MARYKNOLL & ST. MARY

kimimi

各位媽媽

只可選一間, 你地會點選,
請各位比些意見, 二校都是名校, 真是難選擇,
好似話ST. MARY的小六生, 可以直上中學, 是否真呢 ?
如果係, 咁壓力應該無MARYKNOLL咁大, 是嗎 ?
功課和校風又如何呢 ?

謝謝大家,

RickyGloria

Maryknoll and St. Mary are placed in different 'School Net'.  Is it an impossible question?

Or, do you have 2 different residential address?

kamen

我諗kimimi個女係有20分，可以係第一輪抽st mary or MCS。
我上年都好似你咁，st mary 可以直上中學而又低調Ｄ，本來想揀呢間，後來，覺得MCS嘅位多Ｄ，机會好似大Ｄ，MCS首輪大約有93位，扣除60%必收，大約有３x個抽，而st mary衹得48位，扣除必收，得十幾個位，最後我個女係第一round ok左。當然，如果兩間任揀 (        發夢)，我會揀St Mary唔使煩中学。

bau

Most of the girls in this year if getting 20  marks chose St Mary because of the through train of them. I never have friend chose Maryknoll because they thought it was difficult. But I think the seats are far more in Maryknoll made the chance bingo high. So if you have no address in both net, I think Maryknoll is higher chance than St Mary.

franky speaking, luck is the most important to all.
I got 20 marks and in net 31, failed in both round and still find schools now. But one of my friend got in Part A in second round.

Smalljokerbb

I like ST Mary more.

BoBoCute

Maryknoll english primary, english better
St. Mary chinese primary, chinese better

If both equal marks, i would pick Maryknoll.

BoBoCute

其實一向Maryknoll spoken eng 比 St. Mary's 好D, written 就唔知,但no doubt St. Mary's chinese language 較Maryknoll 好.  St. Mary's english 都比一般好, 但comparing to Maryknoll 就感覺Maryknoll 好D.
At least 身為St. Marian 嘅我及我嘅舊同學如此認為。
以前F.5 好多人中英文都A, A level almost all my class got distinction in English.
Regarding school campus, Maryknoll's campus is more spacious.
校風就唔知which is better.
But St. Mary's 一條龍就保險D。

ZaraZara

Bobocute,

咁Maryknoll 收回小一學生的百份比為多少

kimimi

kamen

You are right.
Congratulation that you daughter got a seat in MCS, very nice, so happy.
May I know where you can find that "MCS首輪大約有93位，扣除60%必收，大約有３x個抽，而st mary衹得48位，扣除必收，得十幾個位" ??
You are very nice mami to search such kind of information for your daughter.

kimimi

bau

May I know which is  "art A in second round" ??
Don't give up, pls try to lock the door and send letter, you 1st and 2nd round also choose St. Mary. Good lucky.

bau

The first round is counting your marks.
The second round has A & B, A you can choose 3 schools all over the nets. B you only choose those in your net. But A only has few seats for all the applicants and the chance is slim.

I send the profile already but not in high expectation. I only expect I can get a seat in a better private or Direct Subsidiary school now.

kamen

kimimi,
在小一概覧裏，MCS小一共有185位，有一半比第一輪即係93個位。