現在d小學派位都唔公平....造馬

traeh

係一定有書讀，適齡就一定要入小一，讀到中三起碼。只係唔一定係讀最心儀學校啫。

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-9-17 11:31 發表
諗深一層，其實香港已經好好，大陸同好多地方唔係個個小朋友有書讀，邊有我地咁差唔多肯定有書讀。

或者香港o既家長已經覺得受教育是理所當然，要求亦越黎越高。
...

aiyah

學校營運模式都要按市場要求走。多數人追捧的心儀的學校，相信會好似 Ying Wa, DBS, DJS, SPCC...等轉直資，這只是時間的問題。“市場”上或會出現兩個情況： 私立／直資照顧一批堅持要去”心儀“學校的家長；官津照顧另一批要求相對較少的家長。這都是兩全其美的方案!

appleycma

原帖由 runme 於 10-9-17 09:45 發表
"現在d小學派位都唔公平....造馬 ... 都唔係睇成績..." ???

樓主, 睇成績時你又會吾會鬧制度俾你同細路好大壓力呀!

請問樓主樣先係公平?  其實人人入到想入果間就最公平.

不如叫St. Joseph, Maryknoll, DBS, D ...

不如把全港學校都用同一個校名,例如:SPCC (九龍塘分校/上水分校/元朗分校等......)會好d嗎?

AAma

個game係咁玩法, 關造馬咩事? 無話公平唔公平, 要玩咪跟rule玩囉.

原帖由 fmc 於 10-9-16 23:43 發表
都唔係睇成績，受洗過有分,老豆老母係個度做／讀有分，兄弟姊妹個度讀又有分，首名出世子女又有分.，我唔係要我仔讀勁學校,我知我仔讀唔黎,但真係xyz....甘派位有d白痴 ...

Ving

So, there is no faireness or not in the world.

You can go into good school like Marymount, St Joseph, St Mary, La Salle even he/she don't know A-Z or 1-10, or bad manner or absolute implolite. The only thing is that you have enough marks, religion + old boy/girl. That's all..

hui3328

香港的政府及津校的派位制度的確有不少需要改善的地方.

直資料學校唯然競爭激烈, 甄選過程也很主觀. 但相對而言非常公平. 大陸制度更黑暗. 認識一個北京朋友, 其女兒成績不是太出色, 為了進一間著名的外語中學, 要付給學校負責招生的人20多萬. 聽說這個負責人後來因為太多家長找他, 整個暑假都要躲起來, 一般大陸名校3成學額是留給有錢有關係的人.

在香港, 如果你是達官貴人, 要進超級名校會容易些. 但也不能保證, 不是有錢就一定能進.

原帖由 aiyah 於 10-9-17 12:18 發表
學校營運模式都要按市場要求走。多數人追捧的心儀的學校，相信會好似 Ying Wa, DBS, DJS, SPCC...等轉直資，這只是時間的問題。“市場”上或會出現兩個情況： 私立／直資照顧一批堅持要去”心儀“學校的家長；官津照顧另一批要 ...

thomasha

From my experience with 8 DSS/private schools, they do not add that many marks (maybe 10 out of 50 or 5 out of 60) to those with relations or the same religion, except St Paul's Co-ed which reserves "no more than 70%" to the affiliated candidates, though same religion does not give extra marks.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-9-17 12:42 發表
So, there is no faireness or not in the world.

You can go into good school like Marymount, St Joseph, St Mary, La Salle even he/she don't know A-Z or 1-10, or bad manner or absolute implolite. The on ...

shootingstar

如果你係細仔媽咪, 特別係12月出世個D, 你就會慶幸有這計分制度存在.

aiyah

“直資料學校唯然競爭激烈, 甄選過程也很主觀...."
Agree v much. Applications for some DSS range 1k to 3k plus, and some first round interviews need to be done within 2 days.  Imagine a kid may have only several minutes to be "interviewed"- with such a timeline, subjective impressions on kids definitely count. Fast and proactive response, lovely faces ... may win marks.

Personalities and abilities of kids vary, and such interviews are not fair to some group again. Though comparatively, DSS/private schools at leastdo not give big privilege to those having relations with schools, and it is this sense of "fairness" that can comfort many of the parents.

原帖由 hui3328 於 10-9-17 12:44 發表
香港的政府及津校的派位制度的確有不少需要改善的地方.

直資料學校唯然競爭激烈, 甄選過程也很主觀. 但相對而言非常公平. 大陸制度更黑暗. 認識一個北京朋友, 其女兒成績不是太出色, 為了進一間著名的外語中學, 要 ...

Mandysyl

每位小朋友都有書讀,都係好事. 係大陸,入稍好的幼稚園都話要收幾萬贊助費,北京的朋友仲話你香港人仲有學卷添...太好了.
我的兒子也是明年準備入小一,我也有報直資,也參觀過傳統名校,新派直資及官津學校,其實都各有可取之處. 我想講最重要的是看孩子的性格及能力, 佢天資聰穎,家長有能力的可以報名校,直資. 但如果孩子資質平平,就算過5關斬6將入到名校, 將來他可能只是墊底...會唔會揀間課程不太深,但校風純樸,讓孩子開開心心,可能成績中等,培育他的自信?
看到1間直資3,4千人報名,我也覺得很誇張,其實間間直資都可能來來去去都係果幾千個家長報名. 講真, 我不太寄望兒子可以突圍而出,我已在區內挑選了幾間心儀的官津, 去開放日,跟校內家長溝通, 了解學校是否合適兒子的性格, 我想做父母的盡力就可以了,不要給孩子太多的壓力!!

Ving

So, I don't really believe and understand religion or old boy/girl chidren is anything related with the children's ability. If that is to be fair, I think all intake should at least have some interview process although it might be clumsy. Otherwise, I don't believe in fairness

Geni

我就咁睇:

自行 - 靠關係
大抽獎 - 靠策略+運氣

面試 - 靠實力+策略+運氣+關係 (邊項比重高d?? 間間都唔同~~~)

無一個方法係百份百公平, 對唔同o既人都有唔同o既程度o既利同弊.

flostangraphy

不太明白....

原帖由 manmak88 於 17/9/2010 09:24 發表
「千猜」...... 不是潮州福建朋友可能不太明白......
我因為聽得多父母說才知道, 雖然周星星有教過

[ 本帖最後由 flostangraphy 於 10-9-17 15:05 編輯 ]

thomasha

They are more related to whether the parents have similar visions with the school in educating the child.

For DSS/private schools, all candidates, whether related or not, have to be interviewed, as far as I know.  You may be given extra marks, but if your child interview performance is bad, the child may still not be accepted.

原帖由 Ving 於 10-9-17 14:05 發表
So, I don't really believe and understand religion or old boy/girl chidren is anything related with the children's ability. If that is to be fair, I think all intake should at least have some intervie ...

fongyuen

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-9-17 15:41 發表
They are more related to whether the parents have similar visions with the school in educating the child.

For DSS/private schools, all candidates, whether related or not, have to be interviewed, as f ...

同意。
曾聽說一些非教友家長，入了某間天主教名校，竟然要求學校減少宗教課，令校方很為難。所以，若果教會學校可以選擇，當然希望盡可能多一些教友學生入讀。

vaga

每個遊戲都有一套規則, 試問有邊一種方法會人人覺得公平？ 冇謂怨天怨地, 接受哩個事實啦……

thomasha

The parent should have read the curriculum thoroughly and carefully before registering his/her child in the school.  Once the child is studying in that school, there is little ground for the parent to request a change in any part of the curriculum.

原帖由 fongyuen 於 10-9-17 15:49 發表


同意。
曾聽說一些非教友家長，入了某間天主教名校，竟然要求學校減少宗教課，令校方很為難。所以，若果教會學校可以選擇，當然希望盡可能多一些教友學生入讀。 ...

manmak88

我父母是福建人, 細時聽得多現在識聽唔識講
「千猜」-> 是旦

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 10-9-17 14:56 發表
不太明白....

山山

原帖由 Ving 於 10-9-17 12:42 發表
So, there is no faireness or not in the world.

You can go into good school like Marymount, St Joseph, St Mary, La Salle even he/she don't know A-Z or 1-10, or bad manner or absolute implolite. The on ...

Totally agreed!!

hellomickey

原帖由 shootingstar 於 2010/9/17 13:46 發表
如果你係細仔媽咪, 特別係12月出世個D, 你就會慶幸有這計分制度存在.

仲有內向型子女的家長!又名面試死硬型!