KTS的結果很有代表性嗎?(誠邀過來人分享.謝謝^^)

dougdora

原帖由 shiuchen 於 09-10-16 11:31 發表
今天KTS公佈二輪名單.
我的孩子榜上無名.
第一輪面試後,我聽孩子說出面試的內容,英文讀句子,說出圖中的故事,畫圖完成故事,計減數.問是誰帶去面試等等問題.
我覺得這學校的面試方式很有代表性.所以早幾天就覺得如果入 ...

shiuchen,

dun be too sad.. .though my son can get in 2nd round, we are also only on 優才 waiting???   I also dun know why...

I thought we can help him a bit on 優才 as parents were also interviewed... in the end??!?!?!

more, i know some successful story was you can convince the principal even you are not in the waiting list.. .

so dun give up... and trust your son can make it.

Good luck to you all and ourselves..

wingheimom

Anybody know what's the selection criateria of KTS? I think the academic and daily life questions are not difficult.

oasismcmug

Just like all the other mummy said, please do not mind the result. I know exactly how you felt especially when you thought your child was doing fine. I truely believe interview is a bias game and it really depends a bit on luck. Please review all the points that you think your child did not do well and improve it for the next interview. I think that is the positive way to look at the result. One single interview does not review how your child perform at all (in fact, I do not believe any interview result review any of the childrens' performance even for the very top famous school. Including the one said they can tell by just taking a look at the kid for 5 mins. (What a joke!) I reckon the interview game only review the child is outspoken and talkative especially they are so young. A lot of the acadamically top and smart people when they grow up are not outspoken in nature anyway.) My daughter was interviewed last year and KTS did not have 2nd interviewlast year. I did not feel their interview was serious as most of the students come out in around 15mins. I also remember the teacher did not allow my daughter to calculate by counting on fingers. I do not see why she can not calculate by counting finger as this was taught from her kinder. I did not get a seat in KTS but my daughter got in DGJS. My friend's daughter also did not get accepted but then she got in St. Paul co-ed. One of my friend's daughter did not get a seat anywhere, but KTS only. Well, she eventually got in good hope by knocking on door.
So just be ready for the next interview and do not mind too, too much on the result.

magiccandy

This is a very good way of positive thinking.

原帖由 oasismcmug 於 09-10-16 19:41 發表
Just like all the other mummy said, please do not mind the result. I know exactly how you felt especially when you thought your child was doing fine. I truely believe interview is a bias game and it r ...

Ben2003

原帖由 oasismcmug 於 09-10-16 19:41 發表
So just be ready for the next interview and do not mind too, too much on the result.

goodboyg

原帖由 oasismcmug 於 09-10-16 19:41 發表
Just like all the other mummy said, please do not mind the result. I know exactly how you felt especially when you thought your child was doing fine. I truely believe interview is a bias game and it r ...

希望在人間，大家努力！如冇second-in下年6月後可再叩門?

salina0817

Shiuchen,

my daughter also K3, playing the game. But I did not apply for KTS. still have 2 interview Sunday and next week.

My girl is shy and she does not want to express her ideas. She need time to warm up, everything of her is good except interview.

bb亞媽

非常同意你講那某港島直資男校的求其和唔專業~~~

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-16 12:07 發表


如果你有in過某港島直資男校及見識過那種求其和唔專業，你會知道KTS的interview其實幾認真。

我就原全唔知那間男校的收生標準了。

paulmak818

原帖由 bb亞媽 於 09-10-16 21:00 發表
非常同意你講那某港島直資男校的求其和唔專業~~~

me too, that' why the no. of applicant is not too big compared with others.     :tongue:

shiuchen

Thanks a lot for your comfort and sharing. You are so kind! :)
My son has taken all 1 st interview, we can only look for good news in the upcoming release.

原帖由 oasismcmug 於 09-10-16 19:41 發表
Just like all the other mummy said, please do not mind the result. I know exactly how you felt especially when you thought your child was doing fine. I truely believe interview is a bias game and it r ...

[ 本帖最後由 shiuchen 於 09-10-16 22:31 編輯 ]

Lovelycat

我阿囡都有apply kts, same as u, no 2nd interview , 我都不太失望既, 我同老公都打定輸數, 阿囡讀番津校, 我幫阿囡total apply 5 間, 全已1st in, 3間已"衰左"....都幾heart 架(對我), 我地傾好不將結果俾阿囡知...

原帖由 shiuchen 於 09-10-16 22:10 發表
Thanks a lot for your comfort and sharing. You are so kind! :)
My son has taken all 1 st interview, we can only look for good news in the upcoming release.

jeremyphlam

原帖由 bb亞媽 於 09-10-16 21:00 發表
非常同意你講那某港島直資男校的求其和唔專業~~~

那天囝囝in完後，我真的有被騙的感覺，我和太太講：「有冇搞錯，佢地咁樣in學生，同大抽獎有咩分別？咁都中直頭要去買六合彩啦！」

囝囝由我視線消失到出現不足廿分鐘，六人一組，减去上上落落的數分鐘時間，玩兩分鐘Lego再逐個小朋友講故事就可以揀到邊個細路適合你間學校？咪玩啦，我都in個人，二、三分鐘連個樣都未睇得清楚，除非班老師有超能力啦。

我做父母都唔想個小朋友太辛苦，好不容易揀幾間直資私小出來，又要填表又要交Form又要安排他面試時間。我們那麼認真，竟然得到這種對待？最慘重要比佢用了個quota。

老實說，如果經過一個認真的面試你唔收我完全沒有意見，學生揀學校，學校揀學生天公地道。當人地官津校為冇得揀學生而煩惱，用盡叩門位去選擇優秀的小朋友時，一所老牌名校竟然倒退若斯。

不過要補充老師們相當友善和有禮貌，相信是管理層問題。

tracytang

同意.  仲要老師講完個故事之後, then all the children need to re-tell the story one by one.  My son told me he is in order of 5th, so when the time he told the story again, he may be forgot some.  This is truely unfair for the child which told the story in 1st and in 6th.

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-17 10:45 發表


那天囝囝in完後，我真的有被騙的感覺，我和太太講：「有冇搞錯，佢地咁樣in學生，同大抽獎有咩分別？咁都中直頭要去買六合彩啦！」

囝囝由我視線消失到出現不足廿分鐘，六人一組，减去上上落落的數分鐘時間，玩兩分鐘Lego再逐個小朋 ...

jeremyphlam

原帖由 tracytang 於 09-10-17 11:02 發表
同意.  仲要老師講完個故事之後, then all the children need to re-tell the story one by one.  My son told me he is in order of 5th, so when the time he told the story again, he may be forgot some.  This ...

I really want to lodge a complaint to their senior management.

gingerale

其實家長們都以為小一面試要像考試一樣﹐考中英數常﹐答對多少題就有多少分數﹐ 越高分越有機會被取錄。
其實不盡是這樣﹐像你們所說這一間﹐很有可能是觀察小朋友的互動﹐玩LEGO﹐可能是不夠分的﹐看他們會不會分享﹐ 還是霸著自己玩。  聽故事﹐可以看他們專不專心和學習態度。  小朋友輪流講﹐不一定是講得最準確的拿最高分﹐可以是看他們的耐性﹐表達能力。
他們沒有用“考試”的形式去面試﹐而是以平常上課的形式去觀察﹐有經驗的老師﹐那怕只有幾分鐘﹐應該很容易看到那些是他們想要的學生的。  家長們﹐這些方面要有好表現不是一時三刻可以訓練出來的﹗

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-17 10:45 發表


那天囝囝in完後，我真的有被騙的感覺，我和太太講：「有冇搞錯，佢地咁樣in學生，同大抽獎有咩分別？咁都中直頭要去買六合彩啦！」

囝囝由我視線消失到出現不足廿分鐘，六人一組，减去上上落落的數分鐘時間，玩兩分鐘Lego再逐個小朋 ...

[ 本帖最後由 gingerale 於 09-10-17 12:23 編輯 ]

jeremyphlam

原帖由 gingerale 於 09-10-17 12:15 發表
其實家長們都以為小一面試要像考試一樣﹐考中英數常﹐答對多少題就有多少分數﹐ 越高分越機會被取錄。
其實不盡是這樣﹐像你們所說這一間﹐很有可能是觀察小朋友的互動﹐玩LEGO﹐可能是不夠分的﹐看他們會不會分享﹐ 還是霸著自己玩。  ...

我唔反對你的意見，有些學校是用你所說的方法去甄選小朋友，但那直資男小絕不是你所說的那樣，我問過囝囝，Lego是相當足夠。況且，二分鐘又砌到幾多Lego呀？

還有，好多學校都唔係問咩深問題，不過他們會如你所說用自己的方法去觀察個小朋友，they would spend reasonable time to observe.

但那學校給我的感覺是盡快見完所有細路，收工。

[ 本帖最後由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-17 12:35 編輯 ]

gingerale

你囝囝跟你講的﹐不一定是事實的全部。  不要誤會﹐我不是說他說謊。 雖然小朋友都很聰明﹐但老師在面試時的安排背後的用意﹐不可能理解得到。  再經他轉述給你聽﹐再由你去猜﹐你認為有多準﹖況且﹐如果你不是老師﹐你又點知他們不能用他們的方法去找到想要的學生呢﹖

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-17 12:26 發表


我唔反對你的意見，有些學校是用你所說的方法去甄選小朋友，但那直資男小絕不是你所說的那樣，我問過囝囝，Lego是相當足夠。況且，二分鐘又砌到幾多lego呀？

還有，好多學校都唔係問咩深問題，不過他們會如你所說用自己的方法去觀 ...

[ 本帖最後由 gingerale 於 09-10-17 13:12 編輯 ]

jeremyphlam

原帖由 gingerale 於 09-10-17 12:44 發表
你囝囝跟你講的﹐不一定是事實的全部。  不要誤會﹐我不是說他說謊。 雖然小朋友都很聰明﹐但老師在面試時的安排背後的用意﹐不可能理解的到。  再經他轉述給你聽﹐再由你去猜﹐你認為有多準﹖況且﹐如果你不是老師﹐你又點知他們不能 ...

以上所說的是綜合幾位小朋友所得的過程，所以也不會相差太遠。

我同意他們學校自有一套評分標準，不過是我和數位平庸家長不能參透罷了。

有一樣野可以肯定的，這間男小是我認識的一群家長一至覺得最求其的。除此之外，我們並沒有對其他學校的面試安排有意見。

gingerale

“以上所說的是綜合幾位小朋友所得的過程，所以也不會相差太遠。”

幾位小朋友所能講的﹐大概不會差距太多。  但老師們在觀察什麼﹐他們不一定看的出。  

但是﹐凡事都是雙方面的﹐如果學校的安排讓很多的家長不滿﹐最後也不一定收到想要的學生。  

不過﹐說到底﹐如果最後他們收了你的兒子﹐你會因為這個原因不讓他讀嗎﹖  

很多更有名的學校在面試時給家長的感覺都很差﹐但最後小孩被收﹐還是乖乖的去讀呢﹗

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-10-17 12:55 發表


以上所說的是綜合幾位小朋友所得的過程，所以也不會相差太遠。

我同意他們學校自有一套評分標準，不過是我和數位平庸家長不能參透罷了。

有一樣野可以肯定的，這間男小是我認識的一群家長一至覺得最求其的。除此之外，我 ...

Gooddaddy

oasismcmug>
good for your. I would'nt mind faililng all interviews but got accepted by DGJS. you daughter must be very smart. you didn't have any connections with DGJS (ie old girls), did you?

原帖由 oasismcmug 於 09-10-16 19:41 發表
Just like all the other mummy said, please do not mind the result. I know exactly how you felt especially when you thought your child was doing fine. I truely believe interview is a bias game and it r ...