根德園定york好呢?

Fanny413

相信好多父母都好想替孩子選擇一間理想既幼稚園，
想問問大家根德園定york好呢?
根德園好似名氣，學生品格及升小學各方面都好好，
而york校園靚ｄ，好多設施，英文方面就好好．．．
我要兩間選一間，唔該大家比ｄ意見我！
謝謝啊！

cicicheung

I LIKE YORK

kenng89

其實兩間學校都有佢不同的好處,好難話邊間好啲,最緊要係睇妳的小朋友係邊一類,如係坐定定又係大b,kv會較適合,如小朋友係活潑型,york係好選擇,因為york比較活動教學,唔似kv太traditional,我都知道有時好難取捨,其實講到最後都係睇小朋友鐘意邊間,讀得開心都好important!
小朋友開唔開心,可能係interview妳會feel 到佢對邊間開心啲!

s204oxox

kenng89  good and fair comments

栢喬媽媽

我仔仔讀緊york .He is Like.

pandabonita

apple and orange, depends on what kind of person you want your bb to become really.

twins_daddy

原帖由 pandabonita 於 08-12-6 16:58 發表
apple and orange, depends on what kind of person you want your bb to become really.

well, personally i dont like the atmostphere of KV when we went to the school for the interview. Our family are well educated and education is key but not the only criteria for us.....

However, York give us the expression that it's a kindergarten..... and kids can have some fun....

I am not talking about which one is good and which one is not.... just personal feeling......

Big-Mouth

我覺根德園好d, 最重要係升小學,邊間容易敲門, 加上根德園出名中和數都好, 致於英文,可以比佢讀出面d課程, 再者根德園收費平過York, 無今多雜費。

原帖由 Fanny413 於 08-11-30 01:54 發表
相信好多父母都好想替孩子選擇一間理想既幼稚園，
想問問大家根德園定york好呢?
根德園好似名氣，學生品格及升小學各方面都好好，
而york校園靚ｄ，好多設施，英文方面就好好．．．
我要兩間選一間，唔該大家比ｄ意見我！
謝謝啊！ ...

twins_daddy

原帖由 fujitasze 於 08-12-8 19:32 發表
唔好玩啦，十個有九個家長都揀KV啦，York係人都收你會唔會揀....

i also tend to agree that most parents would prefer KV if accepted, that's no doubt about it.

but "York係人都收你會唔會揀.... " do u mind to explain more and why u said so?

e.g. it's obvious for KV this year younger kids were given a lot lower priorities (as per replies from parents in this forum)... do u mind to share your personal/friends experience on "York係人都收".  your valuable input would be very much appreciated.

Mamusia

如果係我, 我一定一定揀kv,

論學術水平, 辦學態度, 畢業生素質, etc,
兩間kg根本就完全吾同級數,....
(my personal opinion only, though some FANS may not agree)

s204oxox

咁 firm???!!!!
how can u get the data ??

論學術水平, 辦學態度, 畢業生素質

twins_daddy

原帖由 s204oxox 於 08-12-9 14:24 發表
咁 firm???!!!!
how can u get the data ??

論學術水平, 辦學態度, 畢業生素質

I think the above are mostly depending on family education .........

I never expect the KG will provide very high 學術水平..... well .....  but interesting thoughts and comment !

s204oxox

yes, i agree, intensive drilling not equal to high academic standard.

joetsang

原帖由 WanWah 於 08-12-2 13:08 發表
有時真係好難取捨, 家長又想子女讀得開心但又想佢哋成績優異, 真係好難決擇

其實你地有冇真係識過小朋友自己講返KV 返得唔開心呢.

Fanny413

真的很謝謝大家呀!

wilsonchanwh

以下係從BK收集到對KV意見。


KV 係數學方面比其他強很多。


好既英文補習係外面好易揾, 但中文同數學相對無咁多.


我揀KV係一心想幫個仔打好個底, 加埋佢既性格夠定, 獨立同吸收快, 所以我覺得KV岩佢多d.


我聽聞KV的學術水平真係唔錯,
同埋紀律 train得好好﹐KV的小朋友大多很文靜, 學校要小朋友好乖咁坐定定

KV讀過既小朋友真係好有禮貌及有規矩﹐聽聞話KV所學到既野令人感意外既,如k1已學到五大洲,七大洋

怕再讀埋活動教學上小學會追唔上.因為英文比較容易响出面幫到.所以KV應該係我嘅選擇.

KV - traditional school, no outings, start writing in K1 (so no problem with 'big' kid), good for parents that don't have time to study with kids as the school will train the kids to do their homeworks by themselves.

問過現就讀KV既朋友,佢地都認為kv既老師有佢地對小朋友既一套,佢地覺得在校既老師都好nice,小朋友都讀得好開心,可能大家都比老師面試果日既急趕樣子嚇怕左姐

cookiegg

我個仔今年O係KV讀K1,其實果時我就O係學之園,施德福同KV揀.

我就咁睇囉:都明白揀KV可能無咁多活動,功課壓力可能大D,不過如果O係香港讀既,遲D都一定要面對,所以我最終想比佢試下,若果佢讀唔上,追得好辛苦,到時咪轉校囉,我諗轉去第二間一定會易過由第二間轉返入去.

佢宜家返左學幾個月,都好開心,每晚臨瞓前都話我要返學,我要上堂,而我好佩服D老師,佢地真係TRAIN到D小朋友獨立D,佢成日同我講:'我大個仔喇,要自己試下',我真係好多謝D老師.尋日送我個仔返學後,跟住o係窗門望入去,老師一同小朋友講:'聽到鐘聲o向,即係夠鐘喇,要點做呀?'跟住佢地個個即刻坐好晒,然之後個個'僕'o係張枱度,真係好神奇,所以我好放心比個仔o係度讀書.

雖然我唔知道當初若果揀第2間會唔會仲開心d,不過到現時為止我都無覺得自己揀錯.

[ 本帖最後由 cookiegg 於 08-12-10 17:52 編輯 ]

kyliema2006

所以唔同家長會有不同的期望，若是我，KV is not my cup of tea。

原帖由 cookiegg 於 08-12-10 17:50 發表
我個仔今年O係KV讀K1,其實果時我就O係學之園,施德福同KV揀.

我就咁睇囉:都明白揀KV可能無咁多活動,功課壓力可能大D,不過如果O係香港讀既,遲D都一定要面對,所以我最終想比佢試下,若果佢讀唔上,追得好辛苦,到時咪轉校 ...