做 Exercise 還是 【睇書】 好 ? (試驗一年後, 結果 #232 在12頁)

Png

閲讀的益處比較長遠，學的東西是不知不覺地不斷吸收，而且是一種終生的興趣，真係唔好停．
做exercise 可說是用來操考試技巧和時間管理．
如果小朋友是讀傳統學校，要二者兼顧，係辛苦D.但個人認為是需要的．
如果二者選一，個人認為一定是閲讀．

Png

Though I also highly recommend reading rather than doing exercises, I dislike this kind of "condemnation".

There must be some reasons that parents choose "doing exercises" for their kids. For example :

1) their kids are really not interested in reading after years of trial;

2) they have barriers in reading words (it's a kind of sickness); or

3) parents do not know how to establish a reading habit for their kids, etc.

Not everyone is as smart as you guys and not every child is the same.  Be humble.

Png

//Why don't those parents be humble to learn from others how to develop young kid's reading habbit and ability//

It's not a matter of humbleness. It's a matter of ability.  I do think parents are eager to learn, especailly BK parents here. Not everyone has the same level.

Png

當然沒有事情是不可能的． 但有些人在過程中會有不順利，掙扎，也會有放棄， 因此做exercise也許便變成另一出路．好過冇． 閱讀的最大好處是不斷吸收學校以外的知識，是活的知識，而做exercises 吸收的只是巳有知識，是死的．

原帖由 stccmc 於 10-5-4 21:37 發表


1 & 3 就是我說的 D 形人。不知方法式，沒決心意志。這些我相信都可以放正或改善過來的。

Png

Really don't understand why you don't understand what I mean.  Anyway, I'm just trying to explain somes difficulties that parents/children may  encounter when they try to build up a reading habit.  

Thanks for your sharing.

原帖由 jediknight 於 10-5-4 22:11 發表
I don't understand what do you mean by Not everyonehas the same level.

If you are referring to the level of kids, I have said that the reading method described by that BK parent before can apply to a ...

Png

Thanks for your sharing.  
Would you please share whether you will recommend children to read chapter books (instead of picture books) when they are at 6 to 7 years old?  How did you start the "chapter books" stage for your daughter?  From guided reading?

原帖由 stccmc 於 10-5-4 22:14 發表
我女兒每天讀半小時至一小時書，不是很多，亦沒甚麽結構。但我由佢六個月開始到五歲，每天親子閱讀十五分鐘到半小時。唯一教材是書本。全無流行的 DWE, flash card 等玩意。

至於英語環境，我地百份百香港人，佢讀傳统中文小 ...

Png

Thanks for your sharing.   My gal is in P.1 and she's studying in traditional local school.  She now starts reading "The Tiara Club" (princess) series.  Now it is a transition period for her from picture books to chapter books.   I would much appreciate if you could recommend some more simple chapter books at her age, according to your daughter's preferences.   Thanks.

原帖由 stccmc 於 10-5-5 20:58 發表
//
Would you please share whether you will recommend children to read chapter books (instead of picture books) when they are at 6 to 7 years old?  How did you start the "chapter books" stage for you ...

Png

真開心有mattsmum這類家長，就是實實際際地介紹很多有效方法幫助小朋友增加閱讀成效．有些真用得著．我會試的．

看這個topic，就是期待這些回應．