DGJS 與 CKY

wingsma

一向心儀DGJS, 最近看過CKY的開放日，很欣賞學生在小壓力和愉快的氣氛下，也能有很出色的表現。可能成績未必達到頂尖，但卻可換來快樂的童年。是否值得呢？
兩校的成績又如何比較呢？
請指教。

[ 本帖最後由 wingsma 於 10-3-6 03:21 編輯 ]

vet

如小朋友有能力, 肯讀書一定揀DGJS,
如小朋友好動, 坐唔定, 唔太肯讀書就CKY

DGJS好難考, 收你先諗都未遲。

fatgoat

同意最後個句， "DGJS好難考, 收你先諗都未遲。"

同時，如果求穩陣，應該係DGJS, CKY只不過開了十年，第一屆GCSE未有成績，IBD又未囉到。

原帖由 vet 於 10-2-15 01:42 發表
如小朋友有能力, 肯讀書一定揀DGJS,
如小朋友好動, 坐唔定, 唔太肯讀書就CKY

DGJS好難考, 收你先諗都未遲。

[ 本帖最後由 fatgoat 於 10-2-15 15:29 編輯 ]

Charlotte_mom

有d小朋友細細個已經對自己好高要求, 有晒planning知道自己要d咩, 點去achieve, 呢類小朋友入dgjs真係如魚得水
如果小朋友爭勝既心唔強, 讀cky應該會開心d

原帖由 wingsma 於 10-2-14 10:51 PM 發表
一向心儀DGJS, 最近看過CKY的開放日，很欣賞學生在小壓力和愉快的氣氛下，也能有很出色的表演。可能成績未必達到頂尖，但卻可換來快樂的童年。是否值得呢？
兩校的成績又如何比較呢？
請指教。 ...

MAMAMEEE

原帖由 fatgoat 於 10-2-15 15:27 發表
同意最後個句， "DGJS好難考, 收你先諗都未遲。"

同時，如果求穩陣，應該係DGJS, CKY只不過開了十年，第一屆GCSE未有成績，IBD又未囉到。

CKY都好出名, 但當然vs DGJS會易考好多, 請問知唔知兩者係幾多個報考收幾多位?

wingsma

聽講dg二千人考，收108人，cky千二人考，收155人。

vet

好多人考到CKY都唔去讀

但冇セ人考到DGS而唔讀

lui

My girl is a student of CKY.
DGJS is no doubt the best school in Hong Kong.So it is not surprising that very few of the girls will reject the offer from her. CKY is a  good school with a new teaching approach, so it is not surprising that a certain number of students/parents will give up the offer as they may concern about the standard (as no track record of public exam).

原帖由 vet 於 10-2-16 22:24 發表
好多人考到CKY都唔去讀

但冇セ人考到DGS而唔讀

poison

Hi Lui,
我有去最近CKY的開放日，見小一學生的作品內容十分深。當然相信家長一同參與製作才有如此效果。但我想問究竟學生是否真的明白及理解他作品的內容？對其他人的作品，學生又是否明白及有作出討論或研究呢？課程並不是越深越好，而是要學生明白及理解並加以運用。若學生做了作品，卻不理解內容或其中原理，則達不到學生的本質了。請問你的女兒的學習情況如何呢？
poison

原帖由 lui 於 2010-2-17 14:37 發表
My girl is a student of CKY.
DGJS is no doubt the best school in Hong Kong.So it is not surprising that very few of the girls will reject the offer from her. CKY is a  good school with a new teaching  ...

kyliema2006

呢樣我都有所感受，課程深但孩子不明白祇會是浪費大家的時間。雖然我並不太曉得你說的作品是那些，可能是science projects又或是其它，若是說science project，學生是需要向所有同學面前present自己的作品，亦會被老師及同學問問題。由搜集材料到做model，再做presentation，孩子都一定要明白箇中內容的，否則老師很容易會知道的。我的孩子現在已是四年級了，現在做project，找題材到搜集材料就是他一人包辦，可能仍未能掌握presentation flow，即是有齊材料，但唔識落鑊，那我們會與他討論大綱流程應如何。到中學時，家長基本上已經全都退役了。

但若你指的是課程內容艱深，我都會覺得很神奇，孩子如何會記得的，好像今年英文教Middle Ages，所教的內容及生字其實頗艱深的，但在觀課時所見，很多同學都會懂。孩子要讀得好，相信是靠平時多閱讀所致。

原帖由 poison 於 10-2-18 00:54 發表
Hi Lui,
我有去最近CKY的開放日，見小一學生的作品內容十分深。當然相信家長一同參與製作才有如此效果。但我想問究竟學生是否真的明白及理解他作品的內容？對其他人的作品，學生又是否明白及有作出討論或研究呢？課程並不是 ...

[ 本帖最後由 kyliema2006 於 10-2-18 10:37 編輯 ]

lui

Hi Poison

My girl has been studied in CKY for five months (insert in p2).

I didn't go to P1 Classroom but i bet what you have seen are the science projects. To share my view, the school would like to let the student know how to do a project, where the topic not necessarily being taught at school. However, the school provides a very clear guide for how the project is done (well, it is a booklet with several pages, i admire their effort in that). Parents might take part in the whole process (more or less), of course, it is up to the parents whether they would really teach the kid what is it all about. They were given time to present in the front of the classmates, being questioned and commented on their presentation (both teacher and the student should feedback). I like the whole process. They can really learn through this. Though the things they learnt are somehow difficult,they can really learn without hesitation. They can still remember a few months later. This is a miracle.
Like Kylie2006 said, students are encouraged to read books. My girl didn't read much books before joining CKY, not interested and not have enough spare time to do so. However, the school have their "magic" to induce her to fall in love with reading. With the reading habit, my girl has been learning a lot more. Of course, proficiency in Eng and Chi is getting higher.

原帖由 poison 於 10-2-18 00:54 發表
Hi Lui,
我有去最近CKY的開放日，見小一學生的作品內容十分深。當然相信家長一同參與製作才有如此效果。但我想問究竟學生是否真的明白及理解他作品的內容？對其他人的作品，學生又是否明白及有作出討論或研究呢？課程並不是 ...

Blessings

Of course DGJS, ty it first and if your girl can't adapt, she can still have other choices. To me, to be able to study in DGJS is the same as winning the Mark Six (with Jackpot!).

原帖由 lui 於 10-2-18 12:02 發表
Hi Poison

My girl has been studied in CKY for five months (insert in p2).

I didn't go to P1 Classroom but i bet what you have seen are the science projects. To share my view, the school would like  ...

EFM

The daughter of one of the teachers  (a Miss) in CKY is studying in DGJS.

Elsa



[/quote]

wingsma

原帖由 EFM 於 10-2-19 22:31 發表
The daughter of one of the teachers  (a Miss) in CKY is studying in DGJS.

Elsa

[/quote]
Somebody said that her daughter was admitted by DGJS but rejected by CKY. Perhaps that teacher had got the same situation!

hhhc

Hi Lui,

I am also interested a lot in CKY, I really want my boy to study there. I heard that CKY students' oral English and PTH are excellent, how can the school train them? Does applicant needs to have a high proficiency in English and PTH before entering the school? What are the selection criteria of CKY? Many thanks for sharing.

原帖由 lui 於 10-2-18 12:02 發表
Hi Poison

My girl has been studied in CKY for five months (insert in p2).

I didn't go to P1 Classroom but i bet what you have seen are the science projects. To share my view, the school would like  ...

kyliema2006

其實我又唔覺得有甚麼大不了，始終DGS是傳統名校，大部份人都會以既然考得入，何妨入讀的心態，人之常情啦！

原帖由 wingsma 於 10-2-21 21:59 發表

Somebody said that her daughter was admitted by DGJS but rejected by CKY. Perhaps that teacher had got the same situation! [/quote]

penguin_chick

原帖由 hhhc 於 10-2-22 03:46 發表
Hi Lui,

I am also interested a lot in CKY, I really want my boy to study there. I heard that CKY students' oral English and PTH are excellent, how can the school train them? Does applicant needs to h ...

Selection criteria of CKY:
I ‘GUESS’ the parents should have the same vision of the school.
The ability of communicate in English is an advantage, but PTH is not a must.
Sociable and obedient but active child is always the favorite of most school.

CKY students' oral English and PTH are excellent for most of the children but the teachers do not really train them, they have created an excellent atmosphere for the children and give them much changes to use ( not practice ) the both languages.

bakusensei

原帖由 penguin_chick 於 10-2-26 00:21 發表

Selection criteria of CKY:
I ‘GUESS’ the parents should have the same vision of the school.
The ability of communicate in English is an advantage, but PTH is not a must.
Sociable and obedient but a ...

thanks penguin_chick for your valuable information. so, PTH was not tested during the interviews?

but CKY's students PTH are super brillant during the school visit!

judy

but CKY's students PTH are super brillant during the school visit!

PTH好易学。

kyliema2006

對，祇要有一個適當的學習環境，提供足夠講及聆聽的機會，PTH一定係好易學。

原帖由 judy 於 10-2-26 12:19 發表


PTH好易学。