教統局-“嚴查”和 "嚴懲”虛報地址, 特別是 41校網 - 小一選校

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1160

41^#

發表於 08-1-14 23:06 |只看該作者

原文章由 irenec 於 08-1-14 09:51 發表
我朋友都有去教統局, 但對方唔接受佢嘅解釋, 最終都要放棄 12 net 囉！

嘩，原來真係會有人比教統查出，唔比佢報．
我更覺得自己無教小朋友說謊是正確的．　
因會影響她一生．　第時要教好她就有點困難了！　

d2343130

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	4468

42^#

發表於 08-1-15 12:49 |只看該作者

你有個朋友真係咁做,用假地址, 你會舉報佢??

原文章由 vic6 於 08-1-14 23:06 發表

嘩，原來真係會有人比教統查出，唔比佢報．
我更覺得自己無教小朋友說謊是正確的．　
因會影響她一生．　第時要教好她就有點困難了！　

[ 本文章最後由 d2343130 於 08-1-15 13:43 編輯 ]

回望這半生　也許是場夢年月已帶走　幾個秋與冬淚也倦了夢也不斷轉眼逝去生命或許是場空

elok

別墅

Rank: 4


	574

43^#

發表於 08-1-15 13:30 |只看該作者

一定唔會舉報佢, 舉報佢? 為咩呢? 始終都是朋友 ! 做朋友做到為左找學校而舉報. 這行為都幾冇品!! 如真是有朋友這樣, 我相信這段日子都唔會好過, 因要擔心比人查.

最多咪同佢講下就算, 聽唔聽就睇佢啦!

[ 本文章最後由 elok 於 08-1-15 13:35 編輯 ]

rohoy2k

複式洋房

Rank: 3 Rank: 3


	195

44^#

發表於 08-1-15 15:15 |只看該作者

朋友係政府部門做,話以前有例因為人手問題,都未必揸得咁嚴.
而家曾生上場後,呢樣"柯秩"果樣"柯秩",有例不執行是死罪. 所以每年都要查吓......

bbpoon

別墅

Rank: 4


	604

45^#

發表於 08-1-15 17:20 |只看該作者

請問若為了某校網而租該區單位,只有租約,沒有其他水電煤証明. 而且不是經常係度住,這有沒有抵觸.

謝謝!

Rank: 2


	57

46^#

發表於 08-1-15 18:30 |只看該作者

回覆 #18 jk67jk 的文章

no! I think you are wrong.
Their requirement is you MUST living in the place which the address is you submitted in the form, either you are the house owner or rent the place.
You MUST living in the place is meaning you and your kid must living 7 days/week during before submit the form and after the lucky draw.
If they received any complaint and suspect you are cheating, they will request you to provide more evidence to approve that. If you are really living there but cannot provide that, they will request you to swear and then visit you suddenly.
Don't against me, because I have this experience......

Rank: 2


	57

47^#

發表於 08-1-15 18:33 |只看該作者

原文章由 YnnMa 於 08-1-9 12:49 發表
咁我想問, 如果真金白銀租個單位, 有齊水, 電, 屋契, 咁又得唔得呀! (實質唔會住個度)

No! You cannot. You and your kids MUST living there 7 days/week. They don't allow you didn't living there either you buy or rent a place only.

Rank: 2


	57

48^#

發表於 08-1-15 18:38 |只看該作者

原文章由 hatfield 於 08-1-9 12:54 發表
如果我係租樓, 二樣都唔係我名喎, 點比呀！唔通唔買樓就唔比讀？

If the place is rented, owned by your parants, and you are really living there. Don't worry, they will ask you to provide some related documents or request you goto swear. Then they will check & clarify and/or home visit........

Rank: 2


	57

49^#

發表於 08-1-15 18:40 |只看該作者

原文章由 KY 於 08-1-9 18:17 發表
咁都得
教育局都無寫明要physically live there
真金白銀租都唔得?

NO! They have writed you "MUST" physically live there.....
either the place you bought , rent or free.......

Rank: 2


	57

50^#

發表於 08-1-15 18:46 |只看該作者

原文章由 easybring 於 08-1-10 17:42 發表

你係唔係講呢句呀? 我呢個問題"唔得咩?", 其實個個都識答, 係可以抽, 我只想反問大家, 我用合理租金租一個地址, 可以搬入去, 但唔搬, 算唔算假地址? (教統話唔得) 如我買一間屋, 可以搬入去, 但唔搬, 可唔可以抽? ...

我用合理租金租一個地址, 可以搬入去, 但唔搬, 算唔算假地址? <-- this is a not a 假地址, but not your living place.

如我買一間屋, 可以搬入去, 但唔搬, 可唔可以抽?
<-- no you can't, because you are not living there too..

Rank: 2


	57

51^#

發表於 08-1-15 18:51 |只看該作者

原文章由 Childhood 於 08-1-10 22:13 發表
其實那些去菲律賓旅行, 順路入去其中一間教堂就可以受浸, 之後参加自行分配學位就加5分, 應該有部份人用這途徑在第一輪入咗, 聖誕前巳開香賓興祝, 依家重駛乜係呢到同大家吹水!
你地話這種人是否更加好惡!
...

I don't think they can have the extra 5 marks so easy. Because some of the schools they won't accept this kind of 受浸....

Rank: 2


	57

52^#

發表於 08-1-15 18:55 |只看該作者

原文章由 vic6 於 08-1-13 22:33 發表

irenec,
嘩,今年咁嚴!! 咁過唔過到關呀? 往年無咁既嘢嗎?

Yes, this year is very seriously, but only in net 11, 12, 41 & some famous ares..... EDB has spent a lot of man power to check those net in this year..

Little_cy

男爵府

Rank: 6 Rank: 6


	6551

53^#

發表於 08-1-16 14:29 |只看該作者

woo, what is net 11, 12 and 41 ah

Rank: 2


	57

54^#

發表於 08-1-16 14:56 |只看該作者

原文章由 Little_cy 於 08-1-16 14:29 發表
woo, what is net 11, 12 and 41 ah

Central-Western 11, Wanchai 12, (LaSa) 41, & some famous net.

puzzledmama

別墅

Rank: 4


	903

55^#

發表於 08-1-16 16:57 |只看該作者

12 net灣仔區出貓嚴重!!

有個家裡做灣仔區地產的朋友話我知, 在12 net即灣仔區, 有一座舊樓,叫"齊安大廈"既, 近天樂里, 就專係租比d想大抽獎報讀12net, 但根本唔係住在那裡的家長!

佢話d地產都做慣呢d"勾當", 成幢樓都係呢類個案, 教育局應立即睇下有幾多人係用"齊安大廈"來報讀St Joseph/ Wah Yan/ Marymount等, 呢d個案多數有問題!!

個地產話其他地區都有d咁既舊樓, 間一間間套房出來租比呢d家長出貓!!

:tongue: :tongue:

vic6

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1160

56^#

發表於 08-1-17 02:10 |只看該作者

原文章由 talk3talk4 於 08-1-15 18:55 發表

Yes, this year is very seriously, but only in net 11, 12, 41 & some famous ares..... EDB has spent a lot of man power to check those net in this year..

OH, i see. thanks.

River

Rank: 2


	62

57^#

發表於 08-1-17 16:09 |只看該作者

I also heard from my friend who works in Government
which is same advice as Rohoy's friend.
Especially, net 41, as their complaints is much serious and it seems they collected numbers which represent facts of
suitable age children.

原文章由 rohoy2k 於 08-1-15 15:15 發表
朋友係政府部門做,話以前有例因為人手問題,都未必揸得咁嚴.
而家曾生上場後,呢樣"柯秩"果樣"柯秩",有例不執行是死罪. 所以每年都要查吓......

annienorman

Rank: 5 Rank: 5


	1449

58^#

發表於 08-1-18 12:38 |只看該作者

原文章由 elok 於 08-1-15 13:30 發表
一定唔會舉報佢, 舉報佢? 為咩呢? 始終都是朋友 ! 做朋友做到為左找學校而舉報. 這行為都幾冇品!! 如真是有朋友這樣, 我相信這段日子都唔會好過, 因要擔心比人查.

最多咪同佢講下就算, 聽唔聽就睇佢啦! ...

你真係好！我個fd在教統局做，佢話大多數報串的都是朋友／熟人！！！

Charlotte_mom

王國長老

Rank: 14

醒目開學勳章王國長老


	58851

59^#

發表於 08-1-18 16:28 |只看該作者

其實我唸, 如果教育署有個制度, 硬性規定校巴/保母車只可以接載去果一個"註冊地址", 要改地址都要中央處理, 睇下d人o係無車搭情況下, 仲會唔會報假地址丫!
咁多人報親戚做監護人, 係咪真係咁多人靠親戚湊仔呀:evil:

YongXin

Rank: 5 Rank: 5

醒目開學勳章


	1869

60^#

發表於 08-1-18 17:00 |只看該作者

跟本係個制度有問題, 等0的人有罅可走, 又借地址又租假屋又改監護人. 制度有問題就用行動去堵塞. 唔夠人手? 住址証明要求再嚴格0的, 虛報係刑事要坐監(依家係唔係?)...要査? 税局, 統計處都大把市民既人口資料, 核對下就露0西馬腳啦, EDB点解唔做?

既得利益者永遠多過熱門網真正受害人, 我住12網三十幾年, 好彩我女舊年自行階段就得0左區內學校, 如果我會因為作弊0個班人而統一階段落空本網首志, 我實同當局死過!

如此謊繆既事, 只會繼續.