合唱團

fatping1

請問"香港兒童合唱團" 或 "香港童聲合唱團" 好D?  

Thanks a lot!

fatping1

I read other comments about 香港兒童合唱團 which is a 老字號 with long history, but quite commerical, the teachers might not have passion to teach children singing.  Is this true?

[ 本帖最後由 fatping1 於 09-3-11 17:53 編輯 ]

fatping1

YYML,

May I know how old is your girl?  Which class at treble choir she is taking now?  Thanks a lot!  

原帖由 YYML 於 09-3-11 14:13 發表
「香兒」今期已過了報告日期，暫時不用想。
「童聲」，囡囡唱緊，以前有三個中心，現在只縮減至一個，位於太古。看你覺得是否方便。囡囡就話以前唱得較開心，現在轉了地點和老師，她覺得老師有時惡了些。
我就因覺得童聲遠，想轉，不知 ...

fatping1

YYML,

I prefer HK side.  As HK Children Choir requires interview before accepting students, will it be very strict in students selection?

Which Choir do you think the children feel more enjoyable and fun?

原帖由 YYML 於 09-3-11 20:44 發表
Nearly 5 years old. She is attending the Class One. Anyway, I will make the decision of joining another choir or not after the annual performance held in June.

About the HK Children Choir, the class  ...

fatping1

YYML,

My girl is 4 years old, she can attend 預一 班.  May be I will call and ask for a trial class.  My girl sometimes act quite shy in a new class, so I am afraid she won't go inside the classroom without me accompanying her.  As she likes to sing, that's why i like her to try Choir ar...

I don't know much about 葉氏 as the minimum age is 5 years old from what I read from their website, so i just check 香兒 &  童聲...

Thanks for your reply!  

原帖由 YYML 於 09-3-12 13:38 發表
fatping 1

若你想在香港區，就不妨試「童聲」。雖然呀女話Miss有時惡些，但這是因為她試過跟另一個Miss,故有比較。而且我再問過她Miss點惡，她說有些同學頑皮，比Miss鬧，但你知小朋友就算Miss不是鬧自己也會有d驚。

整體而 ...

fatping1

gershwin,

May I know what kind of exam did you take for Choir / singing?

Do you still teach in any center or school now?  

Thanks!

原帖由 gershwin 於 09-3-12 15:32 發表
以我所知，香兒有部份教唱歌的老師只有鋼琴CERT. 未必識教唱歌,而香兒較好的導師和學生都在英皇道和何文田。不過近年佢地鍾意請舊生教,我覺得D舊生都係有唱CHOIR經驗，唔等於識教，除非佢受過訓練。

至於葉氏CHOIR唱成點 ...

fatping1

There are also other courses from YIPS, anyone had joined before?

幼兒音樂啟蒙班

幼兒音樂及藝術智能發展課程

Are they good?  Thanks!  

原帖由 gershwin 於 09-3-15 18:07 發表
無留意有這2隊CHOIR

fatping1

If not talking about YIP's high school fee or extra charge of gala concert, is the quality of YIPS choir and teaching better?  I would like to know their quality of teaching, not the amount they charge.

Also, is it necessary to attend YIPS 幼兒音樂啟蒙班 or 幼兒音樂及藝術智能發展課程 before the children can join their Choir?  

Thanks!  

原帖由 octoct 於 09-3-18 19:29 發表

我本來想同阿仔報YIPS，但之前有媽咪在bk內曾提及yips好謀利，如有gala concert，就規定每名學員要買2、3張門票，是一定要買，每張飛幾百元，仲有其他投訴，我問過價錢，學費好貴仲有好多野要買，所以我無報了。

至於香兒，他們是非牟 ...

fatping1

That means even YIPS is not good?

原帖由 gershwin 於 09-3-31 10:03 發表
哇!$1XX? 可能我老師講的是好耐之前，老實講，出手咁低，難怪香港D CHOIR水準下降。學校出手好好多！

fatping1

But it seems YIPs or 香兒 got more opportunities to perform outside, is it true?

fatping1

gershwin,

Are the school choir organized in primary schools?  May be it is good for the children to join choir in outside organization during kindergarten, then enter school choir when the kids study primary.  

Do you know which schools have high reputation school choir?

Thanks!  

原帖由 gershwin 於 09-4-1 21:50 發表
不一定，我以前都會帶隊CHOIR出席HKIED工作坊的guest performer, 出席比賽，CHRISTMAS仲去過教尖沙嘴一間5星級酒店唱聖誕歌等等，如果學校CHOIR搞得好，會有不同的機構CONTACT你，所以可以揀D較高質素的活動參加。我以前有幾個 ...