教育王國

標題: 決擇 [打印本頁]

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-25 14:33 標題: 決擇

請問荃灣香港浸信會聯會小學及聖瑪加利男女英文中小學你會選揀那一間?

作者: sampapa 時間: 10-6-28 13:04

荃灣香港浸信會聯會小學 Free of charge
Chinese school, Heavy workload
P1 to P6, No Secondary School
Have TSA result for Sec. school
famouse school in Tsuen wan

聖瑪加利男女英文中小學 $30K+ per year
English school, less or small workload.
P1 to F6, 12 year, with Sec. school
No TSA result.
General DSS in SSP, not top one.

Both is good school.
Close your eye to choice.

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-28 13:36

原帖由 sampapa 於 10-6-28 13:04 發表
荃灣香港浸信會聯會小學 Free of charge
Chinese school, Heavy workload
P1 to P6, No Secondary School
Have TSA result for Sec. school
famouse school in Tsuen wan

聖瑪加利男女英文中小學 $30K+ per year
En ...

thank you for your sharing...

作者: Tammy.Lai 時間: 10-6-28 13:48

if money is no problem and your child is good english, i choice 聖瑪加利男女英文中小學

作者: 好命婆 時間: 10-6-28 14:11

聖瑪加利男女英文中小學if money not a problem.

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-29 09:40

原帖由 好命婆 於 10-6-28 14:11 發表
聖瑪加利男女英文中小學if money not a problem.

請問除左英文好外,其他還有什麼比浸聯好的呢?

作者: 好命婆 時間: 10-6-29 12:22

英文好已經係非常好既優勢, 係好到可比美國際學校喎!謂一真係中文要落多啲功夫囉!咁針無兩頭利嘅!

原帖由 deyond 於 10-6-29 09:40 發表

請問除左英文好外,其他還有什麼比浸聯好的呢?

作者: ShinTeresa 時間: 10-6-29 12:23

st margaret超多人爭, 入到而錢又唔係問題, 一定簡佢la

原帖由 好命婆 於 10-6-29 12:22 發表
英文好已經係非常好既優勢, 係好到可比美國際學校喎!謂一真係中文要落多啲功夫囉!咁針無兩頭利嘅!

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-29 12:40

原帖由 好命婆 於 10-6-29 12:22 發表
英文好已經係非常好既優勢, 係好到可比美國際學校喎!謂一真係中文要落多啲功夫囉!咁針無兩頭利嘅!

請問你係咪有小朋友喺St. Margaret's讀緊呀??可否給多些資料好讓我作出最正確的決擇呢??

作者: sampapa 時間: 10-6-29 13:29

So far, SMC is good Pri Sch.
English standard as P5/6 for P1/2.
Most kid complete Flyer in P1/2, some complete PET/FCE in P3/4.
Many kid can watch English program without chinese sub-tittle bar.
Chinese is 100% PTH
Modern Language is other advange, 浸聯 no this subject.
You can see many comment and topic in 小學一覽.
Manner is good, due to kid is selected not lucky draw. Quality is controlled.
Most family background of kid is middle class, not rich family.
Only 80 kids admitted as P1 in each year. Seat is very tight.
Less homework for kid, less workload for parent.
No exam for P1, happy school life.

If kid english standard is not good, it is painful road in SMC.

Remaind :-
P1/2 is 3 class, around 26/7 per class.
P3~6 is 2 class, around 40 per class.
P5~6 has Phy, Chem, Bio, History, Geo subject. <- it is secondary school subj.
No good public exam result in F5/6 in recently years.
It is second year, his own kids go to sec sch.
Some pri. kids are admitted other top DSS or good Engish sec. sch.

The quality of Primary is 99% good.
The quality of Secondary is waiting.....

作者: kiu-mummy 時間: 10-6-29 13:57 標題: 回覆 1# deyond 的文章

Hi deyond,

你是否自己去叩門而得浸聯學位呢? 因為我小朋友都係smc 收咗後而要取消統一派位的. 你嗰日有無去造校服呀?

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-29 14:56

原帖由 kiu-mummy 於 10-6-29 13:57 發表
Hi deyond,

你是否自己去叩門而得浸聯學位呢? 因為我小朋友都係smc 收咗後而要取消統一派位的. 你嗰日有無去造校服呀?

係呀..我自己去叩門架..你係咪無參加統一派位呀?係咪會讀SMC呀?

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-29 16:13

原帖由 sampapa 於 10-6-29 13:29 發表
So far, SMC is good Pri Sch.
English standard as P5/6 for P1/2.
Most kid complete Flyer in P1/2, some complete PET/FCE in P3/4.
Many kid can watch English program without chinese sub-tittle bar.
Chi ...

好詳細呀..唔該晒你.但因我係住荃灣,如果要返SMC好遠,無車直接到我屋企,每日都要搵人接返學放學,車程比起浸聯遠好多....真係難決擇...

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-29 16:23

原帖由 kiu-mummy 於 10-6-29 13:57 發表
Hi deyond,

你是否自己去叩門而得浸聯學位呢? 因為我小朋友都係smc 收咗後而要取消統一派位的. 你嗰日有無去造校服呀?

我果日有去聽升小一簡介呀.不過就未做校服..

作者: sampapa 時間: 10-6-29 17:06 標題: 回覆 13# deyond 的文章

So many parent lived in Tsuen Wan.

If not use school bus, by MTR & walk,time is 30~35 min

From Tsuen Wan to Cheung Sha Wan 16~18 Min.
From Cheung Sha Wan Station to School by walk is 14~16 min.

I think the time is acceptable.

作者: deyond 時間: 10-6-29 17:28

原帖由 sampapa 於 10-6-29 17:06 發表
So many parent lived in Tsuen Wan.

If not use school bus, by MTR & walk,time is 30~35 min

From Tsuen Wan to Cheung Sha Wan 16~18 Min.
From Cheung Sha Wan Station to School by walk is 14~16 min.

I t ...

但係我唔近地鐵站.要坐小巴落MTR,再搭MTR,再行,小朋友會唔會太辛苦呢?

作者: twin1411 時間: 10-6-29 17:33

超多人爭 - 請問比例是多少？

原帖由 ShinTeresa 於 10-6-29 12:23 發表
st margaret超多人爭, 入到而錢又唔係問題, 一定簡佢la

作者: sampapa 時間: 10-6-29 20:27 標題: 回覆 16# deyond 的文章

If LS, DBS, DPS, SPCC accepted your kids.
Are u consider the time of travel?
Before u apply the school, u must concern the travel time.
If school is good for kid, travelling is small problem.
Some parent move to location near school or move to best travel location.
But if you more then ONE kid, I think 浸聯 is good for you.
It is becasue of SMC is not sure the next kid accepted.

作者: sampapa 時間: 10-6-29 20:31 標題: 回覆 8# ShinTeresa 的文章

Admitted rate less than 8~10%.

TSL's rate is 4~6%, arround 3500 kids apply 150 seat in first round.

作者: Sharon.123 時間: 10-6-29 21:03

Actually, you are living really near to SMC comparing to me. I am living in TKO and my son will also study in SMC this coming September. I guess if my younger son can lucky get an offer from SMC, I will move near to SMC so that we can save the travelling time. However, I know it is quite hard.

Sampapa is right. On the P.1 Briefing talk, I noticed most the parents come from middle class not very rich so I feel very comfortable. Too many rich kids in a school that may become pressure on me or my son.

原帖由 deyond 於 10-6-29 16:13 發表

好詳細呀..唔該晒你.但因我係住荃灣,如果要返SMC好遠,無車直接到我屋企,每日都要搵人接返學放學,車程比起浸聯遠好多....真係難決擇...

作者: kiu-mummy 時間: 10-6-29 23:12 標題: 回覆 12# deyond 的文章

我當然無得參加統一派位喇, SMC 一收咗比埋留位費, 我就放棄咗派位喇, 如果有嘅話, 多好呢!

我都係住荃灣喎, 我睇過路線都有好多個站吖! 由萬景峯開到荃威再MTR, 之後再到海濱喎. 你無一個啱咩?

作者: brian61950 時間: 10-6-29 23:15

好多時就係咁,
一間好好直資/私校vs一間唔錯津校,
令不少家長挖爆頭.

如我住九龍,SMC我都滴濕幾條口水肩.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)