York vs Cannan, how do you choose?

sfplam

My little daughter is studying pre-nursery in Cannan(KT), she only got an offer from York up to now... should I leave Cannan and join York, please comment!!!  

I read in BK that York's school fee will raise up to 3600/month in 2010, really expensive... My son study in SC K3 is 3852/month. If York is 3600 x 11, then means even more expensive than SC K3 as SC only charge 10 months...

[ 本帖最後由 sfplam 於 10-1-8 23:04 編輯 ]

WillBmama

九龍塘迦南都OK吖, 我個囝而家都讀緊N班.  如果YORK同迦南, 我會選迦南.

howma

My son is also studying in Cannan (KT) now but I will definitely choose York.

bobechristy

York also charge many other fee .....

WillBmama

原帖由 howma 於 10-1-9 14:21 發表
My son is also studying in Cannan (KT) now but I will definitely choose York.

其實我覺得迦南老師同課程都ok, 但係就唔夠出名, 考小學會蝕底d. 你的意見又如何呢?

sfplam

Million thanks to all for the comments!!!!

MALTESE2000

迦南D老師真係好好, 但課程真係淺O左D！

dch_07

my friend's son used to go to Cannan.  He is top 10 in his primary school all these years. Not sure what primary school, but I think he is quite smart.  I wouldn't leave if I were you, cos I think both are about the same.

夢妮

九龍城 (不是九龍塘) 迦南收到我呀囡,   大家對呢間有無意見 ?  我見校舍好細,  不過D老師係咪都係咁好?　　如有此校的意見,  可否提供參考 ?  謝 !

pyanny

someone said st cat will increase to 4000

cmfckyccl

我個仔被九龍塘迦南取錄下學年n1，我in時被佢大而靚既校舍吸引，而我個仔in果日又好鐘意間學校，雖然我仍然繼續有嘗試其他學校，但如果最終要讀迦南，我都覺得唔錯！: 我老公有日係街見到個舊同事，佢個仔原來讀緊迦南k3，佢覺得個仔讀得好好，佢好滿意，我覺得小朋友讀幼稚園最緊要讀得開心，開心自然願意學習，不是嗎？我個姪仔幼稚園只在Tuen Mun一間普通學校畢業，但在父母栽培下，一樣入到間傳統名小學。至於YORK，我到過佢間學校參觀，都好大好靚，而聽聞D學生都會讀得好開心，不過學費加離費真係太貴，我覺得倒不如留番D＄，比個仔學其他野，培養佢其他興趣。仲有，我有個朋友熟識YORK，話YORK只著重培育尖子，其他的小朋友會被忽略，唔知係未真的。

Carman1112

九龍塘迦南同 YORK 都收左我個囡 (超細B 0712), 我地選左 YORK, 我個個朋友都話迦南比較淺, 而我個女同事個囡係 YORK 畢業又入到女拔, 仲話佢個囡讀得非常開心, 所以我老公最後都係選咗 YORK.

WillBmama

原帖由 MALTESE2000 於 10-1-11 11:31 發表
迦南D老師真係好好, 但課程真係淺O左D！

我又唔覺得迦南課程淺, 我個囝讀nursery, 第一張拎返屋企的字咭是 "teacher", 到而家, 學左幾本英文課本, 我記得有"Back to School", "Colourful Leaves", "Messy Family", 中文就學左"田","日"等.

以一個n班學生來說, 我覺得課程真係唔淺. 不過, 迦南考名小學的知名度就可能不足囉!

CWNA

小一的直資/私校, 收York的比率高Cannan好多

cytymom

我覺得
1. york是豪不掩飾的搵錢學校,如果你不願意做水魚或不能負擔每月「非常保守估計」嘅$5000起碼 日校開支,不要考慮york(不要忘記 on top 還要花錢參加其他課外活動以增強競爭力)
2. 如果入傳統名校是你對小孩的鎖定目標, york 的確比迦南優勝
3. 如果想經濟d, 孩子不一定做尖子(不代表一定不能成為尖子), 迦南也是相當好的選擇

gret

原帖由 cytymom 於 10-1-13 14:50 發表
我覺得
1. york是豪不掩飾的搵錢學校,如果你不願意做水魚或不能負擔每月「非常保守估計」嘅$5000起碼 日校開支,不要考慮york(不要忘記 on top 還要花錢參加其他課外活動以增強競爭力)
2. 如果入傳統名校是你對小孩的 ...

$5000?? 點計架? 係咪一定要比?  同埋......點解你會知?

LittleEggBB

如果一心唸住考直資/私校: York，因為聲名好似好ｄ

其實Cannan都唔錯，我囡囡讀緊2y班，我覺得課程都唔係淺．　校舍又大又舒服，囡囡讀得都幾開心．　另外，Cannaｎ有學劵，同　Ｙｏｒｋ比起黎真係差幾遠架．　　

cytymom

點知? 日刨夜刨bk睇番嚟架囉。
喺bk search 吓 york+學費, 大把人計過,
當然, 信不信自己決定

原帖由 gret 於 10-1-13 15:40 發表


$5000?? 點計架? 係咪一定要比?  同埋......點解你會知?

SNOWPUI

原帖由 sfplam 於 10-1-8 23:00 發表
My little daughter is studying pre-nursery in Cannan(KT), she only got an offer from York up to now... should I leave Cannan and join York, please comment!!!  

I read in BK that York's school fee wil ...

迦南

cmfckyccl

點解會揀迦南？可否分享一下。