教育王國

標題: 聖芳濟各英文小學 Vs. 英華 [打印本頁]

作者: isaacmum 時間: 09-12-17 11:57 標題: 聖芳濟各英文小學 Vs. 英華

你會點揀? 請給意見，謝謝!!

作者: Bilobi 時間: 09-12-17 12:09

100% vote of Ying Wa

作者: goodmama2003 時間: 09-12-17 12:46

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: amypekkle 時間: 09-12-17 14:25

英華: 無論父母是否buy校長, 英華是一條龍, 6年後唔需要再搵學校.
SFA: 我覺得英文會好一點, 尤其oral.
如果父母覺得小朋友中學讀到英華書院已經滿足, 就應選英華小學. 如果覺得英華書院未夠理想, 想考名氣再高一點的中學, 就可考慮SFA.

我自己會揀英華.

作者: childrenfirst 時間: 09-12-18 00:19

check the statistics of SFA graduate before you make the decision.

作者: isaacmum 時間: 09-12-18 17:12

you mean good or not good??

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 09-12-18 00:19 發表
check the statistics of SFA graduate before you make the decision.

作者: VKwan 時間: 09-12-18 19:18

原帖由 amypekkle 於 09-12-17 14:25 發表
英華: 無論父母是否buy校長, 英華是一條龍, 6年後唔需要再搵學校.
SFA: 我覺得英文會好一點, 尤其oral.
如果父母覺得小朋友中學讀到英華書院已經滿足, 就應選英華小學. 如果覺得英華書院未夠理想, 想考名氣再高一點 ...

點解呢？學校會有好多oral環境？

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-4 11:51

不計一條龍, 那間好d?

作者: seanandangus 時間: 10-7-4 20:17

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: vet 時間: 10-7-4 21:26

Of course 英華

if your son has talent to be one of the top students in 英華, he can still go to DBS or other better secondary school after 6 years.
If your son is not band 1 top, he can stay in 英華.

作者: winchoy16888 時間: 10-7-5 06:41

sfa

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-7 12:12

其實我也有同一情況:聖芳濟各英文小學及英華也收了小兒插班小2, 應如何決擇?
請多指教

作者: Glau 時間: 10-7-7 15:17

YW 係直資一條龍, 咁仲可唔可以中學轉呢 ?

原帖由 vet 於 10-7-4 21:26 發表
Of course 英華

if your son has talent to be one of the top students in 英華, he can still go to DBS or other better secondary school after 6 years.
If your son is not band 1 top, he can stay in 英華 ...

作者: 莎莎莉莉 時間: 10-7-7 15:43

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-7 12:12 發表
其實我也有同一情況:聖芳濟各英文小學及英華也收了小兒插班小2, 應如何決擇?
請多指教

你在哪間小學讀開?
係咪成績好好?

作者: ukodelechan 時間: 10-7-7 18:50

英華比較活潑, 而聖芳濟各則較傳統, 差別很大.

英華注重課外, 成績普通, 但較輕鬆. 聖芳濟各十分注重學術, 底子會打得很好, 但課外會較少

作者: 4in1family 時間: 10-7-7 23:37

"英華注重課外, 成績普通, 但較輕鬆"
may i know where you get this impression from?

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-8 23:49

原帖由 莎莎莉莉 於 7-7-2010 15:43 發表

你在哪間小學讀開?
係咪成績好好?

黃埔宣道小學, 成績可以, 班第2.

作者: DrChing 時間: 10-7-9 12:44

Any seat decision made? If I were you and $$$ w/ religion are not the issues. I will choose 英華, most comments here are positive. Also, it has secondary for back up.
As I replied you in other topic. You have to pro-long extend your pressure in SFA, no rest or no mark! That's why I gave up there.
I don't have more info about 黃埔宣小, but I think 紅馬 has just a little bit higher academic level in your region only.

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-8 23:49 發表

黃埔宣道小學, 成績可以, 班第2.

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-9 13:42

原帖由 DrChing 於 9-7-2010 12:44 發表
Any seat decision made? If I were you and $$$ w/ religion are not the issues. I will choose 英華, most comments here are positive. Also, it has secondary for back up.
As I replied you in other topic ...

DrChing, Thanks for your opinion.
Just talked to the Principal of current primary school that she also recommened Ying Wa. She gave me a lot of ideas and analysis about our confirmed schools.
Now already up to 80% go for Ying Wa, but just wait for Pui Ching and DPS results. 聖芳濟各 should be given up, just like you.
Besides, for 升英中: 黃埔宣小over 50%, 紅馬over 60%. Both are definetly give-up.

作者: lusanna 時間: 10-7-9 23:07

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-9 13:42 發表

DrChing, Thanks for your opinion.
Just talked to the Principal of current primary school that she also recommened Ying Wa. She gave me a lot of ideas and analysis about our confirmed schools.
Now al ...

Hi Liktin,

My son also got acceptance fm Ying Wa P2, and we also apply DPS, but got reply on Apr that no seat was available. May i know if your son has attended the test already or still awaiting the reply fm DPS for the chance of interview/ test? Thanks

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-10 17:04

原帖由 lusanna 於 9-7-2010 23:07 發表

Hi Liktin,

My son also got acceptance fm Ying Wa P2, and we also apply DPS, but got reply on Apr that no seat was available. May i know if your son has attended the test already or still awaiting t ...

Already be replied about the test, it will be next Tue. Actually, I think I will not select DPS even they accept my son.
The school staff tolk me that Ying Wa only accept 3 or 4 P2 students this year.
Will you take it or others? your son may be the classmate of my son then.

作者: lusanna 時間: 10-7-10 22:22

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-10 17:04 發表

Already be replied about the test, it will be next Tue. Actually, I think I will not select DPS even they accept my son.
The school staff tolk me that Ying Wa only accept 3 or 4 P2 students this yea ...

Sorry i confused DPS with DBS, DPS hs also asked my son to attend the test on next Tue morning, but my hubby dosen't want him to take the test, since he prefer Ying Wa and next Tue day is the last day for my son to be in the original school.

We hv also sent file to DBS, but they replied that there was no seat available, that 's why i 'm very concern about when u mention it.

I think we are quite possible to choose Ying Wa unless DBS accept my son.

And so i think our son may be classmate on next year. I'm really happy to know u here, as we are in the similar situation, we can share our point of view and not be alone toward the new school . Hope we can keep in touch.:)

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-11 15:15

原帖由 lusanna 於 10-7-2010 22:22 發表

Sorry i confused DPS with DBS, DPS hs also asked my son to attend the test on next Tue morning, but my hubby dosen't want him to take the test, since he prefer Ying Wa and next Tue day is the last d ...

Is your child from 聖芳濟各英文小學? i met a classmate from 聖芳濟各 when register.
Can U pm me for your child's name?

作者: lusanna 時間: 10-7-11 20:42

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-11 15:15 發表

Is your child from 聖芳濟各英文小學? i met a classmate from 聖芳濟各 when register.
Can U pm me for your child's name?

no, my son is not fm SFA, we did not apply this school.

Pls check PM, thanks.

作者: lusanna 時間: 10-7-11 20:53

原帖由 lusanna 於 10-7-11 20:42 發表

no, my son is not fm SFA, we did not apply this school.

Pls check PM, thanks.

Just found cannot send PM, no idea what's wrong with it

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-11 22:07

原帖由 lusanna 於 11-7-2010 20:53 發表

Just found cannot send PM, no idea what's wrong with it

.

Oh great!, then we got 2 transfered classmates of Ying Wa P2 already.
One of them is your son and one of them is from SFA, I met him at the registered date, he is very smart also.
Besides, I heard that there are total 3 new transfered students only this year for P2.

作者: lusanna 時間: 10-7-11 22:23

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-11 22:07 發表
.

Oh great!, then we got 2 transfered classmates of Ying Wa P2 already.
One of them is your son and one of them is from SFA, I met him at the registered date, he is very smart also.
Besides, I heard ...

if there are totally 3 transferred student of P2, then u hv already found all the 3, yr son, my son and the one fm SFA!

Don't know if we 3 will be in the same class?
I think may be we should go to the page of YingWa to go ahead our conversation or via PM. But i don't know why i cannot send message via PM, do u know how to do it?

作者: hangsing 時間: 10-7-11 23:19

What is the full name of DPS ?

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-11 23:20

原帖由 lusanna 於 11-7-2010 22:23 發表

if there are totally 3 transferred student of P2, then u hv already found all the 3, yr son, my son and the one fm SFA!

Don't know if we 3 will be in the same class?
I think may be we should go to ...

Same to me, don't know how to operate the PM but only can reply.
Who can help us about sending message from PM?

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-11 23:23

原帖由 hangsing 於 11-7-2010 23:19 發表
What is the full name of DPS ?

DPS is stand for Diocesan Preparatory School (拔萃小學)

作者: lsltennis 時間: 10-7-14 17:21

I vote for YW as my son is now in YW and going to be promoted to P2. Perhaps our sons will be classmates in Sep.

Last year, all P1 students promoted to same class. But heard that the feed back is not good(The kids know one another to much that they are really friendly and to active in P2....haha). So this year, heard that the teachers still debating for promottion to same class or diff. class. To be announced in late Aug.

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-14 20:59

原帖由 lsltennis 於 14-7-2010 17:21 發表
I vote for YW as my son is now in YW and going to be promoted to P2. Perhaps our sons will be classmates in Sep.

Last year, all P1 students promoted to same class. But heard that the feed back is n ...

Oh really? Please let me know which class your son when they announce? 可能要搵你個仔多多照顧了！

作者: lsltennis 時間: 10-7-15 16:57

heard that it will be announced in late Aug, then request the parents to meet class teacher in very short notice, 3 or 4 days before (I head from parents from senior class).

hope to see u soon.

by the way, quite a lum sum of parents of P1 students (2009-10) open email account in gmail and we chit chat there to exchange some information, sometimes we will arrange some gathering of P1 students.

please PM me your class and your child's name. so that I will introduce you into the gmail group.

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-14 20:59 發表

Oh really? Please let me know which class your son when they announce? 可能要搵你個仔多多照顧了！

作者: liktin 時間: 10-8-31 22:14

原帖由 lsltennis 於 15-7-2010 16:57 發表
heard that it will be announced in late Aug, then request the parents to meet class teacher in very short notice, 3 or 4 days before (I head from parents from senior class).

hope to see u soon.

by t ...

My son confirmed to Ying Wa, and studying in Class 2D.
Thanks for all who were given their opinion before.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)