名校刁鑽小一面試題 網上熱傳

loveheiting

我阿仔依家k2,我今日問佢有$10000會買啲mud?

佢話會買...........橙,出前一x同牛油.

我講比佢知$10000有好多,佢食唔哂,會浪費!

佢竟然話比我知係送比保良局啲小朋友(因為我同佢講過嗰度啲小朋友無父母)同依佢依家啲同學,人人都有,仲話一定會比一個橙我.

個答案唔係o甘logic, 但係我都幾開心!

laiws

原帖由 阿西 於 08-9-30 10:43 發表

我知，就係...................燈燈燈鄧.........................滙豐銀行！咁既要求，一定係申請銀行貸款，你拆左信呀.............唉.............攪錯晒

aknchan

Its really funny when so many people commented that the questions are so difficult and unreasonable for a 5 year old.

When there are 10-13 applicants competing for ONE SPOT, wouldn't you expect that some of the questions MUST BE DIFFICULT ENOUGH so that 90% of the kids won't be able to answer.
Or else the school would have nothing to choose the top 10% of the applicants.

In fact, the difficulty of these questions is indirectly controlled by the number of applicants, that means us, parents.

Gisele

think it is the response that counts, not the answer.

原帖由 aknchan 於 08-10-2 11:05 發表
Its really funny when so many people commented that the questions are so difficult and unreasonable for a 5 year old.

When there are 10-13 applicants competing for ONE SPOT, wouldn't you expect that  ...

VIR

我試過模擬問阿囡呢條問題, 佢嗰答案超搞笑:

我: If you have lot of money, which country shall you go?

囡: U.S

我:  What is the reason ?

囡: Because i want to buy something

我: What would you like to buy?

囡: Fries.......

係呢個時候, 我已笑到收唔到聲.....之後問佢點解要去到咁遠買薯條...佢竟然話...因美國d薯條有皮, 好食d喎 !!!
所以話呢...小朋友真係創意無限 !!

原帖由 soso1 於 08-9-30 12:49 發表
我問阿囡, 阿囡話買書lor, 我知佢唔知$10,000係幾多錢, 問佢係咪全部用嚟買晒, 可以用嚟買玩具, 糖....佢話:'係吖, 全部買晒, 因為我好鍾意書吖'。可惜唔係考中阿囡, 但我都好開心, 我想這個答案已經答得好好, 係佢 ...

andrewpapa

其實問題是否完全真確，你共我也不知。

有些超難問題是否有人成機造出來制造生意呀

I also agree that the answer is not the main concern.  Is our kid's response do matter.

Whether it is logical or creative do matter

aknchan

原帖由 Gisele 於 08-10-2 11:28 發表
think it is the response that counts, not the answer.

I agree to a certain extent.

How amny kids can tell the difference between a clinic and a hospital?

Of course there will be bouns points for those kids who can answer because they shows a better command of the language.
For those who can't but are brave enough to ask for the answer, they will also get points because they show maturity.
The worse case would be to freeze up in front of a difficult question, but after all, these kids are only 5.

What I really wanted to say is: Parents please don't worry too much because the interview is DESIGNED to fail 90% of its applicants.

Geni

"What I really wanted to say is: Parents please don't worry too much because the interview is DESIGNED to fail 90% of its applicants." <-- 睇完呢句我個心真係舒服o左好多, 講真o家~~ Thanks!!