教育王國

標題: 瑪利曼vs St. Paul's Convent 點揀好? [打印本頁]

作者: bobomegan 時間: 10-6-5 16:40 標題: 瑪利曼vs St. Paul's Convent 點揀好?

瑪利曼vs St. Paul's Convent 點揀好，請給些意見…….

女兒會係9月升上St. Paul's Convent 既小一, 點知今天派位既結果係第一志願:瑪利曼, e+唔知點揀好, 好亂………
估唔到呢個問題會輪到我去煩, 因為根本冇想過會”禁”好彩!

以女兒既性格基本上讀兩間都冇大問題, 對我黎講最concern會係升中: 聖保祿係一條龍, 而瑪利曼要等派位. 我又係個要返工既呀媽, 怕冇時間同個女溫書, 點算? 虛心請過來人指教.

[ 本帖最後由 bobomegan 於 10-6-7 09:59 編輯 ]

作者: cy.muimui 時間: 10-6-5 16:50

瑪利曼 should have Secondary, if not too bad I think yr daughter can be directly to their Secondary. But for St. Paul Convent also is very good, really difficult to choose ar....still have time, 09-Jun is the deadline, compare more within these few days, anyway don't worry, both are the good school!!

作者: kaka01 時間: 10-6-5 17:18 標題: 回覆 2# bobomegan 的文章

我囡囡讀緊 Marymount P1，感覺課程似乎比較淺，每天放學已在學校完成功課，所以有很多空閒時間，一個星期默中文，一個星期默英文，不是太緊迫，不過到高年班應該會忙啲。

作者: abc媽咪 時間: 10-6-5 18:06

kaka01

由中文幼稚園升上去, 會唔會辛苦呢?
要唔要補習呀?
我個女都係派咗瑪利曼, sigh!

原帖由 kaka01 於 10-6-5 17:18 發表
我囡囡讀緊 Marymount P1，感覺課程似乎比較淺，每天放學已在學校完成功課，所以有很多空閒時間，一個星期默中文，一個星期默英文，不是太緊迫，不過到高年班應該會忙啲。 ...

作者: NAJ 時間: 10-6-5 21:58

原帖由 bobomegan 於 10-6-5 16:40 發表
瑪利曼vs St. Paul Convent 點揀好，請給些意見…….

女兒會係9月升上St. Paul Convent 既小一, 點知今天派位既結果係第一志願:瑪利曼, e+唔知點揀好, 好亂………
估唔到呢個問題會輪到我去煩, 因為根本冇想過會” ...

SPC if you daugther can handle the curriculum, as it is more guaranteed to get in the secondary section.

~60% of Marymount PS goes to the secondary school, so you need to keep your daugther at the top half to play safe. On the other hand, the MPS curriculum is relatively easier than SPC, so it may not be too difficult to get in the top half.

作者: summerbb 時間: 10-6-6 01:04

請問SPC小學一年級收唔收街外學生呀? 而中學係咪收晒100%既SPC小學生呢?

原帖由 NAJ 於 10-6-5 21:58 發表

SPC if you daugther can handle the curriculum, as it is more guaranteed to get in the secondary section.

~60% of Marymount PS goes to the secondary school, so you need to keep your daugther at the ...

作者: Jack0128 時間: 10-6-6 01:11

100% go for SPC, because no need to play the game again 6 years later.

原帖由 bobomegan 於 10-6-5 16:40 發表
瑪利曼vs St. Paul Convent 點揀好，請給些意見…….

女兒會係9月升上St. Paul Convent 既小一, 點知今天派位既結果係第一志願:瑪利曼, e+唔知點揀好, 好亂………
估唔到呢個問題會輪到我去煩, 因為根本冇想過會” ...

作者: samuellor 時間: 10-6-6 07:30 標題: 回覆 1# Jack0128 的文章

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Astoria 時間: 10-6-6 07:39

If school fee is not your major concern, I will 100% vote for SPC. SPC can gaurantee you to the secondary session. SPC secondary is one of the best top band 1 school in HK.

SPC Primary school fee is only $2xxx. For Marymout, since you have to fight for the secondary school 6 year later, you might to spend more on tutorial class and extra-curricular classes.

Hope it helps.

作者: csk 時間: 10-6-6 13:58

St. Paul Convent 。中學的課程尤其吸引和有方向。

作者: brian61950 時間: 10-6-6 14:05

揀邊間我冇意見,但有好多家長會去瑪利曼叩門,你揀st. Paul既佢地機會又大d.

原帖由 bobomegan 於 10-6-5 16:40 發表
瑪利曼vs St. Paul Convent 點揀好，請給些意見…….

女兒會係9月升上St. Paul Convent 既小一, 點知今天派位既結果係第一志願:瑪利曼, e+唔知點揀好, 好亂………
估唔到呢個問題會輪到我去煩, 因為根本冇想過會” ...

作者: bonbon123 時間: 10-6-6 14:16

如$$不是你考慮的問題就揀SPC,如都要CONCERN的就揀瑪利曼,兩間都係好學校。

作者: River_Amazon 時間: 10-6-6 14:33

想問"物"SPC唔係唔比大抽獎架咩，我覺得你都可以從間學校的culture 去睇，間間學校的culture 會有唔同，例如BPS 的女仔比較純樸，DGS 的比較outspoken, presentable, （個人感覺）你可問下有女係呢2間學校讀緊的家長朋友，究竟邊間學校的Culture mode 出黎的性格你係鐘意d 呢，又或岩你個女多d 呢。感覺上2間出來的女仔都好smart. 當中的分別就你要去研究啦。

作者: season_sincere 時間: 10-6-6 16:10

Of course both are good schools. You really have to appreciate the luck and fortune you have!

I think Marymount will be a better choice personally. As everyone knows, Marymount is really competitive and your girl will be a lot more aggressive and confident. St. Paul's is also a nice one, but the girls will be a bit more realistic.

Marymount focus more on all-rounded education, so you can expect that your girls will be sort of well-rounded, a bit more out going. But your girl must have good self-discipline to survive in this school, that's mean she has to take initiative to revise, study and be motivated to join a certain kind of activities. Or else, she may be a bit behind others.

St. Paul's focus more on academic studies, but students still get some extra-curricular activities, of course. IF your girl is not self -motivated, choose St. Paul's for a brighter future, as St. Paul's has a stricter school rules and will be chasing behind students for most of the things.

作者: happypiano 時間: 10-6-6 17:09

我睇完以下既回應, 我有小小不同的意見. 我小女讀緊spc, 所以我係以第一身既經歷去回應.

1. spk 同spn 不嬲都可以參加大抽獎的, 學校既sister講到明係俾你地抽架. 佢地好open mind, 亦好為d家長切想, 係9月尾(我個女那一年)就已經通知spc收唔收番你個女, 等有d 一心想入spc既家長唔駛再受選校, interview既折磨.

2. 話就話spc係一條龍, 事實上亦都係. 但係而家spc既中文課程比以前深左好多, 要中英數3科都over 60分先可以上得番spc中學. 初頭未入spc時都諗住60分應該唔太難啦, 但係佢地教得淺考得深, 所以都有d經險既情況出現過(即係真係得6x分). 唔好咁大安旨意一定入得番呀!! 英文佢地亦係比出面既小學深d既, 呢個唔駛講, 反而呢個就早有心理準備.

3. spc既校規既可以話好嚴, 亦可以話鬆. 校長好鼓勵d學生想參加咩課外活動就自己主動去報名的. 即係叫等d學生可以真係參加自己意願既課外活動, 而唔係亞媽想佢參加既課外活動. 無規定帶咩色既髮夾番學, 只要唔跨張便可. 可以著自己既羽擁番學, 只要係深藍色便可. 無話好似其他小學咁, 限住著學校指定既校褸.(呢d我就覺得佢free law). 學校都幾多課外活動俾小朋友參加的.

我想講既係入左spc 都一樣有壓力架, 只係你睇下大唔大law, 唔好咁大安旨意一定入得番spc中學呀.

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 10-6-6 19:02

唔好唔記得校車費. 我有朋友之前都係可以咁樣楝. 但因佢家可以行番學, 去瑪利曼搭校車都差唔多. 所以, $$未必一定可以畀GUIDELINE.

後記, 佢揀左SPC.

原帖由 bonbon123 於 10-6-6 14:16 發表
如$$不是你考慮的問題就揀SPC,如都要CONCERN的就揀瑪利曼,兩間都係好學校。

作者: cheng2 時間: 10-6-6 19:16

in compare with the secondary school, st paul convent is better of course. Besides, the family background of the student, st paul convent is better also because it is a private school and it is hard to get in

作者: nicoleyiu 時間: 10-6-6 20:11 標題: 回覆 1# bobomegan 的文章

我的情況和樓主一樣，但我有一個剛出世的女孩，如姐姐入marymount，日後會對妹妹有一定幫助。姐姐是否應該由SPC轉到marymount?但姐姐很喜歡SPC的。很頭痛，請各位俾啲意見。

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 10-6-6 22:19

如果不理會妹妹, 你(或你女)鐘意邊間先.

SPC都好講關係, 姐姐在唸書, 妹妹都好大機會入的.

原帖由 nicoleyiu 於 10-6-6 20:11 發表
我的情況和樓主一樣，但我有一個剛出世的女孩，如姐姐入marymount，日後會對妹妹有一定幫助。姐姐是否應該由SPC轉到marymount?但姐姐很喜歡SPC的。很頭痛，請各位俾啲意見。 ...

作者: cheng2 時間: 10-6-6 22:21

I heard that most of the kids studying in st paul convent kindgarten will choose to promote to it's primary, even though they got allocation in marymount successfully. SPC is a very good school, the students are happy and confident. If money is not your concern, I still believe that st paul convent is better for your two daughter's future.

作者: wootaitai 時間: 10-6-6 23:38

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: YongXin 時間: 10-6-7 00:07

各位，係St. Paul's Convent School，唔係 St. Paul Convent School。

St Paul's Convent School definitely if I were you。

作者: KK07 時間: 10-6-7 00:41

我唔熟悉瑪利曼,只知道她是很多家長的首選. 我自己是St Paul's 家長,亦都同意其中一位媽咪所講,入到小學真係唔好以為100%輕鬆上中學. 因為佢既tests 係可以好深, 尤其到四年班以上, 深到相當人數的學生只拿到50-60幾分!佢係唔會勸你自動離校咁殘忍既,但係就會比足機會你重讀又重讀,聽聞有人留班三次呀.

作者: whl3868 時間: 10-6-7 01:15

揀SPC定MPS....最緊要由小朋友做出發點....兩間都係家長們嘅心儀好學校

MPS 唔係一定直上 MSS....只係頭果批學生上到....但反過來說.....如果係一間較輕鬆嘅小學....小朋友成績仍然麻麻....放在SPC會否都係一樣??甚或更差??直上中學又是否跟得上??

作者: muichujamie 時間: 10-6-7 01:29

Yes yes, it's St Paul's not St Paul. I remember the 1st day I entered St Paul's, the sister reminded us "The school name is St Paul's!"
Don't mix up!

I vote for St Paul's Convent.

原帖由 YongXin 於 10-6-7 00:07 發表
各位，係St. Paul's Convent School，唔係 St. Paul Convent School。

St Paul's Convent School definitely if I were you。

作者: VeryHappyMum 時間: 10-6-7 01:56

原帖由 YongXin 於 10-6-7 00:07 發表
各位，係St. Paul's Convent School，唔係 St. Paul Convent School。

St Paul's Convent School definitely if I were you。

St. Joseph's St. Mary's
St. Francis' St. Clare's St. Anthony's

Catholic Schools (even hospitals) are named like this if a Saint's name is used.

作者: bobomegan 時間: 10-6-7 10:06

原帖由 YongXin 於 10-6-7 00:07 發表
各位，係St. Paul's Convent School，唔係 St. Paul Convent School。

St Paul's Convent School definitely if I were you。

Hi YongXin,

Thanks for your comments.
Yes, you are right! I've missed the "'s".

bobomegan

作者: happypiano 時間: 10-6-7 10:21

留班3次!!! 聽到你咁講都好d, 起碼仲有機會唔係一年定生死.

我之前識得一個mummy都係抽到marymount, 最後揀番spc.

其實2間都係好學校, 點揀都唔會錯得去邊的.

原帖由 KK07 於 10-6-7 00:41 發表
我唔熟悉瑪利曼,只知道她是很多家長的首選. 我自己是St Paul's 家長,亦都同意其中一位媽咪所講,入到小學真係唔好以為100%輕鬆上中學. 因為佢既tests 係可以好深, 尤其到四年班以上, 深到相當人數的學生只拿到50-60幾 ...

作者: bobomegan 時間: 10-6-7 10:25

原帖由 KK07 於 10-6-7 00:41 發表
我唔熟悉瑪利曼,只知道她是很多家長的首選. 我自己是St Paul's 家長,亦都同意其中一位媽咪所講,入到小學真係唔好以為100%輕鬆上中學. 因為佢既tests 係可以好深, 尤其到四年班以上, 深到相當人數的學生只拿到50-60幾 ...

Dear KK07,

One of my daughter classmate's sister was asked to leave SPC due to her academic problem when she was P2orP3.

When I discussed this topic (SPC or MPS) with one of my daughters' teachers (SPN) this morning, she told me that a number of P6 students (don't know the exact number) who are waitlisted in F1 this year still not able to get any good news from secondary school. So, "guarantee upgrade" is for those who work hard, but not for all.

Still struggling the final decision, but really appreciate for your comments.

bobomegan

[ 本帖最後由 bobomegan 於 10-6-7 10:29 編輯 ]

作者: kaka01 時間: 10-6-7 10:34

其實中英文也不是太深，如果不是讀教得很淺的幼稚園我想應該ok。至於要唔要補習則很難說，我囡囡因為有太多空閒時間，所以我有俾佢學中英文寫作。

原帖由 abc媽咪 於 10-6-5 18:06 發表
kaka01

由中文幼稚園升上去, 會唔會辛苦呢?
要唔要補習呀?
我個女都係派咗瑪利曼, sigh!

作者: bobomegan 時間: 10-6-7 10:35

Dear All,

Thanks for all your comments which give me some more ideas to make a right decision......... ^o^

bobomegan

作者: KK07 時間: 10-6-7 11:02

Dear bobomegan,

Tks for your info. Wow, this make me a bit worry for my daughter whose performance is always flucuatiing .......

Good luck...

原帖由 bobomegan 於 10-6-7 10:25 發表

Dear KK07,

One of my daughter classmate's sister was asked to leave SPC due to her academic problem when she was P2orP3.

When I discussed this topic (SPC or MPS) with one of my daughters' teacher ...

作者: samuellor 時間: 10-6-7 12:17 標題: 回覆 12# wootaitai 的文章

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: yvomak 時間: 10-6-7 17:02

bobomegan,

我想問問你個囡係咪首名子女同埋天主教徒呀?

作者: bobomegan 時間: 10-6-7 20:02

原帖由 yvomak 於 10-6-7 17:02 發表
bobomegan,

我想問問你個囡係咪首名子女同埋天主教徒呀?

Hi yvomak:

I got only one daughter so she is “首名子女” but I'm not a Catholic.
I won the seat thru the lucky draw system but not in the first round points system, so these conditions can’t help me to get the seat.

bobomegan

[ 本帖最後由 bobomegan 於 10-6-7 20:14 編輯 ]

作者: NAJ 時間: 10-6-7 21:16

原帖由 wootaitai 於 10-6-6 23:38 發表
the 2 schools' HKCEE results are very similar. By that logic, one can conclude that Marymount has higher "value added" to their students in terms of an improvement factor since

- it has no selection ...

This may be a risky conclusion on the "value-add", as 40+% of MSS students came from band 1 top students of other primary schools. But I agree both are good primary schools that will try to nurture their pupils.

作者: yvomak 時間: 10-6-8 10:25

你既意思即係話大抽獎就唔會再用分數, 好似當抽六合彩咁!

Hi yvomak:

I got only one daughter so she is “首名子女” but I'm not a Catholic.
I won the seat thru the lucky draw system but not in the first round points system, so these conditions can’t help ... [/quote]

作者: bobomegan 時間: 10-6-8 14:48

that's right!

原帖由 yvomak 於 10-6-8 10:25 發表
你既意思即係話大抽獎就唔會再用分數, 好似當抽六合彩咁!

Hi yvomak:

I got only one daughter so she is “首名子女” but I'm not a Catholic.
I won the seat thru the lucky draw system but not in the firs ...

作者: ukodelechan 時間: 10-6-8 15:09

聽講MPS的學生比較囂張, 也有不少富豪名人子女就讀, 沒有St. Paul's 的樸實...

升MSS 機會只有約50-60%, 其他會升小學的頭二,三名, 重要各樣競爭好大, 鬥成績, 獎項,物質(因大多富裕), 大壓力, 大多會到外國升學.

但marymount 比較注重全面發展, 所以生活開心, 不死讀書.

作者: lin624 時間: 10-6-8 15:15

那未必唷

如果妹妹要讀的那年
姐姐已畢業
那麼　妹妹就不算是必收生

原帖由 nicoleyiu 於 10-6-6 20:11 發表
我的情況和樓主一樣，但我有一個剛出世的女孩，如姐姐入marymount，日後會對妹妹有一定幫助。姐姐是否應該由SPC轉到marymount?但姐姐很喜歡SPC的。很頭痛，請各位俾啲意見。 ...

作者: A9109494 時間: 10-6-8 15:37 標題: 回覆 1# bobomegan 的文章

spc for sure if u dont have a younger daughter!

作者: A9109494 時間: 10-6-8 15:43 標題: 回覆 18# nicoleyiu 的文章

For your case, i will vote for marymount. I also have 2 daughters and my elder daughter will study in spc p1 this sept. I am not so lucky as you to get a gd school in the lucky draw. I notice now so competitive to get a gd school as the birth rate is higher and higher now! And also not guarantee yr younger daughter can get into spk! so play safe to get marymount's offer and u no need to get over the stressful interviews or lucky draw later!

作者: 仔仔錫錫你 時間: 10-6-9 14:45

spc 校舍與spn 相鄰, 小朋友可以起一個熟識的環境下升上小學絕對係一件好事, 而且有咩問題都可以返去spn 傾下, 我prefer spc.

作者: overview 時間: 10-6-9 15:34

但如果有宗教分, 加埋家姐係畢業生, 都有25分, sure win la !

原帖由 lin624 於 10-6-8 15:15 發表
那未必唷

如果妹妹要讀的那年
姐姐已畢業
那麼　妹妹就不算是必收生

作者: somay 時間: 11-6-18 23:48

I have exactly the same case as the editor.  My daughter has both seats (SPC ans Marymount) since November.  I have struggled for 8 months.
I wonder why MPS girls are more materialistic?  Do they come from different background because it is aided school?  I just guess SPC girls are rather more 'princess-like'.  I don't know.  But behaviour, values and attitude would be one of my concern.  Please share!
$$ is also one of my concern.  Although my family is not in the 'low' status, 'free' is better that 'paid', do you agree?
Personally, I prefer MPS.  But my husband and my daughter prefer SPC.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)