身邊多唔多人借地址抽中第一志願

ac321

Yes, so many. Around 30% families doing such things (my friends I know).

原帖由 o^^o 於 10-6-13 22:21 發表
實在不吐不快, 自己住該區就抽唔到, 但見到不止一個人借地址抽中第一志願, 還大講風涼話, "唉!真係唔知搬唔搬好呢!"

[ 本帖最後由 ac321 於 10-6-14 11:51 編輯 ]

ac321

It is because we may visit their flat before. Therefore, we know that they are not living in the area they 抽 for primary school.

原帖由 overview 於 10-6-14 14:48 發表
又會有人咁蠢, 借地址都話比人知 ?

ac321

佢地可以就近入學唔駛山長水遠，可能仲開心
=> I think if they don't need to study in school, they may be more happy (for kids)!!!!!!

It is their own choice (山長水遠入學 or 就近入學).

It is unfair for the education nets. Why some kids can study in 'good' school if they live around? Why some kids can't because they are not living around?

They all pay tax for HKG! They should have equal chance to study in their 'ideal' school.

P.S. How can make sure that if you rent a flat around, you will lives in the same address in the coming 6 years?????????

原帖由 traeh 於 10-6-14 12:12 發表
咁又未必係害咗小朋友，佢地可以就近入學唔駛山長水遠，可能仲開心。如果佢能力okay，第二年都可以轉讀更適合嘅學校。覺得受害嘅係家長多啲，不過出得嚟借地址，都預咗會有今日啦。

...

ac321

most of the cases are using brothers/sisters/grandparents address.

原帖由 tracytang 於 10-6-14 15:29 發表
可能真係唔出奇.  個個身邊都有lee d case 發現.

ac321

呢個問題永遠無圓滿答案 => yes, it has.
If everyone has the same/equal chance
=>fair
If someone has larger chance then others
=>unfair

P.S.
I get the benifits in this unfair system. It is because I (and my husband) studied in net 34 primary schools. Therefore, I don't need to worry about the address (I live in net 95) as I can add points as grad. student in round 1.
However, I find a lot of my friends try to 借地址抽 to increases the chance for their kids to study in their 'ideal' school. At the same time, a lot of schools complain that they can't chose their students by themselves....... Then, I feel the 'game' is unfair!

What I worry is: if the game keep continuous, all / most of the 'best' school don't join the game and becomes 直資 / 私立.
Then, only the rich people can study in 'good' school as they have $. And the poor can't as they can't support school fee!  

原帖由 traeh 於 10-6-14 17:00 發表
點先公平？呢個問題永遠無圓滿答案。你話it is their own choice去山長水遠返學，但亦有好多人選擇就近入學，唔想下下坐成個鐘車，由天水圍去柴灣返學。但如果全港任抽，肯定有人屋企附近的學位，比"their own choice"嘅人霸咗，被 ...

[ 本帖最後由 ac321 於 10-6-14 17:18 編輯 ]

ac321

for most of people:
fair => when they get benefits in the game.
unfair => when they can't get any benefits.

as a third person:
fair => everyone get equal chance

原帖由 traeh 於 10-6-14 17:00 發表
點先公平？呢個問題永遠無圓滿答案。你話it is their own choice去山長水遠返學，但亦有好多人選擇就近入學，唔想下下坐成個鐘車，由天水圍去柴灣返學。但如果全港任抽，肯定有人屋企附近的學位，比"their own choice"嘅人霸咗，被 ...