教育王國

標題: 聖方濟各英文小學 vs 英華小學, 兩間都要乘校車, 你會點揀? [打印本頁]

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-4 11:22 標題: 聖方濟各英文小學 vs 英華小學, 兩間都要乘校車, 你會點揀?

聖方濟各英文小學 vs 英華小學, 兩間都要乘校車, 你會點揀呢?

作者: sunsky 時間: 10-7-4 11:32

of course Ying Wa la.... so hard to get in

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-4 12:19

其實聖方濟各英文小學都係一樣多人考的

作者: fatanna123 時間: 10-7-4 12:48

我會選英華, 因佢係一條龍.

作者: big-head 時間: 10-7-4 15:54

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: DrChing 時間: 10-7-4 18:32

Think about them:
- Cost?
- Secondary allocation pressure?
- Ability of your kid?
- Pressure w/ internal competitors?
- Your religion?

What is your ranking?

作者: SaBB 時間: 10-7-4 18:33

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-4 11:22 發表
聖方濟各英文小學 vs 英華小學, 兩間都要乘校車, 你會點揀呢?

Ying Wah definately! It is such a famous school with a high standard English school back up!
What's the point to choose SFA if you have YW in hand and worry about where to go, preparation for inteviews, lucky enough to get into the first choose school in school allocation round, etc after 6 years?

作者: HoHoMom 時間: 10-7-4 18:47

SFA definitely. Much higher standard.

原帖由 SaBB 於 10-7-4 18:33 發表

Ying Wah definately! It is such a famous school with a high standard English school back up!
What's the point to choose SFA if you have YW in hand and worry about where to go, preparation for intev ...

作者: DrChing 時間: 10-7-4 18:54

liktin,
Read from other topic, seem you have the other schools accepted (MTCHHB). Why don't you request all schools in one topic?

作者: seanandangus 時間: 10-7-4 19:54

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-5 21:03

DrChing, I am the new commer here, first time use. yes, both SFA and MTC are confirmed, Yin Wah will announce tomorrow.
big-head, 我知SFA校內資優生多, 小兒亦經証實是, 可能是這樣,故插班成功了。但競爭非常激烈, 我怕的是我的壓力比較大。
Yin Wah one-dragon is definetly less pressure.

作者: cfaye 時間: 10-7-5 22:34

我就咁睇單單面試難度，英華比sfa艱辛很多，意思並不是單指學術，更要考小朋友常識更要考驗父母。

作者: seanandangus 時間: 10-7-6 11:24

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-6 12:32

原帖由 seanandangus 於 6-7-2010 11:24 發表
咁你巳經放棄馬頭涌?

Hi Seanandangus,
馬頭涌(紅磡)是90%放棄的了。
剛收到電話, 英華小學也ok了, 明天就要去註冊，也先交$1500學費吧。
之前聖方濟各英文小學也交了$2,500學費及填了自動轉賬，慘！

作者: DrChing 時間: 10-7-6 13:39

Hi Liktin,
Good to hear your confirmation to Ying Wa which is one of the quality “one dragon” schools in Hong Kong. Compared with MTC, Ya Wah is more safer to secondary. For my boy, I am not sure if I made the wrong choice to withdraw Ying Wa last Nov, purpose for expecting the better subsidy through lucky draw…Hopefully, a “knocked” school accepted my boy finally. SFA seat has released.

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-5 21:03 發表
DrChing, I am the new commer here, first time use. yes, both SFA and MTC are confirmed, Yin Wah will announce tomorrow.
big-head, 我知SFA校內資優生多, 小兒亦經証實是, 可能是這樣,故插班成功了。但競爭非 ...

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-6 13:45 標題: 回覆 1# DrChing 的文章

Hi Dr. Ching,
then, which one is confirmed and registered so far? It is better to pay save to register first, don't take more high risk.

作者: DrChing 時間: 10-7-6 14:06

Hi Liktin,
Same as you, we paid $2500 to SFA but auto pay form has not been submitted yet. My son “knocked” and succeed into old Yau Tin.

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-6 13:45 發表
Hi Dr. Ching,
then, which one is confirmed and registered so far? It is better to pay save to register first, don't take more high risk.

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-6 14:19 標題: 回覆 1# DrChing 的文章

Just my own opinion, I will choose SFA instead of Old Yau Tin if $$$ is not the big problem.
I did comparasion before, Yau Tin mainly to 華仁書院(九龍), but 華仁 dropped these years in academic.

作者: tracytang 時間: 10-7-6 14:39

你小朋友是否插班p2-p6?

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-5 21:03 發表
DrChing, I am the new commer here, first time use. yes, both SFA and MTC are confirmed, Yin Wah will announce tomorrow.
big-head, 我知SFA校內資優生多, 小兒亦經証實是, 可能是這樣,故插班成功了。但競爭非 ...

作者: DrChing 時間: 10-7-6 15:08

Hi Liktin,
I also think about the academy dropping in Wah Yan. But in SFA for boys, the school net also goes to Wah Yan and CSW Catholic Secondary only, unless the applicants have other net to apply QC, St Joseph. There is no difference in secondary allocation between these 2 schools. Of course, I agree SFA has quality academic level but both parents and kids have to accept the pressure if they need to catch 30% top of students.

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-6 15:36

tracytang, 不知你是否問我, 如是, 小兒是今年插班p2。剛confirm的。
Dr. Ching, I think you were talking Ying Wa instead of Wa Ying. I believe that my son can be the top 30%, but I worry about we argue with him daily about the higher pressure of homework if in SFA!

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-6 15:40 標題: 回覆 12# cfaye 的文章

請問怎樣考驗父母，這是我最擔心的

作者: DrChing 時間: 10-7-6 16:52

Hi liktin,
“…but I worry about we argue with him daily about the higher pressure of homework if in SFA…” That’s why I chose old Yau Tin finally. I said Wah Yan (華仁), not Wa Ying (華英).

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-7 11:15 標題: 回覆 1# DrChing 的文章

Got it, share same feeling with you.
So, my son may also give up the offer of 聖方濟各英文小學 (still considering).
I heard from some of forums of BK that there is much pressure about home work form this school.

作者: 呀Bow 時間: 10-7-7 16:22

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-4 11:22 發表
聖方濟各英文小學 vs 英華小學, 兩間都要乘校車, 你會點揀呢?

我會選英華, 因佢係一條龍中學, 第日不用再煩o 又是好學校, 校長又好人o 小朋友會較開心o

作者: Luna1027 時間: 10-7-7 16:34

你通知紅馬放棄學位了嗎?

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-7 22:44

原帖由 Luna1027 於 7-7-2010 16:34 發表
你通知紅馬放棄學位了嗎?

仲未, 你小朋友也報了?
但今個星期六的迎新日也不去了, 下星期會通知的, 讓waiting的朋友可更快知結果

作者: VKwan 時間: 10-7-8 18:21

原帖由 liktin 於 10-7-7 11:15 發表
Got it, share same feeling with you.
So, my son may also give up the offer of 聖方濟各英文小學 (still considering).
I heard from some of forums of BK that there is much pressure about home work form t ...

查實就算間學校唔嚴，只要有升中壓力，個家長都會嚴啦！學科壓力未必關學校事既！

作者: liktin 時間: 10-7-9 13:25

原帖由 VKwan 於 8-7-2010 18:21 發表
查實就算間學校唔嚴，只要有升中壓力，個家長都會嚴啦！學科壓力未必關學校事既！

為了減少日日強迫個仔做功課, 發生argue, 所以我也較大可能會選擇一條龍的學校了

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)