教育王國
標題: 請問有沒有10大名校(小學)？ [打印本頁]
作者: survivor 時間: 10-11-11 14:19 標題: 請問有沒有10大名校(小學)？
有人在BK列出十大名幼稚園，請問有沒有10大名校(小學)？
作者: YChan.Family 時間: 10-11-11 14:32
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: babybear 時間: 10-11-11 14:32
九龍區同港島區家長心目中既十大，大有不同喎！
原帖由 survivor 於 10-11-11 14:19 發表 
有人在BK列出十大名幼稚園，請問有沒有10大名校(小學)？
[ 本帖最後由 babybear 於 10-11-11 14:35 編輯 ]
作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-11 14:45
第一，係唔係名校，人人睇法唔同，尤其要排名，你想用乜準則？第二，呢張名單唔講其他，連灣仔區大熱St Joe華仁都無，你信唔信？
作者: Edvychan 時間: 10-11-11 14:51
唔係有心看低,不要見怪,不過德雅,真光等其實算唔算名校?我其實都有報到,我覺得只可以算為一些好學校而矣...
作者: eatcookies 時間: 10-11-11 15:45
夾硬要name10 間學校出來話係”名校“，憑咩criteria選定呢？其實最緊要係適合自己小朋友讀啦，人地比唔比面話佢係”名校“唔係咁重要。唔好話係飛仔學校就好了。
作者: PhdJessiema 時間: 10-11-11 16:13
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: easybring 時間: 10-11-11 16:16
軒官小都無wow. 我估個list 係for girls. 似無咩準則, 係十大勁歌金曲選舉.
原帖由 traeh 於 10-11-11 14:45 發表
第一，係唔係名校，人人睇法唔同，尤其要排名，你想用乜準則？第二，呢張名單唔講其他，連灣仔區大熱St Joe華仁都無，你信唔信？
作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-11 16:28
Maybe some of the parents have the same thought as yours. But some of them simply don't have a choice. Under the govt allocation system, the parents can't do much to guarantee their kids' admission to any renowned subsidized schools.
But I definitely won't say these schools "are in no way comparable to DSS/private schools".
原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 10-11-11 16:13 發表
First you should take out those subsidized schools. Nowadays, those schools are different and the students are no way comparable to DSS/private schools. Otherwise, why so many parents need to pay for their childern's education? ...
[ 本帖最後由 traeh 於 10-11-11 16:29 編輯 ]
作者: pho2009 時間: 10-11-11 16:34 標題: 回覆 1# survivor 的文章
請問十大名幼稚園? Can you tell us more?
作者: survivor 時間: 10-11-11 16:45
在本website左面有"談幼稚園"，click入就見！
作者: mow-mow 時間: 10-11-11 17:13
My personal top 10 (not in any particular order):-
聖若瑟小學
瑪利諾修院學校（小學部）
拔萃男書院附屬小學
瑪利曼小學
聖保祿學校（小學部）
拔萃女小學
協恩中學附屬小學
嘉諾撒聖瑪利學校
聖保羅男女中學附屬小學
喇沙小學(男校)
There are many other really good schools, but if I can only choose 10, these are my personal favorites.
[ 本帖最後由 mow-mow 於 10-11-11 17:16 編輯 ]
作者: w_y 時間: 10-11-11 17:48
真係不敢苟同.
如果st jo/華仁肯收, 你估有幾多百分比家長願意放棄, 而去某些建校都無十年既直資呢?
果張list, 真係得啖笑, 無謂認真啦. 不過我諗比較少爭議, 兩間dxs, st paul co-ed, ls, maryknoll, st jo 點都有份, 其他就人人有講法.
原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 10-11-11 16:13 發表
First you should take out those subsidized schools. Nowadays, those schools are different and the students are no way comparable to DSS/private schools. Otherwise, why so many parents need to pay for ...
作者: jm1874 時間: 10-11-11 18:56
軒官小點名法？我真係比較少聽到人提呢間喎~~
作者: mcheung1 時間: 10-11-11 19:10
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: luiluimama 時間: 10-11-11 19:35
其實名唔名校根本唔重要, 做家長既, 唔係要為仔女選擇名校, 而係應該為仔女選擇合適既學校
作者: s9971555 時間: 10-11-11 21:40
我會選:
1.男拔
2.女拔
3.喇沙
4.聖保羅男女
5.聖保羅書院
6.聖士提反女校
7.聖心
8.華仁
9.聖joseph
10.瑪利諾修院學校
11.聖瑪利
12.協恩
13.德望
14.高主教
15.聖保祿
[ 本帖最後由 s9971555 於 10-11-11 21:43 編輯 ]
作者: PhdJessiema 時間: 10-11-11 21:47
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: s9971555 時間: 10-11-11 21:53
這裡是提供平台給其他對標題有興趣既家長討論, 如果你無興趣, 為何要浪費時間睇及發表評論呢, 舉出的都是傳統近百年既名校, 你入唔到或者唔想入, 唔代表其他家長唔想知.原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 10-11-11 21:47 發表
I don't think it is appropriate to rank those schools. Why need to rank? 
Different parents/kids need different schools. The fittest school must be ranked the first in parents' heart. :h ...
作者: gabeparent 時間: 10-11-11 21:54
rankings are meaningless...does it mean any child studying in the top 10 will be guaranteed a successful and meaningful life?????
作者: 35C9 時間: 10-11-11 23:37
亂黎, 可信性程度好底.
作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-12 08:36
Oh, I thought you are doing very much the same thing in another discussion, though the scale is smaller with only four schools??? 
原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 10-11-11 21:47 發表
I don't think it is appropriate to rank those schools. Why need to rank? 
Different parents/kids need different schools. The fittest school must be ranked the first in parents' heart. 
I just think this kind of post is meaningless!
Those parents named out a list is also irresponsible!
...
作者: s9971555 時間: 10-11-14 11:40
名校入大學的比例是很高, 這就是答案, 亦都是事實. 當然, 有些家長只要小朋友讀得開心就得, 都係個句, 每個人有不同的要求, 無興趣, 為什麼睇到此標題, 還要click入黎睇? 還是想人地認同你那套?
作者: YimhYimh 時間: 10-11-14 19:18
Rankings are meaningless. It also depends on what you need.
作者: kanahose 時間: 10-11-14 21:24
我想問，十大名校的準則是否需要符含以下全部或部份條件?
(1) 全港家長最渴望子女入讀的學校？
(2) 全港面試要求最難入讀的學校？
(3) 全港最多升BAND 1英中派位的學校？
(4) 全港可以直升BAND 1英中的學校？
(5) 全港學位少而申請人數極多的學校？
(6) 全港最大佔地面積的學校？
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |