學琴學費

小伊

同意！我識得一個，自己只得5級水平，卻走去教8級，從來唔示范，得把口講。不過宜家唔再教lu！
另外還有一個教古箏嘅，只彈得兩三句流行曲，夠膽死開班教古琴，古箏跟古琴，在技術上有很大差別。他的秘缺就是只用口講，從來不彈，你不滿意咪唔好學，走啰。他志在賺你購買樂器的差價！
此廝仍然有教ga，自封為x軍總會音樂首席總監。

mom5354

原帖由 Pianokc 於 08-11-1 23:13 發表
$ 750 an hour for Grade8-Diploma.
No going to students' house.
Just students to my studios.
Grand pianos (special edition bosendorfer piano)

Motivating and inspiring teaching methods, but presently I ...

Qualification, please

Pianokc

Pm to you.

原帖由 mom5354 於 08-11-2 15:58 發表



Qualification, please

Flowerlam

Dear pianokc,

I also want to know your qulification.

Please PM to me.

Pianokc

PM to You.

原帖由 Flowerlam 於 08-11-2 22:44 發表
Dear pianokc,

I also want to know your qulification.

Please PM to me.

toto@toto

Pianokc could you PM your qualifications to me please?

mom5354

原帖由 Pianokc 於 08-11-2 23:14 發表
PM to You.

Pianokc:

請問你的大學學位是否主修音樂?? 另外音樂治療及兒童心理學主要係針對智力或學習有問題的兒童 , 對一般的教學及演奏技巧無セ幫助ｏ 至於其他文憑(DipABRSM/LRSM)一般的老師也有, 無乜特別.....

Pianokc

I am not soliciting your business Mom5354. I replied because you wanted to know what kind of fees are charged by piano teachers in general, so I replied, because I had time.

All I can say is, even a piano teacher with just GRADE 8 qualifications, can be an excellent teacher. While a PhD in piano performance may be an excellent performer but a terrible teacher.

An excellent teacher to a teenager, maybe a terrible teacher for a 5 year old. Or, a teacher can be excellent in ALL areas like teaching all ages, and performing with superb musicality and skills.

You don't judge people, not just through their qualifications, experience counts alot. I certainly don't have any interest defending myself or to challenge any other piano teachers here with my information.

However, in my opinion, a good piano teacher is one that inspires, motivates, and have ways to make a child/student LOVE playing the piano, and in general become a music lover for life.

Also, I assume you are a mother ? I am shocked and surprised to hear you say "child psychology and music therapy" is useless to performance.
You have a long way to go in researching such areas.

Teaching piano and piano performance is more about PSYCHOLOGY and state of mind more than ANYTHING else. I won't give a lesson here.

Good luck.

[ 本帖最後由 Pianokc 於 08-11-3 21:40 編輯 ]

Pianokc

BTW, Mom5354, you seem to have no respect for other people's privacy. I was not interested in publicly posting my information in the forum, hence the PM. Guess I was too naive to think there is such a thing in here.


[

[ 本帖最後由 Pianokc 於 08-11-3 22:49 編輯 ]

mom5354

原帖由 Pianokc 於 08-11-3 21:48 發表
BTW, Mom5354, you seem to have no respect for other people's privacy. I was not interested in publicly posting my information in the forum, hence the PM. Guess I was too naive to think there is such a ...

Pianokc:

唔好意思, 無留意係Confidential, 我只係怕其他BK Mummy俾人呃啫...

[ 本帖最後由 mom5354 於 08-11-4 16:27 編輯 ]

Pianokc

I think parents should choose piano teachers or any instrumental teachers based on referrals, study the teacher's qualifications, past results, experience, AND most important of all, watch HOW your child reacts and interact with the teacher.

learning music is a LIFELONG journey, a good teacher will guide you towards a rewarding, and inspiring direction.

Whether the teacher is "qualified" or not..... parents certainly have eyes and ears to decide upon.... not based on some forum 's posts.

Just my opinion.

miss321

Education 呢個範疇係有包括psychology。好老師應該懂得與學生溝通，"如何溝通得好" 都有技巧架...所以pianokc有讀music therapy 同psychology 係絕對正確。

Pianokc

Thank you Miss321 for your clarification and educating remark.  I was beginning to think I am the only one who think so in here!

原帖由 miss321 於 08-11-4 22:20 發表
Education 呢個範疇係有包括psychology。好老師應該懂得與學生溝通，"如何溝通得好" 都有技巧架...所以pianokc有讀music therapy 同psychology 係絕對正確。

miss321

其實老師係應該有本科知識(音樂知識, 演奏技巧等等), 和教育知識(心理,哲學, 課程設計...), 少一樣都唔得。

Sindy

原帖由 Pianokc 於 08-11-3 21:37 發表
I am not soliciting your business Mom5354. I replied because you wanted to know what kind of fees are charged by piano teachers in general, so I replied, because I had time.

All I can say is, even a ...

如果只得八級,可以教到小朋友幾多級?

miss321

如果老師有繼續進修, 即使只有八級証書，但可能已有演奏級level, 可教到八級到冇問題。但如果老師只停留在八級level的話, 只能教到6-7級。

miss321

正如你去讀中學，一個中學畢業既人教你，你都覺得未夠班, 咁解....

小伊

唔系嘛! 8級點教6.7級呀? 大家差唔多咗窩!

miss321

級數只係一個標準, 有八級的人都可分好同唔好。所以一概而論八級教唔教到x級, 好難講。當你去到某個級數，覺得老師再教唔到你, 咪轉個勁d既老師囉, 唔使著重於老師有幾多級。我識一個人，佢自己考既証書唔多，都只係一個music degree+ LTCL, 但佢既level 唔止, 佢教過學生考FTCL, 仲合格左。所以都係學琴既人自己感覺下老師啦。