想知多d ~~英文小學

zakka069

有無家長可以俾d意見呀!
如果選英文小學給小朋友,有什麼利弊呀?

[ 本帖最後由 zakka069 於 09-2-10 15:41 編輯 ]

YanYan0116

原帖由 召藥師 於 09-2-19 00:39 發表


THANKS~
咁請問妳自己又點教囡囡背?九因歌定要佢背英文?我覺得好似好難轉channel咁......

係屋企都係背中文, 如果係學校, 老師只係叫佢地計, 用英文回答, 無叫過佢地由1開始背.
如果要用英文背真係幾"橋"口.

mandy_lee

原帖由 召藥師 於 09-2-19 00:39 發表


THANKS~
咁請問妳自己又點教囡囡背?九因歌定要佢背英文?我覺得好似好難轉channel咁......

我地學校都係背中文

decision

原帖由 召藥師 於 09-2-16 02:57 發表
我想請教小朋友讀英小嘅父母，小朋友到學乘數時，老師點教?母語教數學有背九因歌，咁英文教時又如何學習呢?

老師容許用廣東話背。
至於自己背都選了廣東話，
因為要背出聲，廣東話易背熟,
e.g. "774拾9" 順口過 seven times seven equal to forty- nine.
答題轉channel 不感困難。

stevema

我认识很多中英兼善的人都是小学3、4年斑才开始学英文的。中文其实难学，不过社会要求不高，马马虎虎便算。往后几十年中文的地位也不应忽视。我的选择是中文小学、英文初中、高中、大学。要读英文日后大把机会，小学多读中文也不错！

召藥師

原帖由 YanYan0116 於 09-2-16 11:51 AM 發表


我個女好似係咁讀four times four is sixteen.

THANKS~
咁請問妳自己又點教囡囡背?九因歌定要佢背英文?我覺得好似好難轉channel咁......

zakka069

多謝各位給意見,但我還是會選擇英小給孩子讀.
我個人意見英文實在佔一個很重要的環節,我覺得應由細給他接觸多一些,將來唔洗怕英文呢種語言.

還有一些問題想知.

為何香港的英小不是太多呢?真的怕小朋友學不到,聽不懂嗎?

但到了選中學時,很多家長都希望子女能入讀英文為主科的中學?到那時他們真的明白所有英文詞句?完全明白老師所講的英文嗎?

olima

樓主，請問熟意那些英文小學﹖大家交流下。

又，香港有那些中文小學好似st paul co-edu咁，高小用英文呢﹖好似英華是其一, 對不對﹖

YanYan0116

原帖由 召藥師 於 09-2-16 02:57 發表
我想請教小朋友讀英小嘅父母，小朋友到學乘數時，老師點教?母語教數學有背九因歌，咁英文教時又如何學習呢?

我個女好似係咁讀four times four is sixteen.

召藥師

我想請教小朋友讀英小嘅父母，小朋友到學乘數時，老師點教?母語教數學有背九因歌，咁英文教時又如何學習呢?

ahdee

I think most of the primary school subjects reference materials (including those from EDB) are in Chinese. For example, I have a very difficult time in finding relevant General Studies English reference materials for my daughter outside her text books. Most of materials I can find from EDB and other websites in HK are in Chinese (e.g. ETV GS programs are in Chinese, and a lot of schools show these programs to their students even though they are using English text book). Of course you can find learning materials from overseas websites, but the context might not provide a life-like environment in HK, and kids might have a difficult time to build the relationship between the concepts behind and their daily life.

原帖由 馬媽媽 於 09-2-11 16:54 發表
This arrangement has been used by St Paul Co-ed. Besides, I agree to use English to teach Maths and other subjects in Higher primary. I also let my child to try some English Maths Ex.

HKQQbaby

My baby is studing in an English Primary School(P1),since he is an active & creative boy, he is not suitable for the traditional school, and I maybe let him to study oversea when he will be 12 years old. So I prepared his interview for English primary school from K1.

小朋友讀英文小學後英文進步很快 學會很多英文生字 開學半年 已能完成一篇50字的英文作文. General Study, Maths, Arts and P.E all subject (except Chinese in PTH) are taught in English, so his listening and reading skill of English are improving. Of course, the standard of Chinese is not higher than other Chinese Primary School. But the homework of School is less than others.(within one hour). And school requests student to read 40 chinese books and 15 English books within 40 days. So my boy can learn many Chinese / English words.
Since I have to read the books with my boy, so I read a lot of books at the same time.

[ 本帖最後由 HKQQbaby 於 09-2-14 21:43 編輯 ]

馬媽媽

This arrangement has been used by St Paul Co-ed. Besides, I agree to use English to teach Maths and other subjects in Higher primary. I also let my child to try some English Maths Ex.

原帖由 NeoMom 於 09-2-11 16:05 發表


小學(尢其初小)為何要用母語教其他科目如數學是因為可讓小朋友可更了解, 更深刻及更快去掌握一些基本概念, 因為如果基本概念掌握得唔好, 上高年級就好容易會混亂

你說得對, 語言發展越早越好, 但中小也不是沒有 ...

NeoMom

原帖由 rabbitpiggy 於 09-2-11 12:23 發表
咁點解去到中學又差不多所有家長都想小朋友讀英中呢? 到了中學所有學科才轉英文不是仲難嗎? 因為差不多所有專家都同意語言發展是越細越好的.

中小+英文, 和  英小+英中, 那個組合較有優勢呢? ...

小學(尢其初小)為何要用母語教其他科目如數學是因為可讓小朋友可更了解, 更深刻及更快去掌握一些基本概念, 因為如果基本概念掌握得唔好, 上高年級就好容易會混亂

你說得對, 語言發展越早越好, 但中小也不是沒有英文學, 再者而家有一些中小其實在高小階段已用英文教數學同某些其他學科, 我反而覺得呢個安排最好, 一來可讓小朋友在初小不需要在一下子接觸很多新概念時要同時兼顧語言問題, 二來可讓他們在學科內容未是很艱深時習慣用英語,

mandy_lee

原帖由 YanYan0116 於 09-2-11 13:07 發表
我個女係讀屯門某英小, 好處是好的英文能力大大進步了, 佢聽同講都叻咗好多了.

但maths真係要花時間來跟她溫習, 好似P2上學期教時間, 中文直接?時?分便可以, 但英文就要小朋友識得用pass, to, a quarter, 仲有圖型/ ...

我女都是讀英小我自問英文不太好無物支援到佢, 但佢身邊有好多同學英文底子其實已經真不錯, 甚至有D 反而不懂說中文, 我就是英文不太好所以我希望女女從細開始打好英文基礎, 學校是活動教學所以女女都跟得上.
阿女P.2 個陣常識有教4大發明, 不過我反而覺得常識用英文教好多生字都好深.
數學科有家長說英數是容易過用中文教. 不過當然都係要串好多英文生字.
而家一路同阿女溫書我都學多了英文, 不過唔知仲可以跟到幾多年班.

馬媽媽

I agreed with what you have mentioned here. That's why I gave up the place at an English Primary School and took the place at a Chinese Primary School.

A Maths educationist has mentioned that it is very difficult to let children to understand Maths if applying languages apart from mother tongue, especially at primary school.

原帖由 NeoMom 於 09-2-11 10:39 發表
我以前都曾希望小朋友入讀英文小學, 但發覺香港既英小實在太少, 再要加上一些考慮因素如教學理念, 學校地點等, 差不多冇乜選擇, 於是我想, 英小需求咁大, 為何香港只有少數英小呢, 好多名校如st paul co-ed, ls等都 ...

YanYan0116

我個女係讀屯門某英小, 好處是好的英文能力大大進步了, 佢聽同講都叻咗好多了.

但maths真係要花時間來跟她溫習, 好似P2上學期教時間, 中文直接?時?分便可以, 但英文就要小朋友識得用pass, to, a quarter, 仲有圖型/3d, 都幾多生字要串.

而常識料的課程是跟中小不同的, 中小好似教四大發明, 我個女是學識業, 光, 運動類別......  

你仲想知D咩ar?

rabbitpiggy

咁點解去到中學又差不多所有家長都想小朋友讀英中呢? 到了中學所有學科才轉英文不是仲難嗎? 因為差不多所有專家都同意語言發展是越細越好的.

中小+英文, 和  英小+英中, 那個組合較有優勢呢?

easybring

入讀英文小學, 我想家中支持一定不少.