it is very "fake", force some outstanding students under the hot sun for a whole day in order to please the parents.

作者: sachan701 時間: 09-11-10 00:11

我都有同感．那天的安排有些少令人不安．流動廁所是最令人氣憤的．有朋友話，當天有老師在高空觀看各家長動態，所以安排所有家長在操場等．老師們的態度比較冷酷．
這次interview後，如果有幸收到confirm信，都要重新想想讀唔讀！？

作者: Georgette 時間: 09-11-10 01:11

I will definately hesitate to send my son to this school if he's being accepted.

I remembered when I submit my application after waiting for a long time, I finally sat down in front of the teacher. I took out my plastic folder & I started to take out the application form & some supporting documents from it. I only took less than 3 seconds to do so. The teacher had no patience at all & she grabbed & pulled my folder out of my hand, with a black face & she said"俾我啦!" in a very annoying voice.

I was so shocked but I did not let go. I pulled it back & also gave her a black face, & then I said "I have some personal docs inside that are not supposed to give to u!"

After I sorted out the docs quickly, only within 2 secs, then I gave it to her, she stared at me with a very black face.

What kind of teacher is this? I swear to god I only wasted her less than 8 secs in total, do I deserve all these black face & staring & pulling things out of my hand?

作者: gordon 時間: 09-11-10 10:17

你BUY 間學校就讀, 唔BUY就放棄. 當年雖然IN 咗好多間, 但目標只是SFA. 所以當OK咗, 我就放棄所有學校包括政府LUCKY DRAW.

我地3年前去INTERVIEW時, 佢地都係用同一套方法
(排隊交表,
排隊CHECK DOC, 排隊INTERVIEW, 企操場一個鐘等接仔, 同學SHOW OFF 學校既LANGUAGE). 但我依然比仔仔入讀, 因為我BUY 間學校.

2年後, 我依然會講, 我冇後悔.

我不是要HARDSELL間學校, 但這是個人意見.

你地自己衡量吓啦.

作者: f0569 時間: 09-11-10 11:59

Agree!!!
The interview system is very old style. I am very unlike their arrangement especially the submittion date. Please change la!!!

You know that the school is nearby a market. They let parents go outside to take a walk when their children in room. I saw some parents went to "shopping". One of them bought a home appliance. One of them bought some towel.

原帖由 Georgette 於 09-11-10 01:11 發表
I will definately hesitate to send my son to this school if he's being accepted.

I remembered when I submit my application after waiting for a long time, I finally sat down in front of the teacher. I ...

[ 本帖最後由 f0569 於 09-11-10 12:19 編輯 ]

作者: lbb 時間: 09-11-10 13:03

Agreed. You buy then you apply, if not, actually no need to discuss...

作者: KwokYi 時間: 09-11-10 13:46

如果冇申請, 點多方面了解多一些, 點知buy or not buy呢? 何況我們只於Interview arrangement比些意見, 不是多些意見,討論,才有機會進步嗎? 我們不是直接批評其教育質素呢。如果他們加以改善, 這學校不是更完美嗎???

原帖由 lbb 於 09-11-10 13:03 發表
Agreed. You buy then you apply, if not, actually no need to discuss...

作者: Georgette 時間: 09-11-10 13:56

Through this interview, this school gave me the following impression:

inconsiderate; impatience; very traditional; cold-hearted;

作者: MiuMiu2004 時間: 09-11-10 17:00 標題: 回覆 26# fatbb_mama 的文章

Super agree! I think this school is sooooo ... inconsiderate!

作者: jackie_lau2000 時間: 09-11-10 17:09

當天面試時, 學校有貼出通告給家長: 面試過程太約45分鐘至1小時.

大家其實可以出外再回來. 點解大家要係操場等呢 ? 跟住仲係到投訴 ? 如果你們不是因為此間學校的口碑, 相信大家都不會到深水涉區取申請書.

如果大家由登記果一刻已經唔喜歡此學校, 為何仲要去interview呢 ?

(不喜勿插, 有感而發)

大家有冇想過老師都好辛苦幫大家interview, 仲要係咁多人當中選出來.

作者: tiksilong 時間: 09-11-10 17:16

I have another view. Although it appears quite "fake" from the perspective of the school as you have said, I feel if I am the parent of the student I will appreciate the school giving the student the chance to talk with strangers and to practice in English.

原帖由 fatbb_mama 於 09-11-10 00:05 發表

actually, I feel it is very "fake", force some outstanding students under the hot sun for a whole day in order to please the parents.

作者: jeremyphlam 時間: 09-11-10 17:19

原帖由 jackie_lau2000 於 09-11-10 17:09 發表
當天面試時, 學校有貼出通告給家長: 面試過程太約45分鐘至1小時.

大家其實可以出外再回來. 點解大家要係操場等呢 ? 跟住仲係到投訴 ? 如果你們不是因為此間學校的口碑, 相信大家都不會到深水涉區取申請書.

如果 ...

hehe，我和老婆去了茶餐廳high tea及去洗手間。

作者: jackie_lau2000 時間: 09-11-10 17:41

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-11-10 17:19 發表

hehe，我和老婆去了茶餐廳high tea及去洗手間。

我都係, 不知幾爽.

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-11-10 17:41

原帖由 fatbb_mama 於 09-11-10 00:05 發表

actually, I feel it is very "fake", force some outstanding students under the hot sun for a whole day in order to please the parents.

Yeah, I was told the students spoke very well, so my wife asked whether they take external supplement classes...you can guess the answer...

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-11-10 17:48

Arrangement wise, its not very different other schools, long wait for app form, long wait for submission, long wait for interview and comparatively very short interview session. And, long wait for the result!

At least you had the choice of going shopping, drinking tea, chatting with other parents, etc. In some schools you have sit thru presentation, student performances, etc.

作者: cherryyim 時間: 09-11-10 17:51

We went shopping at 高登商場. Lucky that we haven't tried the toilet! But that's a good school afterall.

Would appreciate if anyone who manage to gain a place there, just give some constructive advice to the teacher / principal regarding the interview arrangement pls. I will definitely do.

作者: twinnie 時間: 09-11-10 18:28

只係等叫no.果時唔係順次序之外, 其它都冇乜問題.

原帖由 jackie_lau2000 於 09-11-10 17:09 發表
當天面試時, 學校有貼出通告給家長: 面試過程太約45分鐘至1小時.

大家其實可以出外再回來. 點解大家要係操場等呢 ? 跟住仲係到投訴 ? 如果你們不是因為此間學校的口碑, 相信大家都不會到深水涉區取申請書.

如果 ...

作者: pyyip 時間: 09-11-10 20:45

Of course, I don't think it is fake. If the training is not enough, how the students can do it. Besides, it is difficult for a P4 - P6 student to talk with a stranger, especially for speaking with the second language.

原帖由 tiksilong 於 09-11-10 17:16 發表
I have another view. Although it appears quite "fake" from the perspective of the school as you have said, I feel if I am the parent of the student I will appreciate the school giving the student the ...

作者: euka 時間: 09-11-10 20:45

yes, my husband drove me to resturant in Shamshuipo and I shopped for a while at Golden Computer Centre before I returned.
haha...

作者: tiksilong 時間: 09-11-10 20:58

In fact I was quite enjoy being interviewed by the students. Since I was in the first session so when the 2 students come to do an interview with me, they felt a bit nervous at the very beginning and their teacher then come to them to calm them down and to give them support. After that they did pretty well during the entire interview, I also did ask them questions in English after the interview like how do you think about the school? are there many homeworks, exams, etc? They can answer all the questions in English very well and I am pretty impressed and of course this cannot be fake...

原帖由 pyyip 於 09-11-10 20:45 發表
Of course, I don't think it is fake. If the training is not enough, how the students can do it. Besides, it is difficult for a P4 - P6 student to talk with a stranger, especially for speaking with t ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)